What this covers
Patricia Fara argues that the received story of science—a progression of revolutionary breakthroughs achieved by solitary geniuses—distorts how knowledge actually advances. In conversation with Tyler Cowen, Fara traces this distortion through overlooked historical evidence: the term "scientist" didn't exist until the 1830s; the Principia required translators and simplifiers to reach an audience; women performed essential mathematical and illustrative labor that made experiments replicable across borders. She contends that Isaac Newton and Charles Darwin, while remarkable, operated within dense networks of collaboration, patronage, and inherited ideas—not in isolation. The Scientific Revolution itself, she argues, is a misleading twentieth-century label imposed retrospectively, born partly from Cold War rhetoric comparing science to religion as a universal language.
The conversation spans the unglamorous materials of scientific practice: Alessandro Volta's role in creating current electricity alongside myths about Benjamin Franklin; Robert Hooke's seventeenth-century inference of ancient seas from geological strata; the way transport infrastructure—canals and railways—exposed the evidence that changed geology. Fara examines portraiture, satirical caricature, and scientific illustration as windows into how discoveries were communicated and received, with Marie-Anne Paulze Lavoisier emerging as a pivotal figure whose drawings made chemistry reproducible. The discussion turns to why women appear underrepresented in science histories: not because of capability gaps (data from Muslim-majority nations shows women dominate STEM when barriers are highest), but because the Heroic Model of Science erases the domestic, collective, teaching-centered work where women were centrally placed. Fara challenges Thomas Kuhn's model of revolutionary Paradigm Shift while describing how Linnaeus's classification system won acceptance through promotion despite significant flaws and opposition.
Fara argues that science advances through continuous, collaborative processes rather than discrete revolutions led by lone geniuses, which means the 'Scientific Revolution' is a misleading label and that communicators, illustrators, and women have been systematically undervalued contributors.
- The term 'scientist' wasn't coined until the 1830s, so there was no nonscientific-to-scientific break in the 16th-17th centuries
- Science depends on communication and collaboration (translation, illustration, calculation), roles in which women were central
- Apparent 'late' discoveries (geology, classification) were gated by other social activities, not sudden insight
Science developed gradually from practical human needs, not as a revolutionary break from non-science.
- There was no Scientific Revolution; it is an inappropriate 20th-century label (largely a post-WWII construct comparing science to religion as a universal pacifist language) because the word 'scientist' wasn't even coined until the 1830s, science as we know it didn't exist in the 16th-17th centuries, and the change was a long process of continuity rather than a precipitate revolution from a nonscientific to a scientific state.
“I personally don’t think there was a Scientific Revolution. I think it’s a very inappropriate label.”
- Many ancient civilizations had very advanced knowledge but were not directing it toward what we now call science; they wanted to live better, be healthier, grow more crops, travel, and become rich, and the techniques they developed for those practical ends were only later adapted and reframed as part of science.
“they weren’t directing it to what we would call science. They wanted to live better. They wanted to be more healthy. They wanted to grow more crops.”
- The abacus is a good example of an instrument developed not for scientific reasons but for trading and marketing—merchants needed to add up bills—illustrating how many tools later associated with science originated in commerce.
“It’s a good example of an instrument that was not developed for scientific reasons but for other reasons — in this instance, trading and marketing.”
- Geological insight into a changing earth came late in Europe partly because of Christian beliefs in a six-day creation and a fixed world, but the unchanging-earth view had already been overturned long before Darwin; Robert Hooke argued from marine fossils on the Surrey downs in the mid-17th century that a sea once covered the land, and infrastructure projects like canals and railways later exposed geological strata, so a different activity—improving transport—stimulated scientific insight.
“Already, in the middle of the 17th century, Robert Hooke was arguing that there must once have been a sea that lay over that land because he was finding all these marine fossils.”
- The Antikythera mechanism—an intricate ancient Greek geared device far predating the Middle Ages when such mechanical sophistication was assumed to begin—confirms that many similar devices must have existed, prompting historians to reread ancient texts for overlooked indications that advanced technology existed far earlier than believed.
“The fact that one has been found which is so technically proficient suggests, or really confirms, that there must have been many, many others as well.”
Women made essential contributions to science through collaborative work before the 19th-century shift to professionalized laboratories.
