What this covers

This is a Rule Classroom Plus session in which Rick Rule is the only speaker, working through questions about resource investing. It begins with the Bre-X fraud. Rule says he avoided it without suspecting a scam. He simply could not build a valuation model for a $7 billion company when he could not establish deposit size, expropriation risk, or construction timing, and could not inspect fresh core. He sold at $10 with warrant coverage while the stock traded at $20-25. He first felt that was a mistake, but the stock went to zero. From there the session turns to method: framing the story first and then testing whether it is true, and running sensitivity analysis on a PEA (Preliminary Economic Assessment)) with downside, base, and upside price cases.

The range after that is wide. Rule goes company by company through gold, silver, copper, uranium, and graphite. He covers Equinox Gold shifting away from Mexico, the Lumina financing, and Seabridge needing a major acquirer for an $8 billion build. He also argues that a Fission–NextGen merger would eliminate $500 million in duplicate infrastructure. He criticizes Bear Creek Mining for moving from exploration into operating a mine. He also discusses the Resolution copper project's 26 years in permitting and Zijin chairman Chen's ability to draw on Chinese state backing. His claim that Russian uranium restrictions are a sideshow rests on commodity fungibility. The germanium and gallium discussion is brief, and he says those markets are too small for him to analyze.

The later part of the session is about positioning for downturns. Rule argues that producers with low decline rates and modest capital needs hold up better than growth pipelines that depend on confidence-driven funding. He treats cash as a negative real yield that is still worth holding short, so that it can be deployed in a liquidity squeeze. He cites Warren Buffett, the Exxon selloff during the COVID oil collapse, and his own aim of buying deposits at under half their value, with a chance at a 10-bagger. His answer to what business he would start today is unexpected: property and casualty insurance and environmental bonding for mining and oil and gas.

Sharpest takeaway

Rule emphasizes that successful investment in mining and resource companies requires disciplined valuation analysis, a willingness to deploy capital during dislocations, and focus on large deposits with identifiable warts selling at substantial discounts to intrinsic value.

  • The Bre-X case shows that valuation discipline (not knowing if a deposit works) matters more than expert opinion or hype
  • Liquidity crunches create spectacular bargains for investors with cash and courage to act when others are afraid
  • Large deposits (10+ billion in reserves) offer asymmetric risk-reward better than small mines or early-stage exploration

The claims · ranked57 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

It is not necessary to predict whether a fraud exists to avoid it; disciplined investors can exit positions based purely on valuation uncertainty and asymmetric information, which serves as protection against both fraud and mispricing.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“I wasn't because I knew it was a scam. I had no idea it was a scam. I just couldn't construct a valuation. And I thought with a $7 billion market cap headed by a reputed liar and a known drunk uh I wasn't rich enough to own the stock.”

0.80

Investors examining investment opportunities should establish a framework of the story first, then determine whether that story is true, using techniques that can be learned and applied systematically.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“understand uh how the process of determining whether or not you want to buy something goes. Uh I thought those were great preliminary discussions and once you establish the framework of a story, uh it's up to you then to determine whether or not that story is true.”

0.74

Bear Creek Mining decided to transition from pure exploration to production, which was problematic because explorers rarely understand how to operate mines well, and Bear Creek has been so busy fixing their small mine that they can't return to exploration, which is what they do well.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“they, as you may recall, decided to cease being purely an exploration company and go into production. The problem with that is that explorers seldom understand how to operate mines well, and that has been their case. It seems to me that they are so busy trying to fix a small mine that they can't get back to doing what they do well, which is explore.”

0.74

In an economic slowdown, companies with low decline rates, good margins, and low capital requirements outperform companies with growth pipelines that require increasing amounts of future capital, because liquidity recedes during slowdowns and confidence-dependent funding becomes unavailable.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“certainly the companies with low decline rates, good margins, uh and low uh capital requirements. One thing that happens in an economic slowdown is that confidence recedes and the consequence of that is that liquidity recedes and companies whose business plan involves the acquisition of increasing amounts of capital that they don't yet have over time are the ones who pay the price in a liquidity squeeze.”

