What this covers

Jeremy Grantham, the investor and co-founder of GMO, sits down with Tyler Cowen to argue that capitalism and mainstream economics have a structural blindness to slow-rolling catastrophes—climate change, soil depletion, insect collapse, lithium scarcity, and falling fertility rates. The conversation weaves together economic history, resource physics, and climate science to make a single claim: markets respond only when forced to, after a crisis hits, not in anticipation of it. Against this backdrop, Grantham contends that venture capital is the most potent tool available, because the near-zero marginal cost of green energy, paired with startup iteration and innovation, can displace fossil fuels and engineer around resource bottlenecks before cascading failures arrive.

The discussion ranges across several distinct territories. Grantham dismisses mainstream climate economics—particularly Bill Nordhaus's estimates—as abstractions that ignore civilizational collapse risk, arguing that no serious climate scientist believes societies survive at five or ten degrees of warming. He examines real resource constraints: lithium reserves supply only 5 percent of what a full green transition would require; topsoil in the American Midwest has thinned from a foot to inches. He identifies self-reinforcing climate feedback loops, from methane release to jet stream shifts, that could spiral out of control with another degree or two of warming. He also traces how fertility rates have crashed across developed nations—South Korea at 0.8, Japan at 1.35—creating an aging-population problem no economy has solved. The conversation touches on housing bubbles, the fourth great market superbubble in modern history, geothermal prospects, and fusion startups, along with a historical digression on Margaret Thatcher's economic reforms and why Brexit succeeded when it did.

Sharpest takeaway

Grantham argues that markets, economists, and capitalism systematically underrate slow-burning long-term resource and environmental problems (climate, soil, insects, lithium scarcity, fertility collapse), and that early-stage green venture capital is the most powerful and profitable lever to engineer around these bottlenecks in time.

  • Capitalism only responds when 'banged on the nose,' so it fails to anticipate commons problems like climate and soil erosion
  • Economist estimates of climate damage (e.g. Nordhaus) are absurdly low because models abstract away civilizational collapse risk
  • Green energy's near-zero marginal cost plus venture capital innovation can green the whole system, but timing is the binding constraint

The argument · threads15 threads · 36 claims
0.80

Multiple interconnected resource constraints—lithium inadequacy, topsoil loss, finite commodity reserves, and mineral shortages—make the green transition materially impossible at current scales.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Reserves of topsoil in the Midwest have dropped from at least a foot to an inch or two, and although most prime land still has soil, the safety margin has dwindled to next to nothing, so unless Big Ag changes to reduce erosion, productivity loss will begin in the next decade.

    “The reserves of topsoil in the Midwest have gone from at least a foot to an inch or two... If we do not change Big Ag to be less conducive to erosion, we will start to lose productivity pretty soon. In the next decade, it will start.”

  • Because lithium reserves are inadequate, we must redesign around lithium and make lightweight batteries from something else, and sodium and potassium are very good candidates since there are hundreds of times more of them available than lithium.

    “We’re just going to have to find another way to make lightweight batteries using something other than lithium, and potassium and sodium are very good candidates and will probably do it. There are hundreds of times more sodium and potassium around than lithium.”

  • Commodities differ from most growth phenomena because the store is completely finite: even if your growth rate decelerates, the reserves still shrink and never mystically increase, so slowing growth does not reverse depletion the way it might ease other constraints.

    “If your growth rate slows, the reserves do not mystically increase. That’s the difference to almost all aspects of growth and resources.”

  • Even mining every ounce of lithium in known reserves would supply only about 5 percent of what is required to green the entire economy once, ignoring that batteries would need replacing roughly every 30 years, so lithium reserves are totally inadequate to the task.

    “If we mined every ounce of lithium that is in the known reserves, it would probably be about 5 percent of what is required to green the entire economy once, forgetting about the fact that every 30 years, it would then need to be replaced.”

  • The global mining industry as currently configured cannot produce sufficient raw materials for the green transition—not a prayer, not even close.

