
Great Authors - Literature of Ancient Greece and Jerusalem - Aristophanes and Very Old Jokes
What this covers
This is a single lecture by Michael Sugrue on Aristophanes, built mostly around Clouds, with Lysistrata as a second reference point. It begins from comedy as a genre: it tends to portray types rather than individuals, and its plots usually move from a breakdown of moral order to a restored one, often with a happy ending. Sugrue sets this against tragedy, noting that Oedipus and Hamlet still produce suspense on repeated viewings, and asks what that implies about the human condition. He also treats the didactic and cathartic functions of laughter as serious ones.
The Clouds material covers the plot and its targets. Strepsiades, an indebted father who stands for fraying old Athenian values, enrolls at the thinkery of Socrates. There he meets a doctrine in which Zeus is displaced by vortex, a satire of the pre-Socratic physicists. The chorus of Clouds embodies the nebulous quality of abstract philosophy, and rhetoric is taught through hair-splitting over grammatical gender. Sugrue stresses that this Socrates is not the historical figure but a stand-in for the whole Sophistic movement. The ending is ironic: Strepsiades sees clearly and burns the school, but he has already been declared incompetent.
The lecture also takes up the wider context and some contested judgments. Aristophanes belonged to the peace party during the Peloponnesian War, and Sugrue finds an uneasy quality in great comedy being written while Athens faced destruction. He explains the parabasis, in which the poet addresses the audience directly. He notes that Socrates named a comic poet among his accusers in the Apology, and that Plato answered in the Symposium by portraying Aristophanes as a lustful buffoon. Sugrue's own verdict is blunt: Aristophanes was a conservative, not a deep thinker, and could not tell Socrates from the charlatans. His lasting value lies in comic craft, such as the phallus gag in Lysistrata, which still works without historical background.
Aristophanes' Old Comedy, exemplified by *Clouds*, is serious didactic drama that entertains while morally instructing through humor about universal human flaws and social transgressions, making 2,500-year-old jokes perpetually funny because they target permanent features of the human condition rather than fleeting trends.
- Some humor bears repeating across centuries because it targets recurring human mistakes and moral imperfections rather than time-bound facts
- Aristophanes uses comedy (satire, parody, slapstick, obscenity) to critique intellectual and political corruption, particularly sophistry and the undermining of traditional moral order
- The enduring greatness of Aristophanes lies not in his political effectiveness or intellectual depth but in his mastery of comedy as an art form that continues to make audiences laugh
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Socrates himself, in his apology speech, identified Aristophanes as one of his major accusers, citing a comic poet's lampooning as contributing to conservative Athenians' mistaken identification of Socrates as a corrupter of youth.
“in socrates apology when he is about to be condemned to death and when he tries to explain what his life has all been about he says one of the most important of my accusers apart from politicians and other vermin running running athens is a certain comic poet and clearly what he has in mind is aristophanes lampooning socrates trying to conflate him with people that he really despises”
Comedy typically depicts types of people or character archetypes (arrogant wealthy, inexperienced young) rather than individualized protagonists, allowing the humorous situations to represent generalizable human flaws rather than specific personal circumstances.
“most of comedy is not about individual people specific people it's about types of people arrogance in the wealthy is funny especially when they get foiled at the end inexperienced in the young is funny especially when you know they get their comeuppance... the flaws we see in various types of people can be the occasion for humor”
Comedy is serious didactic genre that both entertains and informs audiences, making it one of the more educationally purposeful forms of literature.
“comedy is pretty serious stuff and that although it entertains us it also informs us and it is one of the more didactic genres of literature”
Great tragedies like Hamlet and Oedipus produce sustained emotional responses (suspense, worry, anxiety) even after repeated viewings, suggesting they connect to something either permanent in the human condition or changing so slowly as to be imperceptible across historical time.
“every time i go and see hamlet a play i know very well i feel suspense i feel worry i feel anxiety even though i know everybody dies at the end... something about hamlet speaks to something either permanent in the human condition or something that moves and changes so slowly that the transformation is imperceptible across historical time”
In *Clouds*, Socrates is portrayed not as the actual historical Socrates of Plato's dialogues or Xenophon's writings, but as a clearly bad man and corrupter of Athens, conflated with the entire Sophistic movement because Aristophanes could not distinguish between different sophistic figures.
