What this covers

Patrick McKenzie sits down to trace the hidden logic behind infrastructures most people treat as immovable: payments systems, banking, fraud enforcement, labor markets. He argues that what appears broken often isn't—it's simply shaped by incentives that favor inertia. A Western Union remittance fee isn't greed; it reflects the astronomical cost of maintaining physical presence in two countries. Banks over-provision parking not from incompetence but because the queuing math of account openings makes the investment rational. Even signature capture on checkout screens persists not through laziness but through social anchoring, where removing a practice costs organizational will for no visible gain.

The conversation ranges across crime (why actual bank robbers are typically addicted or mentally ill, while credit card fraud is the rational alternative), supply chains (maple syrup theft as a quiet billion-dollar problem), informal economics (Tide detergent as currency where dollar access fails), and organizational psychology (why salary negotiation remains taboo despite its tractability). McKenzie recurs to a specific claim: that spiky talent assembled quickly via the internet can outperform credentialed institutions—he cites VaccinateCA's pandemic coordination work as existence proof—and that elon musk reduced orbital launch costs by three orders of magnitude, forcing a revision of what counts as genuinely intractable. He also sketches why people overpredict evil, underpredict competence, how Twitter functions as infrastructure for federal coordination, and whether insider trading enforcement catches only the incompetent. Throughout, he treats these inefficiencies not as mysteries but as legible byproducts of layered systems where no single actor has sufficient leverage or incentive to act.

Sharpest takeaway

McKenzie argues that the modern world's infrastructure layers—payments, banking, fraud, labor markets—are riddled with vestigial practices, hidden inefficiencies, and underrated tractability, and that nonspecialists wielding the internet and a willingness to act can unlock outsized value where credentialed institutions and incumbents have not.

  • Long-standing systemic problems (false declines, remittance fees, salary under-negotiation) persist not because they are unsolvable but because no one with leverage has bothered to fix them
  • Evil and competence both exist but people overpredict evil and underpredict competence
  • The internet enables spiky nonspecialist talent to outperform credentialed institutions quickly

The argument · threads10 threads · 39 claims
0.72

Apparently intractable problems or industries harbor massive room for improvement that large organizations rationally neglect.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Bank robbery is a low-return, high-risk crime: the FBI-reported median haul is about $8,000, career bank thieves are inevitably caught over time, and credit card fraud is dramatically more lucrative with no need to threaten anyone, so actual bank robbers are disproportionately drug-addicted or mentally ill people not optimizing their criminal returns.

    “The median haul that a bank robber gets is about $8,000. It is the worst possible way to earn $8,000 because a career bank thief — the other word for that is long-term guest of the United States government.”

  • Contrary to the assumption that large professionalized regulated industries have near-zero crime rates, maple syrup supply-chain fraud is substantial because the chain of custody for cars of syrup is far less regimented than expected and boutique buyers perform few checks, making it possible to steal and resell millions of dollars of syrup on a black market.

    “it is possible to steal millions of dollars of maple syrup and sell it on the black market, which blew my mind.”

  • Western Union's high remittance fees are explained by reading its annual reports: about 50 percent of revenue goes to maintaining retail points of presence in both the sending and receiving countries, and compressing that fee requires coordinating a worldwide behavior change rather than replacing a single branch.

    “What they spend all the money on is retail points of presence by the customer in both countries, so 50 percent of all revenue taken in by Western Union goes to have a physical point of presence”

  • Anti-money-laundering and know-your-customer regulation impose enormous compliance costs on small transfers of value, justified by preventing structured transfers that enable crime, terrorism, and tax evasion; this both degrades user experience and lowers success rates relative to an unburdened parallel process, and society could choose to implement it better but has not.

    “Due to anti–money laundering and know-your-customer requirements, the amount of compliance drag on small transfers of value in the world is very, very large.”

  • Banks gratuitously over-provision parking because of queuing theory: quick teller visits have short dwell time but new account openings take 30-60+ minutes, and since a branch only opens 200-500 checking accounts a year, turning away even one or two account-opening customers in a peak window does outsized damage, making over-provisioning rational almost all the time.

    “this is a straightforward result from queuing theory... the thing that the bank really wants to optimize for is new account opening. New account opening requires 30 to 60 minutes plus of dwell time”

0.61

Financial systems tolerate unnecessary friction and security theater that impose real costs on users.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The original purpose of signing the back of a credit card was solemnization—making a legally binding promise to the bank that you are good for charges—rather than authentication or authorization, which is why it is now a vestigial feature honored in the breach as society universally understands that handing over a card is itself a binding promise.