    “If we mined every ounce of lithium that is in the known reserves, it would probably be about 5 percent of what is required to green the entire economy once, forgetting about the fact that every 30 years, it would then need to be replaced.”

0.71

Green energy's marginal cost advantage and venture capital's vigor, paired with policy momentum, offer the only realistic pathway to avoid collapse despite resource constraints.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Recycling early-stage green VC—investing, earning a return, and reinvesting—is a candidate to make more profit than any other area of venture capital, because the real and financial environment is moving in its favor as countries put their shoulders behind climate change with carbon taxes and electrification incentives, and the real money is in the early stages of the next wave of inventions.

    “I think recycling early-stage green VC, having it come back with a decent return, go out a second time, come back with profit — I think it’s a candidate to make more profit than any other area of venture capital.”

  • American venture capital is the last and best form of American exceptionalism: the biggest and best in the world, very vigorous, attracting the best foreigners and paired with a lion's share of the great research universities, and it is the sector that will do the heavy lifting to save us, especially on climate.

    “I am a great fan of American venture capital. It is, I think, the last, best American exceptionalism... If we save our bacon, that is the sector that will do the heavy lifting for everybody, including the US.”

  • The marginal cost of wind, solar, and almost all green energy is essentially nil once the expensive plant is built, and since even falling fossil fuel prices can never reach nil on a marginal cost basis, green energy will drive fossil fuels out of business.

    “the marginal cost of wind and solar and almost all green energy is nil. It’s very hard for even a falling price of fossil fuels to get to nil... we will drive fossil fuels out of business.”

  • Geothermal will likely also work and has a good shot at commercial viability because the cosmic engineering improvements from drilling hundreds of thousands of fracking wells over 15 years can be transferred to geothermal, so with tens of thousands of geothermal wells and engineers iterating, it should expand from a handful of easy commercial sites to large chunks of available commercial geothermal.

    “we have just drilled hundreds of thousands of holes in fracking. And the technology improvement, the engineering improvements in that 15-year window were just cosmic, and now we can transfer a lot of that technology towards geothermal.”

  • Big bureaucratic fusion efforts have maybe a one-in-four chance of becoming commercial because they build on 30-year-out-of-date technology like the Concorde, while the roughly 30 newer second-generation fusion startups, leveraging advances in math and science, have a better-than-50/50 collective chance of achieving scientifically and engineering-wise successful fusion, though it may still be uneconomic if storage and cheap renewables advance enough.

    “I think there’s some chance that the big bureaucratic fusion efforts will work — maybe one in four... but I think there’s a bigger chance than that that one or more of the 30 newbies, where they’re basing their research on brilliant new ideas.”

  • Greening is extremely energy- and resource-intensive upfront because building windmills, solar, and battery storage front-loads all the labor, materials, and mining; this massive buildout creates a strange surge in energy demand that green energy cannot yet meet, so it temporarily raises demand for fossil fuels.

    “That pulse, if you will, to build at a massive increased rate — wind, solar, and storage — creates an enormous, strange increment in demand for energy, which cannot be met yet, of course, by green energy, so it causes the demand for fossil fuels to go up.”

0.70

Current financial markets are in a dangerous fourth superbubble, with US stocks dramatically overvalued while bonds and global real estate are universally mispriced.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Unlike the universal bond overvaluation and near-universal real estate overpricing, the stock market overpricing in this event is curiously confined principally to the US, while other countries are merely in ordinary bull markets, mirroring the year 2000.

    “the overpricing, rather like 2000, is concentrated in the US in the stock market. Plenty of places around the world are merely in a bull market — ho-hum, ordinary stuff.”

  • Markets are a function of human behavior that is normally fairly efficient, but once in a blue moon extended good economic years, peak profit margins, near-perfect conditions, and a slow build-up of euphoria conspire to hit a flashpoint where people buy stocks with no regard for fundamentals; there have been only three such superbubbles, all sharing unique characteristics, and the current one is the fourth.

