Conversations with Tyler - Henry Oliver
What this covers
Henry Oliver and Tyler Cowen examine Shakespeare's Measure for Measure as a work fundamentally concerned with the limits of principle and the necessity of pragmatic compromise. Oliver argues that the play demonstrates the impossibility of individual consistency—that the principle of abstract justice collapses into hypocrisy when anyone tries to live by it—and that Shakespeare endorses pragmatism as the only workable solution: forced marriages and body trick substitutions avoid death and tragedy, making an unhappy ending nonetheless the least-bad outcome a society can achieve. Cowen presses alternative readings of the same material, seeing the play as feminist critique and skeptical of Christian morality, where the imposed solutions harm women and amount to a form of enslavement. Throughout, both speakers treat the play not as allegory but as engagement with immediate concerns of James I's court—justice, law, religious tension, and the link between fertility and economic survival.
The conversation moves across several distinct registers. Oliver traces the play's logic through its coinage imagery, fertility crisis, and the mirroring of the Duke and Isabella as pragmatists willing to deceive for good ends. He distinguishes Measure for Measure from Jonathan Swift's work and from other plays by its rejection of Girardian mimetic desire, arguing the substitutions must fail to be true doubles precisely to show that one cannot measure one's brother against oneself. Cowen counters with attention to the play's costs for women and its treatment of consent. Beyond Shakespeare, the speakers discuss how Jane Austen absorbed ideas from Adam Smith on moral judgment through narrative technique, and how temperament—roughly 60 percent inborn—shapes both literary creation and interpretation. Oliver also digresses on advertising history, distinguishing the hard sell from image-based approaches and crediting David Ogilvy with the creative fusion that made modern advertising work.
Oliver argues that Shakespeare's Measure for Measure is fundamentally a work of pragmatism—showing that no individual can stay consistent with abstract principles, so imperfect, imposed solutions are the best a society can hope for—while Cowen presses more skeptical readings (feminist, anti-Christian, even incest-coded) of the same play.
- The play demonstrates that one cannot 'weigh our brother with ourself'—abstract principle always collapses into hypocrisy
- The forced marriages and substitutions avoid death and tragedy, making the unhappy ending nonetheless the least-bad outcome
- Shakespeare engages contemporary concerns (James I, religious tension, the fertility/economy link) without being reducible to allegory
The play is pragmatically anti-idealistic: forced marriage prevents tragedy, individual consistency is impossible, and arbitrary law works.
- Measure for Measure picks up the problem of mercy from The Merchant of Venice and argues that no individual can be consistent with their own principles ('we cannot weigh our brother with ourself'); spouting abstract principles only produces hypocrisy and inconsistency, so the play is a great work of pragmatism that accepts arbitrary imposed law as the only way to make things work.
“Measure for Measure is saying no individual can be consistent with their own ideas, and Isabella makes a point of that again and again. "We cannot weigh our brother with ourself."”
- The Duke and Isabella are mirrors of each other—he is justice and temperance, she is mercy and passion—and both, despite hating lying and wrongdoing, are willing to be deceitful in a good cause, sharing a pragmatism; their marriage works because they are the two least sexualized characters, making them the least badly matched pair.
“He's justice, and she's mercy. He's temperance, and she's passion. They both, it turns out, are happy to be deceitful in the cause of justice.”
- The play is ideologically pragmatic because the alternative to forcing everyone to marry is not more happy marriages but tragedy and death—if Isabella had submitted to Angelo she would likely have killed herself and others would have died—so imposing marriage, where no one dies, is the only way things can work.
“either we force everyone to get married, or they all end up worse off. In this scenario, no one is dead.”
- Unlike A Midsummer Night's Dream (a cleanly Girardian play of mimetic desire) or Troilus and Criseyde, Measure for Measure is anti-Girardian: its characters are driven by inner desires rather than imitation, Isabella is not mimetic at all, and the substitutions must be obviously fake (not true doubles) precisely to show that one cannot measure one's brother against oneself.
“In this play, I think everyone is strongly motivated by their own inner desires. I think of this almost as anti-Girardian. Isabella is not mimetic in any way.”
Shakespeare wrote for performance and reading; best film treatments are least Shakespearean, and best stage productions trust the text.