0.74

Warren Buffett's investment approach is to be brave when others are afraid, afraid when others are brave, and to act decisively when confronted with circumstances where the odds are strongly in his favor.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“Buffett says he made his money by being brave when other people were afraid, afraid when other people were brave, and by when he confronted those strange circumstances where the odds were strongly in his favor. Going in. Going in.”

0.70

Russian uranium export restrictions are essentially a sideshow; if Russia restricts sales to US, France, or Germany, that uranium will be sold to China and India instead, and existing Australian and Canadian uranium destined for China and India will be redirected to the US—sanctions don't work due to commodity fungibility.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“this is a side show. Okay. It'll get three or four people excited. The Russians will say we will not sell America or France or Germany uranium. Yeah. So they'll sell that uranium to China and India. Yeah. Okay. And the existing Australian and Canadian uranium that goes to China and India will be sold to the US. Okay. Sanctions don't work.”

0.69

Seabridge Gold is worth more at higher gold prices due to optionality, but the deposit requires $8 billion USD in front-end capital that Seabridge cannot raise and cannot execute due to lack of technical expertise, so they must find a major mining company acquirer.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“Seabridge is an optionality story. Uh it becomes worth more and more with higher and higher gold prices. But understand that the front-end capital cost around that deposit is something like 8 billion US, not Canadian. And understand that the front-end capital cost escalation with inflation is going up every day. Seabridge is not, will not, cannot build this deposit themselves. They don't have access to that much money and they don't have access to the technical expertise to build it.”

0.69

A Fission-NextGen merger would be logical and economically superior to separate development because it would eliminate $500 million in duplicate infrastructure and overhead costs.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“There's no particular sense spending $500 million on duplicate overhead or pardon me, duplicate infrastructure.”

0.66

Holding cash on deposit at even high-paying institutions like Bank of America provides a negative real yield: if you're earning 5% in treasuries while purchasing power is declining at 7.5%, you're actually losing 2.5% per year in real terms, which argues against holding cash on a mathematical basis.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“People need to understand that if you have cash on deposit uh even at high-paying institutions like Battle Bank uh that uh after the decline in purchasing power you have a negative real yield. Uh it's difficult for people to understand that. If you are getting paid like five in treasuries uh in a currency where your purchasing power is declining at seven and a half, you're actually losing two and a half percent a year.”

0.65

When holding cash reserves, investors should keep maturities very short (2 years or less) rather than extending the yield curve, to maintain flexibility for opportunistic deployment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“I would also ask people who are deploying money in cash to keep the maturities very very short. Don't go out the yield curve uh in hopes of a slightly higher yield. Keep your uh keep your maturities at two years or less.”

0.64

Equinox Gold is deemphasizing Mexico in favor of the United States and Canada, reflecting heightened jurisdictional risk selection.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“Equinox, too, uh is also saying to the investment community that they are deemphasizing Mexico in favor of the United States and Canada. In other words, there's some jurisdictional selection going on with regards to Equinox.”

0.64

A billion-dollar Lumina build financed with $250 million in Wheaton Precious Metals streaming capital plus debt of $5-6 billion should be financeable given reasonable gold prices, making the project viable for capable builders.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“if it's a billion-dollar project and you begin with $250 million in streaming capital from Wheaton, uh it is highly likely that the debt markets will give you somewhere between five and six. Uh you don't have to find that much money. Uh so it is certainly financeable in the hands of somebody who can build it.”

0.61

Rio and BHP have been involved in the permitting process for the Resolution copper project in Arizona for 26 years, illustrating that even the largest mining companies face multi-decade permitting timelines.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“two of the largest money companies in the world, uh Rio and BHP have now been involved in the permitting process in Arizona around Resolution for 26 years. Maybe this is the year. We'll see.”

