Helen Castor
What this covers
Helen Castor examines why the parallel reigns of Richard II and Henry IV matter for understanding how England confronted the nature of kingship itself. The conversation centers on the 1399 deposition as a constitutional turning point: Henry IV deposed Richard II not by simple seizure but through a laborious justification grounded in the claim that a king ruling by arbitrary will rather than law, or ignoring the interests of his people, becomes a tyrant. The deposition forced England to ask what could legitimately be done about a tyrant—a question whose answer, involving actions beyond existing constitutional consensus, proved destabilizing for centuries. Castor frames medieval England as an alien world best understood through the choices individuals made within bare structures of power: a king with no monopoly of force, no standing army, relying instead on hierarchies of private landed wealth to enforce his will; nobles bound to obey not only by self-interest but by the doctrine that the king was anointed by God himself.
The conversation ranges across the economic and social rifts that made this period volatile. The Black Death squeezed elite incomes while creating sudden mobility for lower orders—pressures the political classes struggled to contain while maintaining their war machine. Castor traces how the Deposition Articles of 1399 became living precedent, reused by men opposing Charles I in the 1640s, showing the English constitution as a sedimentary process that evolves by what takes hold. She also examines how Shakespeare encountered these events through chronicles, and how the parallels between Richard II's reign and Elizabeth I's own precarious position became so pointed that printers omitted the deposition scene from early editions. The discussion opens outward to questions of Historical Contingency, how Geoffrey Chaucer became possible once English ripened as a language of power, and why Science Fiction as Historical Lens helps recover a past where outcomes were genuinely unknowable to those living through them.
Castor argues that Richard II and Henry IV matter because their parallel reigns forced England to confront what kingship was and when it shaded into tyranny, and that the 1399 deposition became a sedimentary precedent built into the evolving English constitution; she frames medieval England as an alien world best understood by reconstructing individual psychology within bare-bones structures of power.
- Late medieval England was the most centralized state in Europe yet lacked a monopoly of force, so royal authority worked through private landed hierarchies.
- The 1399 Deposition Articles set precedents reused as late as the 1640s against Charles I, showing how the English constitution evolves by precedent.
- Castor's method is chronological and psychological because medieval England exposes individual choices against skeletal structures of power.
Medieval kingship rested on two functions—lawgiver and defender—both dependent on wealth and enforced through private landed hierarchies rather than state monopoly.
- Medieval English government did not have a monopoly of force—no professional police force and no standing army (only a hard-to-recall garrison at Calais)—so enforcement was its key problem; to enforce the king's edicts it relied on a hierarchy of private power, the great landowners who were wealthy through land and controlled the people who lived and worked on it, meaning the king's theoretical authority had to work through private landed power because modern communications and transport did not exist.
“What a government doesn’t have in the medieval period is, it doesn’t have a monopoly of force... So, enforcement is the government’s key problem. To enforce the king’s edicts, it therefore relies on a hierarchy of private power on the landed, the great landowners of the kingdom”
- The medieval king had two key functions depicted on the two sides of his seal: as lawgiver and judge (seated in state with crown, orb, and scepter) who imposes law and maintains order, and as defender of the realm (in armor on a warhorse with sword drawn) who must be a warrior to repel or launch attacks, which in turn required money raised through Parliament.
“the king has two key functions which appear on thetwo sides of his seal. On one side, he sits in state wearing a crown... a lawgiver and a judge... On the other side of the seal, he’s wearing armor on a warhorse with a sword unsheathed in his hand. That’s his function as a defender of the realm”
- Landed nobles obeyed the king because the king was the keystone of the hierarchy within which they were powerful and wealthy; while they wanted more power and wealth, they did not want to risk everything they already had, so they had every interest in maintaining the existing order—like competing safely within a game knowing a referee will step in—and this referee was additionally understood to be appointed and anointed by God, so resisting the king risked not only worldly position but one's immortal soul.
“the king is the keystone of the hierarchy within which they are powerful and wealthy... It’s like having a referee. You can compete safely within the rules of the game if you know the referee is there to step in if it gets really dangerous. On top of that, we have to imagine that the referee is appointed and anointed by God.”
