What this covers

Sujatha Gidla, an author and journalist, makes the case for understanding caste as rooted in economics rather than religion—a distinction that carries implications across Indian society and its diasporas. Speaking with Tyler Cowen, she argues that caste persists because it solves a structural problem: the need for a permanent underclass trapped in menial labor. Because the system is fundamentally about organizing production to keep certain groups available for unwanted work, it survives religious conversion, urbanization, and even immigration. She traces the logic through caste endogamy, spatial segregation, and assigned occupations, and extends it to explain why constitutional protections like Article 17, a Dalit president, and the system of reservations have failed to dismantle caste.

The conversation ranges widely through history, politics, and contemporary India. Gidla examines the rivalry between Mahatma Gandhi and Ambedkar over untouchable leadership, critiques reservations as Band-Aids that leave the underlying structure intact, and argues that both Congress and Modi's government—along even the Indian Communist Party—carry caste attitudes into their rule. She traces caste as social not religious by showing its persistence among Indian Christians, Sikhs, and Muslims, including among Dalit immigrants to the United States. On solutions, she departs sharply from mainstream reform: education and legal change cannot work, she contends, because genuine emancipation requires radical restructuring of production itself. She also ranges into cinema, technology, gender politics, and the distinction between old and new forms of exploitation under digitization and demonetization, sometimes reaching positions that place her at odds with both left and liberal orthodoxies.

Sharpest takeaway

Gidla argues that caste is fundamentally an economic and social system of imposed labor—not a religious one—so it persists across religions, cities, and even immigration, and can only be dismantled by radically restructuring the system of production rather than through reservations, education, or legal reform.

  • Caste stems from occupation and the economic need for a captive menial labor force, so it survives religious conversion and urbanization
  • Reservations and education are 'Band-Aids' that leave the underlying social structure intact
  • Both Indian parties (Congress and Modi/BJP) and even Communists carry caste attitudes, so political reform within the existing society cannot end caste

The argument · threads10 threads · 38 claims
0.85

Caste persists because it stems from economic organization requiring a permanent underclass for menial labor.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Converting to Christianity, Buddhism, Islam, or Sikhism does not remove one's caste, because caste is fundamentally a social rather than a religious issue; Hinduism is a 'tailor-made religion'—mysticism that functions as a prop for the caste system, dictating rules for untouchables and women—but since caste is social, casteism persists among Christians, Sikhs, and every other religion in India.

    “Hinduism is a tailor-made religion. As one anthropologist said, it’s mysticism, but basically it’s a system to prop up caste system. It tells you the rules for untouchables and for women.”

  • Despite constitutional bans (Article 17), a Dalit president, and reservations, caste segregation persists because caste stems from the economic system and occupation: as long as production is organized to require a group of people always available to do menial and hard labor, social forces will keep untouchables in their place as a labor supply; caste does not go away unless the economic system and system of production are radically changed.

    “Caste is basically . . . it stems out of economic system. It stems out of occupation. It stems out of what job you do in the society.”

  • Caste is also about occupation—an imposed occupation where each caste has its own assigned work—and the occupations forced on untouchables are precisely those Hindu society deems unclean and menial: handling dead bodies, tannery, removing dead animals, and cleaning latrines, work nobody else wants to do.

    “The occupations that are given or forced on untouchables are what Hindu society deems unclean and menial.”

  • Caste persisted in India because, unlike colonial Australia where English servants could find their own land and stop being servants, people in India had to be forced into a caste system—suggesting special geological, geographical, and climatic conditions tied to scarce land necessitated a coercive division of labor.

    “there’s an example in Australia, when people went from England to colonize. People went there, and some people were taken as the servants there. Servants soon found land of their own, and they were no longer servants. That’s the case in India. People had to be forced into a caste system.”

  • Recognizing caste discrimination in American law would change nothing because Brahmins and upper-caste Indians are formally entrenched in high places in America—among TV anchors, New York Times staff, and Trump's administration—and they will never allow caste to be recognized as a form of discrimination.