- If science is understood as continuous and collaborative—not a range of mountain peaks with lone geniuses on top—then women played a crucial role, because before the 19th century science happened at home and depended on teaching, illustrating, drawing, editing, running museums, and collecting specimens; the very spread of Newton's deliberately obscure Principia required others to translate and simplify it, work in which women were vital.
“if you think of science as being continuous, not as a range of mountain peaks with individual geniuses standing on top of them, then women played a very, very important role”
- A high proportion of early-modern German astronomers were women because astronomy was then a craft requiring home-made instruments; the strong German guild structure meant women in instrument-making shops inherited their fathers' businesses or were trained from childhood, and astronomers' wives like Joanna Flamsteed and assistants like Caroline Herschel performed the essential mathematical work of turning raw stellar readings into catalog measurements.
“The guild structure was very strong in Germany, and a lot of women — in England as well — who were working in instrument-making shops inherited their father’s business”
- Marie-Anne Paulze Lavoisier was the greatest female illustrator of science: she learned English to connect her husband Antoine with English-speaking chemists, and drew the 12 plates in his revolutionary chemistry textbook that dissected each instrument so readers in Berlin, New York, or London could exactly replicate his apparatus and results; she also produced sketches depicting his laboratory with herself at its center recording observations, portraying science as collective work rather than the product of one brain.
“somebody who reads the book in Berlin or New York or London could replicate Lavoisier’s results precisely and build an instrument that was exactly the same as the one that he was using. She drew all those plates.”
- Dorothy Hodgkin, the only British woman to win a Nobel Prize for science, determined the molecular structures of insulin, vitamin B, and penicillin through X-ray crystallography, and—being an affable person who campaigned for maternity leave, supported other women, raised four children, and lacked a glamorous tragic narrative—is the ideal role model for a scientist precisely because she was an ordinary woman who simply got on with her work.
“She identified the molecular structures through X-ray crystallography. She identified insulin, vitamin B, and penicillin.”
Cultural bias and social structures, not intrinsic ability, drive women's underrepresentation in STEM fields.
- Women's low representation in theoretical physics is driven by cultural bias—a lingering belief that women aren't clever enough for physics, too few good physics teachers in girls' schools, and men in physics unwilling to recruit or promote women—rather than any intrinsic inability.
“I also think we still have a cultural bias, which is very unfortunate, which suggests that women are not clever enough to do physics.”
- The cross-national pattern in which women form a high share of STEM students in oppressive Muslim nations but a low share in egalitarian Nordic nations strongly confirms that representation is driven by social prejudice and cultural beliefs rather than intrinsic ability; in Arab nations women who study science often go on to teach other women, a model worth emulating, whereas in Britain the problems begin with girls being poorly taught and discouraged at school.
“that does very strongly confirm what I was saying, that it’s a social prejudice, a set of cultural beliefs rather than an intrinsic inability of women to do physics.”
- Single-sex education is wrong because gender equality cannot be achieved by separating people; achieving it requires not only improving women's position but changing the attitudes of both men and women toward work and life, and the more cooperative parenting now visible (fathers involved with children) reflects the kind of shift needed, since life and happiness matter more than work.
“We’re never going to get away from gender discrimination if we keep separating people, and we’ve got to bring them together.”
- After leaving university Fara learned never to admit she had a physics degree from Oxford because at parties a large empty space would form around her, reflecting a double bind in which she was simultaneously encouraged to succeed as a scientist and expected to be the perfect wife and mother, leaving her feeling she fulfilled neither role and lacking confidence until her 40s or 50s.
“I should never ever admit that I had a degree in physics from Oxford because if I was at a nightclub or a party or something, there would soon be this big empty space all around me.”
Newton was a complex figure driven by wealth and social position, not a solitary genius with an apple insight.
- Newton became extremely wealthy not from his Cambridge professorship but from running the London Mint (which paid a fat salary plus a premium per gold coin minted) combined with investments in global trading companies like the East India Company and stock market ventures, leaving an inventory of possessions recorded on a 17-foot vellum scroll.
“He got a fat salary for that. He also got a premium, a reward for every single gold coin that was minted.”