0.60

The Bre-X fraud was avoided by Rule not because he knew it was a scam, but because he could not construct a valuation model for a $7 billion market cap company with a reputed liar and known drunk as CEO when he couldn't determine deposit size, government expropriation risk, construction timeline, or inspect fresh core samples—demonstrating that valuation discipline is more reliable than trying to detect fraud.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“I literally woke up at 2:00 in the morning. Hmm. And I figured out that Bre-X had a market cap of like 6 and 1/2 billion dollars. And I didn't know how big the deposit was. Nobody did. I didn't know how much of it the Indian government Indonesian government prepared was prepared to steal. I didn't know how to construct a net present value model on it because I didn't know what the start date would be. And I knew that nobody was allowed to look at fresh core.”

0.56

Gallium and germanium markets are too small for Rule to meaningfully analyze; however, significant gallium and germanium can be captured from existing porphyry copper product streams but hasn't been captured because doing so could collapse those specialty metal markets.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“The germanium market is too small for me to comment on. Gallium and germanium are, of course, um specialty metals. They're involved in a whole bunch of microelectronics applications. I I will say that there is a fair amount of gallium and germanium that can be uh captured from existing uh porphyry copper product streams. It hasn't been captured because capturing all of it, relative to the size of the current gallium and germanium market, could collapse those markets.”

0.56

Rule sold Bre-X stock at $10 (with $1.50 warrant coverage) when it was trading at $20-25 per share, which he initially felt was a mistake, but was actually correct because the stock eventually went to zero; the warrant exercise at $1.50 sold at $220 per share demonstrates that proper risk management (getting capital back early in a 10-bagger) outperforms holding for the full move.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“anytime you get a 10-bagger, especially if you got full warrant coverage, you ought to get your capital out, which I did. Yeah. But I thought at the time it was a mistake. Uh and I remember a couple clients, including my great friend Jim Blanchard Orleans, uh emailing me when it was uh at 20 bucks or 25 bucks joking about snatching defeat from the jaws of victory around my stock sale at 10.”

0.56

In 2021, uranium PEAs used $50 per pound uranium prices in valuation models, which Rule found useful data even though the actual market price was lower, because he believed the market-clearing price for uranium was $60, making the company valuations informative even if not predictive of near-term returns.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“I remember in 2021 when people were using $50 a pound uranium uh in their PEAs. And I understood that. The price wasn't selling anywhere near 50, but it was useful to me to see what the deposit would be worth at $50. Because I believe that the market-clearing price of uranium was 60.”

0.56

When doing sensitivity analysis on Preliminary Economic Assessments (PEAs), investors should run three cases: a downside case using prices below current prices, a base case using current prices, and an upside case using prices that would allow current producers to earn their cost of capital—and the goal is always to get closer to the right answer, not to achieve the right answer.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“when I do sensitivity analysis uh I I stress uh a deposit with prices below current prices. I use current prices. And then I use an upside case that reflects my own view of the price of a material that would be necessary for all of today's producers to earn their cost of capital. And so, in the course of doing the sensitivity analysis on PEA on PEAs, you actually need to run three sensitivity analysis. Uh And you have to understand, too, that you never get the right answer. Yeah. The idea is to get closer to the right answer than you were when you began the exercise.”

0.56

The downside risks of development-stage mining investments include: (1) execution is not the founder's day job; (2) company's claims are uncertain; (3) investors must endure 5+ years of waiting; (4) investors face volatility (not the same as risk); (5) bad markets exist alongside good markets; (6) share price can decline further despite good fundamentals—requiring sufficient confidence in your valuation to weather these storms.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“What are the downsides here? Well, it's not Ross Beaty's day job. Uh I don't know that what he says is true is true, although I believe it to be true. Uh the biggest downside for most people is that they have to subject themselves to five years of waiting for the 10-bagger. They have to subject themselves to volatility, which is not the same as risk. They have to subject themselves to risk, too. They have to sell subject themselves to the possibilities of bad markets as well as good markets. It's not an impossible, just because the company's gone from having a 650 million market cap to a 200 million market cap, that it couldn't fall some more. And you have to have enough confidence in your assessment of the value that you're willing to weather those storms.”