“socrates in the clouds is not the socrates we see as we see in plato's dialogues it's not the socrates that we see and say the writings of xenophon the socrates here is a clearly bad man he's clearly a corrupter of athens he's clearly one of the sources of athens difficulties socrates represents the entire sophistic movement in the clouds because aristophanes can't tell any difference between one sophist and another”
Aristophanes uses parabasis, a technique in which a character steps out of the action of the play and addresses the audience directly, to editoriialize about politics and morals, breaking the distinction between representation and audience and allowing him to lobby for his own play's success.
“the clouds engage in what is called parabasis now this is an important thing if you're going to understand aristophanic comedy parabasis is a particular technique by which one of the characters in a play steps out of the action of the play and addresses the audience directly um and it's restricted for the most part to comedy and aristophanes makes good use of it but you occasionally see it in other even contemporary playwrights think of something like bertolt brecht right in which someone will direct directly talk to you what it does is sort of undo the distinction between representation and the audience he says well let me tell you what's really going on here let me address you outside of the action of the play”
Plato wrote a response to Aristophanes' attack on Socrates in the *Symposium*, wherein Plato portrays Aristophanes as a swine, stupid buffoon, and pig who lurches from one lust and passion to another, while presenting a highly laudatory image of Socrates.
“most of which are unmerited but on the other hand if any of you read the symposium you know the dialogue where plato has a go at aristophanes well he writes a sort of reply to this or in other words they sort of balance each other out plato's representation of socrates is highly laudatory and his representation of aristophanes is that aristophanes is a swine a stupid buffoon a pig who lurches from one lust and passion to another”
Aristophanic comedy is inherently didactic in nature, and Aristophanes consistently editorializes and inserts his own moral and political views into his plays because he finds it impossible to avoid doing so.
“aristophanes comedy like most comedy is a very didactic genre it tries to teach us something aristophanes like many comedians finds it impossible to avoid editorializing in his comedies”
Certain humor is permanently funny because it addresses recurring flaws and imperfections in the human condition that people make repeatedly in every generation, making such jokes both informative and capable of providing catharsis through laughter rather than pity and fear.
“some things are permanently funny in other words that there are certain flaws or imperfections in the human condition certain mistakes that people make repeatedly in every generation that bear repeating because they are both informative and humorous you get a sort of catharsis out of it you laugh instead of have the pity and fear that we get with tragedy”
Athens in the Peloponnesian War period was in a 'macabre situation' with Aristophanes churning out great comedies while his city faced military destruction, creating an 'uneasy feeling' as people laugh while civilization decays.
“it's a kind of macabre situation because remember that he's an athenian and then athens is involved in in a war that ultimately is going to result in the destruction of that city and at the same time aristophanes is churning out some of the greatest comedies ever written so laughing while the ship sinks right gives us a certain uneasy feeling”
Socrates teaches at his school a doctrine in which Zeus does not exist and vortex (a natural whirlpool mechanism) is the only god, representing Aristophanes' satire of pre-Socratic physicists' displacement of traditional mythology with mechanistic natural explanations.
“socrates comes back and says zeus oh you're such a blockhead i can't teach you anything there's no such thing as zeus no no no no now vortex is the only real god zeus so we gave up on that long ago we believe in the clouds they're divine we believe in vortex we believe in a number of natural things as being somehow divine but we don't believe in zeus or any of that hogwash come on that's for old fogies like you”
Lysistrata is a play about Athenian and Spartan women going on a sex strike to force men to stop the Peloponnesian War, and the basic premise is intrinsically funny because it targets a permanent feature of human sexual nature and male-female relations.
“aristophanes is a contemporary of thucydides and socrates he lives uh during the golden age of athens and during the peloponnesian war the athenian women and the spartan women go on a sex strike so they can make the men stop the war now i see some of you laughing kind of smiling that's an intrinsically funny idea the idea that women aren't going to have sex until men give up war that's a funny thought the problem is it's 2500 years old if you see what i'm saying and every time i see that play i think it's funny and it taps into something that's true and permanently humorous”
The phallic sight gag in *Lysistrata*—where a character enters wearing a two-foot phallus strapped to his loins—is one of the oldest and most effective sight gags in the world, remaining consistently funny across 2,500 years.
