
China Reacts To North Korean Troops In Ukraine | EU-China Trade War | Tesla vs BYD
What this covers
This 13-minute China Update video, narrated by Tony, splits into three segments: North Korean troops fighting alongside Russia, BYD overtaking Tesla in quarterly revenue, and the EU's tariffs on Chinese vehicles. The first part opens with Zelinsky's warning that 10,000 North Korean troops were headed to Russia, then turns to Washington's pressure on Beijing. Sullivan directed an effort to get other countries to raise concerns with China, and Matthew Miller called the moves destabilizing for China's neighbors. Tony notes that officials and analysts doubt Beijing will intervene. He also covers Russian readouts of talks with Le Shing and Wang Yi, which blame US and allied military buildup.
The commentary on China's motives is the most speculative stretch. Bill Bishop asks whether Beijing wants Moscow to stop using North Korean troops or finds them useful for Putin's stability, provided NATO gains no foothold in Asia. He also raises a risk that South Korean arms reaching Ukraine could give Kim Jong Un a pretext for action on the peninsula, possibly bringing more THAAD deployments.
The EV segment is mostly about numbers. BYD's third-quarter revenue of 201.1 billion yuan topped Tesla's, but Tesla's profit is far larger, and BYD's gross margins slipped as subsidy-driven domestic sales climbed. Its hybrid vehicle lineup has cushioned it against weakening demand for fully electric cars.
The last section covers the EU's tariff of up to 45% on Chinese EVs and Beijing's WTO dispute settlement mechanism filing. It also covers threatened retaliation on pork, dairy and brandy, and a Reuters report that China told automakers to hold back investment in countries that backed the duties. That report deepens the split among EU members. The segment also notes Volkswagen's 64% profit drop and the disagreement over whether price undertakings should be negotiated company by company or through a chamber of commerce.
China faces a complex geopolitical and economic situation where North Korean troop deployment to Ukraine, rising EV competition from BYD, and EU tariffs on Chinese vehicles create interconnected pressures that challenge Beijing's influence and strategic interests in both Europe and Asia.
- North Korean involvement in Ukraine links East Asian and European security, complicating China's ability to manage its regional relationships while supporting Russia indirectly
- BYD's revenue surge over Tesla demonstrates China's EV dominance but faces headwinds from EU tariffs and potential retaliatory trade measures
- EU and US tariffs on Chinese vehicles represent protectionist responses that China claims are unfair while Beijing considers retaliation, creating cascading trade friction
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Reuters reported that China has told its automakers to halt big investment in European countries that supported the extra tariffs on Chinese EVs, a move likely to further divide Europe between the 10 EU members supporting tariffs (including France, Poland, and Italy), the 5 members opposing them (including Germany), and the 12 abstaining
“uk-based Reuters in an exclusive report writes today that China has told its automakers to Halt big investment in European countries that support extra tariffs on Chinese built electric vehicles a move likely to to further divide Europe 10 EU members including France Poland and Italy supported tariffs in the vote this month five members including Germany opposed them and 12 abstained”
Beijing wanted a blanket deal to be applied to all companies through a state-backed chamber of commerce, whereas the European Commission preferred to negotiate with individual companies, with negotiations continuing even as tariffs are in place to ensure breaches of price undertaking agreements automatically trigger tariff imposition
“Beijing wanted a blanket deal to be applied to all companies through a state-backed chamber of commerce whereas the European Commission refer to negotiate with individual companies negotiations will continue even as the tariffs are in place this would ensure that any breaches of price undertaking agreements that are reached in the future would automatically trigger the imposition of tariffs”
The US National Security advisor Sullivan directed the US government to engage China and organize an effort to get other countries to reach out to China with concerns about North Korea sending troops to Russia and the destabilizing implications
“a senior official speaking to UK based Outlet CNN for example expressed that the US National Security advisor Sullivan quote directed the US government to engage the PRC and to organize an effort to get other countries to reach out to the PRC as well over concerns about dprk sending troops into Russia and the implications of that end quote”
Russia's Foreign Ministry stated that Le Shing and the Russian Deputy Minister agreed to continue close coordination to create a fair and indivisible security system on the Korean Peninsula and that Washington and its allies should eliminate risks of large-scale armed conflict
“the ministry Sid Leo and the Russian Deputy Minister agreed to continue close coordination to quote create a fear and indivisible security system in quote on the Korean Peninsula saying that Washington and its allies should quote eliminate the risks of a large-scale armed conflict in quote”
BYD has benefited from resurgent domestic demand in China spurred by improved national and local government subsidies aimed at tempting consumers to trade in gas cars for electric vehicles and hybrids, with local sales cushioning BYD against overseas resistance to Chinese car makers' expansion
