What this covers

This is a one-on-one conversation between SumZero and Guy Spier, running about seventy minutes. It moves between his current holdings, a live situation at Credit Suisse, and personal lessons from his career. The two India positions anchor the discussion: India Energy Exchange and CARE Ratings. Spier explains why he paid more than 30 times earnings for the exchange, pointing to real cash earnings, buybacks, and electricity demand that is continuous and hard to store. He argues that incumbent exchanges keep a first-mover advantage even after losing a legal monopoly.

The ratings discussion is the most detailed. He describes a credit rating agency as a high-margin business that cuts clients' borrowing costs, by about 100 basis points for a large corporate. He also covers the oligopoly structure of the industry, why CRISIL is so far ahead, and why staff compensation matters, since alumni become bankers who bring in new clients. He is candid about CARE's credibility problem after its A-rating of ILFC, which preceded the company's bankruptcy, while noting that Moody's and S&P missed comparable cases in the US. On Credit Suisse, he sees a classic Graham-style opportunity at one-third of book value, but stresses that leveraged financials can go to zero, so position sizing matters.

The wider terrain is temperament and conduct. Spier prefers owning businesses he would hold indefinitely, caps new positions at 5% of the fund, and made no new investments last year, choosing to sit still rather than go to cash. He favors regulated businesses with regulated counterparties when investing abroad, and he rejects geography or asset-class mandates as marketing devices. The more personal turns include his admission that being antagonistic with management was a mistake, which leads him toward a friendlier, more helpful engagement. He also recounts how discovering Warren Buffett and reading self-help books helped him leave a bad environment at DH Blair, and he explains why reputation and the company you keep matter so much.

Sharpest takeaway

Guy Spier argues that successful value investing requires long-term holding periods, gravitating toward regulated businesses with durable competitive advantages, maintaining strong personal reputation and ethical standards, and being willing to invest globally while carefully assessing governance and country-level risks.

  • Reputation is everything and associating with unethical actors causes lasting career damage regardless of personal wrongdoing
  • Exchange businesses and highly regulated platforms with first-mover advantages can sustain returns for decades despite losing legal monopolies
  • Country-level governance concerns should inform investment decisions but shouldn't be applied with absolute rules—context and business quality matter more than geography alone

The claims · ranked60 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Credit rating agencies are businesses with very high margins themselves that actually lower the cost of doing business for their clients—a large corporate will pay about 100 basis points less in interest rates on bonds with a credit rating than without one—making them high-return-on-capital businesses.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“what's so amazing about a rating agency is that despite having very high margins themselves they actually lower the cost of doing business for their clients so in most cases in many cases you can't even issue a bond to the markets unless you have a rating from a recognized rating agency and it's well understood that the cost of the the interest rate that a large corporate will pay on their bonds goes down significantly by about 100 basis points if you have a credit rating”

0.75

Even when a legal monopoly is taken away, incumbent exchange operators like the New York Stock Exchange maintain extraordinary first-mover advantages through setting rules, providing information, controlling clearing mechanisms, and managing interactions with depositories, allowing them to continue performing well.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“in European and U.S share trading exchanges no longer have a monopoly the New York Stock Exchange doesn't have a monopoly on New York Stock Exchange stocks anybody can be in exchange in those stocks but the the New York Stock Exchange has by setting the rules by by providing information by setting clearing Rules by having interactions with depositories they have an enormous encumbent Advantage”

0.75

When companies have been hit by major share price declines (like meme stocks or bubbles), both commentators and investors become very convinced of the investment case because they had invested in it during the bubble and are now rationalizing it as 'inevitable' despite changed fundamentals.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I feel like a lot of people like no no personally and care about have been very very badly Bound by the um I guess you can call it the basting of the whatever it was the Omni bubble that we had in 2000 ending in 2022 and I I you know there are uh both commentators and investors who are extremely convinced for many many good reasons of the qualities of the businesses that they were investing in which we're going to conquer the universe conquer the planet for sure and um they were buying shares for their portfolio because they were even more enthusiastic about the prospects of the company than the sellers of those shares and uh the prospects were extraordinarily good but my experience has shown even though it's very hard to do that we do well as investors when we buy off people who are not enthusiastic”