    “Then once in a blue moon, circumstances conspire to get us into an irrational fever... Then it hits a flashpoint, where people start to buy stocks without any regard to the fundamentals, as we’ve seen in the meme stocks recently.”

  • Global housing markets, having reached preposterous multiples of family income by historical standards, are more dangerous to disturb in economics than stocks and will spend the next big chunk of time unraveling and causing all manner of perhaps unexpected problems.

    “housing, of course, is a more dangerous thing to mess with in economics. I believe the housing markets around the world will spend the next big chunk of time unraveling and causing all manner of, perhaps, unexpected problems.”

0.70

Capitalism cannot anticipate commons problems like climate change, soil depletion, and insect collapse until crisis forces response, leaving civilization dangerously unprepared.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Markets can be relied upon to be wrong on any horizon over two years, and economists can be counted on to be wrong about anything long-term, anything involving the commons, or anything requiring common sense, because their models drift into abstractions and assumptions detached from the real world.

    “On a horizon that’s over two years, I count on the markets being wrong. As for economists, I typically count on them being wrong for anything that is long-term, anything to do with the commons, anything that requires a lot of common sense.”

  • Markets are occasionally efficient, occasionally ludicrously inefficient as in bubbles, and everything in between, but capitalism has no ability to anticipate commons problems like climate change or soil erosion; it waits until banged on the nose and then sometimes responds brilliantly, but it does not anticipate problems.

    “I have, unfortunately, no confidence in capitalism in dealing with the commons... Capitalism waits until you bang it on the nose, and then it responds — sometimes brilliantly, quickly, and effectively — but it does not anticipate problems very well, does it?”

  • Homo sapiens have a profound ability to avoid long-term, slow-burning issues such as soil erosion, water shortages, toxicity, loss of insects, and falling fertility rates, showing no interest even though these may detonate on a fuse only 20 or 30 years out.

    “The ability of Homo sapiens to avoid long-term, slow-burning issues is truly profound... We show no interest in these things at all, even though they may be burning on a fuse that’s only 20 or 30 years out.”

0.56

Climate change involves self-reinforcing feedback loops and civilizational risk that economic models grotesquely underestimate, with economists dismissing genuine existential stakes.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • There are several potential self-reinforcing climate feedback loops—methane and CO2 release from thawing tundra and offshore clathrates, jet stream and ocean current shifts, and ice-albedo loss where dark ocean absorbs heat formerly reflected by ice—any of which could spiral temperature out of control, and no serious climate scientist can guarantee these won't trigger with another degree or two of warming.

    “the temperature in the far north releases methane and CO2 from tundra and from offshore frozen methane — clathrates, they call them — and that could spiral the temperature out of control... The ice reflected the sun, and now the dark ocean absorbs it, and the temperature goes up faster, and more ice melts.”

  • Estimates that warming costs only 5 to 10 percent of GDP, and Nordhaus's claim that even 10 degrees centigrade would cost only about 10 percent of GDP, are utterly trivial jokes, because no serious climate scientist believes global society would survive at 5 degrees, let alone 10, so economists' tiny GDP numbers ignore civilizational collapse.

    “It strikes me as utterly trivial and only producible by economists... He said, “Even if there was 10 degrees centigrade, it would only cost something in the range of 10 percent of GDP.” To which I say, “Dudes, we will be long gone as a species at 10 degrees centigrade.””

  • Climate mitigation has barely begun; there are no great sea walls and the world is in complete denial about ocean level rise, operating a pay-as-you-go system where we spend nothing in anticipation and only respond after being whacked on the nose, as Miami eventually will be by a major flood.

    “This is a pay-as-you-go system that we have. We respond, as I say, when we get whacked on the nose. We’re not anticipating in mitigation expenditures. We’re spending nothing.”

