What this covers

Margalit Fox, who has written over 1,200 obituaries for the New York Times, discusses the craft and philosophy of obituary writing with Tyler Cowen. The conversation treats the obituary as journalism's most purely narrative genre, distinct from eulogy or veneration. Fox walks through how the form works: its cradle-to-grave Narrative Arc, its rigid deep structure that must be disguised as light reading, and the single criterion that determines whether someone gets a Times obit—whether they changed the culture. The scope ranges from canonical subjects (presidents, royalty, captains of industry) to what Fox calls backstage players: unsung inventors like Edward Lowe, whose Kitty Litter transformed pet ownership, or Pablo Casals, who reconceived the cello as a solo instrument and reshaped classical music's landscape.

Fox addresses the mechanics and ethics that separate obit writing from other journalism. She explains the operational reality: the Times maintains roughly 1,700 advance obits for figures whose lives are densely documented, yet about 90 percent of working time is spent on daily obits reported and written in a single day. She discusses how obit writers must apply the same selection criterion to villains—segregationists and Nazi war criminals—as to heroes, since the salient question is whether a person made history, for good or ill. The conversation also touches on broader themes: why earlier obits skewed white and male (a function of historical stage access, not editorial choice), how the inverted pyramid emerged from Civil War telegraph constraints and endures because it mirrors human cognition, and why Fox's own approach stems from a childhood passion for Heuristic Clue-Following and code-cracking.

Sharpest takeaway

Fox argues that obituaries are the most purely narrative genre in journalism, and that their core function is not eulogy but determining who changed the culture—surfacing 'history's backstage players' alongside the famous while preserving strict journalistic balance.

  • Beneath the boilerplate, an obit has a built-in cradle-to-grave narrative arc that can be exploited for great writing
  • The single selection criterion is 'Did he or she change the culture?', applied to heroes and villains alike
  • An obit is a balanced news profile, not veneration, so unflattering truths and even villains belong

The argument · threads7 threads · 26 claims
0.72

The single criterion for a Times obituary is whether someone changed culture, applying equally to unsung inventors and great villains, with no regard for fame or strategic intent.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The single dispositive question for whether someone earns a Times obituary is 'Did he or she change the culture?'—a criterion that admits unsung inventors who put a wrinkle in the social fabric (Kitty Litter, the lawn flamingo) alongside the famous, and applies equally to villains who made history for ill.

    “The criterion we look for, if we had to pick a single question that can be asked of every applicant at our gates, is: Did he or she change the culture?”

  • Very few people who receive obituaries did what they did to become famous; fame is applied post hoc by the news media, so there is no meaningful fame incentivization for the vast majority of obit subjects—the social changes they wrought were spontaneous, not strategic.

    “I think very few people about whom we write do things for fame. The fame comes post hoc, applied by people like us in the news media.”

  • The Times writes two distinct categories of obituaries: marquee names (presidents, royalty, captains of industry, old-time film stars) whose well-documented lives yield few surprises, and 'history's backstage players'—unsung inventors and creators whom reporters approach cold, having often never heard the name.

    “there are essentially two categories of obituaries that theTimesdoes. One are the marquee names... On the other hand, there is this whole other category of people whom I call history’s backstage players”

  • Edward Lowe's 1947 invention of Kitty Litter caused social change by making cats much easier to keep indoors, and a few decades later cats passed dogs as the most popular American pet.

    “it did indeed cause social change because it made cats much easier to keep indoors than formerly. For the first time, a few decades later, cats actually passed dogs as the most popular American pet.”

0.68

Obituaries are the most purely narrative genre in daily journalism, with an inherent dramatic arc that skillful writers exploit while maintaining a rigid underlying structure.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Because an obit is charged with taking a subject from cradle to grave, it carries a built-in narrative arc, making it the most purely narrative genre in any daily paper; the great ledes and 'kickers' exploit this inherent narrative potential while still disguising the rigid 'deep structure' underneath.

    “obits turn out to be the most purely narrative genre in any daily paper. The reason we have these great ledes and we hope great kickers, as we call them, at the end is that we are exploiting very happily this inherent narrative potential that is a news obit.”

