What this covers
Tyler Cowen interviews Mark Miller, a chef and food writer, about how taste functions as a learned cognitive skill rather than a matter of ingredient quality or culinary status. Miller makes the case that approaching food with the right mental framework—what he calls Deep Tasting—fundamentally changes what a person actually perceives. He traces this argument across the neuroscience of flavor perception, the economics of industrial food production, the history of specific cuisines, and the cultural psychology underlying how different societies relate to cooking. The conversation moves between granular technical observations about chile selection and terroir, and broader claims about which food traditions survive and why.
Miller spends substantial time on Perceptual Paradigm in Tasting, arguing that the brain's categorization of flavor depends entirely on how a person approaches it—reframing a dried chile as "fruit leather" rather than heat source changes what flavors emerge. He discusses how cuisines flourish when freed from what he calls Identity-System Constraint on Cuisine, citing Korea and Singapore as examples of places that broke defensive cultural loops to achieve culinary creativity, while suggesting Japan and France have grown rigid. He makes empirical claims about the impossibility of industrial scaling in authentic cooking, the decline of Chinese cuisine due to low social status of the profession, and the role of Consumer Level 3 in displacing brand authority. Several positions prove contentious: his critique of the Michelin guide, his argument linking the industrialization of corn after 1925 to Mexico's diabetes crisis via lost probiotics in masa, and his claim that women and men cook with fundamentally different sensory philosophies. The interview includes practical advice on hamburger orientation and how to taste properly over time.
Miller argues that great food is a learned act of deep perception rather than ingredient luxury or branding: tasting is a trainable cognitive skill unfolding over time, authentic cuisines arise when cultures break free of identity anxiety to use local ingredients creatively, and the most complex, valuable food traditions survive in villages and street markets rather than in chains or status systems.
- Taste occurs over time and space and must be approached with the right mental paradigm, not as immediate cognition
- Cuisines flourish when freed from defensive identity systems (Korea, Singapore) and stagnate when trapped in perfectionist comfort zones (Japan, France)
- Complexity is achieved through traditional practice (probiotics in masa, smoked chiles, single-village products) that chains and 'shoppers' cannot replicate
Tasting is a learned cognitive skill requiring proper technique and repeated attention.
- What you have in your head when you approach a taste determines what you actually taste: if you think 'chiles' and go for heat you will miss the fruit, so you must reframe a dried chile as 'fruit leather' and ask which fruit you detect (cherry, blackberry, cassis) rather than whether it is spicy.
“the paradigm — what you have in your head when you go after the taste is what you will taste. If you think chiles and go for heat — you need to think fruit leather.”
- Taste occurs over time and space and must not be processed with cognitive/verbal systems: texture and temperature register first by the autonomic nervous system, but the enzymatic breakdown of flavonoids takes time (some flavors take up to 30 minutes), so one should smell first, chew briefly, stop, hold for at least 15 seconds, and taste a second time to let the brain fill in complexity and length.
“taste occurs over time and space. Do not use cognitive systems for sensual perception.”
- Miller is not biologically a supertaster (defined by taste buds per centimeter); his ability is at the cognitive level — 'deep tasting' analogous to deep reading — looking for patterns in perceptual space, just as great art critics like Berenson or painters like Turner did not have extraordinary eyesight; his childhood auditory processing disorder caused him to categorize the world through taste.
“the term supertaster is about the number of actual taste buds per centimeter on your palate. Actually I am not, biologically, a supertaster”
- Because you have about 2,500 taste buds each with 10,000 nerve endings generating roughly two million perceptions per second and taste registers in a 200th of a second, the brain cannot process all of it unless it has preset categories; like reading by scanning, the brain scans known flavors and fills in complexity, so tasting a second time with memory lets you perceive the full richness and length.
“The brain scans known flavors. It fills in complexity. You taste in 200th of a second. You have 2,500 taste buds; each one has 10,000 nerve endings.”
- The key to teaching flavor is teaching what an ingredient is not rather than what it is, because the brain does not know what something is — it knows what it's not; thus a sous-vide lamb that is uniformly pink with no Maillard crust gives the brain too few perceptual zones to differentiate and tastes like 'a lamb piece of bubblegum,' whereas varied doneness and browning give the brain four or five zones to appreciate.
“The key to teaching flavor is not teaching what that ingredient is, it’s teaching what it’s not.”
Cuisines become creatively ambitious when they stop seeking validation from external cultural authorities.
