What this covers

Katherine Rundell discusses John Donne's place in English poetry and argues for the overlooked merit of children's literature as a form that speaks to adults. The conversation weaves between literary history and contemporary questions about how language shapes thought. Rundell traces Donne's unusual linguistic habits—his coining of compound words like "super-infinite" and "super-eternal"—as a reflection of his restless search for ways to express states beyond ordinary speech. She positions him as a poet who rejected the conventions of his era, insisting on strange imagery (fleas, sucking fish, compasses) where his contemporaries like Sir Walter Raleigh relied on roses and doves. Throughout, she returns to a single conviction: that how something is said matters as much as what is said, and that finding one's own language is the mark of genuine talent.

The discussion ranges across Donne's relationship with religious conversion, his treatise Biathanatos on certainty and chaos, and the historical conditions that shaped his writing—including the brutal schooling of his era and the financial pressure to produce paid verses like epithalamiums. Rundell also addresses T.S. Eliot's influential but incomplete reading of Donne, and the role of survivorship bias in how we credit literary invention to the authors whose work survived. In the second half, she turns to children's fiction, arguing that the best examples—she cites Diana Wynne Jones—operate without condescension and reconnect adults to the uncompromising idealism and sense of discovery that children's literature uniquely offers. She considers how linguistic freshness and difficult vocabulary rarely impede young readers as much as writers assume, and reflects on why books now struggle against forms of entertainment designed for constant satiation.

Sharpest takeaway

Rundell argues that John Donne's genius lies in his embrace of strangeness and the building of one's own language, and that children's fiction—far from being lesser literature—offers adults a vital reconnection with discovery, idealism, and linguistic freshness.

  • Donne stood against the coherent, conventional love poetry of his era by insisting on human fracturing and strange imagery
  • Children's books teach uncompromising hopes (love, kindness, equality) framed as truths and can reawaken adults' sense of discovery
  • The way one says a thing matters as much or more than what one says

The argument · threads11 threads · 45 claims
0.85

Donne's writing demonstrates genuine conviction through radical honesty and linguistic invention rather than mere ambition or survival.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Donne's writing—the passion in his religious poetry, the focus in his sermons, and the dedication of thought it required—makes it credible that both his early Catholicism and his later Protestant conversion were genuinely sincere rather than mere products of poverty or ambition.

    “I find it very easy to believe both in the reality of his Catholicism and in the reality of his Protestant conversion.”

  • The most interesting thing in Donne's sermons is his radical honesty—rare among sermoners who saw themselves as regulatory ideals that should never admit vulnerability—about the difficulty of finding God, confessing that even a mind capable of rigorous poetry could not control itself in prayer, distracted by a carriage, a straw, a thought, a chimera.

    “the radical honesty that he has — that you will find in so few other sermons of the time — about the difficulty of finding God.”

  • The Straussian reading that Donne was secretly an atheist who took orders only for survival has been undermined in the last decade by newly discovered and re-dated letters showing he pushed toward ordination even after attaining wealth, against Buckingham's offers of secular posts.

    “even after he had started to reach some form of real middle-class wealth and solidity, he still kept pushing in a way that could have, in fact, been detrimental to him towards being ordained.”

  • Donne was compelled by the heavens and the stars yet deeply troubled by scientific discoveries (consulting Kepler on celestial motion) that cast doubt on the great certainties of the previous generations, giving him a complicated relationship with innovation.

    “compelled by the idea, which he found deeply troubling, of scientific discoveries which were casting in doubt the great certainties of the previous generations. He had a complicated relationship with innovation.”

  • Many people in Donne's era believed in religion because it offered a structure to put down their anxiety, hopes, and chaos, giving purpose and meaning, while others attended church merely out of legal obligation and conformity rather than conviction.

    “a lot of people believed because it was offered as a way to put down your anxiety, your hopes, your chaos. It was a structure that gave people purpose and meaning.”

  • Biathanatos comes close to a radical position by arguing that all certainty carries the peril of being wrong in chaos-creating ways—'we have been wrong about the stars'—and that there is no single great truth upon which anything can be based.

    “It famously says we have been sure about so many things, and we have been wrong about them. We have been wrong about the stars.”

  • Donne's treatise on suicide, Biathanatos, may have been a personal attempt to write his own suicidal desires out of himself, consistent with the idea that those who talk about suicide most are perhaps least likely to commit it.

    “Biathanatos was, in fact, a personal bid to write out of himself his desire towards suicide, that in some ways, those who talk about it a great deal are perhaps the least likely to commit it”

0.72

How something is said matters more than what is said because universal human experiences require originality to overcome complacent inattention.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The mark of writing talent is understanding that how you say a thing matters as much or more than what you say, because what people want to express is usually the same universal thing (love, courage, patience); only those who find a way to say it with flair and originality cut through their interlocutor's complacent inattention and across time, space, and cultural difference.