  • Contrary to the premise that obits lack rigid structure, they possess a rigid 'deep structure' that undergirds everything—without it the story would fall apart; the art lies in disguising that infrastructure to make the piece light, frothy, and a good read while maintaining complete fealty to journalism's tenets.

    “I don’t know that I agree with your initial premise because there is also a pretty rigid structure to an obit... To put it in Chomskyan terms... it’s thedeep structure. It’s there undergirding everything.”

  • The inverted pyramid—broadest information first, finer detail later—emerged during Civil War telegraph coverage as a do-or-die adaptation to unreliable lines, and has endured over a century because it mirrors how humans process information, making it 'cognitively perfect.'

    “It came about during Civil War battle coverage, when they had the medium of telegraphy for the first time available to reporters... Get the broadest information through first, so if the lines go down, at least your readers back in Boston or Baltimore will have something.”

0.68

Writing obituaries is life-affirming rather than morbid because it celebrates how subjects actually lived, not how they died, making it fundamentally retrospective and historical.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Writing obituaries is almost never depressing and is in fact life-affirming, because in a thousand-word obit only a sentence or two concerns the death while 98 percent celebrates a fascinating life; it is life-affirming precisely because it is not tragedy.

    “In a strange way, with rare exceptions, writing obits is a kind of very life-affirming thing to do”

  • Obit writing is the most retrospective genre, akin to looking through a window that slides backward along the rails of time; this explains why earlier obits skewed white and male, because the only people allowed to be actors on the world stage in the 1940s and '50s were overwhelmingly white men, and the page diversifies as the window slides into the civil rights and women's movement eras.

    “We are not in the revision business. We can’t revise history, no matter how much it may be painful to look on it with hindsight.”

  • Immersion in so many lives instills a carpe diem sense: since you never know whether the metaphorical crocodile—sudden death—is around the next bend in the river of life, you might as well live as good a life as you can and enjoy it before reaching that crocodile.

    “You never know, as you go through life, whether or not that crocodile is around the next bend in the river. So you might as well try to live as good a life as you can and enjoy the hell out of life before you get to that crocodile.”

0.54

Modern obituaries are balanced news profiles that include unflattering truths and avoid Victorian sentiment, requiring reporters to maintain professional distance from grieving families.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A modern news obit is not veneration or eulogy but a balanced news profile that, like any profile of a living person, must include unflattering truths; this is why writers ask preemptive questions to surface earlier marriages and other children that families may withhold, and why hoary Victorian clichés about being 'surrounded by loved ones' have no place.

    “we’re not in the veneration business. We’re not eulogists... A modern news obit is a news article like any other. The particular subtype it is — it’s a profile.”

  • Obit reporting and grief counseling share an identical process of eliciting information, but diverge in what is done with it; reporters must be careful not to present themselves as a grieving family's friend or counselor, while still treating them as well as possible within professional limits—both for journalistic candor and human decency.

    “the elicitation of information — that process is identical. Where they diverge, of course, is what you do with the information once you have it.”

  • Obit writers are charged with metaphorically ushering people out of the world, including the great villains of history—segregation enforcers like Sheriff Jim Clark and Nazi war criminals—because the salient question is whether a person made history for good or ill; writing such obits leaves no warm feeling, only a need for a shower and a stiff drink.

    “We are obliged to write news obits not only of the great heroes of history but also the great villains... the salient question is, “Did this person make history?” — for good but also for ill.”

0.45

Obit writers must report cold subjects by combing archives and interviewing around them, transparently telling readers when a subject deliberately obscured their own life.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • To write the advance obit of a reclusive figure like Pynchon or Salinger, the reporter combs the clippings, attempts to reach the elusive subject (likely impossible), and interviews around them—editors, friends, neighbors, old lovers—then assembles the best account while transparently telling readers that the subject deliberately obscured his life.

    “you interview around them. You interview their editors. You interview friends. You interview neighbors. You interview old lovers.”

  • Aspiring obituary writers should not try to specialize; because no child grows up wanting to be an obituary writer, the path is to become a journalist first—go to journalism school—since writing obits is simply one satisfying, narrative way of doing journalism.

    “I would say, don’t feel you can or should specialize... Be a journalist first. Go to journalism school.”