- There is no huge gulf between a 'war state' and a 'law state'; kings who dealt with subjects over the needs of (including aggressive) defense also understood they needed effective government, the imposition of law, and the provision of justice at home, and Edward III and Henry IV both demonstrated that the two functions went hand in hand.
“I don’t see a huge gulf between what is described as a war state and a law state. I think they went hand in hand... kings who had to deal with their subjects in terms of the needs of defense... also understood that they needed to deal with their subjects in terms of effective government at home”
England's early centralization and sophisticated surviving records make the period ideal for studying how individual psychology inhabits skeletal power structures.
- By the late 14th century England was the most centralized state in Europe, a result of two formative periods: the Norman Conquest of 1066, which let the Normans take over the whole country, and Henry II's late-12th-century rule over an empire stretching from Scotland to southwestern France, which required a system of government and law that could function in his absence.
“England, at this point, was the most centralized state in Europe, and that has two reasons. One is theConquest of 1066... Then, the other key formative period is the late 12th century when Henry II is ruling an empire that stretches from the Scottish border all the way down to southwestern France.”
- Because England was such a centralized state, vast quantities of central government and law court documents survive down to manorial level, so new evidence for this period comes less from digitization or new diaries and more from the historical process of historians sifting, returning to the material, and asking new questions to see what those documents can be made to yield—occasionally aided by a document not previously looked at or looked at in a particular new way.
“It’s less a question of things being digitized and more a question of the historical process of sifting and finding, and what questions are being asked, and returning to the material and seeing what those documents can be made to give up.”
- Castor is preoccupied by the human dimension of history in two directions—the psychology of her protagonists moment to moment, and the functioning of power; she loves the Middle Ages because, while looking at a sophisticated structure of power, it appears in 'bare bones' without the great apparatus of the modern state, so individual choices and individual psychology become extremely exposed, making it the ideal site to study how skeletal structures of power are inhabited by particular individuals.
“you’re looking at a very sophisticated structure of power, but it’s present in bare bones because we don’t have the great apparatus of state. Therefore, individual choices and individual psychology become extremely exposed”
Historical understanding requires chronological narration of individual psychology and choices, recognizing contingency rather than imposing inevitable structure.
- If studying another period with her same interest in psychology and power, Castor would go back rather than forward—to ancient Greece—because that is a chronological extension backward, the classical world being at the root in many ways of medieval culture, and she would far more happily leap back than forward.
“I’m thinking Greece, ancient Greece, but of course it’s a chronological extension backwards... because the classical world is at the root, in many ways, of medieval culture.”
- These are interesting if uncomfortable times to think about the past, because if ever we needed a reminder that people in the past had no idea what was coming next, we are getting it now—and that produces fresh perspectives even on much more recent parts of the past, just as the I, Robot stories and English history alike keep going without a known ending.
“if ever we needed a reminder that people in the past had no idea what was coming next, we’re getting it now, and it produces interesting perspectives even on much more recent parts of the past.”
- Science fiction helps Castor understand medieval England because it puts recognizably human people into another world where landscape, culture, and assumptions differ from ours; Paul Atreides as the Lisan al-Gaib, the chosen one who speaks with 'the voice' and is obeyed, mirrors how Richard II thought of himself as a unique being entitled to command—except Richard was not in Dune but in England, where it did not work; history is both finding a narrative within the records of the past and recognizing the narratives people in the past told themselves.
“that sense of Paul Atreides as the Lisan Al-Gaib, the chosen one — that’s how Richard thought of himself... Trouble is, he’s not in Dune. He’s in England, and it doesn’t work... history is a process of finding a narrative within the records of the past, but it’s also a question of recognizing the narratives that people in the past told themselves”
- Castor loves Asimov's I, Robot for two reasons: the conceptual rigor of the Three Laws of Robotics, which are astoundingly thought through and precise, and a woman at its heart (unusual in sci-fi), watched across stories with the sense that nothing was inevitable but one thing led to the next—linking directly to the chronological, contingency-attentive work she does now.
“The three laws of robotics are so astoundingly thought through and precise... Watching that progression through the stories, with that sense that nothing was inevitablebutone thing was leading to the next.”