    “These people, the Brahmins, are formally entrenched in all high places in America. If you look at TV anchors, they’re all Brahmins. If you look at people who work in New York Times, they’re all Brahmins.”

  • Contrary to the assumption that all Indians are vegetarian, only Brahmins are prohibited from eating meat or fish, and even that varies regionally (Bihar Brahmins eat beef, Kolkata Brahmins eat fish); beef is taboo for all Hindus except Dalits, who survived on the carcasses of dead animals.

    “It’s only the Brahmins who are not allowed to eat meat or fish. Even that is not true of all the places in India. For Bihar, they eat beef (Brahmins). In Kolkata, they eat fish.”

0.75

Caste is maintained through spatial segregation, endogamy, genetic markers, and inherited occupational assignment across generations.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Caste is inherited by birth and cannot be acquired; it is maintained by endogamy (marriage within one's own caste), and marriage outside the caste is so heavily stigmatized that parents themselves may kill a daughter for marrying outside the caste.

    “This is maintained by endogamy, that is, marriage within one’s own caste. Marriage outside of the caste is very, very stigmatized and not allowed. It’s not allowed to the extent that parents themselves can kill the girl for marrying outside of the caste.”

  • The defining feature of untouchability is spatial segregation: while all castes have their own colonies, those colonies sit inside the village, whereas untouchables must live outside the village and enter only to work, because physical contact is believed to pollute caste Hindus.

    “all of these colonies are inside the village whereas untouchables are outside of the village. They come into the village only to work.”

  • An Indian can identify an untouchable on sight: most Christians (except Syrian Christians and some Goa Catholics) are untouchables, so the absence of a forehead dot signals it; moreover, since endogamy began about 1,500 years ago, castes have inherited distinct genetic markers, and body language alone can reveal which caste—untouchable or Brahmin—a person belongs to.

    “the lack of forehead dot tells them that I’m an untouchable.”

  • The particular intensity of women's oppression and the prominence of rape in India stem from caste endogamy: because a woman must not marry outside her caste, enormous value is placed on her chastity, making chastity precious to the family and community, so rape becomes the cruelest, most insulting weapon to hurt a community—evidenced by the mass rape of women during the Partition.

    “the particular intensity of women’s oppression stems out of caste restrictions, they are not allowed to marry from outside.”

0.71

Caste transcends religion and persists among Christians, Sikhs, and diaspora Indians because it is fundamentally social, not theological.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The claim that caste mostly disappears when you move to an Indian city is false; while caste is most rigorously practiced as a village-based institution, it persists in towns—Gidla's own family lived in a segregated area and was not allowed to rent houses elsewhere, with a friend's wife refusing to host them after they arrived with their belongings.

    “Caste is basically a village-based institution. That’s where it is most rigorously practiced. But even when you come to towns, like my family did, we lived in a segregated area. We were not allowed to rent houses in other areas.”

  • The caste system persists very strongly among Indians in the United States: immigrant associations that ostensibly celebrate Indian culture and festivals actually function as caste groups, with some openly identifying as Brahmin associations and requiring shibboleths like gotra and horoscope to join, leading Gidla to abandon Indian networks once she could make American friends.

    “All these immigrant associations—ostensibly, they are there to celebrate Indian culture and festivals, but they’re actually the caste groups.”

  • Gidla considers her own views radical while declining to publicly discuss Obama, feminism, or Black Lives Matter because critiquing them would sound conservative and alienate readers who assume that as a Dalit woman author she must be a feminist, Obama admirer, and Democrat; her position is that what Americans consider radical is in fact conservative.

    “More radical, but I refrain from talking about Obama or feminism, Black Lives Matter. There are certain things that I don’t want to talk about because they sound like conservative views, but I am radical.”