- Koreans are forced out of their culinary comfort zone and into innovation because of intense competitive pressure in their own backyard — North Korea at the border, an aggressive China to compete with, and the finesse of Japan — analogous to how Samsung out-innovated Sony.
“the Koreans are forced out of their comfort zone, because they have North Korea at their border. They have China to compete with, being aggressive, and they have the finesse of Japan.”
- Cuisines become creative when they stop validating themselves against external identity systems: Mexican food was once trapped looking to Spain and the US for validation, and Korea was beaten down in Japan's shadow, but both broke free; mezcal went from a shunned 'peasant' drink to the only thing drunk in Mexico City once people wanted to assert being Mexican.
“Mexico, before, was trapped in looking at Spain, looking at the US, looking at other identity systems, to validate its own food supply.”
- Central Paris French cuisine is the most overrated in Europe and in an identity crisis like the Japanese — trying to reinvent itself but unwilling to let go — so that even finding a good French bistro is difficult, while younger chefs (e.g. at Dersou) prioritize authenticity of the guest experience over authentic technique and recipe.
“the French themselves are, again, like the Japanese — they’re trying to reinvent themselves, but they don’t want to let go.”
- Americans had the most exploratory palate potential because they were 'food-ignorant' rather than hung-up, but were colonized by the idea of European/French/Chinese culinary superiority and immigrant groups asserted status by denigrating others' food; now as a multicultural society with traveling chefs and third-generation immigrant cooks (e.g., Cassia, Slanted Door, Cosme), Americans realize ethnic food is as complex as expensive French restaurants.
“we were colonized by the idea of European culture and French food, Chinese food.”
- A chef should not co-opt an entire cultural identity but can learn from and bring his own interior reality to ingredients; Miller created modern southwestern rather than a Mexican restaurant because as a non-Mexican it would be a lie, contrasting with Roy Choi's Korean tacos which authentically project his LA Korean-Mexican experience.
“you can learn, but you should not co-opt an entire cultural identity.”
Flavor develops through terroir and cannot be replicated outside its native environment.
- A chile variety will not develop the right flavor unless grown in its proper environment: these Mexican chiles require high mountain altitudes (above 4,000-5,000 feet) with the right ultraviolet exposure and alkaline volcanic soil, so growing them elsewhere (Washington DC, or China) cannot reproduce the flavor, which is why one central-valley village makes the world's best anchos and pasillas.
“It won’t have the right flavor, because it won’t have the right ultraviolet; which has to be grown in the mountains above 4,000, 5,000 feet, and it doesn’t have an alkaline, volcanic soil.”
- The Spanish introduction of rooting animals — pigs, sheep, and beef — ruined the ecosystem of the pre-Columbians, which was not dependent on rooting animals, mirroring the ecological damage done in the Caribbean for trade.
“what the Spanish brought was pigs... Unfortunately, it ruined the ecosystem of the pre-Colombians, which was not dependent on rooting animals.”
- China is exporting cheaper chiles to Mexico that lack the right flavor profile (bitter, alkaline-ish), undercutting the market; people buy them out of economic necessity or because they cannot tell the difference, and they can already be found mislabeled as anchos in Oaxaca.
“they basically are undercutting the market. You see them in Oaxaca; they’re anchos there, I can tell. They’re very bitter, very alkaline-ish; they don’t have a good flavor, but people are buying them because of economic necessity or that they don’t really know the difference.”
- Mexico still has world-class products that exist nowhere else and cannot be duplicated — the pasilla de Oaxaca, smoked for three days with seven different hardwoods, is made by only one village requiring nine hours by Land Rover, has never been shown even to Diana Kennedy, and the Chinese could never duplicate it.
“The place that has thepasilla de Oaxaca, the great smoked chile, the best smoked chile in the world — smoked for three days with seven different hardwoods — requires nine hours in a Land Rover to get to that village.”
Culinary mastery demands thousands of granular seasonal and ingredient-specific decisions accumulated over years.
- Culinary mastery is the accumulation of thousands of seasonal, per-ingredient decisions: a tempura chef takes 15 years because a June eggplant has less water and is less bitter than an August one, requiring different batter and temperature, so a 20-course meal demands 75-85 decisions, and a Tokyo sushi chef may know 1,900 varieties of seafood.
“why does it take 15 years to be a good tempura chef? Because that eggplant in June is tighter, has less water, is less bitter than the one in August, to where it has a different batter, a different temperature.”
