Noam Chomsky
What this covers
Tyler Cowen interviews Noam Chomsky in this 2018 conversation, ranging across language, political economy, media, and existential risk. Chomsky defends two large claims: that human language is an innate biological capacity fundamentally rooted in thought rather than communication, and that modern democracies operate as Manufacturing Consent systems in which elites shape public opinion to exclude ordinary people from meaningful participation in policy. The conversation weaves between these threads — historical, scientific, and normative — with Chomsky tracing connections from Wilhelm von Humboldt's theory of the "infinite use of finite means" through Woodrow Wilson's World War I propaganda machine to contemporary debates over AI and global catastrophic risk.
On language, Chomsky argues that Innate Endowment and a species-specific capacity for generating unbounded novel thoughts distinguish humans from all other organisms, and that [natural selection](jargon:natural selection) may have played little to no role in language evolution—a departure from behaviorism's view of gradual, communication-driven origins. He addresses why large language models, despite their statistical power, cannot illuminate human language because they work equally well on Possible vs Impossible Languages, making them silent on the nature of human cognition. On politics and media, he traces manufacture of consent to Walter Lippmann and Edward Bernays, showing how the Committee on Public Information mobilized public sentiment for war while Reinhold Niebuhr articulated the elite doctrine that populations need "necessary illusions." The discussion covers US interventions in Nicaragua and Cuba, the role of economists in excluding the public from economic reasoning, housing segregation and wealth accumulation, and the two greatest threats Chomsky sees: nuclear winter and climate inaction, both manufactured into invisibility by consent systems.
Chomsky argues that human language is fundamentally an innate, biologically-rooted instrument of thought (not a communication system that evolved gradually), and that modern political and media structures function as a propaganda system that manufactures consent to keep an ignorant public passive while elites pursue catastrophic policies.
- Language is a species-specific capacity that emerged suddenly with modern humans and is innate, not gradually selected for communication
- Large language models work equally well on impossible languages, so they reveal nothing about the nature of human language
- Elite institutions deliberately 'manufacture consent' to exclude the public from genuine participation in policy
Elites deliberately manufacture consent by controlling information to manipulate public opinion and exclude ordinary people from power.
- Woodrow Wilson, elected in 1916 on a pacifist platform, faced the problem of turning an anti-war population into supporters of entering WWI, and solved it through the Committee on Public Information (Creel Commission), which included Lippmann and Edward Bernays, brilliantly converting the public into fanatic anti-German sentiment and simultaneously enabling a corporate attack on labor unions via accusations of anti-patriotism.
“Wilson was elected in 1916 on a pacifist program... How do you turn a pacifist population into raving anti-German maniacs? He succeeded brilliantly. Part of the device was a commission that Wilson set up called the Committee on Public Information”
- The standard liberal position held by Lippmann and Bernays is that the population is stupid and ignorant and doesn't know what's good for them, so 'responsible men' must do their planning and protect themselves from 'the roar and the trampling of the bewildered herd' — a Leninist-style doctrine in which the public may be spectators but not participants, fed 'necessary illusions and emotionally potent oversimplifications' as Niebuhr put it.
“both Lippmann and Bernays adopted the standard liberal position, that the population is, as the terms were, stupid and ignorant. They don’t know what’s good for them. We, the responsible men, have to do their planning”
- One aspect of manufacturing consent was separating the economy from public affairs, with economists (including liberal economists) playing a major role by framing the economy as pure science that the public should have nothing to do with, thereby excluding ordinary people from economic decision-making.
“One aspect of this was separating the economy from public affairs. Economists played a major role in this, including liberal economists... separate the economy, which is just pure science. We take care of the science. The public should have nothing to do with it.”
- Chomsky's critique of media stems more from his views on social and political structure than on language; the phrase 'manufacturing consent' was borrowed from Walter Lippmann, a leading liberal public intellectual and member of Wilson's Committee on Public Information, who praised manufacture of consent as 'a new art in the practice of democracy.'
“the phrase manufacturing consent was not mine. I borrowed it from Walter Lippmann, as you know, the leading public intellectual of the 20th century.”
- A recent Pew poll asking people to rank a couple dozen issues by urgency did not even list nuclear war, while climate change ranked at the bottom of 21 choices — which Chomsky cites as manufacture of consent in a form that will destroy us all.
“they gave people a couple of dozen choices of issues and asked them to rank them in terms of urgency. Nuclear war was not even on the list. Climate change was on the list. It was ranked at the bottom of the 21 choices. That’s manufacture of consent in a form which is going to destroy us all.”
- Because society is a rigid class-based system in which the business classes and ultra-rich wage a constant class war and control resources, institutions, and the economy, ideas they dislike (like left libertarianism, socialism, anarchism) simply are not heard; as Orwell noted, unpopular ideas can be suppressed in free England without the use of force, through the class nature of society and the subordination of intellectuals to power.
“The business classes, the ultra-rich are dedicated to class war. They’re basically vulgar Marxists, fight values inverted, constantly fighting a harsh class war.”