  • Gidla's only meaningful connection with her family members is shared political views: with her mother and sister, conversation centers entirely on politics, untouchability, caste, and Modi, and without those political links they would be fighting; she is completely alienated from her brother, partly because he now attends church and reads Freakonomics, which she does not relate to.

    “the only relation I have with my family members is political views. If we have to connect on familial links, we will always be fighting and killing each other. All that we talk about with my mother is politics and untouchability and caste and Modi and things like that.”

  • Gidla's parents steered their children toward science rather than humanities on the reasoning that humanities subjects like history require teaching things that are not fact and would change after a revolution, whereas science stays true irrespective of what society you are in.

    “They’re against humanities. They think that, if one day there will be a revolution, you are required to teach something else other than what is a fact, like in history. But if it’s science, it’s going to stay irrespective of what society you’re in.”

  • Though Gidla does not support the regimes in China or Cuba, she notes that on development indexes both perform well—higher literacy, lower infant mortality, and better women's equality—and considers them better off in these respects, while disclaiming knowledge of North Korea.

    “I’m not a supporter of the regime in China or in Cuba, but from all developmental indexes, they’re doing well. There is more literacy in China and more literacy in Cuba and less infant mortalities, better.”

0.70

Constitutional bans, reservations, and political representation cannot eliminate caste without transforming the underlying system of production.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Even as prime minister, Gidla argues she could do nothing about the caste system because a government presides over and rules the same kind of society; charitable organizations and education operate within that same framework, so genuine change requires the social structure to be smashed and rebuilt on a collectivized basis—with agriculture collectivized, industry under the state, and foreign policy a state monopoly.

    “Even if I become the prime minister of India, I can’t do anything about caste system, being in a government that rules the same kind of society. The society has to be changed, not the government.”

  • Reservations (India's caste-based affirmative action) are like putting a Band-Aid on a bullet wound: because reservations are awarded on the basis of demonstrated suffering, fighting for them is indirectly asking for discrimination to continue so that one can gain a few university and political seats; the better fight is for equal access in all spheres of life, though reservations should still be defended against reactionary upper-caste attacks.

    “reservations is like putting a Band-Aid on a bullet wound. So I would not be fighting for that. What I would be fighting for is equal access in all spheres of life.”

  • Ambedkar's slogan 'Educate, organize, and agitate' makes education central to untouchables' belief that emancipation lies in getting educated, which may be true, but it founders because after education they are not getting jobs—and education is useless if there are no jobs.

    “Ambedkar’s slogan is “Educate, organize, and agitate.” This is a big thing for untouchables. They think that their emancipation lies in getting educated. It may be true, but after education, they’re not getting jobs. What can they do with education if there are no jobs?”

0.61

Indian development policy beginning under Congress and accelerated by Modi economically devastates farmers and small business while enriching elites.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The harmful economic measures in India did not begin under Modi but were started by Congress—the so-called liberal party comparable to the US Democratic Party—after the 1991 market liberalization; Modi merely shoves them down people's throats with the force Congress lacked the will to use, which is why India 'needed' someone like Modi to terrorize people into accepting them, with development benefiting only a few like the Ambanis and Adanis while everyone else loses.

    “They have been started by Congress, the so-called liberal party... They have started all these measures themselves in 1991 after the market liberalization. And Modi is shoving them down our throats.”

  • Gidla is critical of the current Indian regime, charging that it stripped farmers of their lands and let them die—citing 450,000 farmer suicides—and has now turned its focus to pauperizing small-business people.

    “They stripped the farmers of their lands and let them die. So far, 450,000 farmers killed themselves, suicides. Now, they turn their focus on small-business people, and now they’re pauperized.”

  • Demonetization—the scrapping of 500 and 1,000 rupee bills—overnight destroyed the savings of small business people and tea vendors who keep their money in cash at home; Gidla cites a neighbor who, told her sold-house savings were now worthless paper, died of a heart attack, asserting this was not isolated but that hundreds died as a result.