- Measure for Measure fell into non-popularity because it is difficult to enjoy on stage: its ending is unsatisfactory as entertainment, its rapid-clip arguments are hard to follow, and it is a comedy with an unhappy ending in which marriages are imposed rather than desired.
“Because it's very difficult to enjoy on the stage. The ending is unsatisfactory from an entertainment point of view.”
- Measure for Measure was performed at James I's court, never appeared in quarto (suggesting limited popularity), and was perhaps written with the king in mind; it takes up self-measurement and just judgment—themes current at court and of interest to James, who was preoccupied with justice, law, religious tension, and sexual behavior—and offers a reading in which the king rightly imposes the law at the end.
“We know it was performed for him at court. We know it wasn't otherwise hugely popular because there was no quarto.”
- The best film treatments of Shakespeare plays are the ones that are least Shakespearean, such as Orson Welles's films (e.g., Chimes at Midnight), along with some of the BBC productions from the 1980s and Globe productions filmed for online viewing.
“Probably the ones that are least Shakespearean, like Orson Welles and things like that.”
- Many modern Shakespeare productions are terrible and give a bad idea of Shakespeare because directors are too interventionist, devising crazy schemes and metaphors that distract; the best productions, like Jonathan Miller's, simply ensure the actors understand what the words mean and then let them get on with it.
“The directors, I think, are too interventionist. They come up with these crazy schemes and metaphors, and it just distracts.”
- The claim that Measure for Measure shows Shakespeare was a Catholic does not hold water: friars, nuns, and pre-Reformation settings are insufficient evidence because Shakespeare is always writing about the tension between pre- and post-Reformation culture (as in Hamlet), and the necessary evidence for his Catholicism will never be obtained.
“That is not a basis for saying, "Oh, Shakespeare's a secret Catholic, and this play is really trying to be popish."”
- Shakespeare wrote not only to be performed but also to be read: he knew anthologists copied 'good bits' at the playhouse, deliberately wrote anthology speeches, knew his quartos would be printed and sold, and wrote for a divided audience including educated young men from grammar schools and the Inns of Court who relished puns, legal debate, and learned allusions—an audience that persists today.
“Shakespeare did write to be read. The idea that he wrote to be performed is only part of the truth.”
- Atlas Shrugged is an extraordinarily good and exciting novel—maybe the best genre novel ever written—with first-rate B-movie dialogue, and Rand handles ideas less clunkily and more subtly than she is given credit for in the party scenes and train arguments, though the three-hour speech is wearing; readers blocked from enjoying it are usually blocked by hostility to her philosophy.
“It was just so exciting on the plot level. It's maybe the best genre novel ever written.”
- John Milton's Paradise Lost is easily one of the best poems in English and is not read enough; Cowen rates it a top-ten work of all time that basically no one reads, even in excerpt.
“Oh, it's easily one of the best poems in English, and it's not read enough.”
Effective advertising merges hard sell with image-based appeal, while Creative Revolution mistakes discarded information for innovation.
- There are two competing schools of advertising—the hard sell (heavy information, facts, and repeated product naming) and the image-based approach (selling a mood or vibe, as in the Steinway, Frosties tiger, or Marlboro Man ads)—and the real creative revolution under David Ogilvy joined the hard sell with the image, which is when advertising actually works and produces the memorable ads that make people want to buy.
“There are two competing schools of advertising. One of them is the hard sell... The other advertising school is image-based.”
- The 1960s 'Creative Revolution' in advertising—analogous to modernism—made terrible mistakes by discarding the hard sell in pursuit of being new, unexpected, and mood-driven, producing ads like the Levi's short-film that entertain but leave the viewer unsure what product was being sold or shown anything useful.
“Then there was this terrible, terrible thing called the Creative Revolution in the 1960s”
- Cowen is actually quite good at advertising—on his podcast and blog he uses a little hard sell and a little image—which exemplifies the working formula, whereas most advertisers produce ads that 'suck' because they want to be cool and chase the Creative Revolution.
“You're actually quite good at advertising. You do it on your podcast. You do it on your blog. You do a little bit of the hard sell, a little bit of the image.”