    “it matters as much or far more the way you say the thing as what you say, because the thing you want to say is probably a very similar thing that everyone else wants to say”

  • T.S. Eliot rightly credited Donne with a sensibility in which every life element modifies the rest, but he got Donne wrong by failing to accentuate his strangeness—Donne stood against an era of coherent love poetry (Raleigh's rose, Sidney's white doves) by insisting his subjects were stranger, deserving poetry of fleas, sucking fish, and compasses to express the vertiginous and labyrinthine quality of human desire.

    “what he got wrong was he did not accentuate the strangeness of John Donne... John Donne’s poetry often carries with it a beautiful salute to human fracturing and human strangeness.”

  • Donne's habit of coining 'super' words—super-infinite, super-miraculous, super-eternal, super-dying—reflects the linguistic habits of a man who longed for immensities and insisted on things that lead outside the bounds of language.

    “Insistence on things which lead outside language: super-infinite, super-miraculous, super-eternal, super-dying. These are the linguistic habits of a man who longs for immensities.”

  • Her children's novels and her John Donne scholarship cohere because Donne insisted on the necessity of building one's own language—shaking language out of the confines of the day to fit the rhythms of one's own imagination—which she grew up with and which makes her novels idiosyncratic and literary.

    “He insisted on the necessity of building your own language. I think that I grew up with that, and it is why my novels are often referred to as idiosyncratic and literary. I want language that belongs to me”

0.63

Best children's fiction treats young readers as intellectually equal partners deserving uncompromising truths expressed as utopian hopes.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The best children's fiction (e.g., Diana Wynne Jones) is written on the principle that children should never be spoken down to; such books are so full of the furies and anxieties that extend from childhood into adulthood that they also read as great texts for adults.

    “somebody who believed that children should never be spoken down to. And I think a lot of her children’s fiction is so weird and so full of the furies and anxieties that are extending from childhood into adulthood, that those books would also read as great texts for adults”

  • Children's novels teach large uncompromising 'truths'—love will matter, kindness will matter, equality is possible—but these are expressed to children as truths when what they really are are hopes; the best politics of children's fiction is utopian, arguing that what humans have made can be undone and that words are the first way we transform the world.

    “I think that we express them as truths to children when what they really are are hopes.”

  • In children's writing you can use almost any vocabulary you want because children will guess, step over, or find out a difficult word, and hard words rarely put children off as much as writers worry they will; she cut 'adamantine' only because it sat at a peak narrative moment she didn't want to slow.

    “with children’s writing, you can use pretty much any vocabulary you want because they will either guess or step over or find out the word, and it rarely puts children off as much as we worry that it will.”

  • We should have more patience with childhood mischief because children whose mischievousness is quashed become difficult, thwarted, and sometimes quite vile adults.

    “we should have more patience with childhood mischief because children whose mischievousness is quashed become difficult, thwarted, and sometimes quite vile adults.”

  • If much younger children could vote, the idealism we expect from them might be tempered because they would tend to vote in accordance with their parents, plausibly creating a Coasian arrangement that hands more voting power to religious families—an outcome whose actual demographics may not match expectations.

    “children’s idealism would be very much tempered by the fact that they would be voting in accordance with their parents. But then, would they? Would children vote the way that their parents told them to? I don’t know.”

0.63

Reading challenges like The Faerie Queene or difficult older texts requires patience that slows the heart and teaches how texts shape their own reading.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Spenser is held in the correct estimation but is no longer read, and people should set aside about a week to read The Faerie Queene because, though painful, it is worth it when you come out the other side.

    “people should put aside about a week of their lives and read The Faerie Queene. It’s painful, but it’s worth it when you come out the other side.”

  • Difficult older texts like Pilgrim's Progress and The Faerie Queene require patience and a slowing of the heart, and the way Spenser fashions his ideal reader shows that texts themselves tell you how to read them.

    “The way that Spenser talks about fashioning his ideal reader, the texts tell you how to read them.”

  • Although adults feel their discovery time has passed, that feeling is false; reading books made for people in early discovery can remind adults of something adjacent to that freshness and give them a galvanic push to seek out other versions of that feeling, because astonishments still await.

    “although we feel like our discovery time has largely passed, that’s fake. That’s not real. Your discovery time has not passed. There are still astonishments that await.”

  • Memorizing poetry you don't yet understand is valuable because there will be a time later in life when it returns to you with meaning.