    “There was one measure, I think it’s called demonetization. They scrapped 500 rupee bills and 1,000 bills. So all these small-time business people, tea vendors—just overnight, they lost all their money.”

  • India's digitization and biometric/identity technology, ostensibly meant to streamline the system, curb corruption, and bring everyone into the mainstream, is actually a new mode of exploitation: whereas old exploitation meant paying people low wages, the new exploitation means taking back what people already have, since low-literacy citizens cannot navigate minimum-balance requirements or bank accounts and lose their money.

    “Exploitation used to be giving people low wages, but now the exploitation is taking back what they already have.”

0.56

American political and social systems disadvantage women and workers; migration and working-class solidarity offer freedom unavailable to upper-caste Indian society.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Gidla's reason for migrating to America was to be more free, because women are extremely repressed in India compared to the US; she sought social and intellectual freedom—to ride a bicycle like a man, to read books without being questioned, to be carefree like men—scope that did not exist for women like her in India.

    “My idea of coming here is to be more free. Women are very, very, very repressed in India compared to here.”

  • Gidla prefers her lower-paid MTA conductor job to her higher-paid Bank of New York programming job because the MTA workforce is multiracial, open, passionate, and cosmopolitan—discussing things openly without hurting each other—whereas her bank colleagues were narrow-minded and uncosmopolitan, exemplified by a Catholic coworker who glared at her Darwin figurine.

    “the people are really so boring and uncosmopolitan. They are such narrow-minded people. I had this figurine of Darwin on my desk, and this guy was glaring at me because he’s a Catholic.”

  • Democrats and Republicans by and large share the same interests; Democrats merely act liberal—pretending to support women's and gay rights—but pursue the same policies, with Obama's signature achievement, Obamacare, offering no real benefit beyond pre-existing-condition coverage, illustrating that Democratic and Trump-era policies are essentially the same.

    “The Democrats and the Republicans, by and large, they have the same interests. The Democrats act like they’re liberal... but on the whole, they are the same.”

0.47

Indian Communist Party replicated caste hierarchy because its leaders inherited Gandhi's nationalist attitudes without programmatic change.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Indian Communist Party is fundamentally a caste creation not by program but in practice: its leaders came from Gandhi's nationalist Congress and brought their caste attitudes with them, so the only real difference between Communists and Gandhians was tactical—Gandhi demanded non-violence while Communists were willing to break chairs and benches for independence—with no programmatic difference on caste.

    “It’s not in the program of Communist Party to be casteist, but all these leaders, they came from Gandhi’s party... They bring along with them their caste attitudes.”

  • The claim that sub-caste divisions among untouchables (e.g., Malas oppressing Madigas) constitute oppression as severe as cross-caste oppression is false: these divisions were created externally, but untouchables themselves consider one another simply as untouchables and did not seek to steal from or deprive each other—rather, a key tactic that undermines reservations is to divide untouchables and make them fight over common reserved seats.

    “these divisions were created, but we were not aware. There are caste divisions, but we all consider ourselves as untouchables. We didn’t think that we have to steal from them or deprive from them.”

  • Dalit capitalists exist only in small numbers and were likely given perks to become capitalists so that the system could deflect accusations of casteism; figures like Chandra Bhan Prasad used their education to defect and become mouthpieces for Dalit entrepreneurship, but Dalit capitalists remain far smaller than capitalists from other castes.

    “I think that they were given some kind of, I don’t know, perk to become capitalists so that people won’t say, “Oh, how come you’re so casteist? You don’t have any Dalit capitalists?””

  • The Dalit critique of Gandhi centers on a leadership conflict: Ambedkar was seen, including by himself, as the Moses of the untouchables devoted to emancipating them, while Gandhi sought to claim leadership over all Indians including untouchables and Muslims, creating a tussle over who truly represented the untouchables.