    “it was about solemnization, that you are making a solemn, legally binding promise to the bank when you receive your card that you are good for charges made using that payment instrument”

  • Handwritten physical signatures have terrible security properties: anyone who has seen one can reproduce it, computers reproduce them easily, and forensic signature comparison amounts to near-witchcraft—making signatures a technology no one would use today to secure anything actually valued.

    “That handwritten physical signature has very terrible security properties. Anyone who has seen it can reproduce it.”

  • You do not, in a legal-realism sense, have to sign the back of your credit card, and most people who fail to do so go through life untroubled by that fact.

    “You actually don't have to sign the back of your credit card in the legal realism sense, in that you can fail to sign the back of your credit card and go throughout your life untroubled by that fact.”

  • Pointless practices like signature capture on point-of-sale screens persist because there are anchors in social practice that endure far longer than they are required or produce any value, and firms rationally decline to remove them even when they easily could.

    “There are anchors in our social practice about doing things, and sometimes things persist in those anchors for far longer than they're actually required or produce any sort of value, would be my dominant hypothesis.”

  • Spurious credit card declines occur at a rate far higher than any rational person would tolerate because the card ecosystem is a stitched-together patchwork of decades-old systems with no unitary authority to mandate improvement—a collective-action problem—yet the false-decline rate is genuinely movable if even one executive with the right people decided to work on it.

    “The rate of spurious declines is something of a trade secret, but it is much higher than any rational human being would expect is a tolerable rate of spurious false activity within a system.”

  • Whether you are taken advantage of by a bank teller or a waitress is ultimately irrelevant because an effective public-private regulatory machine will make you whole, so consumers can spend almost no cognitive cycles worrying about financial-industry or restaurant-industry fraud against their payment methods.

    “we have an extremely effective public-private regulatory state machine which will make you whole for that. It will be annoying, but you won't actually lose money.”

0.51

Most people dramatically underutilize negotiation and advocacy for themselves due to deep social scripts against perceived greed.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • One should not keep much money in a checking account because it is effectively a favor to the bank—the bank's margin is high and the depositor's all-things-considered return is low.

    “I don't think you even need any inside knowledge about banks to know that one should not keep much money in a checking account. It's a favor one does for the bank.”

  • People are afraid to negotiate—for salary or anything else—because there is a deep, near-universal societal script against being greedy that may be baked into human nature, and overriding it requires immense effort that most people don't expend or don't feel permitted to expend, creating large market inefficiencies.

    “There is a societal script against being greedy, and it is such a fundamental script in so many societies for so long, that I have a strong suspicion it might literally be baked into the operating system that is being a human.”

  • A single 2012 salary-negotiation blog post, written by someone of no special skill in the field over one day, is read by hundreds of thousands annually and generates documented salary gains of $25,000-$125,000 per emailing reader, with self-reported impact exceeding $10 million a year—revealing that society is hideously under-optimized and that many sophisticated actors are making huge correctable mistakes.

    “I keep a folder in Gmail of the aggregate impact of that and stopped counting sometime after it was like $10 million plus a year for economic impact from one blog post.”

0.48

Small groups of nonspecialists can outperform credentialed professionals by rapidly assembling concentrated talent through coordination.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • VaccinateCA provided an existence proof that nonspecialists assembled over two to six weeks can be better at important facets of pandemic preparedness than county health departments staffed by credentialed professionals who prepared for exactly this their whole careers—because spiky talent is unevenly distributed and the internet can rapidly bring together the right spikes to create leverage.

    “relative to credentialed talent in institutions... Can't we be better at important facets of pandemic preparedness given, hmm, two to six weeks versus a county health department... Yes. Straightforwardly, yes.”

  • The author long assumed rocketry was near its physical limits given billions spent and the smartest scientists, but Elon Musk reduced orbital launch costs by roughly three orders of magnitude, providing an existence proof that forces a reevaluation of how tractable apparently intractable problems actually are.

    “Then Elon Musk came around and said, "Actually, I think we can cheat the costs of getting things up to orbit by, oh, three orders of magnitude."”

0.44

Bitcoin and Tether remain substantially overvalued despite years of market signal, revealing persistent mispricing in crypto markets.

9 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The speaker believes Bitcoin is overpriced at $33,000 relative to its demonstrated real-world utility and the tens of billions invested in its infrastructure, yet acknowledges epistemic humility because over a decade the market has persistently voted against his view; manipulation explains some but not all of it, and the puzzle remains that the market rates Bitcoin as crypto's most valuable product even though it is clearly not crypto's best product.