0.75

We do well as investors when we buy off people who are fearful and pessimistic where the mood is very much against the situation, and if you have the courage to go in there you can often do extraordinarily well—by contrast, buying off people who are enthusiastic even about genuinely good business prospects tends not to work out as well.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“we do well as investors when we buy off people who are not enthusiastic by contrast we buy off people who are fearful people who are pessimistic where the mood is very very much against the situation and then if you have the courage to to to to go in there you can often do extraordinarily well”

0.74

An investor should think of themselves as an owner of the business, not a trader of the stock—from this perspective, current interest rates and current valuations are less important than the long-term earning power of the business in 20-30 years.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Guy Spier

“I think of myself as an owner of the business and I just I'm not concerned about where the interest rates are too much uh and I'm not concerned all that much about even believe it or not valuation and time of current earnings as I'm looking out in a certain way I realize that that's what a lot of people were doing in some of the meme and non-earning stocks in the United States uh only difference being that this company is actually generating real cash earnings and is even repurchasing its shares right now but I'm looking at it as an asset and what will the asset look like in 20 30 years rather than what it is today”

0.69

Your reputation is everything, and by associating with bad people you damage your reputation enormously in a way that, when you're young enough, is recoverable but it's long and hard and an arduous world to recover from.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“what I had failed to understand and it's just so super important is that your reputation is everything and by associating with bad people you damage your reputation enormously in a way that when you're young enough is recoverable but it's long and hard an arduous world to recover”

0.69

Credit Suisse is trading at one-third of its book value, which is a classic Ben Graham deep value opportunity, but the downside for leveraged financial institutions can be zero or very dilutive capital raises, making position sizing crucial.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“the book value accounting book value of Credit Suisse is approximately 40 billion Swiss Francs and the market cap is approximately 10 or 12 billion Swiss Francs so you have a company that's trading at one third of the book simple as that that's that is there's a Ben Graham kind of investment if you like”

0.69

Rating agencies are oligopolies or duopolies globally, with only space for perhaps a third player, making it very difficult for Care Ratings to win dominance even if it improves operationally, because CRISIL already holds a far ahead position.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“ratings businesses around the world are oligopolies often do opolis between just two businesses maybe there's space for a third and in India there are five or six and so you know I I have no doubt that care that crizzle is a winner in that oligopoly they've got a position that is far ahead of everybody else but whether care ratings as a winner is not clear to me”

0.65

In periods of extreme economic uncertainty, the best approach is to do nothing, sit and watch without going to cash and panicking, which is why Spier made zero new investments last year despite favorable opportunity.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“and in general when and there is a extreme uncertainty from my perspective I I kind of find the best modus operandi is to do nothing sit and watch and that doesn't mean go to cash and sit in a bunker and be scattered the sky is going to fall in our heads but that also means that I don't have to kind of move the portfolio around enormously”

0.61

When investing in foreign markets where you don't understand local nuances, you should gravitate toward businesses that are highly regulated and whose counterparties are themselves highly regulated, as this provides structural protection against being exploited.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“there's always the question that arises for somebody like me hey you're not Indian you don't speak Hindi you didn't grow up there you have no understanding of local nuances so what are the ways in which this could bite me in the rear end and so I've tended to gravitate in India towards businesses that are highly regulated and over and above that whose counterparties themselves are highly regulated”