0.56

During the COVID-induced oil demand collapse, oil fell to briefly sub-zero and then $20/bbl while the industry required $60/bbl to earn their cost of capital; simultaneously, Exxon was kicked out of the Dow 30 forcing all index funds to sell Exxon into a market with no bid; Rule waited for Exxon to get cheaper (a "felony stupid" decision) because sometimes things are cheap enough that you should buy rather than wait for further declines.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“COVID reduced oil demand to the extent that oil was selling for briefly sub-zero before leveling out at $20 a barrel. Uh in a world where the industry required $60 a barrel to earn their cost of capital. I remember simultaneously with that Exxon getting kicked out of the Dow 30. And so every index fund in the world had to sell Exxon into a market where there was no bid for it because the oil price fell. And I kept waiting for Exxon to get stoop cheaper. This was really felony stupid. Sometimes stuff is cheap enough. So I would encourage people if you see circumstances that are really truly anomalously cheap not to wait for it to get cheaper. Just to go on in.”

0.53

Rule frames his investment approach as buying shares of deposits selling for less than half of what he thinks they're worth, believing the company's value could double within two years, and having a legitimate chance at a 10-bagger within five years—a framework he applies to development-stage projects with obvious and identifiable risks.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“I said in order for me to take risk, I want to buy a company that's selling for less than half of what I think it's worth. Well, let's look at Lumina. If you take Ross at face value, uh PEA billion three, market capitalization 200 million. Check. Got that. I have to believe that what the company's worth could double within two years. In other words, uh I have to believe it's selling for half what it's worth today, and I have to believe that it could be worth twice as much two years from now as it is today, which is to say a four-bagger. Check. I got that. You update in terms of knowledge from a PEA to PFS, you've done that. You've increased your knowledge of the deposit a ton. Finally, I have to believe that over five years I have a legitimate chance at a 10-bagger.”

0.52

Chairman Chen of Zijin Mining is smart at navigating difficult situations internationally, can call upon moral and state resources of the Chinese government to negotiate favorable fiscal stability agreements, and is attracting as an investor because of this capability.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“I've watched him uh go around the world and make difficult situations work. I've watched him as an investor. I've watched him as a value-added investor. And in particular, I've watched Chairman Chen be able to call on the um moral resources, if that's the right word, of the Chinese state, uh using the power of the Chinese state to affect reasonable fiscal stability agreements in various jurisdictions around the world.”

0.52

Permitting challenges for mining projects are increasing because companies base their permitting strategies on regulatory regimes from 10 years ago, but those regimes no longer exist in the present regulatory environment.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“permitting challenges are increasing. Uh companies put out their best effort Yes, with regards to permitting. But it's based on the permitting regime that existed 10 years ago. And those regimes don't exist today.”

0.52

If starting a mining business today, Rule's first choice would be to build a property and casualty insurance and environmental bonding business focused on remediation for mining and oil and gas sectors, because environmental liens hold senior secured creditor status.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“If, knowing what I know today, I was starting out today, I would build a property and casualty business and environmental bonding and remediation business in oil and gas and mining. Uh in other words, I would provide insurance services to the mining and oil and gas company... I've learned as a lender that uh actually the bondholder the lienholder for environmental purposes is senior secured, no matter what.”

0.52

Some mining company management teams pay themselves twice: once through general and administrative (G&A) expense for running the company, and again by billing geological or engineering time to project-level costs, effectively loading compensation costs onto individual projects.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“even worse, many managers pay themselves twice. Uh which is to say they pay themselves in the general and administrative expense for running the company and then they also bill geological or engineering time to the company. So that they pay themselves at the project level and at the company level.”