“in this estrada one of the one of the players comes on wearing a two-foot phallus strapped to his loins and as soon as he steps out on stage it is one of the oldest and most effective sight gags in the world people always laugh they laughed 2500 years ago they laughed ever since and they laugh now and if they put on a production of lysistrata next week and somebody steps out with a two foot phallus strapped to his loins everybody will laugh the whole audience will break up why because we've got something here that touches all of us in a kind of permanent way”
Aristophanes was part of the peace party during the Peloponnesian War and used satire and comedy as a persuasive tool, arguing that satire would persuade the audience that war is an evil and waste of time more effectively than would a sermon or straightforward argument.
“he's very much a part of the peace party he writes plays about peace he writes plays about people that make their own separate peace with the spartans he says essentially look war is a tragic and miserable waste of time i don't want to write a kind of sermon for you because that doesn't persuade people as well as comedy does if i were to persuade you that war is an evil thing that it's a waste of time that we ought to withdraw from the peloponnesian war insofar as it's possible he does it by satire by making fun of things he opposes”
In *Clouds*, the Clouds function as a chorus that represents the ethereal, abstract, and nebulous quality of Platonic forms and socratic philosophy, with the clouds as divine entities replacing the traditional gods that Socrates rejects.
“the clouds form a sort of chorus in this play and they are kind of divinities for socrates and the clouds in are representative or symbolic of the flights of abstraction characteristic of socratic philosophy if any of you know platonism if you know plato's theory of forms the idea that there's a an ethereal insubstantial reality that all the all the physical world participates in and is connected to the clouds are a very nice representation of the fuzziness the kind of nebulous quality of those abstractions and he says naturally socrates worships the clouds he doesn't believe in zeus vortex is king now and while vortex is king we might as well go for something tangible yet almost celestial like the clouds”
Aristophanes uses a variety of comic techniques—body language, obscene and dirty jokes, slapstick comedy, irony, and parody—with the intention of morally improving society and setting Athens back on track in the old way.
“much of comedy can be seen as an attempt to morally improve society sometimes it has kind of uh progressive or radical implications but in the case of aristophanes it has conservative implications he's using body language obscene dirty jokes slapstick comedy irony parody all kinds of stuff with the intention of setting athens back on track in the old way”
Strepsiades finally sees the light and recognizes Socrates as what he truly is—a corrupter of Athens and representative of a rationalistic tradition that undermines morality—and decides to burn down the think tank with fire, symbolically destroying the sophistic corruption.
“strep societies finally sees the light he says he's going to go beat his own mother i can't believe that i was so foolish as to do something like that so he asked the clouds what should i do and he says and the clouds say to him because the chorus is always there at opportune times says well first of all you shouldn't have tried to get out from under your debts you know that you're a wicked man too corruption isn't restricted to these philosophers it's also gotten right to the marrow and fiber of athenian society and you're a good example of it pay your debts stop trying to weasel out of them number one number two perhaps you should go for a little payback perhaps that would work well for you so what at the end what strip societies decides to do is go over to the thinkery or the think tank and burn it down”
Socrates teaches rhetoric through hair-splitting analysis of grammatical genders and other minute distinctions, exemplifying Aristophanes' view that sophistic philosophy is composed of trivial, meaningless word games rather than genuine wisdom.
“i have to teach you about metrics and i have to teach you about aristic and i have to teach you what the difference is between a trough and a trophet there are genders in the greek language”
In comedy, the action typically involves a transgression or breakdown of moral order, followed by a restoration and reestablishment of that order at the end, usually resulting in a happy ending, demonstrating the importance of maintaining moral norms.
“what we find in many comedies and particularly in many of the companies of aristophanes is that they involve the the imperfections of human beings and transgressions of moral order moral order is broken down and then is brought back at the end usually as a rule in comedy we get a happy ending unless we get a kind of particularly perverse comedy and this happy ending always involves the reconfiguration of the re-establishment of the moral order that had been transgressed if nobody made any mistakes there wouldn't be any comedies comedy always involves some kind of transgression always involves some kind of limitation always involves some kind of mistakes”
Aristophanes' intellectual positions are hidebound and conservative with many unattractive ideas, and he lacked the native wit to distinguish between genuinely important philosophers like Socrates and sophistic charlatans, making him not a profound or deep thinker despite being a gifted writer.