0.61

Spier limits new investments to 5% of the fund's value because that's the right number that works for him, though he acknowledges a case could be made for 10%, and allows positions to grow beyond these initial allocations as they compound.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“my my rule of thumb is to invest up to five percent of the the then um value of the portfolio and any new idea I'm unlikely to invest more than five percent because that's just a number that works for me I've also seen there's there's a good case to be made for making it 10 but but once I've made the investment I will allow it to run uh for a long time so there are some position sizes that have absolutely ballooned”

0.61

Electricity demand is inelastic and continuous because electricity must be produced when needed and is difficult to store despite battery conversations, making electricity exchange platforms naturally durable long-term businesses.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“electricity is in demand is produced it's funny it's very hard store electricity despite all the conversations about batteries so you have to produce what this system needs at any one time and for as long as human civilization exists it will be powered by electricity”

0.61

Spier paid more than 30 times earnings for India energy exchange because the company generates real cash earnings and is buying back shares, unlike many bubble-priced growth stocks that have no earnings.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I paid up quite a lot I paid above 30 times earnings for the business but it's real earnings it's real cash earnings cash developing on the balance sheet unlike many of these bubble stocks where they didn't have any earnings”

0.56

Spier prefers to own only companies he wants to sit on forever rather than engage in a 'pass the parcel' game of selling at high valuations, because the holding period approach aligns incentives and reduces the temptation to chase momentum.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Guy Spier

“I figured out I maybe not that long ago but I kind of only want to put companies into the portfolio that I want to sit on forever because it's just too hard to think of a Time Horizon where where effectively you're trying to sell out at a high valuation to other people which which is some kind of past the parcel game”

0.55

Spier is concerned that ILFC's A-rating by Care Ratings, which preceded the company's bankruptcy, represents a credibility crisis for the agency, though he notes that Moody's and S&P also failed to properly rate such companies in the US.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“it seems to have spoiled spilled in on its copy book in that it probably allocated two high ratings to some local borrowers that they should not have allocated and that there was a famous case ilfc where care ratings had allocated an a rating to a company that ultimately went bust it's a story that we know well it happened in the United States with uh agencies like Moody's and standard and Paul's but in this case for example chrisle did not allocate an a Regency an a rating to this company”

0.52

A mandate that restricts an investor in terms of what asset classes or geographies they can invest in are more like marketing tools, and investors should instead have complete freedom to invest across any geography, industry, or instrument, with real due diligence focused on who the manager is and what they've done in the past.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I think it's all along has been to protect and grow the wealth that has been entrusted for to me and I think that all sort of mandates that restrict the investor in terms of what asset classes or what geographies or those are kind of like more like marketing tools if you like and you have to be open to everything potentially and I've I've explained to all sorts of people that if they're entrusting me to manage their money the real due diligence is on me it's not is to is to research who I am what I've said do I do what I say I've done in the past”

0.52

Highly regulated, transparent investment vehicles (like CRISIL credit ratings) where two large institutional shareholders watch each other provide structural protection for minority shareholders, making them mice trading amongst the feet of elephants.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“the two largest shareholders were one was ICICI Bank it was extremely well known large Bank in India and the other large shareholder was standard and Poor's and they were approximately 40 of the shares each and there was a minority of 20 out there so my reasoning which I think was was good reasoning was that um you had two big dogs watching each other and those two big dogs were gonna the the small fry the twenty percent of the public shareholding were not the two were too small to worry about”

0.52

A credit rating agency's staff are its most important source of new business because graduates of the agency become investment bankers and bring new clients through that channel, making employee compensation crucial for competitive success.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“one of the most important places for a ratings agency to invest is in its staff because these staff when they graduate and go on to become investment bankers are the your most important source of new business”

0.52

Credit Suisse's wealth management franchise remains strong at the granular, day-to-day level despite recent asset outflows, because customer switching costs in banking are extraordinarily high due to the operational burden of moving accounts, wire transfers, and account management systems.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“at the granular level of day-to-day banking even in a financial services firm like we are the considerations are simply do I like my client service rep does the it system work when I set up wire transfers when I need to when I need to look at my accounts how easy or how difficult is it and my impression based on that and a few other conversations is that the franchise is extraordinarily strong”