  • The Times keeps about 1,700 advance obituaries on file for figures whose lives are so long in the public eye, rich, and deeply documented that the paper cannot risk writing them on deadline; yet roughly 90 percent of obit writers' working life is daily obits reported and published within a single day.

    “We do indeed have the advance obits — all but the top, as it were — written, edited, on file. We have about 1,700.”

  • It is absolutely forbidden for anyone to see a draft of their own obituary because the Times will not comment on or divulge any forthcoming news story, and an advance obit is the ultimate forthcoming news story; the paper may accept a subject's submitted bio for study but will never reveal whether it will be used.

    “It is absolutely verboten for anyone to see a draft of his or her obit. TheTimesis not permitted to comment on or divulge the contents of any forthcoming news story.”

0.44

Fox's work is unified by a passion for narrative and heuristics—following clues and codes—applied to linguistics, history, and reconstructing how people changed the world.

7 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Fox's work is unified by a passion for heuristics—following clues from A to B to C—rooted in childhood treasure hunts where the goal was the process, not the prize; this same code-cracking pattern runs through decoding an unanalyzed sign language, deciphering the Linear B Aegean script, and reconstructing the heuristics of a life in an obit.

    “I’m passionately interested in heuristics... It’s all about heuristically following clues from A to B to C to get — the goal is not the thing itself.”

  • Fox loves reading writers like Twain because you get not only the paramount stylist but can also see through the writing to how the man's mind works—the prose functions as a window onto the author's cognition.

    “you not only get the paramount stylist... but you can also see through the writing. It’s a window onto how the man’s mind works.”

  • What is most underrated in life is silence, stillness, reading real books on paper, and real human contact—as opposed to social media, which has become a substitute for real contact in atomized, postmodern lives.

    “What in life is underrated? Silence. Stillness. Reading real books on paper. Having real human contact rather than the social media that’s become, in our atomized, postmodern lives, a substitute for real contact.”

  • The unifying thread across Fox's books, her Times obituaries, and her forthcoming nonfiction is narrative—she cares passionately about storytelling and the privilege of telling stories, working exclusively in the nonfiction genre.

    “What underpins the two of my books that are out, the third book that’s coming, my work at theTimes, is narrative. I care passionately about narrative.”

  • Dear Abby and her twin sister Ann Landers were important and remain retrospectively significant as barometers of where the country was heading; though not firebrands, both were pragmatic women a little left of center who embodied progressive mid-century humanism and served as an index of how progressives were nudging the country.

    “were fascinatingly important and remain so, retrospectively, as barometers of the way the country was going to go.”

  • Pablo Casals, through his televised master classes in the early 1960s, single-handedly caused the cello's popularity to soar by reconceiving it as a solo instrument, whereas previously most people thought of the cello merely as going 'oompah-pah' at the bottom of the orchestra.

    “it was he... who really caused the instrument’s popularity to soar. Most people had really not conceived of the cello as a solo instrument before”

  • Whether a paper invests in or eliminates an obituary department is fundamentally an economic decision; in an age of retrenchment and a shrinking news hole, many major papers are scaling back or eliminating obit desks as newspapers themselves decline.

    “you’re an economist. It’s economics. I mean, sadly, even many major papers are scaling back or even eliminating their obit departments in this age of retrenchment, in the age of the incredible shrinking news hole”

0.36

Obituary pages reflect the historical record of who was allowed on the world stage, and diversify only as that window slides forward through time, not through retroactive revision.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The obituary section is not in the business of revising history; because it writes about people who made news while alive, and those people were regrettably overwhelmingly white men through no fault of anyone active today, the page cannot retroactively impose modern diversity onto the historical record.

    “We are not in the revision business. We can’t revise history, no matter how much it may be painful to look on it with hindsight.”

  • Contrary to the impression that many famous people died on 9/11, very few victims were famous in conventional terms; they became high-profile because of the way they died, but were mostly ordinary working men and women, which the Times memorialized in the 'Portraits of Grief' capsule series handled by a special Metro team, not the obit desk.

    “They became in a sense high-profile people because of the way they died, but very few of them were famous in conventional terms.”