0.51

Fertility collapse across developed economies paired with aging workforces creates an unsolvable demographic bottleneck with no institutional preparation or policy response.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Fertility rates have crashed—South Korea at 0.8, Japan 1.35, the US 1.65, the UK about 1.7, with parts of Europe like Hungary and Italy near 1.0—meaning some countries are more than halving each 35-year generation, and we have no idea how to handle an aging population with few workers.

    “The fertility rate in South Korea is 0.8, so they’re more than halving every generation of 35 years... This is a crash. We have no idea how we’ll be able to handle aging population and few workers.”

  • We live in a world of bottlenecks suddenly emerging from COVID, climate change, and resource shortages, so we need to spend more money, time, and talent anticipating the next level of bottlenecks and engineering around them in advance rather than waiting for them to bind.

    “We live in a world of bottlenecks, suddenly, from COVID, from climate change, from resource shortages. We really need to spend more money and time and talent on anticipating the next level of bottlenecks and working on them in advance.”

0.38

Concurrent droughts and floods across major agricultural regions alongside insect biomass decline suggest ecological tipping points approaching without serious scientific understanding.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Wild insect biomass is dropping by over 1 percent, closer to 2 percent a year, with populations down 50 to perhaps 75 percent from tropics to poles, and leading entomologists like E.O. Wilson believe that when insects go it might cascade into a threat to human survivability, though they cannot prove it because the system-wide research needed to demonstrate a cascade effect is not financed.

    “The insect population, from the tropics to the poles, has gone down by 50 percent, and it’s probably closer to 75 percent... when they go, it might cascade into a threat to human survivability also.”

  • Having severe droughts in China, India, Europe, and North America at the same time is completely without parallel in history, alongside record floods that wash away German towns and hit Pakistan, China, and the US without breaking the droughts.

    “The fact that we have severe droughts in China, India, Europe, and North America at the same time is completely without parallel in history.”

0.24

Self-inflicted policy errors like Brexit and political barriers to carbon pricing slow adaptation when rapid proactive engineering around bottlenecks is urgently needed.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Brexit was one of the worst self-inflicted economic wounds in modern times, because manufacturers who might have built plants in Scotland or northern England are now effectively paid to build in Europe instead, and combined with COVID it drove away industrious European workers, permanently lowering the UK's growth rate over decades.

    “I believe Brexit was one of the worst self-inflicted wounds in modern times that any economy could pull... Any Toyota building a plant in Europe, who might have built it in Scotland or the north of England, will of course now be paid, in a way, to build it in Europe.”

  • Because filling up the car and heating the home matter so much to the average voter, raising the cost of dirty energy is a nearly impossible ask of politicians, which makes the EU's effective carbon mechanism and China's struggling cap-and-trade efforts genuinely surprising achievements.

    “It’s so important to the average voter to fill up their car and do their heating that it’s a nearly impossible ask of politicians to do it.”

0.19

Humanity's exponential growth on fossil fuels is nearing its final doubling and will stop abruptly, making contraction inevitable rather than surprising.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Humanity is like bacteria in a petri dish that found fossil fuels as sugar and accelerated into a frenzy, doubling 32 times from nothing to massive; we are now on our last double and can see the outer rim, so it would not be surprising but is inevitable that the growth rate stops fairly abruptly.

    “We’re the bacteria in the petri dish. Someone discovered fossil fuels as sugar, and we accelerated into a frenzy. We can now see the rim of the petri dish... We’ve doubled and doubled 32 times from nothing to massive. We’re down to our last double.”

0.15

Grantham's resource consciousness stems from wartime Quaker upbringing, and his superior long-term judgment has yielded less wealth than ideas warrant due to execution gaps.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Grantham describes himself as a drifter with no great plans who entered finance in 1968 not from a drive to make money but because his friends were having more fun in the industry than anyone else by a wide margin, and he was driven throughout by ideas rather than money.

    “They were having more fun than anybody else by such a wide margin, I would’ve had to be an idiot in 1968 not to try and get a job in such an entertaining industry, so I did.”

