
Deirdre McCloskey on Capitalism and the Bourgeois Virtues 03/31/2008
What this covers
Deirdre McCloskey and Russ Roberts conduct a sustained conversation on whether markets corrupt or ennoble human character. McCloskey, drawing on her book The Bourgeois Virtues, argues that capitalism is ethically improving—not merely because it generates wealth, but because the conditions it creates cultivate virtue. Commerce frees people from the physical drudgery and tradition-bound constraints of pre-capitalist agricultural life, and the responsibility for managing one's own consumption and choices constitutes ethical development in itself. Roberts and McCloskey explore how longer lifespans and expanded individual freedom under capitalism create genuine room for self-cultivation and self-definition, rather than reducing human purpose to consumption alone.
The discussion ranges across history, economics, and philosophy. McCloskey challenges romantic nostalgia for pre-modern community by examining Grimm fairy tales as economic documents—finding little evidence of communal safety nets—and uses revealed preference to argue that workers voluntarily migrated from farms to factories, contradicting the Marxist account of false consciousness. Both speakers critique mainstream economics for treating humans as mere utility-maximizers, flattening the social and relational dimensions that McCloskey sees as essential. They also revisit Adam Smith's vision of commerce as ethically mixed but ultimately life-enhancing, and they push back against the iconic indictment in Chaplin's Modern Times, arguing that hand-harvesting grain was equally machine-like repetition. A secondary current examines economic pedagogy itself—how the profession's drift toward mathematical formalism has abandoned the applied, conversational reasoning that McCloskey identifies as true economic thought.
McCloskey argues that capitalism (commerce) is not merely materially enriching but ethically improving — it cultivates 'bourgeois virtues' and expands human self-definition and freedom, contradicting the view that markets corrupt the soul or community.
- Commerce frees people from the brutal physical drudgery and tradition-bound constraints of pre-capitalist agricultural life
- Having responsibility for one's own consumption and life choices improves people ethically
- Longer lifespans and individual freedom under capitalism create scope for self-definition and meaning, not just consumption
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Capitalism makes people more ethical, not just materially richer, because having responsibility for one's own consumption and life choices is itself an ethical improvement.
“having responsibility for yourself being allowed to go from having responsibility for all your own consumption choices improves you ethically”
Pre-capitalist life was dominated by brutal physical drudgery (e.g., threshing grain by hand for hundreds of hours each winter) and was bound by tradition and the opinion of neighbors, conditions that discouraged commercial and inventive behavior.
“what threshing was did you had a stick attached to another stick and you swelled away at the grain... this was a major task in the wintertime and was just horrible”
When evaluating capitalism, one must be balanced and do empirical work to look at how things actually are, rather than relying on the romantic celebration of either capitalism or socialism.
“I accept that there's a romantic quality and I... do the celebration of capitalism as there is celebration socialism and one needs to be... that's why in my book I try to do empirical work so I think I try to actually look at how things are”
Capitalism created mass prosperity, freeing millions of people by 1848 from drudgery; the descendants of those people now enjoy opportunities once limited to the crowned heads of Europe.
“to make us even up to 1848 and freed millions of people from what they call the”
Pre-modern communities did not actually provide the safety net romantics imagine; the Grimm fairy tales, read as frozen 14th-century economic documents, contain no scenes of being helped by your community, undermining the nostalgia for traditional communal support.
“if you go back to the... grim tale and read them as what they are documents frozen 14th century economic history there's no there is no seam in the grim fairy tales of being helped by your community”
The economic system lets us 'economize on love' — by trading with strangers for everyday needs like food, clothing, and shelter, we reserve our limited capacity for love for our actual loved ones rather than having to love everyone we transact with.
“economics lets us or I think week our economic system lets us economize on love”
Treating people as 'Max U' — beings who only maximize utility (prudence alone) — describes a dissatisfying life that most people neither live nor want to live, so economists err by modeling humans solely that way.
“most people don't live a max euwe life most people aren't max you don't want to be max you and certainly don't behave only that way”
Spiritual and ethical self-development becomes worthwhile because capitalism extends lifespan and prolongs education; if you die at 35 there is little point in spiritual exercises, whereas longer lives create room for self-cultivation.
“your becomes more important because your life is longer if you're going to die at age 35 there isn't a heck of a lot of point in you know engaging in Spiritual Exercises you're going to be dead before it matters”
People throughout history have voluntarily moved from agricultural employment to seemingly terrible factory jobs (early mills, and today in China) because those jobs were actually better — better diets and more freedom — demonstrating revealed preference rather than the Marxist 'false consciousness'.
“people are seen to move voluntarily for an agricultural employment to these terrible jobs in the early mills... because they preferred them they were better jobs they were in diets or one thing”
The best economic understanding — Hayekian emergent-phenomenon thinking and applied price theory — is fundamentally non-mathematical and conditional ('if this is true then this will hold'), a subtler form of reasoning that resists being reduced to a single numeric answer.