    “Do I believe it is overpriced at $33,000 relative to the amount of actual utility that's demonstrated in the world... Absolutely, yes.”

  • Embedding payments into Twitter/X to create a super app is far below 1 percent likely to succeed because users come to Twitter for an entirely different basket of goods that does not involve payments or repeated business interactions, and grafting payments onto that basket will not drive adoption—super apps require carefully engineered adoption loops and biz dev that the organization is unlikely to be resourced or competent enough to execute.

    “The fundamental reason why I am extremely bearish on it happening for Twitter — and I would put the percentage at below 1 percent, far below 1 percent — is that this is very, very hard.”

  • Twitter is descriptively one of the most important products on the internet because it has ameliorated cross-organization coordination problems, functioning as the sub rosa message bus and coordination mechanism for the US federal government, its counterparties, and the media—an integrated part of the operating system of the world.

    “It is broadly under-appreciated how Twitter is the message bus, the sub rosa coordination mechanism for the United States federal government, for every counterparty that the United States federal government or any agency or individual faces, for the media, for everything.”

  • The internet is the capital-G Great Work of the human race—magical, an encapsulation of society's best, and instrumentally useful for improving all good things and ameliorating problems over long time scales—and is more important in aggregate than penicillin by many orders of magnitude and even more important than the entire institution of medicine across all time.

    “I think that the internet is the capital G, capital W, Great Work of the human race in a lot of respects, that it is magical.”

  • The speaker plans to learn next about the engineering reality of geothermal heat and electricity extraction 6-10 kilometers below the surface, doing pro bono work for a nonprofit popularizing the technology as part of the energy mix, an idea he is bullish on and cannot get out of his head.

    “It is more of the engineering reality of geothermal heat and electricity extraction between 6 and 10 kilometers below the surface of the earth”

  • A non-heritage learner of Japanese (or Chinese) should benchmark at least three years of study to become professionally capable at reading and writing, based on the speaker's own roughly six years of less-than-diligent study to reach effective professional proficiency.

    “if you're not a heritage reader of Japanese or Chinese, you should benchmark it at least three years to be professionally capable at it.”

  • Tide detergent is used as an informal currency by people with limited access to dollars because its intact tamper seal lets corner bodegas easily verify it and they have near-unlimited willingness to do small profitable transactions, allowing stolen or illicitly acquired Tide to be recycled into the legitimate economy.

    “the traditional way to use Tide as a currency for people who have less access to dollars was to resell the Tide to a corner bodega.”

  • Banks instruct employees to comply fully with robbers and never resist because the net present value of a young employee far exceeds the typical $8,000 haul—a shot employee could mean millions in settlement liability—and because banks genuinely are not at material financial risk from cash lost in robberies.

    “In the event of a bank robbery, don't be a hero. This does not matter to us at all. Comply with all demands.”

  • People systematically overpredict evil and underpredict competence in the world; the speaker initially thought himself sophisticated for believing this, then had to revise upward his estimate of how much evil actually exists, but still below the level society generally predicts.

    “I broadly think people overpredict evil and underpredict competence.”

0.38

Frauds and crimes persist far longer than detection would suggest because they require liquidity shocks or enforcement action to collapse.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Tether has at times been an out-and-out fraud with essentially no backing—per CFTC findings it was less than fully backed on more than 75 of roughly 540 examined days—and the speaker expects it should eventually collapse, likely triggered by government action against its custodied reserves followed by public disclosure and a classic run, even though frauds (like Madoff's 17-18 years) can persist long before collapsing.

    “there exists sufficient evidence on the public record in the CFTC case... that, at times in the past, it has been an out-and-out fraud that had essentially no backing”

  • We detect far less insider trading than expected, and it is unclear whether it is genuinely rare or whether enforcement only catches the dumbest, most incompetent offenders—evidenced by SEC cases involving people who googled how to get away with it on their work computers—leaving open whether competent criminals simply find easier, lower-risk ways to make money.

    “one place where we detect much less fraud than I would expect us to detect is in insider trading and other forms of, obviously, illegal market manipulation.”

  • Bernie Madoff's fraud persisted for 17-18 years and only became undeniable when the global financial crisis caused investors to request redemptions he could not meet—illustrating that frauds typically continue every day until a liquidity shock forces collapse, not because of detection.

    “Madoff was active for 17 or 18 years, and the only thing that actually brought his fraud to light... was being unable to meet redemption requests in the wake of the global financial crisis.”