Human language is a unique innate capacity for unbounded thought creation that evolved suddenly and has remained unchanged.
- Genomic and archeological evidence indicates the language faculty was already in place before modern human groups separated (~150,000-200,000 years ago), since all living humans share it identically; before modern humans there is almost no symbolic activity in the record, but shortly after their appearance rich creative records like cave paintings emerge, suggesting language capacity emerged suddenly and has not changed since.
“we now have genomic analysis — pretty sound — that shows that the small modern homo sapiens groups that emerged very quickly began to separate quickly again in evolutionary time, maybe 50,000 years. We know that they all share the faculty of language and thought.”
- Contrary to the behaviorist-influenced 20th century view that language is fundamentally an instrument of communication evolved from animal signaling systems, the older tradition that language is fundamentally an instrument of thought is correct; recent work suggests human language and thought evolved in a quite different way that is consistent with actual evolutionary theory.
“my own view is that recent work shows that the tradition was quite right, that that’s not the way human language and thought evolved at all. They evolved in quite a different way, which is completely consistent with the actual theory of evolution, not the naive version that’s often believed.”
- Natural selection may have played very little or almost no role in the evolution of language and thought, which is quite consistent with the theory of evolution because many things happen in evolution beyond natural selection, contrary to Darwin's famous claim that all evolutionary changes must be very small.
“It may be, for example, that natural selection played very little or almost no role in the evolution of language and thought, but that’s quite consistent with the theory of evolution.”
- Like all organisms humans have innate capacities determined by genetic endowment; just as the embryo grows arms not wings, a newborn infant can reflexively pick out the language parts of surrounding noise and follow a determined maturation course to absorb the fundamentals of language by age two or three — a capacity that the smartest chimpanzee or dog entirely lacks, hearing only noise.
“there’s something about the genetic endowment that says that a newborn infant can instantly pick out parts of the noise that surrounds it and say to itself, “Those parts are language.””
- The fundamental property of human language is the unique capacity to create unboundedly many new thoughts and convey them to others, which Humboldt called the 'infinite use of finite means' — a concept not well understood until the mid-20th century theory of computation developed by Gödel, Turing, and others showed how finite means can provide infinite scope.
“Language enables what he called infinite use of finite means. We have a finite system. We make unbounded use of it.”
The United States employs coercive power to control other nations' economies and suppress development models threatening its dominance.
- Cuba has been under savage US attack for 60 years (formal US determination to overthrow it dating to 1960), yet it survived and developed a world-class biomedical system with better health statistics than the United States, despite third-party US sanctions so strict they block vaccine materials and which the UN opposes 184 to 2; the world obeys these sanctions out of fear of the most violent country in the world.
“Cuba has been under savage attack for 60 years. It’s astonishing that it’s even survived... It has better health statistics than the United States.”
- Comparing demographics from China's 1949 liberation to 1979 against democratic capitalist India over the same years reveals a gap of about a hundred million people, meaning Maoist rural development and healthcare programs saved roughly a hundred million people from death and starvation relative to India — a fact discussed by scholars like Amartya Sen but suppressed in public discourse (itself manufacture of consent).
“One of the things that the Maoist policies did was save a hundred million people. A hundred million people were saved from death and starvation, as compared with democratic, capitalist India in the same years.”
- When the European Union tries to trade with Cuba, the US threatens to throw it out of the international financial system, so the EU obeys US sanctions, demonstrating the coercive reach of US third-party sanctions over even allied economies.
“If the European Union tries to trade with Cuba, the US threatens it with throwing it out of the international financial system. The European Union obeys the US sanctions.”
- Nicaragua, the second-poorest country in Latin America after Haiti, began successful development programs under the Sandinistas in the early 1980s that were praised by the World Bank and Oxfam, but Reagan launched a war (for which the US was condemned by the World Court for unlawful use of force) that destroyed these programs and restored Nicaragua to US control, so its poor trajectory reflects US intervention rather than the failure of its model.
“The United States was actually brought to the World Court and condemned for international terrorism, technically unlawful use of force in its war against Nicaragua, ordered to pay substantial reparations.”
- The most enthusiastic Maoist in the country was Henry Kissinger, who adored and worshiped Mao as a sycophant, as documented in Carolyn Eisenberg's archival study of the Nixon-Kissinger years.
“if you want the most enthusiastic Maoist in the country, his name happens to be Henry Kissinger. He adored Mao, he worshiped him.”
Humanity faces existential crises of nuclear war and environmental destruction that require immediate urgent action and popular resistance.
- The world faces two enormous crises — the growing threat of terminal nuclear war and the failure to take feasible steps against environmental destruction — and is moving in the wrong direction on both, with leadership 'racing to the precipice,' which is why the Doomsday Clock was moved to 90 seconds to midnight.