0.52

Some businesses can almost certainly survive nearly any apocalyptic scenario (like American energy or Northern Railways), while others like Care Ratings easily would not, making apocalypse-survivability a key criterion for business quality.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“there are some businesses it's very very hard to see why they wouldn't survive pretty much the apocalypse if you think of American energy is a great example of that or burning to Northern Railways this is a business that could easily not survive the apocalypse and so I want to be extraordinarily careful”

0.52

I should never speak to management according to my book, but I've recently realized this is wrong because being antagonistic toward management gets you a bad reputation in management circles, so you should instead seek to help management achieve their goals.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I've not been involved with management and if uh if somebody reads my book you'll see that I have this statement or this this idea in my book that you shouldn't speak to management I think that that's a really bad idea if I ever do an update on my book that's one of the first things that I'll put front and center”

0.52

Spier recognizes people in his annual report by naming all suppliers and the specific partners (not managing partners) who do work for his firm, with the intent to attract better people into his circle through recognition and positive association.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I learning from Monash at the back of my annual report have a page that looks like a company Tombstone called team aquamarine and in that I name all of our suppliers and even in the case of kind of major accounting and law firms I name the partners not the managing Partners but the ones who actually do the work for our firm and the idea is to recognize uh recognize the people in my circle and when they get that recognition I will track some of the best people into my circle”

0.52

Discovering Warren Buffett and reading self-help literature (Anthony Robbins, Dale Carnegie, Napoleon Hill) helped Spier escape his bad orbit at DH Blair by imagining what Buffett would do and applying motivational principles to reorient his career.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I discovered Warren Buffett and started um uh engrossing myself in everything Warren Buffett but I also had encountered the self-help uh um genre of literature so self-help from Anthony Robbins to Dale Carnegie How to Win Friends and Influence People Napoleon Hill Think and Grow Rich and I you know I needed a way to get out of where I was and so I started applying many of the ideas in those books to get me to where I wanted to be and so one of the things I did was I imagined what Warren Buffett would do in my shoes and I thought Warren Buffett would not be at this place so it helped me to leave”

0.52

Management teams don't wake up wanting to rip off shareholders or run businesses badly; they want help achieving their goals, so investor engagement should focus on amplifying good management actions and attracting better management.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I don't think any management team wakes up in the morning and says I'm going to rip off the shareholders or I'm going to manage the business badly none of them really want that but they are looking for people to help them to get things done and I so I think that I try to amplify the good actions of all the management teams that I follow and in the expectation and hope that uh I will constantly be attracted to better and better management teams”

0.52

'Friendivism' (term coined by William Green) is an approach to shareholder engagement where the investor seeks to help management achieve their goals, amplifies good management actions, and acts as a resource rather than an antagonist—it's distinct from traditional activist investing that uses confrontation.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“my friend William Green the author of Richard wise are happier he calls that friend of ism you know I like that I like that term um friendivism”

0.52

Looking at multiples of current earnings is very dangerous because it discourages investment in long-term capability building—Spier would be fine with CARE trading at 2x the multiple of earnings if he knew the company was investing that difference intelligently in talent, systems, and capability.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“and that's what's very dangerous about looking at kind of things like multiples of earnings you actually if I knew that they were spending the money in an intelligent way I would even be fine with multiple of earnings that was double that if they were spending half of their earnings and for example employee salaries”

0.52

Spier believes it's inappropriate to engage in an antagonistic approach with management because this behavior spreads through professional circles and prevents future access to management.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Guy Spier

“I think that something that I've only realized Divya recently is that if you take a an antagonistic view approach towards management that word gets around and very quickly you're not going to be very popular in management circles so of any company because they'll find out that that's the your Nature”