    “Gandhi wanted to encroach on this leadership. He wanted to claim leadership of all of the people in India, including untouchables and Muslims. So there’s a tussle between Ambedkar and Gandhi. Who is the real representative of untouchables?”

0.38

Education creates narrow windows of opportunity for untouchables but yields no advantage without jobs, and white missionary imperialism obscures genuine historical aid.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The educational and professional success of Gidla and her siblings is attributable to India providing 'narrow windows of opportunity' for untouchables that opened at just the right moments—like green lights turning in time: missionaries educated her great-grandmother, post-independence liberal fervor educated her parents' generation, and she herself benefited from two prior generations in a tradition of education.

    “I think that India provided narrow windows of opportunity for untouchables. It’s like we were driving in a car and all the lights were turning green just in time.”

  • The whole Christian missionary enterprise is part of the 'white man's burden' and a prop for colonization—a way to win the colonized people's support for their colonizers—even though many individual white missionaries are unaware of this function and sincerely seek to help; Mother Teresa, despite being a target of Hindutva accusations of imperialism, did much genuine good in India as perceived by Dalits.

    “The whole Christian missionary thing, it is part of white man’s burden, a prop for colonization.”

0.34

Individual liberty requires rejecting both patriarchal feminism and paternalistic regulation; Dalit identity is lexically flexible across eras and contexts.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Gidla rejects feminism because it divides the world into men and women, and argues feminism has lately become a force for backwardness that restricts individual liberty: forcibly ripping the burka off Muslim women in Europe ignores choice, and the Nordic model criminalizing those who seek prostitutes is draconian since not all prostitutes are forced and sex work is a livelihood for many women.

    “Not all prostitutes are forced into it. What do men do if they don’t have any partner? It’s livelihood for many women.”

  • Gidla holds that the proper response to the burka and to prostitution is to preserve individual choice rather than impose paternalistic prohibition—people should be free to wear or not wear the burka, and since not all prostitutes are coerced and sex work is a livelihood, criminalizing clients (as the Nordic model does) is draconian.

    “Not all prostitutes are forced into it. What do men do if they don’t have any partner? It’s livelihood for many women.”

  • Terms like Dalit, Harijan, untouchable, and Scheduled Caste all refer to the same group, with the specific word used depending on the political era; 'Dalit' is the latest politically correct term, also accepted by untouchables themselves, while 'untouchable' is the neutral, matter-of-fact word that literally encodes the prohibition on being touched.

    “Dalit is the latest politically correct term for untouchable, which is also accepted by untouchables.”

  • Gidla defines her Marxism not as wanting government ownership of all means of production but as a worldview: just as feminists divide the world into men and women and religious people into believers and non-believers, Marxists view the world in terms of workers versus capitalists, locating problems in class difference and solutions in class action.

    “Marxism is a worldview, and Marxism looks at the world in terms of class, like feminists looks at the world as men and women... and Marxists look at people as workers and capitalists.”

0.24

Indian cinema abandoned caste critique in favor of casteist narratives; outsiders remain indifferent to caste because Indian elites conceal it and American media dominates.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Whereas early Indian cinema, in the fervor of post-independence equality, made many films about caste, dowry, laborers, and untouchability (e.g., a Brahmin hero marrying an untouchable woman), today's films no longer address social issues—and the highest-grossing Indian film, Bahubali, is an outright casteist film asserting that some people are born to rule and others born to be ruled.

    “There used to be films about dowry system. There used to be films about laborers. There used to be films about untouchability. Now, it’s not that.”

  • Outsiders are indifferent to Indian caste—unlike apartheid—for two reasons: America's global media dominance means events there are broadcast worldwide while Indian events are not, and Indian castes and rulers are deliberately secretive about caste, often denying it exists, treating exposure as 'washing dirty linen in public.'

    “while practicing caste, Indian castes and rulers are very secretive, very, very secretive about caste. They’d like to tell people that there is no such thing as caste.”