0.52

There are numerous porphyry copper deposits in the Western Cordillera that could theoretically have recovery circuits added to capture rhodium, gallium, germanium, and other specialty metals ending in 'ium'.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“There's a lot of porphyry deposits some producing copper porphyry deposits uh in the Western Cordillera that you could uh put uh a a product recovery cycle on and theoretically capture uh rhodium, gallium, germanium, all that stuff that ends with IUM.”

0.52

In a recession and liquidity squeeze, there will be spectacular bargains available for investors with cash and courage; Rule remembers the money made deploying capital in 2009 after the 2008 collapse with real fondness, and expects similar opportunities will emerge from future downturns.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I remember the money that I made in 2009 after the 2008 collapse and I remember it with real fondness. I don't know which companies will uh exhibit the best relationship between price and value. But to the extent that we have uh a recession and a liquidity squeeze uh there will be spectacular bargains to be had.”

0.51

The molybdenum market experienced a price surge during which the world feared shortage; three or four major copper producers then added molybdenum recovery circuits to their porphyry copper operations and obliterated the molybdenum market through supply flooding.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I remember when the molybdenum price was on a scare and the world was going to run out of molybdenum, and three or four big copper producers put molybdenum recovery circuits on the back of their copper porphyry product streams and obliterated the molybdenum market. And the molybdenum market's pretty big market.”

0.50

For investors with risk tolerance and work capacity, exploration-stage companies offer the best risk-adjusted returns because valuations are exceptionally cheap and the sector is widely despised.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“In today's market, the royalty and streaming companies offer reasonably good value, but I would suggest that for investors who can take risk and who will do the work, that the sector that you want to be in is exploration because everybody hates it and the valuations are insanely cheap.”

0.49

China General Nuclear (CGN) opposing the Fission Paladin merger is a tactical move to get a seat at the negotiation table; the Canadian government has zero chance of allowing CGN to control the deposit due to political sensitivities, so CGN's real objective is offtake rights, minority equity, and influence over the inevitable merger of Fission and NextGen.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“I happen to know and I won't describe all of how I know that CGN believes that Fission and NextGen should merge. And that those two deposits should be developed as one. They're right in that. Uh there's no particular sense spending $500 million on duplicate overhead or pardon me, duplicate infrastructure. And my suspicion is that this is a tactical move on the part of CGN so that they get a seat in the table, offtake, uh minority equity position, something in what they see as the inevitable amalgamation of NextGen uh and Fission.”

0.48

Occidental Petroleum made a strategic decision 10-15 years ago (before it was popular) to focus on long-lived, shallow reserve decline US onshore basins, which proved to be an absolutely brilliant decision with technological advancement.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“What's attractive with Occidental is that they made the decision 10 or 15 years ago, before it was popular, to focus on long-lived shallow reserve decline US onshore basins. And that turns out, with the advance of technology, to have been an absolutely brilliant decision.”

0.48

Energy Fuels has small deposits, which Rule dislikes; however, the market will like Energy Fuels because they are primarily US-based deposits that will likely receive welfare (subsidies) from US taxpayers, though Rule prefers larger deposit bases and owns Uranium Energy Corp instead for aggregate resource size.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I think the market will like energy fuels. I don't own energy fuels because I don't like small deposits. Uh I think the market will like the fact that they are primarily US deposits. I like the I think the fact the market will like the fact that they will likely receive welfare from US taxpayers.”

0.48

Craig Parry at Vizsla Silver is in the sweet spot with regards to exploration; Vizsla understands the genesis of the deposit and stratigraphy, their drilling has become predictive, and they are using capital effectively to add ounces very quickly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“He is in the sweet spot with regards to exploration. He's going to be able to add ounces very, very, very quickly because they understand the genesis of the deposit, they understand the stratigraphy. Their drilling has become predictive. And they are going to be using a ton of money drilling that deposit.”