- Newton was frustrated at Cambridge in part because, though a devout believer, he rejected the orthodox Anglican belief in the Trinity, putting him at odds with colleagues; a well-connected friend, Charles Montagu, secured him the prestigious Mint job, which he took immediately.
“he was a very, very devout believer in God, but he didn’t adhere to the traditional, to the orthodox Anglican theological belief in the Trinity, so that was difficult for him.”
- The famous apple-falling story was a myth Newton himself only began telling about five years before he died, recounting it to four separate people, suggesting he was constructing a mythological version of scientific creativity; the story then vanished for decades and only resurfaced in the 19th century, making the apple his secular-saint attribute.
“it was a story that he only started telling about five years before he died, and he did tell it to four separate people.”
- Despite his antisocial reputation, Newton owned vast quantities of catering equipment—hundreds of plates and sets of cutlery—and the ultimate Georgian luxury of two silver chamber pots, along with portraits used as bribes, furniture, a carriage, a sedan chair, and many servants.
“he owned two silver chamber pots.”
- Newton initially profited from the South Sea Company by selling after the stock rose, but then made the classic beginner's error of reinvesting at a higher price and watched the value crash, losing several million in today's currency.
“He invested in again at a higher price, and he watched the value crash.”
- 17th-century portraits of scholars like John Evelyn or Newton were often given melancholic expressions because melancholy was associated with scholarship—the image of sitting in a darkened room with white skin and fine bones—so that physical attributes were taken to reflect the brilliance of the brain, whereas 18th-century portraits shifted to depicting men as noble and austere.
“being melancholy was associated with scholarship — the idea that you would sit inside in a darkened room, and you had very white skin and fine bones. Your physical attributes reflected the brilliance of your brain.”
- Newton solved the problem of coin clipping not merely by melting and reissuing coins but by modernizing their manufacture: keeping the secret dies and introducing milled (ridged) edges so that shaving off silver became immediately noticeable and the coins much harder to forge.
“the fact that all the coins have this milled edge — the little ridges around the rim of the coin — meant that you couldn’t shave a bit off because it would be noticeable.”
Credit for scientific discoveries is often misattributed, overlooking women's actual contributions and promoting false heroic narratives.
- The credit for identifying the full power of electricity belongs not to Benjamin Franklin but to Alessandro Volta, who built the 'pile' (a precursor to the modern battery), produced a continuous current, and demonstrated it was the same kind of electricity present in living bodies—making him the key figure in creating current (as opposed to static) electricity.
“He managed to produce a current of electricity, and he showed that it’s the same as the electricity that’s in our bodies.”
- Satirical caricatures capture how the public reacted to new science: Gillray's famous print showed Jenner's smallpox-vaccination patients sprouting horns and turning into cows because the vaccine was based on cowpox, while Darwin was drawn as an ape and Marie Curie depicted demurely hiding behind Pierre as if he were the genius—revealing both contemporary terror of innovation and the misattribution of women's discoveries to men.
“Gillray did a very famous caricature of all the patients in the clinic sprouting horns and turning into cows because the vaccine was based on cowpox.”
- Charles Darwin's grandfather Erasmus Darwin developed one of the earliest British theories of evolution, expressed in the closing pages of his medical textbook Zoonomia, which Charles read as a student; Charles later titled the notebook containing his first sketch of an evolutionary branching tree 'Zoonomia,' showing his grandfather's deep intellectual influence alongside inherited traits and an aversion to slavery.
“There’s one notebook that has got his first sketch of an evolutionary branching tree, and that notebook is called Zoonomia.”
History of science trains essential reasoning skills and reveals how theory, evidence, and belief interact in ways scientific training alone does not.
- The most valuable contribution of philosophy of science is its treatment of the nature of truth and objectivity—whether truth can ever be attained—and the relationship between observation and fact, showing that the link between theory and evidence is far more complicated than most people are led to believe.
“the philosophical relationships between an observation and a fact, that the theory is much more complicated than most people are led to believe.”
- History of science should be compulsory for all science students because, beyond exposing them to still-relevant ethical debates, it teaches the skill of arguing, interpreting, and expressing one's own position—essential for tasks like writing grant applications—whereas standard science training only teaches calculation from a fixed knowledge base, and students consistently love the chance to think for themselves.
“We teach science students how to write essays, how to present their own position. That’s the skill that everybody is going to need.”