  • Grantham admits he has been far better at getting long-term ideas right than at turning them into money, needing a great hedge-fund partner because implementation is a separate skill; his foundation holds 1.5 billion when the quality of ideas implies it should be 10, since he lacks interest in working out the fine derivatives of execution.

    “I have been much better at long-term ideas — getting them right — than I have been at turning those ideas into making money... The quality of the ideas was much better than my execution, which has always sucked.”

  • Grantham's worldview on scarcity and resources was shaped by being raised in a coal-mining town by Quaker-influenced grandparents during wartime, in a waste-not-want-not world where everything was recycled and waste was thought disgusting, so resource consciousness is now in his cortex.

    “we lived in a world of waste not, want not... Everything was recycled, waste of any kind was thought to be disgusting, you reused everything.”

0.10

Sudden shocks like 1987 crashes and 9/11 are unpredictable outliers distinct from bubbles, while property values collapse suddenly only when insurance becomes unavailable.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Unlike a classic stock market bubble such as 1929, 2000, or 2022, the 1987 crash turned out to be a unique outlier event not replayed in the following 25 years, just as 9/11 was an outlier shock bearing no resemblance to a bubble, illustrating that sudden shocks are impossibly difficult to predict.

    “It turned out that the ’87 crash was a unique outlier event that was not to be replayed in the next 25 years.”

  • Early flooding has little or almost no effect on property values, like going bankrupt slowly then suddenly; prices will start to decline only on the day insurance becomes unavailable except via government subsidy, after which a panic may make prices drop like a stone more than warranted, then rally.

    “The history so far on early flooding is that it has little or almost no effect... When you need to buy insurance one day, you will not be able to get it except from government subsidy, and on that day, the house prices will start to decline.”

0.05

Boston's cluster of universities and engineering talent creates persistent unfair advantage in generating venture capital success and good ideas.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Boston's central role in asset management stems from its cluster of universities producing people who think and generate good ideas, combined with strong engineering at institutions like MIT and the highest incidence of students of any major city, giving it a long-standing unfair advantage.

    “It has a good cluster of universities... if you think, pretty soon you’re likely to come up with good ideas, and then you need to implement them. Good engineering, MIT, and so on... The highest incidence of students of any major city.”

0.05

Brexit timing caught immigration sentiment at its historical peak; held later when disapproval would be far lower, the referendum would have failed entirely.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • British disapproval of immigration fell steadily from 90 percent in 1947 to 82 percent in 1957 down to about 55 percent at the Brexit vote, so the referendum which became a vote on immigration caught the most favorable possible moment; had it been held any other time after World War II, or 20 years later when sentiment would be near 42 percent, Brexit would have failed.

    “you did it in 1947, 90 percent of the people disapproved. If you did it in 1957, it was 82 percent... and finally to about 55 percent. And they decided to have Brexit, which became a vote on immigration. They could never have picked a point with as favorable a vote on immigration.”

0.05

Shorting equity markets is structurally asymmetric and unwise because upside is limited while downside is theoretically unlimited even without leverage.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Shorting is a mug's game in almost any area because even an unleveraged short position is asymmetric: a stock can rise tenfold and cost you ten times your initial stake while your upside is limited, so you don't need leverage to do badly, and adding leverage just kills you quicker.

    “Shorting is a complete mug’s game in almost any area, because once you’re short, you can lose 10 times your money, and you can only make a decent return if you’re right. This is an asymmetry”

0.05

Margaret Thatcher broke England from class-based malaise by hiring purely on merit, producing a faster and more competitive economy.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Margaret Thatcher was amazingly successful because she broke England out of economic and social malaise rooted in the class system by picking people entirely on merit, recruiting expatriate Brits from McKinsey to run nationalized companies, leaving a far more competitive Britain where things happened faster and London felt like New York.

    “She picked people entirely on merit. It was a kind of shocking introduction of meritocracy into the old establishment based on class and land... At the end of her era, it was a different Britain, much more competitive.”