- Miller's 'interrupted sous vide' technique combines stages to get intensity while preserving freshness — e.g., brining a Chinese squab with 14 spices, then sous-viding at a higher temperature, then deep frying; or cooking scallops sous vide with fresh chamomile so the aromatic profile matches the chamomile in a sauvignon blanc.
“I find that that, what I call interrupted sous vide, as a technique — you get intensity while preserving some freshness.”
- Flavonoids develop and change every two or three degrees of cooking, so the notion that more cooking makes meat or fish more 'liver-y' is a misnomer tied to temperature thresholds; for someone averse to cooked fish, the objectionable flavonoids may not have developed at 130 degrees (versus 135 being cooked), so cooking to a lower temperature or starting with halibut may avoid the off-flavors.
“Flavonoids develop and change over every two or three degrees. That’s why it’s a misnomer, the more you cook meat, the more liver-y it’s going to get.”
Industrial food systems cannot truly cook at scale and transparency reveals their contradiction.
- Chinese cuisine is entering a period of mediocrity because the low social status of cooking deters trained workers; restaurants staffed by untrained workers straight from the countryside can still profit because customers lack trained palates, so traditional, training-intensive cooking is dying out, as evidenced by declining quality at Din Tai Fung dumplings.
“the workforce is either coming straight from the countryside without being trained — the restaurants are making a lot of money because the people who are going there don’t have trained palates”
- The era of big food companies is over because at scale you cannot truly cook: a 2,000-restaurant chain claims to cook but its food comes from two plants manufactured by suppliers like Miniat processing 200,000 pounds a day, so transparency forces a contradiction — if you're actually cooking you can't be a chain, as evidenced by Chipotle closing ShopHouse and its stock falling.
“you have 2,000 restaurants. You say you’re cooking the food, but the food comes from two plants, from a factory likeMiniatthat takes 200,000 pounds a day... if you’re cooking, you can’t be a chain.”
- The Chinese government, citing health reasons, is controlling where food can be sold, pushing street vendors into department stores and eliminating the dense informal street-food ecosystem of dumpling stalls and noodle stands that once filled Shanghai, causing distinctive regional foods to disappear entirely.
“The Chinese government is afraid of . . . basically, health reasons; is now controlling where food is basically exhibited, where food can be bought and sold.”
Market quality signals fail because consumers lack trained palates and mislabeling is rampant.
- Ninety percent of all chiles are mislabeled, so whatever is written on the package may not be true; you must open them up and inspect them by holding to the light, where a mulato shows more coffee-ish dark tones and reddish-purple translucence, distinct from an ancho.
“First of all you have to open them up, because 90 percent of all chiles are mislabeled.”
- The concept of brand is becoming dated because brands historically served as consumer guides and trust signals, but in 'consumer level 3' consumers themselves define brands and how they get used, and information (e.g., discovering a local fair-trade Guatemalan coffee instead of relying on Starbucks) now substitutes for brand trust.
“You don’t need brands anymore. The consumer used to have brands as guide and trust. Today there are other ways of developing that. We’re in consumer level 3. Consumers are defining brands”
- Varietal differentiation in the market (such as the return of Native American corn varieties or microbrews) only emerges when consumers train their palates to detect differences, because if people cannot taste the difference between six varieties of corn (or a first-growth Bordeaux versus Trader Joe's wine), they will not pay for them.
“If I give you six varieties of corn and I tell you “eat them” and you can’t tell the difference, then you probably are unwilling to pay for them.”
Traditional food practices encode probiotics and complexity that industrial substitutes destroy.
- Nixtamalizing corn makes it more nutritional by freeing the amino acids (avoiding pellagra unlike Italian polenta), and traditionally the never-washed metates plus wild yeast-bearing grasses re-introduced probiotics into the masa; the loss of these probiotics in the postindustrial diet after Maseca's 1925 introduction explains why diabetes was absent in Mexico before 1925 and why Mexicans now are prediabetic.
“When you nixtamal corn, it becomes more nutritional, because you free up all the amino acids. The Italians have polenta; they’ve got pellagra.”
- Village cooks achieve more complex, interesting flavors not by buying premium ingredients on Amazon or at Whole Foods but by using their bodies as a window of opportunity — traditional practices like wild-yeast grasses and unwashed metates introduce probiotics that change flavonoids, so studying these perceptional patterns reveals how they attain complexity that modern chefs ('shoppers') miss.