0.48

Occidental had financial challenges around the Anadarko acquisition and balance sheet/investor confidence challenges; the CEO showed Buffett the value in Occidental's grade-A undeveloped locations; Buffett recognized that oil and gas were universally hated and that Occidental's challenges could be fixed through his involvement, leading him to make a large investment rather than a toehold position.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“Occidental had financial challenges around the acquisition of Anadarko. They had balance sheet challenges. They had investor confidence challenges. The woman who ran Occidental showed the value inherent in those A-grade locations to Buffett. Both in the Permian and up in the Anadarko. Uh he looked at the fact that everybody hated oil and gas. He looked at the fact that there were challenges around Occidental, confidence challenges, that he could fix by getting involved. And he didn't buy a toehold.”

0.47

The more significant constraint from Russian uranium export restrictions would be enriched uranium; Russians control ~50% of global fuel enrichment and re-enrichment services, so if this trade were blocked, utilities would have to overblend (burn higher-quality fuel) rather than downblending Russian-enriched material.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“what would be affected in the near term would be uh enriched uranium. Uh and what would happen is that the utilities would have to overblend. Which is to say they'd have to burn more fuel of higher quality because [clears throat] the Russians' market share uh in fuel and re-enrichment is up around 50%.”

0.47

Seabridge is spending $200 million on pre-works to maintain project continuity and regulatory approval (demonstrating to BC government and Taltan Nation that the project is 'substantially started'), which keeps their claim alive while they wait for a major miner to become a buyer.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“Seabridge is spending $200 million on pre-works on the project so that the BC government and the Taltan Nation will describe the project as substantially started, which maintains Seabridge interest in the project.”

0.46

Rule doesn't have deep experience in the rutile market and has actively avoided the graphite market for most of his career; therefore his ability to assess Sovereign Metals is limited by his own knowledge gaps, not the deposit's characteristics, though the deposit is huge with at least two payable products.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Rick Rule

“I would also like to see some data that I understand. Understand now that the problem is me, not them. In other words, I need them to increase my knowledge of the variability of uh material and grade inside the deposit. And how they manage that variability. Uh the wonderful news is it's a huge deposit. And it's a deposit that has at least two payable products. Uh the bad news is that I don't understand [laughter] the deposit. Uh and as I say, it isn't the deposit's fault, it's mine. But given that I don't have deep experience in the rutile market and I've actively avoided the graphite market for most of my career uh the challenge will be in educating me.”

0.43

Bear Creek Mining has two very large, albeit very low-grade, silver deposits as a hedge; if silver prices rise significantly, the market will value those resources regardless of Bear Creek's operational challenges with their small mine.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rick Rule

“the backside of Bear Creek, however, is that they have two very large, albeit very low-grade, silver deposits. If the silver takes off, I'm not saying it will, I'm not saying it it won't, but if silver takes off, the market won't care very much uh about my fears around the mechanics of their operating mine. And it'll take a look at their silver resources and the optionality it opens up.”

0.42

Occidental Petroleum is second in the United States after Exxon in so-called grade A undeveloped locations (which can be drilled using today's costs and today's oil prices at 50% or greater internal rates of return), and Occidental's inventory is ahead of Chevron's.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“As I understand it, Occidental uh is second in the United States after Exxon in uh so-called uh grade A undeveloped locations, which is to say locations that can be uh drilled using today's costs and today's oil prices at 50% internal rates of return or greater. And my understanding is that Occidental's inventory of said locations is the second best in the industries after Exxon's and ahead of Chevron's. Uh I haven't independently verified that. Uh I got that from a research note.”