    “even if you memorize poetry that you don’t understand, there will be a time in your life when it will come back for you”

  • Sir Walter Raleigh is overrated because he has been given credit for many things he didn't do, including the false notion that he brought back the potato.

    “Overrated because we have given him such credit for so many things he didn’t do. He didn’t bring back the potato. That’s nonsense.”

0.54

Adults should read children's literature for pleasure and idealism while recognizing it competes with entertainment offering constant satiation.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Rather than making adult fiction more like children's fiction, more adults should read children's fiction—for pleasure and for its unabashed politics of idealism—while adult fiction continues its own urgent tasks of elongation and experiment.

    “I would argue, rather, that adults should occasionally read children’s fiction for pleasure, but also for the unabashed politics of idealism that they have.”

  • Children's literature now competes with forms of entertainment that offer the insatiable hunger for being wooed absolute constant satiety, making the slower, richer, ultimately punchier offering of books vastly harder to sell to children.

    “it is a form of entertainment that offers your insatiable hunger for being wooed absolute constant satiety. What we are trying to offer to children — something slower and richer and ultimately, you would hope, punchier — is vastly harder to sell to them.”

  • Data consistently reports that boys largely read stories about boys while girls largely read stories about both genders, and we should get boys to read more stories about girls—though the claim that 'boys don't read books about girls' risks being a self-fulfilling prophecy.

    “The data constantly reports that boys are, by and large, reading stories about boys, and girls are, by and large, reading stories about both genders.”

0.45

Seventeenth-century England's febrile intensity—mixing devotion, violence, plague, war, money, and printed knowledge—mirrors present explosive possibilities and fears.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Seventeenth-century Britain was a febrile, contagiously intense era of thought—where great devotion and great violence coexisted before breakfast—exacerbated by recurring plague, proximity to death and war, an influx of money, and a boom in printed knowledge, all of which combined to create an intellectually and emotionally extreme moment.

    “a febrile intensity of thought became not just commonplace but contagious. Certainly, you could wake up in the morning, and you could see acts of great devotion and great violence before breakfast.”

  • The present moment feels analogous to 17th century England in having newly explosive possibilities and newly explosive fears, an extreme intensity arising from different causes.

    “there is a similarly explosive moment, where we have newly explosive possibilities and newly explosive fears. There feels like something similarly extreme happening, although I would say from different causes.”

  • The voting age in England should be lowered to 16 because youth tend to skew left of center and Britain currently skews right, a position Rundell holds from standing left of center.

    “In England, I would like to lower the voting age to 16 because I stand quite far to the left of center, and the youth, of course, tend to skew more left, and currently, Britain skews right.”

  • Bear-baiting was overrated as entertainment and was largely faute de mieux, but the theater of the period, though already richly rated in Britain, is still underrated because of how staggeringly new it was relative to what came before.

    “the theater, even though madly rated in Britain with gold, still underrated because of what came before, of how staggeringly new it was.”

0.40

Donne's strangeness lay in insisting human desire deserved wild metaphors that went against coherent love poetry conventions of his era.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Donne provides no physical description of his lovers, including his wife Anne; instead his poems convey what physical beauty does to the person witnessing it, making the poems more about his own startlement, embracing, wariness, and bitchiness about love than about the bodily facts of the women he was with.

    “the poems are more about him looking at her than they are about her.”

  • Going to school in Donne's era introduced boys to a ruthless brutality difficult to recover from—boys were beaten, sometimes to death, were expected to fight their compatriots from around age 12, and routinely died at school—which is partly why Catholic boys like Donne were homeschooled.

    “Boys were beaten, some of them to death. It was expected that you would fight your colleagues, your compatriots from the age of about 12, and boys routinely died at school.”

  • Ben Jonson was historically more popular than Donne because he was more famous, wrote plays that pleased the queen and king, and wrote for the glamorous boy players that Queen Elizabeth was nearly obsessed with.

    “partly because he wrote for the boys of the boy players, and the boy players had a real glamour at the time, and Queen Elizabeth was borderline obsessed with them.”

0.40

King James Bible language infuses the best English literature including writers who identify as atheists, making it culturally foundational.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Book of Common Prayer is more beautiful than commonly credited, and its cadences have informed much beloved poetry—we would not have Seamus Heaney without its rhythms; to read it well one must remember the hope and comfort it was meant to give and the many battles fought to have it.

    “I don’t think we would have Seamus Heaney without the rhythms of The Book of Common Prayer.”

  • The King James translation of the Bible is highly valuable because its language infuses much of the best English literature—not only Donne and Shakespeare but even self-described atheists like Philip Pullman, who call themselves 'King James atheists' informed by its language.