“They don’t buy things on Amazon or go to the store or go to Whole Foods. They are actually using their body as this window of opportunity to create complexity.”
Authentic dining requires presence and full sensory engagement that virtual reality threatens.
- Because a hamburger has six layers offering 36 possibilities of being eaten, turning your favorite hamburger upside down makes it eat completely differently, since all the fat receptors are now engaged in a different mode — like turning something to a mirror — demonstrating that orientation changes the eating experience.
“Six layers in a hamburger is 36 possibilities of eating it. Next time you eat a hamburger, just put it upside down... You’ll see that it eats completely different. All the fat receptors are now in a different mode.”
- Great food creates a heightened 'sense of being there' and presence by demanding the diner's full perceptual engagement (e.g., a three-year-old tabuko ham), but the emerging virtual reality is causing us to lose that sense of being in presence.
“The virtual reality that’s happening: we’re losing our sense of being in presence.”
- Chains only exist when the local community doesn't provide the same service: in Kyoto's 300 noodle places nobody charges more than $10-12 and they're all good and distinct, so high-end-real-estate chains like Yoshinoya have no reason to exist, whereas the same quail costs 75 cents in a Thai street market versus $18.95 in Washington or New York — the proposed correct model is a 10-seat restaurant charging $100 with no rent, labor, or overhead.
“Chains only exist when the local community doesn’t provide the same service.”
- Supertasters experience flavors as such powerful sensations that they become fixated on liking or disliking things, and children in particular don't know how to handle that — associating an entire category with one bad bitter experience (e.g., refusing all green beans because something green was very bitter); a strong aversion like to cooked fish may reflect being an actual supertaster.
“supertasters tend to have — the problem with parents who don’t realize the child — they become very fixated. They like things or don’t like things because they’re such powerful sensations for them.”
- You should always use silver tequila rather than gold because silver has no wood, especially when adding fruit; the 'gold coin' upscale gold tequila is just a marketing ploy that makes more money but makes worse margaritas.
“that idea of the gold coin or the upscale — that’s just a marketing ploy to make more money. It makes them more money, but it makes worse margaritas.”
- Native cultures had vastly richer culinary repertoires than modern Americans: Franz Boas collected 254 salmon recipes and a Kwakiutl recipe book would have run to 3,000 recipes, whereas the average American housewife makes only 79 dishes in her lifetime — raising the question of who is actually richer.
“Franz Boas, we get into that, but he collected 254 salmon recipes. A Kwakiutl book would have been 3,000 recipes. The average American housewife does 79 in her lifetime, so who’s richer?”
- Europe could not grow its own food, and at the time of Columbus's departure roughly 30 percent of people were starving to death without warfare, rising toward 50 percent dead if late-15th-century warfare is included.
“if you take Columbus leaving, 30 percent of the people were starving to death without warfare. If you throw in warfare, in the end of the 15th century, 50 percent of the people would have been dead.”
- The 1925 introduction of Maseca after the Mexican Revolution was a government move to control the food supply, which is why tortillas are kept artificially cheap — paralleling how the French government keeps baguette prices controlled.
“the step for Maseca intervention in 1925 after the Revolution, because the government wanted to control the food supply and that’s why tortillas are so cheap. That was the same thing in France.”
- In a mole, each chile plays a structural flavor role: the ancho is the workhorse carrying the most fruit, the mulato supplies the coffee and chocolate undertones (fermented umami flavonoids forming the wide foundation), while guajillos and arbols are accessorized in to brighten the heat and fruit tones — heat being the last thing to look for.
“The ancho is always the workhorse, because it carries the most fruit. The mulato carries the coffee and chocolate, which is those more-or-less fermented umami — more complex sort of flavonoids. Then we throw in someguajillos,arbolsto brighten it all up”
- The best way for a non-local to find safe, good food in Bangkok is to go to the night markets and use crowd size as a heuristic: if a thousand Thai people are eating somewhere, it is safe and good to eat there, and day food versus night food should be matched to the time.
“If a thousand Thai people are eating there, it’s safe to eat there.”
- When buying chiles, the thickness of the flesh is the most important quality indicator because tannins come from skins, seeds, and stems, so thicker flesh means a lower percentage of tannin and more fresh-fruit flavor; Mexicans select the most pliable, thick chiles (primeros) and look for heat last.