0.49

India energy exchange will become 20 to 30 times larger within 10-15 years because Indian per capita electricity consumption needs to increase by approximately 3x to match developed country standards, and exchange penetration could grow from 10 percent to 70-80 percent.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I just did a simple calculation of um or what is calculation is there for everybody to see it's not even a calculation the the in in Europe and in the markets in the United States where there are exchanges they tend to have a 70 to 80 Market penetration so if you take uh income the power generated per capita and multiply by approximately three to get it up to developed country standards and you look at the penetration of the exchanges and say that it's it's going to be from 10 to 70 or 80 percent so you've got a business that you can easily see will be 20 to 30 times larger”

0.49

When India energy exchange volumes contracted in the previous year due to high power prices making bilateral contracts more attractive, the market incorrectly extrapolated this temporary condition into a permanent decline, causing the valuation to compress significantly despite the fundamental thesis remaining intact.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“what's interesting right now is that um the conditions of last year created uh a uh there was there was little to no growth in volumes traded on the exchange for understand reasons but in a in a market like India where people don't look too far ahead uh that needs you know people extrapolate last last year's experience and say there may be no growth left and so that company trades with a far lower valuation than it did um it's sort of 18 months beforehand”

0.49

The approach of following successful investors like Monish Pabrai and doing independent work on their ideas is a strategy Spier regrets not employing in the case of Race course in Turkey, which Pabrai made 20x on, representing a significant missed opportunity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“two years ago I was aware that monish was investing in race us and it may come up in my letter as a um a kind of a mistake of a mission that I have to analyze because there is no reason why I could not have put one percent of aquamarine fund into race us after I knew that monish owned it and after I did my own work on it and I believe that that is up about 20 x permonish”

0.49

Care Ratings is a homegrown Indian credit rating agency that hasn't had the benefit of foreign ownership like Moody's or S&P to teach global standards, but this domestic control provides an opportunity to build a world-class rating agency under Indian leadership.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“care has something which is really really important which is it it is not owned by Colonial foreign powers and I use that I I'm probably using that word very Loosely but um what I see with care is an enormous amount of low hanging fruit this is a company that certainly can grow into being a far more far better processes far better systems our better approach to rating businesses but it's locally owned and controlled”

0.49

Credit Suisse's restructuring into wealth management, asset management, and a separately capitalized investment banking division makes strategic sense because the bank's problems originated specifically from the investment banking division and the cultural clash between Swiss and New York decision-making styles.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“all of the problems of Credit Suisse arose from its Investment Banking Division and from the fact that the way the Swiss think and the way New Yorkers think is very very different and uh when you look at the decision making at Green cell which was the one downfall and the other one was our Tiga us you kind of get a mix of two different cultures that don't really mix very well but what they're doing is they're sort of having the Investment Bank off into a separately capitalized vehicle with a separate board very clearly run out of New York by this guy Klein”

0.49

Spier refuses to invest in countries at war with the West but acknowledges he cannot apply simple rules to distinguish between countries with human rights abuses (Turkey, China, Russia), as the reasoning would require case-by-case analysis where he admits his own decisions may not be rational.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I don't think that I want to invest in countries that are at war with the West for example I I would not do that you can't do it if you're an American regulated fund anyway”

0.48

The Swiss banking culture has unique qualities—precision, the legacy of the Swiss Army, and alignment with brand Switzerland (Alpine mountains, architecture, the ETH Polytechnic)—that appeal to global customers regardless of Credit Suisse's reputational setbacks.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“Credit Suisse has a culture of being far more entrepreneurial and being far more client oriented I think there probably is space in terms of a global audience that are interested in Swiss banking for those two kinds of cultures to exist I would also say that um I am there there is certainly there's no doubt in my mind there is there is a Precision around Swiss thinking that also comes into Banking and there are many people around the world child who want that precision”