    “that is the version that infuses much of the work I love most. Not just, obviously, Donne and Shakespeare, but also Philip Pullman talks about being an atheist, but a King James atheist”

  • The Irish appear more narrative and engaged with longer trains of thought, partly because Irish people not long ago had to learn English as a second language, which still makes them more self-conscious about language; Rundell notes her Irish friends have a linguistic dexterity her English friends lack and a cohesive body of folk stories.

    “my Irish friends have a form of linguistic dexterity that a lot of my English friends lack.”

0.40

Donne serves as a refuge against anti-intellectualism by demonstrating what the mind and language are capable of beyond popular culture's narrow vision.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Donne serves as a refuge and bulwark against anti-intellectualism because so much of popular culture offers an unexciting vision of what the mind and language are capable of.

    “So much of popular culture now offers a quite unexciting vision of what your mind and language might be capable of. I found him a brilliant antidote to that, a bulwark against a kind of anti-intellectualism.”

  • Samuel Johnson loathed Donne and found him dangerous because Johnson's vision of poetry was monovocal—holding that there was one correct form whose correctness should be prized and whose erosion would lead to social breakdown—yet by reading and thinking about Donne, Johnson inadvertently kept him alive.

    “Johnson’s vision of poetry still leaned towards the fashion of thinking of it as a monovocal exercise, that there was a correct form of poetry... and that the chipping away at that correctness would lead to social breakdown.”

  • The Oxford English Dictionary has historically attributed first uses of words to canonical authors partly because those are the authors whose works survived fire and time, so Donne may have merely recorded words already in common parlance rather than inventing them.

    “the OED has always found first uses in canonical authors, in part because they’re just the ones who survived fire. So of course, he may have just been noting down a word in common parlance rather than being its inventor.”

0.31

Market constraints on writing—financial disincentives for non-output—force productivity but most writers avoid them to preserve writing as joyful luxury.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Poets of Donne's period, including Donne himself, had to compose paid verses (epithalamiums) in the fashion of the time to make money, which held back their more radical and inventive impulses; their best work came when they were not being paid.

    “the need to make money meant that they had to compose in all ways which absolutely were, step by step, in the fashion of the time, and therefore held back their more radical and inventive impulses. So, when they weren’t being paid, they often wrote their best work.”

  • Self-imposed market constraints work to force writing output: she made a pact with a friend that failing to write a thousand words a day of their PhD theses meant giving £100 to the richest donkey sanctuary in England—deliberately chosen so the money would do no good but no harm—and the disincentive was effective, with only one failure.

    “if we didn’t do the requisite number of words — usually a thousand words a day of our doctoral theses — we had to give £100 to a donkey sanctuary.”

  • She can no longer read Dickens because, having once loved the atmospheres of London smoke and smog he conjured, she now finds vividly visible the fact that he was getting paid per word.

    “I now find very vividly visible the fact that he was getting paid per word.”

  • Few writers use market-based self-constraint despite its effectiveness because they want to keep writing as a form of joy and delight, and adding sharp-edged incentives would remove the feeling of luxury that writing has.

    “people want to keep their writing as a form of joy and delight... adding those sharp-edged incentives will remove the feeling of luxury that writing often has”

0.31

Seeing a city from above reveals patterns of human movement and how places work, informing fiction-writing and understanding vertigo as self-distrust to be managed.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Seeing a city from above—whether by roof walking or flying—is connected to her fiction-writing because it allows her to hold the whole of something in her head, understand how a place works through its movements, and perceive the prehistoric, crowd-based patterns of human movement that look merely grubby at street level.

    “It is very difficult, when writing a story, to hold the whole of it in one’s head... I like the idea of being able to understand the way a city works by seeing its movements from above.”

  • Doing a daily cartwheel was sustainable at 25 but not at 35, reflecting greater fatigue with age.

    “The thing about doing a cartwheel every day — that was true when I was 25, but it’s not true now I’m 35.”

  • Growing up in Zimbabwe with parents who allowed enormous freedom—vanishing for the day without adult supervision from around age 10—gave a freeing quality to the imagination that likely contributed to her becoming a children's writer.

    “The shining quality of that childhood time... spent entirely without the presence of adults — the freeing quality that gives your imagination, I imagine has something to do with the fact that I became a children’s writer.”

  • Per Philippe Petit, vertigo is not the fear that you will fall but the fear that you will jump—a beast that must be tamed piece by piece and can never be overcome all at once—and roof walking is the practice of separating one's sense of danger from one's distrust of self.

    “Vertigo, he says, is not the fear that you will fall. It is the fear that you will jump.”