“the insights of Hayek about how markets work and the insights from from your price Theory class... which are fundamentally non-mathematical... there's no easy answer there's no the answer is number 17 the answer is well if this is true then this will hold”
Actually existing capitalism — not collectivism of the left or right — has reached beyond mere consumption to produce the best art and best people, by giving people scope to pursue their varied purposes (e.g., dog shows, antique shows, bird watching, square dancing).
“I claim that actually existing capitalism not the collectivism of the left or of the right has reached beyond mere consumption producing the best art and the best people people have purposes a capitalist economy gives them scope to try them out”
The common criticism that 'capitalism delivers the goods but damns the soul' is wrong; commerce actually has many ethically enhancing virtues rather than corrupting human character.
“sure capitalism delivers the goods buttons the soul I think you disagree why”
Charlie Chaplin's 'Modern Times' indicts capitalism for turning man into a cog tightening the same bolt, but ironically pre-capitalist agricultural labor (e.g., harvesting grain by hand all day) was just as machine-like; modern post-industrial life is far less machine-like because machines now do that repetitive work.
“harvesting that the grain was a lot like tightening a bolt on a machine you're out there outside swinging it all day long and human beings in the modern world in post-industrial America are much less machine like”
A capitalist life is fundamentally a life of free choice in which voluntary exchange is mutually advantageous; the Marxist claim that one person's free choice enslaves others fails because when I make a deal with you, both parties benefit.
“when people have the choice they choose a capitalist life in fact the capitalist life is a life of free choice”
Adam Smith held that commerce, while subject to obsessive materialism that can harm appreciation of the immaterial, had many character-enhancing virtues and played a welcome role in human life.
“Adam Smith felt that it had many enhancing virtues the role of Commerce in our lives was his the welcome”
State provision of welfare creates a moral hazard whereby individuals say 'I gave at the office' and feel relieved of real concern for their neighbor, crowding out private and church-based individual care that may serve people better.
“there is the great danger which i think is true of people saying I gave at the office I don't need to exercise real concerns for my for my neighbor”
Over the past roughly 30 years, the economics profession has become more Samuelsonian — more mathematical, less intuitive, and less applied — drifting away from the applied price-theory, puzzle-solving, intuition-based style once taught at Chicago.
“if anything in the 30 years that have passed our profession has become more Samuel Sounion more mathematical less intuitive less applied”
We learn by talking; economic education advances through conversation, as in seminars where grad students hold forth and are critiqued, and the best economic education may tragically take place outside the classroom in books and podcasts.
“we learn by talking and i think i like to think that these podcasts are a version of that”
True economic education is held back by the compulsion to grade: because emergent market-based and conversational forms of teaching are hard to write exams for, instructors fall back on vacuous problems that misrepresent the subtle reasoning at the heart of economics.
“either the use of of emergent market-based thinking or the conversational exploration of concepts they're very hard to write exams for... what's holding back true economic education in the university setting is our compulsion to grade”
Under capitalism the individual is valued and encouraged rather than being made by the central planner, by tradition, or by the neighbors, and material consumption becomes a vehicle for self-definition and meaning rather than mere entertainment or pleasure.
“a life in capitalism values the individual the individual is encouraged they aren't being made by the central planner they aren't being made by the by by tradition or the neighbors”
Modern people who corrupt their purchases or watch excessive TV are no worse than their ancestors and on average better; nostalgia for the moral superiority of past generations is historically unfounded.
“yes some people engage in corrupting purchases but they are no worse than their ancestors and on average better”
Modern welfare-state 'safety nets', even where they work well (Sweden, Holland), are a small part of government expenditure, and the welfare net largely functions as a way to employ university graduates in government jobs rather than primarily to help the poor.
“these so-called safety nets even when they worked very well as in places like Sweden or Holland are a small part of government expenditure that mainly with the what the safety net turns out to be is a way of employing university graduates for jobs government”
The pursuit of the material can hurt our appreciation of the immaterial, so monetary or material obsession is a genuine but common danger.
“I think the pursuit of the material can hurt our appreciation of the immaterial”
Treating people only as atomized utility-maximizers leads economists to bad conclusions because it strips away the social and relational nature of human beings.
“we get from thinking of people atomizers”
It is good and even necessary to romanticize the freedom and scope for human self-expression that modern capitalist life provides, because people take these opportunities for granted and don't realize how radically different and constrained the pre-modern world was.
“I think it's good to romanticize it because I don't think people appreciate the scope for human expression that our current modern lives give us they take it for granted”
Welcome to EconTalk, part of the Library of Economics and Liberty.
“welcome to econ talk part of the library of economics and liberty I'm your host Russ Roberts”