“byid has also benefited from resurgent domestic demand in China spurred by improved national and local government subsidies aimed at tempting consumers to trade in gas cars for EVS and hybrids those local sales have helped cushion byd against overseas resistance to Chinese car makers expansion”
Europe's automotive industry, which employs nearly 14 million people and accounts for 7% of EU's GDP, is confronting a perfect storm: demand for cars is falling at home and abroad while car makers navigate a risky and expensive multi-year transition from combustion engines to electric propulsion, exacerbated by China whose high-quality, low-cost EVs are now being exported to Europe in greater numbers
“Europe's automotive industry which employs nearly 14 million people and accounts for 7% of eu's GDP is confronting a perfect storm demand for cars is falling at home and abroad while car makers are navigating a risky and expensive multi-year transition from combustion engines to Electric propulsion all these problems are being exacerbated by China whose competition for sales in the once lucrative domestic Market is ferocious whose high quality lowcost EVS are now being exported to Europe in greater numbers”
BYD and Tesla have emerged as leading threats to legacy automakers as the latter struggle with the path to profitability with their EV transitions, particularly as growth in consumer demand for fully electric cars wanes
“byd and Tesla have emerged as leading threats to Legacy automakers particularly as the latter struggle along the path of profitability with their EV transitions as growth in consumer demand for fully electric cars waines”
As of October 17th, Ukrainian president Zelinsky warned that 10,000 North Korean troops were set to be deployed to join Russia's fight against Ukraine, a deployment that has been confirmed by official releases and media reports from South Korea, the United States, and Europe
“on October 17th Ukrainian president zalinsky warned that 10,000 North Korean troops were set to be deployed to join Russia's fight against Ukraine since then a steady stream of official releases and media reports from South Korea the United States and Europe have confirmed the presence of a large number of North Korean soldiers in Russia”
Matthew Miller, spokesperson for the US Department of State, expressed concern that Russia and North Korea's actions represent destabilizing moves by two of China's neighbors, and the US communicated with China that Beijing ought to be concerned about these actions
“Matthew Miller spokesperson for the US Department of State similar expressed quote we've communicated with the PRC about this matter to make clear that we are concerned about it and that they ought to be concerned about about this destabilizing action by two of its neighbors Russia and North Korea end quote”
The presence of several thousand North Korean troops cooperating with the Russian military represents a flagrant violation of the UN Charter and multiple UN Security Council resolutions, according to the European External Action Service
“the European external Action Service the eu's Diplomatic service expressed in an official statement this week quote the presence of several thousand troops cooperating with the Russian military represents a flagrant violation of the UN Charter and of multiple un Security Council resolutions it is a unilateral hostile act by the dprk with serious consequences for European and Global Peace and security end quote”
Volkswagen stressed the urgent need for steeper cost cuts after Europe's largest car maker reported a 64% drop in quarterly net profit from slump in China sales and restructuring charges during the first nine months of the year, with vehicle sales dropped 12% in China and down 1% in Western Europe
“Volkswagen has stressed quote the urgent need end quote for steeper Cost Cuts after Europe's largest car maker reported a 64% drop in quarterly net profit from a slump in China sales and restructuring charges during the first N9 months of the year vehicle sales dropped 12% in China as the group faced competition from local Brands sales in Western Europe were also down 1%”
BYD has been insulated more than Tesla from declining EV demand due to its strong lineup of hybrid vehicles, and BYD comes in third in global market capitalization behind Toyota Motor and ahead of Volkswagen, Mercedes, and Detroit's three car-making giants
“byd has been insulated more than Tesla due to its strong lineup of hybrid vehicles as us-based Outlet Bloomberg explains this week Tesla's AI potential and its lead in fully electric vehicle sales has helped cement its place as the world's most valuable automaker byd comes in third behind Toyota motorco and ahead of VW Mercedes and Detroit's three car making giants”
BYD, Warren Buffett-backed electric vehicle maker, posted higher quarterly revenues than Tesla for the first time, with third-quarter revenues reaching 201.1 billion yuan (28.2 billion USD) compared to Tesla's 25.2 billion USD
“China's biggest electric vehicle maker byd has posted higher quarterly revenues than us rival Tesla for the first time but a rough prolonged price war in its domestic Market dragged on its profitability revenues for the Warren Buffett backed car maker in the third quarter reached 2011 billion yen 28.2 billion surpassing the 25.2 billion Us sales that Tesla reports Ed last week”
Two days before Wang Yi's meeting with the Russian Deputy Foreign Minister, the Russian Deputy Foreign Minister held talks with Le Shing, China's special representative for Korean Peninsula affairs, and both sides expressed concerns over escalation of tensions in the region, blaming the buildup of military activity by the US and its allies
