What this covers
Tom Holland traces how Christian ideas became so embedded in modern Western thought that we no longer recognize them as Christian at all. He argues that Christianity as source of liberalism runs far deeper than most accounts admit, rooted in St Paul's Letter to the Galatians and Jesus's teaching to render unto Caesar—both of which planted the seeds for the secular/religious distinction as Christian invention. The conversation moves swiftly across history, theology, and politics, asking how a framework supposedly neutral between faith and irreligion actually embeds Christian assumptions so thoroughly that even Muslims, Jews, and secular republicans in modern Britain have internalized it without noticing. Holland also traces the Persian inheritance: the dualism and moralization of power that flowed from the Sasanians through Christianity and Islam into the modern West's moral posturing about enemies and reform.
The range is genuinely broad. Holland defends Herodotus against academic dismissal, arguing that his endless curiosity and commitment to custom is king deserve respect rather than judgment from rationalist standards. He examines how the failure of the apocalypse at the first millennium precipitated the papal revolution and opened the path to all Western revolutionary thought. He discusses spirit-mediated reading of scripture in radical Protestantism, the American civil rights movement as a late ripple of evangelical Protestantism, and the Church of England's existential crisis now that the state has absorbed its social functions. Elsewhere he considers classical Luddism, the Roman Empire's economic sophistication, the geography of capitalism's emergence, and biodiversity collapse. The argument that we must inhabit the past's worldview rather than pin it down with rational critique runs through everything.
Holland argues that modern Western liberalism, secularism, and even the concept of the 'secular' itself are largely secularized descendants of Christian (and earlier Persian) ideas, and that to understand the past we must inhabit its supernatural worldview rather than judge it by rationalist standards.
- Paul's Letter to the Galatians and Jesus's 'render unto Caesar' planted ideas that became liberalism and the secular/religious divide
- Even Muslims, Jews and republicans in modern Britain have internalized a Christian-derived secular framework
- The Persian idea that power can be moralized passed through Christianity and Islam into the modern West
Christianity's radical egalitarianism, especially Paul's vision of no ethnic or class distinction, became the foundational premise enabling liberalism and successive reform movements.
- Jesus is radically anti-state in that he opposes the interfusion of power with those claiming a mandate to interpret the divine, in both Jerusalem and Rome; his 'render unto Caesar' saying is a potent insight that separates the divine from the earthly and is the origin of the idea of the secular.
“Jesus, I think, is all about separating the divine from the earthly, and that is an incredibly potent insight.”
- The common framing that the Jews were religious and Pontius Pilate represented secular authority is mistaken; the Romans were no less secular than the Judean authorities, with their power equally interfused with an understanding of the divine, as seen in the cult of Augustus and the Capitoline temple.
“But the Romans are no less secular than the Judean authorities.”
- Radical Protestants, Quakers and evangelicals held that the Bible could only be understood as mediated by the Spirit rather than its literal black-and-white words, which enabled them to argue slavery was evil even though the Bible nowhere says so.
“It’s this, in due course, that enables Quakers and evangelicals, for instance, to argue that slavery as an institution is evil, even though notoriously and nowhere in the Bible is that ever said.”
- Paul's Letter to the Galatians, with its verse that there is no Jew or Greek, slave or free, man or woman in Christ, is the most foundational biblical text for liberalism; even bracketing out 'in Christ', the idea that there should be no discrimination by ethnicity, gender or class remains foundational, and liberalism is in many ways a secularized rendering of that verse.
“I think that liberalism, in so many ways, is a secularized rendering of that extraordinary verse.”
- Paul's letters function like a depth charge released beneath the fabric of classical civilization: the reverberations begin faint but become louder and more disruptive over time, continuing to reverberate to the present day.
“I think actually, more appropriately, of a depth charge released beneath the vast fabric of classical civilization.”
- The American civil rights movement is one of a succession of great awakenings in Anglo-American Protestantism; African Americans inherited the radical evangelical Protestant tradition (the idea that the Bible is understood through the Spirit and the power of the Exodus story), which let figures like Martin Luther King articulate civil rights in a way that resonated across Black and White churches, and which also animated later movements like feminism and gay rights.