- Advertising is not optimal: we don't know how well it works, are impeded by laws on who can be targeted online, and most people would be surprised how poorly advertisers can actually target—being followed by a toaster ad is basic, not real targeting, since everyone gets the same toaster ad.
“Everyone thinks they're being targeted all the time, but being followed by a toaster advert is really quite basic... That's not targeting.”
Measure for Measure explores fertility crisis and demographic necessity, with coinage imagery linking procreation to state survival.
- Rather than an incest play, Measure for Measure is a fertility-crisis play: closing the brothels threatens the birth rate (voiced by Lucio), and coinage imagery linking the stamping of a coin to procreation reflects the importance of demographics to sustaining the economy—the state must have a population to exist, so Isabella is effectively being forced into the sex market and the convent is her escape.
“there's a genuine question among them all that if we shut down the brothels, what will happen to the birth rate?”
- The play's coinage imagery raises a question relevant to an economist: is it the metal, or the face stamped on the metal, that gives a coin its value—mapped onto whether Isabella's persuasiveness comes from her words or from her mere presence inflaming Angelo, a double meaning the audience is meant to wonder about.
“Is it the metal, or is it the face stamped on the metal that gives it the value?”
- The plot is encapsulated by Portia's lines that 'a substitute shines brightly as a king, unto the king be by'—Angelo shines like a king until the real Duke returns, at which point his authority is immediately drained away and his true nature is revealed.
“Angelo shines like a king until the real Duke comes back, and then his authority is immediately drained away. We see him for what he really is”
- The play is skeptical of a secular authority's ability to impose moral rules in a world full of vice; on the South Bank near the playhouse the main institutions were pubs, brothels, and bishops' residences, reflecting Shakespeare's point that such laws cannot be implemented and everyone knows it.
“the main institutions were pubs, brothels, and bishops' residences. I think that's reflected in the inability of the law to work in this play.”
Isabella remains virtuous throughout; her submission refers to yielding an argument premise, not sexual or spiritual defeat.
- In act 1, scene 4, Isabella's wish for 'a more strict restraint' is a criticism of the nunnery's laxity rather than an admission of her own desires, and Lucio's 'Hail Virgin if you be' mocks the institution; consistent with the play, the virtuous individual always stands out against the corrupt institution, making Isabella good and everyone else the problem in a Kafka-esque reality.
“The individual always stands out against the institution, against the abstract argument, against some high ideal of justice that can't be implemented.”
- Isabella's act 5 line 'and I did yield to him' refers not to literal sexual surrender but to yielding the premise of Angelo's argument when he backed her into a corner in act 2, scene 2; her 'prayed and kneeled' language means exactly what it literally says, and she remains an image of virtue throughout.
“That is a reference to the argument that they were having when he backed her into a corner, and she had to admit that there was an inconsistency in her position.”
- The ending of The Taming of the Shrew is genuinely ambiguous—Kate's submission may signal she has found the only person like her and enters a happy mutuality, or that she has been broken by the patriarchy—whereas Isabella's kneeling at the end of Measure for Measure is not ambiguous: she has simply been broken.
“It's an open debate in that play. It's not, for me, really an open debate when Isabella kneels down and pleads at the end. She's just been broken”
Writers like Swift, Johnson, and Austen served practical purposes through literary talent, advertising ideas and arguments effectively.
- Reading Gulliver's Travels before working in politics proved useful because Swift understood the day-to-day life and sociology of politics—how people interact—so well that it was startling, and it was among the factors that convinced Oliver to leave politics.
“I was often startled by how much Swift understood about the day-to-day life of politics, the way people interact.”
- If advertising is understood not as headlines and banner ads but as the calling of attention to something of importance, then many great writers were excellent advertisers of their own work and ideas—Swift being so good that one could obtusely reframe his whole career as lobbying and PR—and writers like Samuel Johnson, who could write a sermon, a legal opinion, or an advert, show literary talent serving many practical uses.
“you could reframe his whole career as an exercise in lobbying and PR, and realize that no one's ever been as good at it as he was.”
- Jane Austen drew almost everything from Adam Smith: she is interested in how to be good in a commercial society and uses narrative techniques—controlling whose head we are in and what information we receive—to show that we must create our own internal impartial spectator and develop our own moral judgment, a deeply Smithian idea.
