What this covers
Jess Wade, a physicist at Imperial College London, sits down with Tyler Cowen to argue that gender imbalances in science stem not from biology but from how societies educate, advise, and fund researchers differently based on gender. The conversation moves fluidly between her two main tracks: the structural barriers embedded in academia—unequal mentorship, hidden curriculum in proposal writing, institutional bias in funding review—and her technical research into chiral molecular materials that could enable room-temperature quantum technologies and more efficient displays. Wade illustrates her institutional critique with concrete examples: how editing a single Wikipedia page about Gladys West, the largely unrecognized mathematician whose calculations enabled GPS, led to her sudden public recognition and prestigious awards; how Germany's funding agency DFG improved outcomes by removing résumé review and judging proposals alone; and how the pandemic's differential impact on women scientists reveals structural vulnerabilities in academia that the private sector sometimes handles better.
On the science side, Wade explains chirality—the handedness of molecules and structures—and how chiral materials can generate circularly polarized light and selectively transport spin-polarized electrons, potentially eliminating the cryogenic cooling currently required for quantum technologies. She notes that all life on Earth is homochiral, a profound mystery, and that her research suggests electron transport efficiency may explain why. Beyond her lab work, Wade discusses her Wikipedia activism—filling documented gaps in coverage of women scientists and non-Western research—and pushes back against both well-meaning but counterproductive messaging ("only 8 percent of engineers are women") and proposals to shrink funding proposals without equal support to write them. She argues that fairness in research funding is pragmatically justified because breakthrough science is not coming mainly from repeatedly funded established labs, and that the biased study design often used to manufacture evidence of biological sex differences obscures how thoroughly social conditioning shapes apparent aptitudes.
Wade argues that gender gaps in science are produced by social conditioning, education, and institutional bias rather than biological preference, and that targeted public service (like editing Wikipedia) plus equitable, proposal-focused funding can correct these distortions while her own chiral-materials research opens new room-temperature quantum and display technologies.
- Apparent differences in women's scientific 'preferences' stem from how society teaches and advises them, not biology
- Wikipedia's content gaps reflect who edits it, so deliberate volunteer effort can democratize knowledge
- Chirality lets molecules control light polarization and electron spin, enabling more efficient, room-temperature technologies
Chiral molecules control both charge and spin transport, offering practical quantum technologies without requiring extreme laboratory conditions.
- Chiral molecules don't just emit twisted light but also transport spin-up or spin-down electrons preferentially depending on their handedness—a molecule's shape pushes one electron spin through with ease and the other with difficulty—offering control over both charge and spin transport that could enable new quantum technologies and may even explain why life on Earth is homochiral, since electron transport is more efficient when electrons move in one direction.
“Depending on whether you have a left- or a right-handed molecule, you’ll get a preference for up electrons passing through the system with ease or passing through the system with difficulty.”
- Carbon-based chiral molecular materials offer lightweight, easy-to-process, low-environmental-impact semiconductors with new functionalities like twisted-light generation and high spin-polarization, and a chiral molecular thin film that spin-filters electrons at room temperature could enable quantum technologies without the cryogenic cooling and pressurized chambers currently required.
“If you could create some kind of chiral molecular-thin film that, at room temperature, could spin-filter electrons, can that enable some kind of quantum tech thing to happen much more efficiently without the huge infrastructure that we need, at the moment”
- Chirality is the property of molecules and other structures existing as non-superimposable mirror images of one another—like left and right hands—appearing across length scales from electron and photon spin (spin-up/down, left/right circularly polarized light) to molecules and macroscopic forms like snail shells and wisteria barks.
“they can also exist as non-superimposable mirror images of one another. That’s what chiral is.”
- Chiral structures detecting very weak magnetic fields—such as those generated by neurons firing in the brain—optically and at room temperature could yield a much more flexible medical imaging system, and circular polarization could also enable multiplexed, encrypted optical communications where only sender and receiver know the chirality pattern.
“If you could use some kind of chiral structure to be able to detect those magnetic fields optically, you could generate some kind of medical imaging system that was much more flexible.”
- Within five years, possibly less given how fast display manufacturers innovate, chiral molecules emitting circularly polarized light will become the active layer of LED/OLED displays (phones, Nintendo Switch, large TVs), doubling display efficiency and extending battery life because less power is wasted generating light inefficiently from pixels.
“you’ll see chiral molecules being the active layer of your LED display... you could double the efficiency of those displays by just using something that emits circularly polarized light.”
- Emissive chiral molecules twisted clockwise or anti-clockwise can make emitted light slightly left- or right-circularly polarized, which is useful for display technologies because it can double brightness and reduce power consumption.