0.38

Casual statements about industry viability or personal choices carry disproportionate weight in shaping others' life trajectories.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Even people held in high regard sometimes make very large life decisions based on very small amounts of data or consideration, so one should be careful with casual statements like 'the tech industry is so over' because someone may take them at surface level and the field could lose a person it would have wanted.

    “even people you have a high degree of regard for sometimes make very large decisions based on very small amounts of data or very small amounts of consideration with regards to that decision”

  • The speaker built a rigorous spreadsheet to choose Japanese as the language to learn—based on the Wall Street Journal's prediction that US engineering employment would collapse—and the premise turned out to be entirely false, illustrating that you can have great reasons for a decision that utterly fail to matter, while the decision itself can still prove pivotal.

    “It turns out that there was a great deal of rigor there, chasing a conclusion that had absolutely no basis in fact.”

  • The speaker counts as one of his great regrets that in his twenties he had too little ambition, was beaten down, and spent his peak energy and health on a World of Warcraft guild and a salaryman job rather than exiting earlier to higher-impact work—an experience he believes he could have extracted in six weeks to six months rather than six years.

    “one of the great regrets of my life is that, in my twenties, I had so little ambition and was so beaten down, and didn't take more aggressive actions to exit out of the situation I found myself in.”

0.38

Work environments and local economic constraints shape job choice even when workers find the labor soul-destroying or unethical.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Debt collection draws some workers because the existence of evil is real and some people derive genuine utility from inflicting suffering, making the job a desirable fit for them—analogous to how some (not all) people enter policing for that reason.

    “There are some people who enjoy inflicting suffering on others. If you enjoy inflicting suffering, debt collection is a wonderful gig for you.”

  • Debt collector turnover exceeds the near-100%-a-year fast-food rate, and despite a real productivity production function where collectors vary by an order of magnitude in dollars collected per hour, the overwhelming reason people leave is not incapability but that the job is soul-destroying.

    “the turnover rate for debt collectors is astounding. It's on the order of... It is higher than it is for fast food restaurants, which is already close to 100 percent a year”

  • Many debt collectors take the job because, in the rural places where collection call centers are located, the local economy is not at full employment and a collection center may be the only available office job, so it is the most rational choice among those actually presented even if the worker hates it.

    “in rural New York, that might not be great. It might not be quite so full employment. For office jobs that are available, a debt collection call center or a more salubrious call center might be the only office job available.”

0.24

Cultural institutions encode status directly rather than requiring purchase, creating different incentive structures than Western consumption.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Returning to the US after 20 years, the speaker experiences sharp reverse culture shock most strikingly in dramatically larger restaurant portion sizes (verifiable in McDonald's portion data over time) and in a pervasive American 'lack of the will to have nice things'—a million small avoidable failures that a rich, powerful nation needlessly tolerates, in contrast to Japan.

    “portion sizes are so much larger than they were when I was growing up... You can look at pictures of McDonald's portion sizes over time and track them as they go up into the red.”

  • Where the US professional-managerial class earns money to consume social status (the big house to show friends), Japanese salarymen pursue promotions that confer little additional money but directly award social status within a tightly observed workplace hierarchy—so the system awards status directly rather than letting people buy it.

    “Most people want to become wealthy so they can consume social status. Japanese employers believe this is inefficient and simply award social status directly.”

  • Entrepreneurs are historically and substantially undervalued in the Japanese dating market—a preschooler concluded 'just as I thought, he is unemployed' upon hearing the word entrepreneur—reflecting that Japan loves entrepreneurs only retrospectively, in the way Catholicism loves saints who all lived long ago, though this is changing over time.

    “Just as I thought, he is unemployed... entrepreneurs are extremely undervalued in the Japanese dating market.”

0.20

Fictional media shapes entrepreneurial identity and participation by conferring social permission that founders later disown publicly.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The film The Social Network is one of the most influential works of fiction ever in that it raised the status of entrepreneurship for proto-entrepreneurs worldwide, visible both in spikes of Y Combinator applications and in the personal narratives of founders, though founders tend to expunge this 'social permission' origin from their public stories.

    “The Social Network raised the status of entrepreneurship for proto-entrepreneurs worldwide. Thus, we can see it in the data — there was a wave of applications to places like Y Combinator”

  • Having abundant free evenings with no English outlet in Japan pushed the speaker to write far more than most people do in their twenties, and the compounding effects of that consistent writing are responsible for much of the good fortune and accomplishments in his life.

    “having a lot of free time on your hands in the evenings and no outlet for English was a great push in the right direction of writing more than most people do in their 20s.”