“We are facing two enormous crises. There’s a reason why the Doomsday Clock of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists was recently moved to 90 seconds to midnight. One is the growing threat of nuclear war, which will be terminal war. Another is the failure to take the necessary and feasible steps to deal with an existential crisis of environmental destruction.”
- Despite the crises, there are grounds for hope because throughout history people have organized, resisted, and overthrown repressive structures to create broader freedom and justice; the United States is far more civilized than 50-60 years ago not by magic but through popular struggle, as evidenced by activism among young people demanding a better future.
“Country’s much more civilized than it was just 50 or 60 years ago. Didn’t happen by magic. It happened by lots of popular struggle.”
- Chomsky attributes his late-life mental vitality to the incentive of so much work of enormous significance, since on both intellectual and human-survival fronts we are in a unique moment requiring a decision within decades whether the human experiment continues, leaving no way to relax.
“Just the incentive of so much to do of such enormous significance. I don’t see any way to stop”
- Even contemplating nuclear war between major powers is literally insane because the country that launches a first strike will be destroyed even without retaliation, simply from the effects of nuclear winter; therefore every step must be taken to ensure it cannot happen, and Schelling's game-theoretical analyses are abstractly fine but miss this basic point.
“The country that launches a first strike will be destroyed, even if there’s no retaliatory strike, just from the effects of nuclear winter.”
Structural racism and imperial history constrain social progress, though popular movements have civilized American society despite ongoing domination.
- Chomsky says he was wrong to get involved in opposing the Vietnam War only in the early 1960s when Kennedy escalated it, because the basic government decisions that set the stage for the most hideous crime of the 20th century were made in the early 1950s, which was the time to have gotten involved.
“I got seriously involved in the early ’60s, when Kennedy sharply escalated the war... but the time to have gotten involved was 10 years earlier. I didn’t know it at the time.”
- The new right's anti-establishment rhetoric is a joke because the right wing of the Republican Party are servile worshipers of the very rich and corporate sector, as shown by the 2017 Trump tax cut (which Stiglitz called the 'Donor Relief Act') and the program to defund the IRS to protect wealthy tax cheats, while Trump as a demagogue tells working people 'I love you' with one hand while stabbing them in the back with the other.
“During the Trump years, there was one major legislation — what Joseph Stiglitz called the Donor Relief Act of 2017 — a tax cut that was a gift to the super-rich”
- The New Left of the 1960s, though a very brief period that scattered and splintered, left a major imprint by civilizing society in many ways and changing how almost everyone sees and thinks about things, so it is wrong to say the left libertarian tradition has vanished.
“the New Left of the 1960s, which incidentally was a very brief period — it scattered, splintered, but it left a major imprint... It civilized the society in many ways.”
- In the 1960s the United States had anti-miscegenation laws so extreme that the Nazis refused to accept them, and federally mandated housing segregation meant a Black man could get a decent auto-plant job but could not buy a home in Levittown, cutting the Black population out of property-based wealth accumulation during the 1950s-60s growth period.
“In the 1960s, the United States had anti-miscegenation laws which were so extreme that the Nazis refused to accept them. We had federally mandated housing segregation”
- Chomsky observes that the easiest way to write and reach people today is through the internet because many people no longer read books much, leading him to publish regular books of interviews and discussions instead.
“the easiest way to write and reach people is through the internet because a lot of people don’t read books much anymore.”
Classical liberalism grounds human freedom on the innate instinct for liberty and capacity for unbounded creative thought and inquiry.
- Wilhelm von Humboldt was both the founder of the modern research university and a founder of classical liberalism, whose fundamental principle (which became an epigram for Mill's On Liberty) is that the fundamental right of every person is to be free from external illegitimate constraints, free to inquire, create, and pursue their own interests without arbitrary authority restricting them.
“His fundamental principle — as he said, it’s actually an epigram for John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty — is that the fundamental right of every person is to be free from external illegitimate constraints, free to inquire, to create, to pursue their own interests and concerns without arbitrary authority of any sort restricting or limiting them.”
- Plato's theory of reminiscence was basically correct but had to be purged of the error of an earlier life; instead the relevant knowledge is something intrinsic to our nature that has evolved and become intrinsic, which for Humboldt was the 'instinct for freedom' that should ground social and economic reasoning.
“Leibniz pointed out that Plato’s theory of reminiscence was basically correct, but it had to be purged of the error of reminiscence — in other words, not an earlier life, but rather something intrinsic to our nature.”
Large language models cannot illuminate human language nature because they make no distinction between possible and impossible languages.
- Large language models have a built-in property that cannot be modified: they work just as well for impossible languages as for possible ones, scanning massive data for statistical regularities to predict the next word; because they make no distinction between possible and impossible languages, they can in principle tell us nothing about the nature of human language and thought, just as a periodic table including all impossible elements would tell us nothing about chemistry.
“they work just as well for impossible languages as for possible languages. It’s as if somebody came along with a new periodic table of the elements which included all the elements and all impossible elements and couldn’t make any distinction on them. It would tell us nothing about chemistry.”