“two days before this meeting the Russian Deputy foreign minister held talks with Leo Shing ch's special representative for Korean Peninsular Affairs according to Russia's foreign Ministry the two express concerns over the escalation of tensions in the region blaming the buildup of military activity by the United States and its allies for frictions”
Michael Pettis, professor of finance at Beijing University, argues that the PCE's reading of how Japan, South Korea, and China caught up is distorted: they actually intervened to undervalue their currencies, lowered interest rates while diverting credit mainly to infrastructure and manufacturing sectors, kept wages from growing in line with productivity, and often imposed import restrictions—if they had merely collaborated to improve manufacturing efficiency, household share of GDP would not have declined and large persistent surpluses would not have emerged
“this provoked a response from peing University professor of Finance Michael Pettis who expressed today quote that's a pretty distorted reading of what Japan South Korea and China did to catch up in fact they intervened to undervalue their currencies they lowered interest rates while diverting credit mainly to infrastructure and the manufacturing sectors they kept wages from growing in line with productivity and they often impose restrictions on Imports if they had merely collaborated in order to improve their manufacturing efficiency there is no reason why the household share of GDP would have declined to force up domestic savings and set off large persistent surpluses end quote”
Officials and analysts are not optimistic that China will intervene with North Korea's plans to deploy troops to Russia, despite US pressure to do so
“officials and analysts are not optimistic that China will intervene with North Korea's plans however”
China's Commerce Ministry stated that the EU tariffs represent protectionist practice implementing unfair competition in the name of fair competition, and China does not agree with or accept the ruling and has filed a case under the WTO dispute settlement mechanism
“China's Commerce Ministry said in a statement on Wednesday that quote it is a protectionist practice that implements unfair competition in the name of Fair competition China does not agree with or accept the ruling results and has filed a case under the WTO dispute settlement mechanism end quote”
Bill Bishop raises the question of whether China is trying to pressure Russia to stop bringing in North Korean mercenaries or sees their presence as useful to aid Russia's victory and ensure Putin's stability, as long as South Korea and NATO do not use DPRK participation as an excuse to advance NATO's role in Asia
“is the PRC trying to pressure the Russians to stop bringing in North Korean mercenaries or do they see their presence as useful to Aid Russia's Victory and ensure Putin stability so long as South Korea and NATO do not use the dprk participation in the European land War as an excuse to make progress on a role in Asia for NATO”
Bill Bishop raises concerns that South Korea supplying weapons to Ukraine used to kill North Koreans could give Kim Jong Un a pretext to take kinetic action on the peninsula, potentially requesting more US weapon systems and even additional THAAD deployment for South Korea
“South Korea supplying weapons to Ukraine that are used to kill North Koreans in that theater giving Kim a pretext to do something kinetic on the peninsula a request for more us weapon systems maybe even more Thad for South Korea”
Despite BYD's higher quarterly revenue than Tesla, Tesla's net profit is substantially greater, with Tesla earning 2.2 billion USD in the first nine months compared to BYD's 25.2 billion yuan net income on 5,102.3 billion yuan revenue
“indeed its profit is still overshadowed by the 2.2 billion US Tesla earned in the first N9 months byd had net income of 25.2 billion yen on revenue of 5 102.3 billion yen”
BYD sold a record 1.1 million cars in the third quarter, boosted by a new round of Chinese government subsidies for electric vehicles, but this sales jump came at the expense of BYD's gross margins which slipped from 22.1% last year to 21.9%
“byd sold a record 1.1 million cars in the 3month period boosted by a new round of Chinese government subsidies for EVS however the sales jump this quarter came at the expense of byd's gross margins which slipped from 22.1% last year to 21.9%”
The EU is pushing ahead with tariffs of up to 45% on Chinese electric vehicles following months of negotiations and threats of Chinese retaliation, in response to allegations of unfair industrial subsidies
“the EU is pushing ahead with tariffs of up to 45% on Chinese electric vehicles sharply accelerating the trade war between the 27 member block and Beijing over allegations of unfair industrial subsidies”
The EU rejected China's claims that it was introducing protectionist measures without evidence that Chinese vehicles were receiving undue state support, and new duties come on top of an existing 10% tariff on Chinese car imports in the block
“the EU rejected China's claims that it was introducing protectionist measures without evidence that Chinese vehicles were receiving undue State support new duties also come on top of an existing 10% tariff on Chinese Car Imports in the block”
China has threatened to retaliate against EU tariffs with penalties on European goods including dairy, pork, brandy, and cars with large engines, with an anti-dumping probe into European pork launched in June but not yet finished