“can we make the light that comes out left- or right-handed slightly polarized? That’s really useful for display technologies because it means you can double the brightness that you get and reduce the power consumed.”
Apparent gender differences in scientific aptitude and field distribution result from socialization and training, not biology.
- Apparent gendered aptitudes like women being good at careful observation in astronomy result from how society trains, advises, and teaches women from a young age rather than biology, and biased study designs can be constructed to manufacture evidence of biological sex differences that don't hold up if society's influence is accounted for.
“if you design a scientific study destined that you want to be able to show that there’s some biological difference between men and women’s abilities, you’ll be able to design the study in such a way that you show that because you are so biased in the design of doing it”
- In the early 1900s UK women were taught science more extensively than now because men focused on Latin and Greek, but once society realized women were excelling at chemical and physical sciences with potentially huge implications, it pushed women out and men back in, creating a disconnect between what women could do and what they were allowed to do.
“Then society realized women were getting really good at these things that could potentially have huge implications, pushed the women out and pushed the men back in”
- The differences Wade would allow between men and women on average are physical—men are larger, taller, and can run faster—but she rejects forcing anyone into fields by gender and wants equal training and support so people choose freely.
“They’re larger and taller, and they can run faster. I think that the size difference is probably the word.”
- An unproductive way to encourage women in science is constantly telling them there aren't any women in science (e.g. 'only 8 percent women engineers'); productive approaches instead give everyone equal educational opportunities, good physics and math teachers across all schools, equal career advice, research exposure, lab space, funding, and mentorship.
“unproductive ways to encourage women in science, which happen a lot, is constantly telling women in science there aren’t any women in science”
- The lower share of women in STEM versus biological sciences is not biological preference but the result of how children are taught and introduced to subjects at school and the attitudes of parents; evidence is that UK chemistry undergraduate enrollment is gender balanced precisely because chemistry is mandatory for medical school, so making physics mandatory for medicine would similarly raise women's physics enrollment.
“chemistry undergraduate is gender balanced because girls start studying chemistry at high school, and they’re like, “This is an awesome subject, so I’ll go and do it at university.””
Reducing proposal burden without equal preparation support favors those with prior experience and insider knowledge.
- Reducing proposal page counts is good, but doing so without providing equal support to write them just favors people with prior experience and savvy at writing short proposals; the hidden curriculum in academia—unequal access to support and guidance—strongly influences which science gets funded, so equity requires both shorter proposals and equal preparation support.
“then we’re just going to favor the people who are in places or have this prior history of writing these things and can write these savvy three-page proposals. We need to give people the support to be able to write them.”
- A recent paper found that institutional privilege increases the number of science papers not because privileged researchers make more breakthroughs but because they have more opportunities and money to pursue them; people are equally innovative regardless of institution, so funding should be judged on the proposed research and the support available to execute it.
“It wasn’t that people were making more breakthroughs; it’s just that they had more opportunities to make those breakthroughs because you’d given them so much money to be able to do it.”
- UK science funding judges applicants partly on a CV—reviewers check where you work and whether you have career gaps before reading the proposal—which embeds institutional bias, whereas Germany's DFG progressively removed résumé review and evaluated proposals alone, producing more democratic, fair, and gender-balanced outcomes by removing that bias.
“People often look at the CV first, check where you work, check if you’ve had career gaps, check all of these things that they’re quite biased about, and that impacts their likelihood to fund your science.”
Wikipedia's serendipitous browsing and traceable editing history surface overlooked figures and maintain rigor better than AI-generated summaries.
- Wikipedia has large content gaps—especially in biographies of women, current science, the global south, and climate—because a relatively small group of editors does most of the work and the majority are men, mostly from North America, and many academics don't see editing as a worthwhile time investment.
“because you’ve got a relatively small group of people who edit Wikipedia a lot, doing this huge public service in creating content, the majority of them are men. The majority of them are from the Northern Hemisphere”
- GPT models won't displace Wikipedia because Wikipedia lets you interrogate it—via the history and talk tabs you can see who wrote what, when, which references were added, and the discussion behind a page—whereas ChatGPT gives quick answers without traceable, appropriate citations, so Wikipedia remains important as evidence that someone did rigorous, non-biased sourcing.
“the beautiful thing about Wikipedia is you can interrogate it quite a lot. You can see who wrote what, when they wrote it, and when that reference was added, what that reference is.”
- Wade's Wikipedia work revealed that women are not getting enough awards for science, leading her to spend time writing citations to nominate women as fellows and for medals and honors—a task that will outlast AI taking over routine page editing.