0.48

Indian real estate offers interesting development opportunities that in certain ways are more advanced than in the US and Western Europe, but Spier avoids it because assessing management honesty would be very difficult for a foreign investor.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“there is some really interesting developments going on in the real estate sector in India where it is in a certain way far more advanced than the United States and Western Europe uh but I still knew that I would have to if I was buying into an Indian real estate company I'd have to have some evaluation with the management and how honest they are and that was something that I would have a really hard time doing”

0.48

India energy exchange's growth is restricted by regulatory decisions that prevent it from trading energy derivatives, limiting its total addressable market and future growth potential compared to developed market exchanges.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“they have been restricted from Trading and derivatives so so they have to trade physical power uh derivatives energy derivatives which are a really important commodity in develop financial markets cannot be traded at India energy exchange so that's a whole area of growth that is not available to them”

0.48

The eurotunnel bond investment exemplifies Spier's willingness to invest in unusual instruments and geographies, purchasing bonds yielding 20% of cost in over-the-counter markets while applying the tollgate principle (infrastructure with captive demand).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“my earlier Investments was in the bonds of eurotunnel and uh you know I I kind of was thinking of Warren Buffett's Tollgate and the way if you have a bridge across a one road across a particular Strait that a lot of traffic needs to move across that's an amazing business you can charge them a toll and that eurotunnel was kind of a toll but I invested in bond instruments so so for example I had a significant investment Bond instruments yielding say 20 of the cost that I'd purchased them which were almost not traded in the market they were only traded over the counter”

0.48

Spier has made large investment decisions (Aquamarine fund inception) based on his father entrusting him with family savings rather than a professional mandate, requiring him to balance family wealth preservation with legitimate value-creation opportunity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“he's looking me doing this and I never expected him to entrust me with his savings but that's effectively what he did which is the Inception of aquamarine fund”

0.48

Spier views Monish Pabri as a source of important lessons about how to market oneself without being aggressive or making people uncomfortable, such as letting people know you're open for business through signaling rather than direct solicitation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I learned an enormous amount from and then he's coming on Native from monish pabri about how to approach selling yourself without actually um sort of accosting people and making them feel uncomfortable around you and so there's a way of there's a way of handling yourself such as the world knows that you're open for business so to speak but you're not making them feel uncomfortable at cocktail parties if you like”

0.47

Spier uses a discount rate of approximately 4% when valuing businesses for long-term holding because he believes that's the right long-term rate, regardless of current interest rates in the market.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“in my case I kind of don't think of those what current interest rates are I kind of think of about a four percent discount rate as being probably the right discount discount rate to apply over time”

0.47

China's capacity to lift enormous numbers of people out of poverty diminishes the ethical significance of its human rights abuses in Spier's reasoning, though he recognizes this logic ('if it's expedient it's right') is problematic from a human rights perspective.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“China's capacity to lift so many people out of poverty somehow uh diminishes the significance of their abuses of human rights which all the human rights people that I know would tell me is a terrible terrible means of reasoning because it's basically saying well if it's expedient it's right and one should we should never engage that kind of reason when it comes to Human Rights”

0.47

Spier's early Harvard Business School graduates were offered positions at prestigious firms (JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, McKinsey) but he chose DH Blair, which was a mistake in retrospect because more experience at name-brand firms would have provided less bumpy career path.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Guy Spier

“I could have easily out of Harvard Business School gone and gotten a job at uh you know JP Morgan Goldman's acts McKinsey one of those well-known brand name farms and I think that my path would have been far less bumpy had I actually bit my tongue gotten my ego in check and uh accepted I didn't know everything I needed to know and gone and gotten more experience”

0.45

Spier successfully invested in Alaska Milk (a Filipino company with 98% of the condensed milk market) despite the country having a corrupt political environment and being associated with Imelda Marcos because the company itself was not corrupt.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I had a very successful investment in a Filipino company called Alaska milk which had 98 of the condensed milk Market even though many people told me that Imelda Marcus was one of the most corrupt politicians on the planet at the time that she was around and um and that the Philippines is a highly corrupt company country the company I invested in was not corrupt”