“when you buy chiles, the thickness of the flesh is the most important thing. All fruits: where do the tannins come from? Skins, seeds, and stems. The thicker the flesh, the least percentage of tannin.”
- Authentic modern southwestern cuisine is hard and underrated because the chef must master three full traditions — Mexican, Native American, and the European influence on Western traditions like the cattle drive — along with all their ingredients; sauces can have 30-40 ingredients each requiring tasting, and even chefs in Miller's own kitchen couldn't make some sauces after 11 years.
“For me to do modern southwest, you have to know Mexican, you have to know Native American, and you have to know the history of the European influence on the Western traditions.”
- People have bad taste habits: they eat and immediately take beer or wine, which drowns out the flavors; the better practice is to take the beer or wine first to 'set the stage,' then use the flavors of the food.
“They eat and they take a glass of beer or wine. They’re drowning it out. I say, “What you do is you light up and set the stage, take the beer or wine first, and then use the flavors.””
- The poblano is the most underrated chile in the world — the predecessor of the bell pepper with much more depth and true green-chile flavor without being gaseous — versatile enough that Miller can make 100 dishes and 100 salsas with this one chile.
“The most underrated chile in the world? I would probably say the poblano. I can do 100 dishes, I can do 100 salsas with this one chile.”
Korea's competitive pressure produced culinary innovation impossible in more insular food cultures.
- Of China, Japan, and South Korea, Seoul has the most interesting and creative food world because Korean chefs at restaurants like Mingles incorporate Korean ingredients in modern, creative ways that authenticate the cuisine while reaching international standards (Italian, coffee, pizza, French) equal to the United States, having advanced far faster than expected.
“There’s a restaurant calledMinglesthat every single dish was incorporating Korean ingredients, but in a very creative, modern way. They were not afraid to move their food outside of the traditional vortex of what was seen as Korean food”
- The homogeneity of Japanese culture is both its strength and its weakness: Japanese chefs can reach a high level of the form of foreign foods like pizza or French cuisine but cannot capture the flavor, gestalt, and aesthetic because they remain Japanese, painting themselves into a corner of perfection that never improves further.
“They remain Japanese. The homogeneity of Japanese culture is its strength; it’s also its weakness.”
Michelin guides and brand hierarchies misrepresent food culture by prioritizing status over current innovation.
- The Michelin guide is overrated because it is about status and the reification of a belief system in a food and culture system based on the aristocracy; its inspectors are too old and out of touch, replaying old themes rather than reflecting current food culture.
“I think the Michelin guide is about status, reification of a belief system in a particular food and culture system that was based on the aristocracy.”
- Hungary, especially Budapest, is currently the most underrated European cuisine and 'on fire' with great food and wine, where Miller has eaten meals for 40 euros that equal anything in Paris for 400 euros.
“I have eaten meals in Budapest for 40 euros that equal anything in Paris for 400.”
Cultural depth in crafts reliably correlates with culinary sophistication within traditions.
- Cuisines with old, rich aesthetic traditions in crafts like weaving reliably also have rich, complex cuisines, because both express one cultural mentality; thus a complex triple-ikat weaving from a culture signals that the culture also achieves great culinary complexity.
“I always think that those cuisines that are older, if they have great weavings, they have great cuisine. Because I always say you’re looking at one mentality.”
- Japanese fermented products encode geographic and generational identity: a pickle on the table can reveal within 20 miles where someone grew up, and each great sushi house blends its own shoyu, allowing Miller to identify not only whether someone is from Edo but in what generation (the '30s, '40s, '50s) they formed their notion of correct shoyu, because Japan's roughly 40 regions maintain such isolation that differences accumulate.
“When you’re in Japan, the pickle on the table will tell me within 20 miles of where you grew up and where you live. The shoyu at the sushi — each great sushi house not sushi bars actually blends their own shoyu.”
Women and men taste differently and embody distinct culinary philosophies about ingredient transformation.
- Women and men have different palates and cooking approaches: women prefer more natural, subtle flavors and tend to accept and coax an ingredient's natural personality (the Alice Waters school), while men ('knives, spice, and fire') want to transform the ingredient into something new; women's earlier internalization of body-perceptuality makes them more subtle though not less rich.
“women tend to actually believe that the ingredient should be left alone (Alice Watersor that school of cooking)... If you allowed nature to take its course, then you wouldn’t be cooking. You don’t have to heat. You’re not transforming with spice.”