0.42

Rio Tinto may acquire Sovereign Metals entirely, which would resolve investor uncertainty; Rio has experience in rutile and graphite, significant experience in sub-Saharan Africa operations, and already has a material stake in Sovereign Metals.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“It might be that Rio puts us all out of our misery. It might be that Rio just goes ahead and snaps up the whole thing. Uh they have a lot of experience in the rutile business and a fair bit of experience in graphite and a lot of experience operating in sub-Saharan Africa uh as well as having uh more than a toehold in the company.”

0.39

Newmont is the odds-on favorite to acquire Seabridge because they are active in the district (owning Pretium/Brucejack and Red Chris deposits) and already have scale presence, providing competitive advantage for integration.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“The odds-on favorite, according to the market, is uh Newmont, which is active in the district as a consequence of owning uh the Pretium deposit Brucejack and also um owning Red Chris, uh a copper-gold mine in the same district. So, the odds-on betting is that Newmont is the ultimate acquirer, since they're already in the district in scale.”

0.39

Equinox Gold's likely next move is to attempt an amalgamation with a smaller existing producer to reach the 1 million-ounce production threshold before undertaking another greenfield build.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“my suspicion is that the next thing that you see Lumina uh pardon me, the next thing that you see Equinox do is attempt to do an amalgamation with a smaller company that's already a producer. They would like to get themselves over the million-ounce threshold before they undertake another build.”

0.39

Occidental Petroleum is downgraded to 5 on valuation as the stock experiences strong price momentum from Buffett's buying, while fundamental valuations decline in line with oil price movements.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I have downgraded Occidental to a five on valuation. So many people are buying it that the stock is on a tear. Uh while the valuations that I have to give it are declining with the oil price.”

0.17

Metallurgy is a significant unanswered question for Meteor Resources' project; while the process is not exotic, separating the pay element material from waste is complex, initial metallurgical results are good, but the company still needs to optimize economic recovery and tailor the product to specific customer needs.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“Yes. Yes. Uh this isn't an exotic process at all. But in terms of separating out uh the pay element material from the rest of the material, uh process is always what these deposits are about. The initial metallurgical results are quite good. Uh but the company still has a lot of work to do uh both in terms of economic recovery of material and also uh producing a material that's uh geared to the specific needs of customers for the material.”

0.17

Rule can detect compensation accounting shenanigans because of his experience as a 71-year-old credit analyst, indicating that deep domain experience is necessary to identify when companies obscure cost structures.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“It's kind of tough to throw that kind of shenanigan uh you know, past a 71-year-old credit analyst. [laughter] I expect I expect it and I look for it.”

0.17

Riley Exploration and InPlay Oil are typical growth-pipeline companies; Pinecliff is typical of low-decline, low-capex gas companies; and Occidental has explicitly focused on long-lived, shallow reserve decline, low-decline US onshore basins.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Rick Rule

“companies with a growth pipeline like Riley Exploration Permian or companies with low decline rates and low sustaining capex such as Pinecliff in the gas sector or InPlay in the oil sector”

0.13

Meteor Resources is currently ranked 4 with potential upgrade to 3 following recent share price decline, and Rule is inviting them to attend the Tier One Bootcamp.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I have them at a four and I am looking perhaps to raise them to a three. I'm also inviting them, although they they've not yet accepted, to the Tier One Bootcamp, which is upcoming.”

0.13

Whatever the name of the government act, the opposite of what it purports to do is what it actually accomplishes; Rule cites the Inflation Reduction Act as an example—named to reduce inflation but actually subsidizing uranium and other sectors.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“The ironically named Inflation Reduction Act will go to subsidize some of these. Outrageous. [laughter] I've said that you basically take the whatever the name of the act is, the opposite of it is what it actually does.”

0.13

Arizona Sonoran Copper's PEA project has been upgraded by Rule from a ranking of six to five, but he has not yet run sensitivity analysis on the PEA and is hoping Joe Mazumdar will publish that analysis to avoid doing it himself.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“I have Arizona Sonoran as a five now, upgraded from a six. Uh I have seen the PEA. I have not run the sensitivity analysis on the PEA. I'm hoping uh my lazy self is hoping that Joe Mazumdar will do that uh and publish it in Exploration Insights so that I don't have to.”