0.43

Spier has invested successfully in Oman, Jordan, Zimbabwe, Israel-adjacent markets, and other frontier/emerging markets, proving that geographic diversification can create value for disciplined investors.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“I've not invested in any Israeli businesses but I have invested in Oman I've invested in Jordan and I've even invested in uh Zimbabwe and if I think of those Investments um none of them made me money two of them I exited without having lost much money I exited all of them without having lost much money”

0.41

Mastercraft is a publicly traded small/microcap company (~$500M market cap) that manufactures wakeboarding and water skiing boats, has a powerful brand, buys back its own shares, and is sitting at an attractive valuation that Spier is circling as a potential investment.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Guy Spier

“it'll be a good test to see if um if if anybody pays attention to me or not I mean I I have investments in Moody's and uh in Berkshire Hathaway and some some businesses that are extremely well known and understood but um uh you know uh so I ran a screen the other day and I I modified the screen slightly which which threw up some really interesting companies one of which is a brand that I understand really really well because my son loves wakeboarding and I've enjoyed growing up water skiing and those of us who know water skiing know that you know probably most of the boats that we want to water ski behind are either a brand name Chris Craft or Mastercraft but it turns out Mastercraft is a publicly traded company that buys back its own shares and is a powerful brand and is sitting there at a very very small yeah I think it's on the borderline between microcap and uh and small cap something like that it's a half a billion dollar valuation”

0.40

Credit Suisse has support from two sovereign wealth funds (Saudi Arabia and Qatar, ~20% ownership combined) and can access the Swiss central bank discount window and Swiss government capital support, making a capital shortage unlikely even under stress.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“it's acquired a shareholding from Saudi Arabia Southern wealth fund and Saudi Arabia and Sovereign wealth fund of Qatar which are now approximately 20 of credit source and obviously it has the ability to raise money at the discount window of the Central Bank of Switzerland and the Central Bank of Switzerland and the and the uh the bond uh the Swiss Sovereign government have invested very very significant amounts of money in the previous financial crisis in UBS to the tune of I believe 16 billion uh Swiss Francs”

0.39

Spier's portfolio includes positions where he intended to build them to 5% but never got past 1%, such as Care Ratings and Alibaba, because the thesis, while compelling, has unresolved risks or uncertainties that prevent him from committing capital at scale.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“there are also positions where I I said to myself I will make this up to five percent but I never really got past one percent if you like and actually I would tell you that hair ratings is in that category along with Alibaba”

0.39

A smaller rating agency called Brickworks was put under investigatory procedure and barely kept its license, showing that India will consolidate its rating agency industry through regulatory pressure.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“and not long ago there was an investigatory procedure against a smaller rating agency than care called brickworks where they managed to keep their license but only just”

0.39

Spier conducts intensive research on 5-20 companies, maintains watch lists of 20-100 companies, and reviews hundreds more in a cursory fashion by running screens, but the real question is which companies are studied intensively vs. glanced at once per year.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“the real question is which of the companies you're viewing very very closely and which are the companies that you're kind of glancing at once a year and so I I would say that you know it's a cursory glance at maybe 600 companies but intensive study on maybe five to ten to twenty”

0.32

In India, companies like CRISIL could be found in physical locations like Nariman Point in Mumbai, but the investment landscape has changed as modern financial centers like Bandra Corolla with glass towers and major conferences have developed, changing the atmosphere from colonial-era India to modern India.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“20 years ago when I first visited India uh companies like crizzle you would go to a place called narrowman point which is about halfway down the peninsula that is Mumbai and I I was shocked even at the time because uh Finance Finance business tends to happen in kind of gleaming glass towers and with with lots of money around and that's kind of a feeling of downtown Manhattan and that's not narrowman point and uh it was still a different atmosphere in India the atmosphere in India has changed an enormous amount I still felt the kind of impact of of colonial Traditions if you like a more Modern India”