“because to be honest many of the things that aristophanes believes in are most unpleasant i mean not attractive ideas i mean he's a hidebound conservative who doesn't even have the native wit to tell the difference between gorgeous and socrates between thrasymachus and socrates in other words he's not the most sophisticated thinker a gifted writer yes but not a profound or deep thinker”
In *Clouds*, Strepsiades is portrayed as a father representing old Athenian values who has become somewhat corrupt through debt and loss of control over his slaves, son, and wife, indicating that Athenian society is becoming degenerate and the natural traditional order is breaking apart.
“he creates a figure called strep societies who's a father he represents the old athenian values but he's become somewhat corrupt he's been running up big debts he has trouble controlling his slaves he has trouble controlling his son he has trouble controlling his wife indicative of the fact that athenian society is becoming degenerate and corrupt the normal natural traditional order of society is beginning to break apart”
One can understand and enjoy Aristophanes' comedies without any knowledge of Greek history, philosophy, or politics, though contextual knowledge deepens appreciation of his satirical targets.
“it's entirely possible to find aristophanes a very funny comedian without knowing any greek philosophy or any greek history when you place him in the context of ancient greece particularly pericle in athens he makes a lot more sense”
The ending of *Clouds* is ironic: Strepsiades finally achieves moral clarity and sees Socrates and the rationalistic tradition as evil, but it is too late because he has already been legally declared incompetent, so his newfound sanity and wisdom cannot redeem his situation.
“at that point that's the way the play ends one assumes that the son is going to have the father declared legally incompetent but the father is now not incompetent notice the irony he finally sees light understands socrates for what he is understands moral order but it's too late now he's already been declared mad and his madness involves real sanity finally seeing socrates and this entire kind of rationalistic tradition for what it is corruption and evil”
Aristophanes had very little actual effect on public policy despite his political intentions, though the dramatic artistry and comedic brilliance of his plays remain valuable and enduring.
“although it seems that he had rather little effect on public policy and it's entirely possible to find aristophanes a very funny comedian without knowing any greek philosophy or any greek history when you place him in the context of ancient greece particularly pericle in athens he makes a lot more sense”
Aristophanes lived during the Golden Age of Athens and the Peloponnesian War, contemporaneous with Thucydides and Socrates, and was a very conservative political figure who looked back to old Athenian traditions as the best traditions.
“aristophanes is a contemporary of thucydides and socrates he lives uh during the golden age of athens and during the peloponnesian war”
Aristophanes particularly disliked the effect of the Sophists on the young and the effect of the pre-Socratic physicists on the established mythology and religion of the times, viewing both as corrupting forces undermining traditional values.
“he particularly disliked the effect of the sophists on the young and he particularly disliked the effect of the pre-socratic physicists on the established mythology and religion of the times”
Old Comedy, of which Aristophanes is the only surviving example, is characteristic of Periclean Athens and differs in form and content from New Comedy represented by Menander, which appears about a century later.
“well today i'd like to talk about aristophanes and the old comedy that was characteristic of periclean athens now aristophanes is the only example that we have existing of the old comedy and the old comedy is not all that different in time from the new comedy of menander which comes about a century later”
Comic poets in ancient Athens, unlike tragic poets, were required to compose new and original plots rather than adapting established myths, though the plays were still performed as part of religious festivals.
“the tragic plays were given in a festival and they competed one again the treaty tragedians competed against each other during a festival that was religious and orientation the same thing was true of the comedies comic poets used to write plays and unlike the tragic poets the plays they used to write would have to be based upon new and novel plots they weren't they didn't as a rule take ancient established myths like the oedipus myth or something like that and transform it or the electromyth which many of the tragedians handled instead the comic poets put together their own new uh plot lines for their dramas but they were still religious in their orientation”
Aristophanes makes caustic and obscene jokes about homosexuality throughout his plays, representing the old-fashioned conservative countryside society's disapproval, in contrast to the more accepting cosmopolitan elite who viewed male homosexuality as roughly normal.