“the civil rights movement is one of a succession of great awakenings in American Protestantism and, indeed, in Anglo-American Protestantism”
The West unconsciously inherits Persian imperial logic—moralizing power and demonizing enemies—more than it admits despite claiming Athens as its primary ancestor.
- The Persians had a highly influential dualist intellectual tradition (later institutionalized as Zoroastrianism) in which the world is divided between good and evil, truth and the lie; the Persian king as Ahura Mazda's deputy moralized his imperialism so that those who opposed him were agents of the lie who must be crushed, and this idea that power can be moralized passed through Christianity and Islam into the present West.
“This is what’s so influential about the Persian Empire, is that they moralized their own imperialism.”
- Although the West conceives itself as heir to Athens, it is at least as much the heir of the Persian kings, since the Persian view of enemies (e.g. Athens and Sparta as terrorist states possessed by demons) mirrors the modern Western view of places like Afghanistan as terrorist backwaters to be smoked out.
“We in the West have the conceit that we are the heirs of Athens, but we are at least as much the heirs of the Persian kings as we are of the Athenians.”
The Church of England faces an existential crisis: winning secular victories that transferred its functions to the state left it without clear social purpose.
- The failure of the apocalypse to arrive at the first millennium opened the idea that the Christian people could be cleansed and reformed, precipitating the 11th-century papal revolution, which stands at the fountainhead of the entire Western revolutionary tradition and made liberalism possible.
“That precipitates what I think is the first great revolutionary moment in European, and therefore Western, history — what’s called the papal revolution.”
- The existential problem for the Church of England (and Christians in Britain and America) is that they have won too comprehensively: functions once provided by the Church—education, healthcare, charity—have been nationalized by the state, so people no longer need Christianity to do those things, leaving the Church without a clear purpose.
“in a way, they’ve won too comprehensively. People don’t need Christianity anymore to do all kinds of things.”
- The Queen's death and funeral revealed that many people, including even republicans, were surprised by how moved they were and quite liked the sense of communion with the Christian and royal past, suggesting the Church and monarchy retain emotional resonance even amid very low church attendance.
“lots of people were surprised by how moved they were by those whole two strange weeks and actually quite liked it.”
Population density, infrastructure age, biodiversity collapse, and the emotional resonance of traditional institutions shape societies in ways rationalist analysis often misses.
- Humans have a responsibility to other species sharing their island, and biodiversity collapse harms humans too: hedgehogs are going extinct partly because there are not enough insects to eat, and if we lose insects and the things animals depend on, cascade effects could unpredictably ripple through and damage human interests.
“a world in which biodiversity collapses... if we don’t have insects, if we don’t have the things that animals would depend upon, then that’s not good for humans either.”
- The mention of cricket will induce furrowed brows across America.
“I’m sure the mention of cricket will induce furrowed brows across America.”
- The two areas of Europe with the highest population density—the Netherlands and southeast England—were also the two that first became capitalist, suggesting a sense of critical mass was important to the emergence of capitalism, though both are now arguably too small for easy growth.
“the two areas of Europe that have the highest population density are also the two areas that first became capitalist, the Netherlands and southeast England.”
- The Book of Revelation was recognized by early Christians as a highly dangerous book; it was not included in the New Testament canon of the Orthodox Church until the 10th century, and even Latin Church fathers like Augustine were anxious that Christians might interpret it too literally.
“It wasn’t included in the canon of the New Testament in the Orthodox Church in the realms of the Byzantine Empire until the 10th century.”
- The Bible is an accretion of texts in which stories are often duplicated and stitched together (two creation accounts, Kings and Chronicles telling the same stories, two versions of the Ten Commandments), with the Pentateuch being the most rewritten and contested because it was so doctrinally foundational.
“what we call today the Bible is an accretion of texts. There often seem to be two versions of stories stitched together.”
- Holland's unusual successful work habit is to play period-evoking music (such as Ennio Morricone's score from The Good, the Bad and the Ugly) before and during writing to keep himself in the mood of the historical world he is writing about while reminding him he writes for a general audience who may know nothing about it.