“women are just not getting enough awards for science, so I spend a lot of my time not only researching these people, but also writing citations for people to become fellows or get big awards and medals and honors”
- Wikipedia's value for surfacing overlooked figures lies in serendipitous browsing—people land on it searching for a topic, school, or university and stumble through alumni lists onto pages about women or scientists of color—whereas asking ChatGPT a direct question would just return the few big male names and lose that discovery path.
“One goes on it and types in “climate change” or “number theory” or some kind of thing that they’re interested in, or the name of their high school or their university, and then they look through the alumni”
- Writing Gladys West's Wikipedia page in 2018—when little existed online about the 90-year-old mathematician who computed the earth's deviation from a perfect sphere to enable GPS—catalyzed her public recognition, leading to top-women lists, induction into the US Air Force Hall of Fame, and a Royal Academy of Engineering medal.
“When I wrote about Gladys West, it was the beginning of my Wiki editing world. It was 2018, and there was very little about her online.”
Funding based on supporting people fairly across diverse backgrounds produces better science than repeatedly funding established privileged researchers.
- Funding people rather than projects—as the Arc Institute and Stuart Buck advocate—can be transformative especially in clinically relevant interdisciplinary settings, but it risks creating empires where certain people get huge funding while others lack a seat at the table, so it must be paired with equal and fair representation in who gets funded.
“I would say we’re still at risk there of creating these little empires, where certain people get huge amounts of scientific funding, and other people don’t have that opportunity and that seat at the table.”
- Pursuing fairness over pure meritocracy in funding is justified because the most disruptive and exciting science is not currently coming from repeatedly funding the same few big established people—whose well-funded labs often don't produce innovative work—so fairness is instrumental to getting more exciting and impactful science.
“I don’t think we’re getting the most disruptive or exciting scientific ideas at the moment from just funding the few big people who’ve always had science funding.”
Women in academia face disproportionate caring responsibilities and barriers to building research groups that the private sector addresses better.
- Women succeeded early in astronomy because the science could be accessed and performed from home alongside a wealthy scientist husband or father, allowing tasks like polishing telescope lenses and observing in dark-sky environments without the need for institutional access.
“you were probably allowed to interact with science at home, potentially in things like polishing the lenses that you might use on a telescope”
- Women in academia face particular difficulty building large research groups while disproportionately taking on caring responsibilities, and the pandemic significantly harmed women's ability to return to work; the private sector often offers more flexible return-to-work opportunities than academia or civil service.
“the opportunities they get to build their own big research groups while simultaneously taking on caring responsibilities — because women still disproportionately get that in society — it is really challenging”
Public outreach and children's books deserve academic credit equal to peer review despite current negative perception of such work.
- Material science and chemistry are underrepresented in children's books—bookstores stock dinosaurs, space, and gross human-body topics but not exciting materials like solar panels or future quantum computers—revealing a responsibility for materials researchers to engage young people, and the strong public response to Nano shows the demand exists.
“You go into a bookstore, and all of the books for kids are about dinosaurs or about space or gross things about the human body. But they’re not like, “Here’s amazing materials that you can use as a solar panel”
- Academia currently rewards public outreach like writing children's books with zero or negative recognition—people assume those who do it aren't serious scientists—but it should reward anything that takes science to a bigger audience, and this can be done without de-emphasizing peer review, as some US and UK institutions already credit public service in promotion and recruitment.
“academia should reward anything that is taking the science or the outcomes of their research to a bigger audience, whether it’s something like going out and giving public lectures, whether it’s something like doing a kids’ book”
Social media communities for marginalized scientists build confidence and catalyze funding and field changes after targeted movements emerge.
- Social media is powerfully positive for connecting scientists from marginalized backgrounds—such as the only Black physicist in an institution finding a community—building confidence that enables presentations, funding, and field changes, as demonstrated by movements like Black in Chemistry, Black in Physics, and Black in Neuro that emerged after George Floyd's murder and galvanized new funding and scholarships.
“the magical parts of any of these social media, for me, is uniting people who before didn’t feel like they had a voice”
Raman spectroscopy reveals molecular structure through vibrational fingerprints usable in situ on nanoscale objects.
- Raman spectroscopy is a vibrational spectroscopy in which a laser shone on a material makes its chemical bonds vibrate and scatter light back at a slightly shifted energy, producing a spectrum that acts as a molecular fingerprint revealing which chemical bonds are present and how ordered they are—usable in situ while applying charge or heat, and on objects far too small to see optically.