0.13

Vizsla Silver has backed off its ranking from four to five because the company needs to digest recent stock issuance ($65 million bought deal that just closed), market cap doubled in the last 12 months, and Rule loves the deposit and Craig Parry as management, but the higher valuation no longer supports the lower ranking.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I have backed off my ranking from four to five for two reasons. Uh one, we have to digest a bunch more stock, and the market cap just went up $65 million having doubled in the last 12 months. I love that deposit. Uh I have a a lot of time for Craig Parry. I'm less afraid of Mexico relative to places like Arizona than other people are. So, my backwards ranking just has to do with the fact that the price is a lot higher than it used to be.”

0.13

Rule's views on uranium have shifted dramatically over five years: five years ago, the administration borderline wanted to jail him for uranium interest; now they want to subsidize him, which makes him feel he was more honest then than now.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“If you look at the outlook of the administration over five years with regards to uranium, being interested in uranium five years ago, they sort of borderline wanted to jail me. Now they want to subsidize me. Uh I felt more honest then. Right.”

0.13

Rule has taken money off the table from speculative positions that achieved 2-3 year anticipated gains faster than expected in the last 12 months, while simultaneously finding private placement terms insufficiently generous (inadequate warrant coverage) to deploy that cash, creating a virtuous circle of available capital.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“I also am in the position last 12 months where some of my speculative purchases have given me gains that I anticipated would take two or three years to achieve. And I've been taking money off of the situation you know, off the table in those circumstances. While at the same time the terms and conditions that accompany the private placements that I thought I would be cycling the money into haven't been generous enough with regards to warrants for me to write checks.”

0.13

Rule holds higher cash balances than he would prefer due to liquidity events in the last two years; however, he doesn't want to discuss specific percentages of portfolio allocation to cash.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“I have too much of my portfolio in cash. Um I don't regard myself as an economist. I regard myself as a credit analyst. I've had a couple of liquidity events in the last two years that means that the cash portion of my portfolio is larger than I would like it to be. Um I'll leave it there. I don't want to talk about it exact percentages.”

0.13

Rule does not own Bear Creek Mining but has owned and traded it well historically, and believes the company needs to resolve operating mine difficulties and free management from fixing the production asset to recover operational excellence.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“I do not own Bear Creek, although I've owned a lot in the past and treated it traded it very well. Uh they need to resolve the difficulty that they have with this producing project, and they need to free themselves from the time fixing it is taking.”

0.13

West Red Lake Gold is ranked 5; if substantial de-risking progress accompanies share price increases, ranking will be improved to 4; if exploration tightens resource estimates, ranking could improve to 4; the company is backed by Frank Giustra, who is relentless and disciplined.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“I have it as a five. Uh if I don't see substantial progress in de-risking the project with its share price increasing, I'll probably have to lower it to six... I'm delighted by the fact that the company is backed by um Frank Giustra, who I've known for a very long time and who I knew will not quit. [laughter] He's relentless, this guy.”

0.13

The Tier One Assets Bootcamp will focus on companies with 10-30 billion dollars in situ recoverable reserves/resources at current commodity prices, benefiting from certainty rather than mere commodity price appreciation.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“we want to be talking to companies that have 10 billion or 20 billion or 30 billion dollars in situ recoverable reserves and resources at today's commodity prices uh that will benefit from certainty as opposed merely to higher commodity prices.”

0.13

Arizona Gold and Silver is ranked 5, and Rule has expressed interest in participating in the announced private placement based on attractive terms, awaiting confirmation from company brokers (including Sprott).

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Rick Rule

“Uh I have Arizona Gold and Silver as a five. I haven't done the sensitivity analysis around the PEA as discussed earlier today. Uh given that I fact I think the terms of the private placement are relatively attractive, I have given an expression of interest to participate.”