0.29

DH Blair investment bank was shut down for violations of NASD and other rules; they were at best sailing very close to the wind, but a more accurate interpretation was that they were playing fast and loose with the rules, which basically meant ripping off the client.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Guy Spier

“after I left that bank the farm was shut down for violations of nasd and other rules and they were at at best you could say that they were sailing very very close to the wind but a more accurate and probably correct interpretation was that they were playing fast and loose with the rules which basically meant uh ripping off the client”

0.24

In the Duff and Phelps investment, Spier learned that there are different kinds of businesses—some are better than others—and this recognition of business quality differences became foundational to his investment approach.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I'd had a very very successful investment in a company called Duff and Phelps which was a credit rating agency and um uh Duff and Phelps that I I learned through investing in Duff and Phelps that there were different kinds of businesses some businesses were better than others”

0.24

Because the United States is the world's most 'picked over' market, finding opportunities there requires more scrutiny and effort than in less analyzed markets, though great opportunities still exist.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“there have been so many companies I've rejected and you've got to be careful in the United States because it is the world's most picked over Market”

0.19

Spier helped his niece develop confidence in professional networking by having her personally deliver chocolates to finance professionals (including Divya), which created a positive professional experience and taught her about personable door-knocking.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“a few years ago um I uh contrived a fun exercise for my niece to get to know people in the finance industry in New York uh where I emailed a whole bunch of friends and um acquaintances in New York and told them that my niece would personally deliver probably some chocolates some Toblerone chocolates or something”

0.19

Spier wishes he'd continued riding the Duff and Phelps investment longer rather than exiting, because the company had exceptional business qualities and long-term value creation potential.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I was very sad to see the company sold it was sold to Fitch at some point I wish I'd continue could have continued on that ride”

0.19

Spier uses Warren Buffett's concept of 'circle of competence' to organize his thinking and has been influenced by Ben Graham, Warren Buffett, and more recently by Munish Pabrai's approaches to investing.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Guy Spier

“I thought Warren Buffett would not be at this place so it helped me to leave it also helped me to start visiting the Berkshire Hathaway meetings and I started reading the annual reports of companies that Berkshire Hathaway had invested in”

0.17

Spier owns Moody's and Berkshire Hathaway as American investments, among other well-known businesses that he describes as 'extremely well known and understood'.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“I have investments in Moody's and uh in Berkshire Hathaway and some some businesses that are extremely well known and understood”

0.17

Spier doesn't pay a management fee to his investors, which changes his perspective on whether portfolio inactivity is problematic or acceptable.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Guy Spier

“in my case the answer is they're not paying me so there isn't a management fee so I don't feel as bad as about doing it”

0.16

When you have the right passion for something and you act on it, the world opens up a path for you in one way or another, and the resources that you need come to you through some strange combination of dedicating yourself to the idea and then taking the steps in front of you, but then other things happen as if by magic.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Guy Spier

“there's about been about two or three occasions in my life where I felt so passionate that I want to do something that I've lost sleep over it and there's this idea that when you've when you have the right passion and you act on it the world opens up a path for you one way or another and the resources that you need come to you and it's some strange combination of dedicating yourself to the idea of being totally um convinced by the idea and then taking the steps in front of you but then other things happen as if by Magic”

0.13

Spier is working on developing better internal processes for knowledge management and ongoing research on portfolio companies to keep ideas top-of-mind, acknowledging that without systematic processes he's a 'scatterbrain' who loses focus on businesses unless he's deeply interested.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Guy Spier

“you know I'm a scatterbrain Divya I I I'm good at thinking about things but I'm not good at keeping on the on unless I'm super interested in something my brain can go all over the place and to we to to have processes in place which enable me to continue to do in-depth research on particular businesses and bring them up to my mind as both a question of personal Knowledge Management”