“as a result of that vibration, scatters the light that goes back at a slightly different energy to the light that you shone on it. You get this Raman spectrum”
Wikimedia Foundation's youth and boundary-pushing culture prevents ossification if the editing community mirrors global readership.
- Wikipedia need not ossify like other aging nonprofits because the Wikimedia Foundation employs only about 200 people who are young, globally minded, enthusiastic about open source, and constantly push boundaries on interface and design; the community served must reciprocate by making the editorship represent the global readership.
“There are only about 200 people who actually work for the Wikimedia Foundation. They’re very young, they’re very enthusiastic about open source, they’re very forward-thinking”
Data on autism underdiagnosis in women should precede accepting male overrepresentation in Wikipedia as reflecting autistic preference.
- The hypothesis that male overrepresentation among Wikipedia editors reflects autistic preference for organizing information should not be accepted before gathering data, because autism is likely underdiagnosed in women who socially assimilate to feminine stereotypes—and everyone, regardless of gender or ethnicity, gets excited about contributing to open knowledge once trained.
“there’s probably a huge number of autistic women who would say that, actually, it’s just very underdiagnosed in women because they socially assimilate”
Quantum computing remains far from practical household and business relevance despite primitive demonstrations.
- Although quantum computation has been demonstrated with primitive qubit systems that outperform classical counterparts on some calculations, getting enough qubits to work in harmony to do anything useful is far off—current setups require isolated molecules in vacuum or hundreds of qubits in stadium-sized cryogenic chambers—so quantum computing remains far from being societally relevant or present in homes and companies, and may not even be needed for current needs.
“Whilst people have demonstrated that quantum computation is possible, we’re really, really far away from it being societally relevant or useful.”
AI's impact on funding fairness depends entirely on training data—it risks worsening bias or reducing it by prioritizing research quality.
- AI could make funding evaluation worse—since people who don't care can have ChatGPT write EDI statements indistinguishable from sincere ones, displacing those who genuinely care—but it could also reduce bias if trained on what made past proposals successful and impactful rather than on biased signals like nationality, gender, and institution; the outcome depends entirely on the training data.
“someone who doesn’t care very much and can just run this through an AI-enabled language model can get the position when I can’t”
Telling women they must change rather than giving them genuine opportunity, funding, and support is unproductive.
- Telling women they must become more like men through tactics like 'ten steps to a great presentation' or power stances is not helpful; giving people genuine opportunity, funding, lab space, and support is what actually helps.
“Telling women that they’re different or telling women that they have to become more like a man — “here’s 10 fantastic steps on how to give a great presentation,” like the power stance stuff — that’s not particularly helpful.”
Renaissance masters' interdisciplinary mastery of materials, art, and nanostructure shows silos between scientists and craftspeople are modern, not natural.
- Renaissance masters were extraordinarily interdisciplinary—obsessed with materials, painting, architecture, metallurgy, and glass nanoparticles used long before science could name them—showing that the modern silo separating scientists from artists and craftspeople did not exist then, even as that same society still failed to value women.
“you really learn that this idea that everything has to be in silos, that scientists are distinct from artists or craftspeople, was completely gone then.”
Life's homochirality persists as unsolved mystery driving scientific fascination despite evolutionary advantage.
- All naturally occurring life on Earth is homochiral—all DNA and sugars are right-handed and all amino acids are left-handed—and although life clearly selects for this, the reason remains unknown and is a fascination for many scientists.
“all DNA in human life or in plant life or anything on planet Earth — is right-handed. All sugars are right-handed. All amino acids are left-handed. There’s some reason that that happens, that life selects for that. We still don’t know the reason”
AI reproducing DEI statements indicts the statements themselves as signals of access rather than genuine commitment.
- That ChatGPT can reproduce DEI/EDI statements indicts not just the AI use but the existence of such statements, because like biased entrance exams they reward those privileged enough to have others write them—so having someone (or something) write your statement signals access, not genuine commitment.
“having them at all is an indictment of those statements because it’s almost like those ridiculous entrance exams that are used to go to medical school here or graduate school in America”
Wikipedia editing as evening practice prepares Wade intellectually for collaboration and broadens her research perspective.
- Wade's most unusual successful work habit is editing Wikipedia every evening, which both advances advocacy and serves a practical preparation function: writing the biography or Wikipedia page of a collaborator or speaker before meeting them is one of the best ways to prepare for an experiment or talk, broadening her ideas beyond her own narrow research bubble.
“one of the best ways to prepare for going to do that experiment is to write the Wikipedia page of who you’re going to be with.”