“Jane Austen is interested in the question of how to be good in a commercial society. She is clearly drawing on Smith's ideas”
- Adam Smith drew heavily on 18th-century novelists—loving Gulliver's Travels and Samuel Richardson—using the same examples they did (such as the trivial objects in Gulliver's pockets, whose triviality yet use Smith discusses) to inform his moral writing, and surprisingly endorsing Richardson as a good novelist to read to learn morals.
“Smith is clearly taking a lot from the novelists of the 18th century. He loves Gulliver's Travels. He loves Samuel Richardson.”
- Swift has a different intelligence from Shakespeare: he can handle practical questions of coinage, government, and war in both fictional and nonfictional modes, arguing with either the directness and polemicism of his pamphlets or the incredible ambivalence of Gulliver's Travels, in which he manages not to express his own opinions—giving him a balance Shakespeare lacked on the nonfiction side, even though Shakespeare far exceeds him in fiction.
“He can make those arguments either with the kind of directness and polemicism that we associate with his pamphlets, or with the incredible ambivalence of Gulliver's Travels”
Late bloomers emerge either through dramatic external crisis or by becoming their own interruption and refusing to die unfulfilled.
- Late bloomers tend to bloom either after a dramatic external life event (a suicide attempt, a hotel fire) that makes them resolve to change everything, or by becoming their own interruption—looking in the mirror and refusing to die without doing the thing—an attitude that is worth a lot.
“they become their own interruption. I think those people are very interesting.”
- Second Act succeeded because many people want to be late bloomers and want a serious, real answer to whether they could be one—rather than the usual resilience-and-never-give-up stories—even though the book explicitly argued against the implicit promise that 'you might be a late bloomer if only.'
“I think a lot of people want a serious answer to that question.”
- Grandma Moses is a clear example of late blooming through external circumstance: working as a house servant from around age 12-14, then farming and raising children without modern conveniences, she lacked time to paint until retirement, when, prompted to switch from stitching to painting, her childhood arts-and-crafts ability could flourish again.
“She's a great example of external circumstances.”
- Late bloomers may enjoy their success more because they can leave behind the bad thing and move into something new; as David Ogilvy said, men who have multiple careers are to be envied—it is the ultimate anti-boredom.
“Men who have multiple careers are to be envied, said David Ogilvy. It's the ultimate anti-boredom.”
Readers disagree about fiction's meaning because texts are intentionally ambivalent, context is lost, and temperaments vary.
- Readers disagree about a novel's meaning for three reasons: fiction is intentionally ambivalent (Swift in Gulliver's Travels deliberately sets out polyphonic views and leaves room to get it wrong on purpose); we lose the books' context so quickly that we bring ourselves to them; and some readers temperamentally want more controversial readings than others.
“fiction is intentionally ambivalent, by which I mean Swift in Gulliver's Travels does not want to express his own opinions. He wants to set out a polyphonic set of different views.”
- Fiction changes beliefs by the same mechanism as anything else—not by some magical empathy-granting quality—so that unless the reader does the hard work of absorbing it, thinking about its meaning, and testing their opinions against it in a Smithian sense, it passes straight through as a nice story; empathy works in a Smithian way that is genuinely hard and often fails, just as moral philosophers' work rarely changes their own personal morality.
“We sometimes talk about fiction as if it has a magical quality. "It will give you empathy."... But of course, you can get that in nonfiction or in conversation or in a movie”
- When reading or rereading Measure for Measure, readers should decide for themselves whether they want the painful blow-by-blow with every footnote understood or simply to reach the end and then return to examine it more closely, since readers genuinely differ in this preference.
“they don't want the painful blow-by-blow, but some people really do, so make that decision for yourself.”
Religious fiction will revive within twenty years as young readers seek serious outlets for faith exploration.
- Fiction will likely deal seriously with religion again before too long—perhaps within 20 years—because there are now many religious young people for whom fiction will provide an outlet, even though serious religious fiction has been comparatively rare since figures like Graham Greene, Evelyn Waugh, Willa Cather, and Muriel Spark.
“There are a lot of religious young people now, and fiction will give them an outlet for that.”