- Thomas Kuhn's idea that science proceeds not in a straight line up the mountain of truth but through crises and revolutions—where accumulating contrary evidence overwhelms a fixed belief and flips it into a new paradigm—has had many holes picked in it (which Kuhn himself might accept), yet was enormously influential in changing how people think about the interaction between science and society.
“An enormous number of holes have been picked in Thomas Kuhn’s book, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.”
- Merlin Sheldrake, author of Entangled Life and a former history-of-science student of Fara's at Cambridge, is an excellent example of how studying history of science can produce someone who is both a brilliant scientist and a brilliant writer.
“He is an excellent example of how someone who studied history of science can also be a brilliant scientist and a brilliant writer.”
Newton's natural philosophy, including gravity and ether mechanisms, drew support from serious alchemical and spiritual inquiry.
- Unlike the clockmaker view in which God created the universe and let it run itself, Newton held that God was immanent—constantly present throughout the universe—with comets bearing reanimating live matter, producing a vibrant, living view of the cosmos absent from modern physics.
“Newton’s idea was that God was constantly present throughout the universe. He used the word “immanent.””
- Alchemy was a serious intellectual and spiritual pursuit, not crankery; its core idea that base matter could be transmuted (lead into gold) paralleled spiritual cleansing of the soul, and Newton's alchemical theories actually fed into his natural philosophy, providing mechanisms to explain how gravity could act between inert lumps of matter.
“You can’t draw a hard line between alchemy that’s rubbish and science that’s legitimate and that science is right. It’s not like that at all.”
- Newton's ether—a hypothetical medium of tiny invisible particles through which gravity could be transmitted like sound through air—was floated as a speculative query in the Opticks, and despite sounding bizarre, the ether was believed by eminent scientists throughout the 19th century until Einstein's 1905 theory of relativity dispensed with it.
“It only finally disappeared in 1905 when Albert Einstein introduced his theory of relativity, and one of his aims in doing that is to dispense with the ether”
Scientific classification schemes like Linnaeus's system are arbitrary, flawed, and succeed only through deliberate promotion, not logical superiority.
- Plants had been classified for centuries according to their uses (food and drugs), and the Linnaean system was just one of several competing schemes that was strongly opposed at the time; it is deeply flawed and arbitrary in counting flowers' sexual characteristics, fails for the roughly half of flora without countable flowers, and—like all new scientific ideas—had to be actively promoted through a public-relations exercise to win acceptance, and is now itself being replaced.
“It’s a deeply flawed system that was much criticized at the time. It was like all new scientific ideas — it had to be promoted.”
- From the Renaissance and 17th century it was traditional for a book's frontispiece—the image opposite the title page—to carry a visual summary of the whole book's arguments, as in Charles Lyell's 19th-century geology book whose Temple of Serapis frontispiece encoded his theory of the temple sinking and rising via boreholes from marine organisms on the pillars; this is a tradition worth reviving because pictures can communicate many kinds of information that only work visually.
“the frontispiece carried a visual summary of the arguments of the whole book.”
Fara's own career reflects the costs of gendered pressure to succeed in science while conforming to domestic expectations.
- Despite being intellectually steered into science and excelling at it through an Oxford physics degree, Fara was bored by laboratory physics and ultimately found far greater happiness moving to the arts side and a historical subject, suggesting she was directed into science without anyone—including herself—questioning whether it was what she actually wanted.
“I also steered into studying science without anybody — including me — seriously questioning whether that was what I actually wanted to do.”
- Fara has tried to live by George Eliot's concluding insight in Middlemarch that even unhistoric, small acts within one's grasp can have cumulative beneficial effects, finding her greatest career gratification in helping individual distressed students recover and return to a happy life rather than in any grand achievement.
“even unhistoric acts, small ones that seemed within my grasp, could have cumulative beneficial effects.”
- Running a small family company making educational tape-slide programs about statistics and computing trained Fara to write, because she had to translate complex programming and statistical ideas into very simple phrases each matched to a single illustration—the discipline of presenting an image and an idea together in basic terms that she credits as fantastic intellectual training and the source of the many images in her books.
“You had to present an image and an idea together in very simple, basic terms, and I think that was fantastic intellectual training.”