“I’ve always tried to find pieces of music that will keep me in the mood of the world in which I’m writing about, but will also remind me that I’m writing for people who may know nothing about it”
- Pre-WWII Britain had power devolved to Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and great English cities, but the challenge of defeating Hitler plus a centralizing postwar Labour government concentrated power, producing a 'long Second World War' whose centralizing aftereffects have lasted too long; devolution is therefore not the enemy of the union but the best way for the UK to function.
“in the challenge of defeating Hitler, the British state became so centralized that we have long Second World War, if you want to put it like that.”
- Irish unification is less inevitable than commonly assumed: as sectarian identity fades it does not automatically translate into a desire to join a united Ireland, a solid core still prefers the UK, and Northern Ireland being now much poorer than Ireland creates nervousness among voters in both about the costs of unification.
“it doesn’t translate automatically into a desire, necessarily, to remain in the union or to join a united Ireland, but that there is a solid core, nevertheless, that prefers remaining in the UK”
- An overly objective, academic, rationalist approach to studying how past peoples understood the divine risks alienating us from the very perspectives we are trying to understand, like studying a butterfly by sticking a pin through it.
“It’s a bit like studying a butterfly by sticking a pin through it. Too objective, too academic, too rationalist in approach can risk alienating you from perspective, the very perspectives that you’re trying to understand.”
- The Roman Empire in the 2nd century AD was an extraordinarily economically advanced society with a vast internal market; it has been estimated that no society was as rich again until the Dutch Republic in the late 16th to early 17th century.
“people in the Roman Empire in the 2nd century AD were probably . . . no society was as rich until, say, the Netherlands, the Dutch Republic in the late 16th, early 17th century.”
Classical and modern societies have harbored deep anxieties about technology destabilizing social order by displacing labor and concentrating power unpredictably.
- There was a strain of Luddism in the classical world: Roman and Greek elites were nervous about technology going too far, using the Alexandrian steam engine only for temple gimmicks, and stories of Tiberius killing the inventor of unbreakable glass and Vespasian refusing a labor-saving crane (likely apocryphal but revealing) articulate a suspicion that labor-saving devices would idle and destabilize the lower orders.
“my sense is that there is a strain of Ludditisim in the classical world that makes them suspicious of anything that might lead to what might seem to be labor-saving.”
- America may be more pro-technology than Europe because it is easier to install new technology in newly built houses than to retrofit it into 500-year-old ones; European states are like very old houses full of botched wiring, which is also why the industrial elite moved from older-infrastructure Britain to America and Germany over the 19th century.
“it is easy to bring home improvements into a house that’s just been built than it is to do home improvements in a house that’s 500 years old.”
Islam in Britain has been functionally Protestantized by secular frameworks that treat religion as private belief rather than a comprehensive way of life.
- Islam is in no way the most influential religion in Britain; rather, Islam has been radically Christianized and Protestantized there, because freedom of religion forces Muslims to treat Islam as merely 'a religion' siphoned off from a secular sphere—contrary to the classical understanding of Islam as an entire way of life—so most Muslims have internalized the Christian-derived secular/religious distinction just as Jews, Hindus and Catholics have.
“Islam has been radically christianized in Britain.”
Herodotus exemplifies infinite curiosity despite errors; reconstructing the Achaemenid Empire required pooling Persian and neighboring sources after no Persian historian survived.
- Herodotus, whose Historia means inquiries or researches rather than history in the modern sense, embodies an infinite curiosity about everything; it is arrogant to sit in judgment on his errors because he was the first person ever doing this kind of inquiry with no prior example to follow.
“it brought home to me how arrogant it is for us to sit in judgment on him when he was the first person to be doing this.”
- Herodotus's story of Darius asking Greeks and an Indian tribe to adopt each other's funeral customs illustrates that custom is king: everybody believes their own customs are best, a relativist insight Herodotus used to portray the Persians as they saw themselves.
“This shows to me that custom is king, that everybody believes that their own customs are best.”
- Because no Persian Herodotus survives, scholars over recent decades have pooled every available source—Persian inscriptions, archaeology, evidence from Egypt and Babylonia—to reconstruct the functioning of the Achaemenid Empire, achieving a better understanding of it than has existed since the empire's collapse.
“They have brought us to an understanding of the Persian Empire that is better than anyone’s had since the collapse of the empire itself.”