“it's often been said that athens was very accepting and allowed for homosexual relationships between men and that's true up to a point there's a certain tradition particularly a rather aristocratic elite tradition in which homosexuality was thought of as being roughly speaking normal especially for young men and older men but that's not true of all elements in athenian society the old-fashioned conservative kind of countryside of athenian society hasn't got much use and disapproves of these homosexual relations and there are lots of rather caustic and obscene jokes i mean just dirty jokes about homosexuals not just in this play but throughout the plays of aristophanes”
Aristophanes' plays were performed during the spring fertility festival in honor of Dionysus, the god of theater, wine, and licentiousness, and though the plays often contain obscenity and dirty jokes, they retained this religious orientation.
“it happens during a religious festival and particularly it's the festive it's the spring fertility festival in honor of dionysus and if you remember that dionysus is the god of theater he's also the god of wine all right connected with sex and licentiousness if you think of something like euripides bockeye right he's a chaotic force in the universe”
When Strepsiades observes students of Socrates studying natural philosophy by peering down at the ground on all fours with their butts in the air, the speaker observes this is both a stupid posture and an excellent opportunity for ridicule on stage.
“when he comes in he sees the students not in baskets moving up into the earth they're looking right down on the ground they're kind of on all fours peering into the dirt in the ground and of course if you mention what that's going to look like on stage it's a stupid kind of ignominious posture their butts are in the air their eyes are on the ground they don't know what they're doing and they think this is the deepest stuff around right he's looking for cheap jokes at the expense of his political and kind of moral enemies”
Strepsiades devises a plan to send his son Phidippides to Socrates' think tank to learn the art of avoiding debts, lying, and winning court battles with weaker cases, believing that Socratic teaching provides instruction in how to corrupt the judicial system and renege on debts.
“strep society says i have it i'll get my lazy good for nothing spend thrift son to enroll in socrates think tank or his think shop where it doesn't translate very well into english but his thinking place go to that school learn from socrates and particularly you'll learn the very very important art of how to avoid your debts how to lie how to win court battles even when you have the weaker case rather than stronger case the idea here is that socrates is a professional shyster and he teaches people how to corrupt the judicial system how to renege on their debts and how to undermine the moral order of athens”
Socrates dismisses Strepsiades as too stupid to teach, too old and forgetful to remember lessons, and lacking facility for speech, and refuses to continue his instruction despite Strepsiades' promise to pay him a large sum.
“ultimately soccer he says you know you're just too stupid to teach anything to strip societies you're an old man you forget everything i teach you you really have no facility for speech i don't think you're ever going to make a good shyster so i'm just going to boot you out of my of my school you're not the guy i need and he said oh please i mean i promise that i will pay you a big sum i promised by zeus that if you teach me how to avoid my debts i will pay you a large sum of money”
Aristophanes' plays are brief (approximately 40-50 pages) and translate reasonably well into English, making them more accessible than lengthy philosophical texts despite some loss of wordplay and meter effects in translation.
“one of the nice things about aristophanes is not only that he's witty and funny but also he's brief right it's not like thucydides where you have to wade through four or five hundred pages... aristophanes in and out in 50 pages very very nice and doesn't suffer too much in translation there are some plays on words which don't carry over there are some rhymes and pla and messing with meter and things like that that look in congress and are kind of laughable in the greek you don't get that in the english”
When discussing literature, Phidippides declares that only an unsophisticated country bumpkin would like the old tragedians Aeschylus or Sophocles, and that he prefers Euripides with his tales of incest, showing how Socratic education has corrupted his moral sense.
“the son says only a dunderhead a country bumpkin would like something like that a very unsophisticated taste moral order and things like that me i like euripides i like tales about incest now obviously he's been corrupted obviously i mean not only is the target here socrates but also euripides and that whole kind of humanistic tendency the whole tendency of moving from the divine and the mythological to the human and the merely secular”
Phidippides attacks his father, beating him on stage in a slapstick scene, justifying the violence through Socratic reasoning that if old men beat their sons as punishment, then sons should eventually beat old men in return, subverting the natural filial order.
“philippe says you know now that i think about it i should just start beating my father and he just starts laying it on it's hitting his own father and his father says how now what's this why are you beating me again think about what the sight gags are going to be like here we got slapstick humor here's a son hitting his father on stage it must have cracked the whole audience up it's a funny thing to see and it must have been all kinds of howling and screaming you can see how this is going to be perfect for representation on a stage and the sun says well look i learned from socrates that i should beat my father and that the entire previous order should be upset”