“China has also threatened to retaliate with penalties of its own on European Goods including Dairy pork and Brandy as well as cars with large engines China launched an anti-dumping probe into European pork in June although that has not been finished yet”
North Korea deploying troops to Ukraine inflames a war in Europe which could deepen a broader confrontation over the global order that pits the United States and its allies against an axis of anti-western powers led by China and Russia
“North Korea is inflaming a war in Europe which could deepen a broader confrontation over the global order that pits the United States and its allies against an AIS of anti-western powers led by China and Russia”
Analysts argue that China's leadership concerns include the exchange of military technology from Russia to North Korea in return for troops, which could embolden North Korea to act more aggressively toward South Korea or Japan, while simultaneously diminishing Beijing's ability to influence the state
“an lists also argue that another concern China's leadership may have is the exchange of military technology from Russia to North Korea in return for sending troops that could embolden the north to act more aggressively toward South Korea or Japan and at the same time diminish beijing's ability to influence the state even as it relies on China for trade and Aid”
Industry leaders argue there are no easy solutions: the EU has followed the US in raising tariffs on vehicles imported from China, but protectionism will only make cars more expensive for consumers and accelerate plant closures in Europe
“there are no easy solutions the EU has followed the US in raising tariffs on vehicles imported from China but industry leaders say protectionism will only make cars more expensive for consumers and accelerate plant closures in Europe”
Victor Cha, professor of government and international affairs at Georgetown University and the Korea chair of CSIS, argues that Beijing may not know how to reign in North Korea's efforts to help the Kremlin, and while China supports Russia's efforts in the war indirectly, they cannot be happy with North Korea's actions because there is nothing good for them in this short or long term
“Victor DCH a professor of government and international Affairs at Georgetown University and the Korea chair of the center for strategic international studies in Washington argues that Beijing may not know how to reign in North Korea's efforts to help the Kremlin arguing quote China is caught between paralysis and incompetence on this while they are supporting Russia's efforts in the war indirectly they cannot be happy with the dprk peace there is nothing good for them in this short or long term end quote”
According to the PCE (possible analyst or organization), the European industry needs to get the Chinese to localize in Europe and needs to collaborate with them, particularly around battery technology, in order to catch up
“the pce argues quote the European industry needs to get the Chinese to localize in Europe and needs to collaborate with them particularly around Battery Technology in order to catch up in quote”
Chinese government, which needs international markets open to manage its large manufacturing surplus, piled on pressure right up to the deadline in an attempt to get a deal with the EU on EV tariffs
“us-based political RS that the Chinese government which regular viewers know very much needs International markets open to take its huge manufacturing Surplus quote piled on the pressure right up to the death in an attempt to get a deal end quote”
China's top diplomat Wang Yi met with the Russian Deputy Foreign Minister in Beijing, and in the official readout there was no mention of North Korean troops, only discussion of views on the Ukraine crisis, suggesting China and Russia are staying tight-lipped publicly about the North Korean deployment
“China's top Diplomat wangi met with the Russian Deputy foreign minister in Beijing yesterday in the official readout there was no mention of the North Korean troops but rather that they quote exchange views on the Ukraine crisis in quote”
Henry Gao, a law professor at Singapore Management University who researches Chinese trade policies, observes that the only people more worried about the US election than Americans are the Chinese, as everyone in Beijing is tuned into the US election
“Henry g a law professor at Singapore management University who researches Chinese trade and policies observed this week quote the only people more worried about the US election than Americans are the Chinese everyone in Beijing is tuned into the US election now end quote”
It is possible that Chinese officials will hold off on escalation in the trade war with the Europeans and opt to wait for the results of the US elections, as Chinese leadership is closely monitoring US electoral outcomes
“ultimately however it's possible that officials in Beijing will hold off on any escalation in the trade war with the Europeans and opt to wait for the results of the US elections”
Regulations introducing the EU levies on Chinese EVs were published on the EU's official journal and paved the way for entry into force later that week, with tariffs imposed for 5 years after months of negotiations and threats of Chinese retaliation
“the regulation introducing the levies were published on the eu's official journal on Wednesday this paved the way for their entry into Force later this week after months of negotiations threats of Chinese retaliation and Auto industry pleas to avoid escalation the tariffs will be imposed for 5 years”