- Castor always writes chronologically because we live chronologically and don't know what's coming next, which suits her aim of investigating the role and psychology of individuals—building up a sketch from fragments and filling it out—in contrast to much academic history that takes an eagle-eyed view to trace long-term structural change; she even fills gaps (like Richard and Henry's education) using what she knows of their families and the men they became, working forward to explain their actions at successive ages.
“I always, always write chronologically because we live chronologically... a lot of academic history... is written with the kind of eagle-eyed view of the past, where you are trying to see long-term development, structural change... But because I am trying to investigate the role of individuals and the psychology of individuals... We all live from day to day, and we don’t know what’s going to happen”
- Writing this kind of history is a constant dialogue with Shakespeare and the sources, and as someone said, you don't finish a book, you stop—it is a conversation Castor is lucky to be a tiny part of.
“Whoever it was — I should know — who said you don’t finish a book, you stop. That’s how I feel. It’s a conversation that I’m lucky to be a tiny part of.”
- Castor's most notable work habit is learning to live with herself: she always expected to grow out of having 'essay crises' but never did—they now spread over five years per book—and she has accepted that that is how she works, a form of self-acceptance rather than a conventionally successful habit.
“I have always thought that I should grow out of having essay crises, and I never have. Even if they’re now essay crises that spread over five years for any individual book, I’ve had to accept that that’s how I work”
- Elizabeth I is an enigma because she wore masks all the time: you could be in the same room with her and not know what she was thinking, which is part of why Castor finds her endlessly fascinating and intends to write a full-length biography of her.
“She’s such an enigma because she wore masks all the time. You could be in the room with her and not know what she was thinking.”
- Watching Being John Malkovich again, Castor finds it more prescient about the world we now live in than The Matrix (both released the same year): its premise that you can be somebody else for 15 minutes through a portal, and that it would be addictive, anticipates the present; meanwhile the most farfetched thing to her 23-year-old son was that a whole company could exist just to do paper filing, illustrating how rapidly the recent past becomes alien.
“watchingBeing John Malkovichagain, now it seems to me to be far more prescient about the world we live in now — — thanThe Matrixis. That sense of, well, you can be somebody else for 15 minutes through a portal, and it’ll be addictive”
Richard II's personal failures—indulgence, stupidity, and obsession with image over effective rule—made him unfit to govern despite superb artistic taste.
- Richard II's late-reign trip to Ireland was a stupid mistake but consistent with his fundamentally stupid approach to governing England: believing he had safely destroyed his greatest rivals (his three opponents of 1397 and the exiled Mowbray and Henry, whose inheritance he seized in 1399), he felt free to indulge himself; he went personally because his 1394–95 visit had been enjoyable, where Gaelic chiefs prostrated themselves and swore homage so he would go away delighted while leaving them emboldened—and his absence left the kingdom undefended and open to Henry's return.
“Itisa stupid mistake but not one that Richard, I think, could have recognized because his whole approach to governing England was a stupid mistake... leaving his kingdom open and undefended gave Henry an opportunity to come back”
- Richard II had superb artistic taste and was a great commissioner of visual art—the life-size coronation portrait in Westminster Abbey, the first-ever double tomb for an English king (for himself and Anne of Bohemia), and the exquisite Wilton Diptych—but he was likely not a great reader; his interest in written literature was 'polite,' and it is no accident that all three great artworks place stunning portraits of himself at the center, reflecting that Richard was all about the image and iconography of his kingship.
“He had superb tastes artistically... It’s no accident that the three great pieces of visual art he commissioned all have stunning portraits of himself at the center.”
- After Essex's rebellion was put down, in April 1601 Elizabeth I, looking through archives with the keeper of the records in the Tower, reportedly turned to him and said 'I am Richard II. Know ye not that?'—recognizing the parallels even though she was far shrewder, more farsighted, and more self-aware than Richard ever was.
“Elizabeth was looking through some archives with the keeper of the records in the tower, and he later made a note that she turned to him and said, 'I am Richard II. Know ye not that?'”
- Shakespeare's Richard II, written around 1595 and published in 1597 and 1598, was clearly popular (multiple editions), but the printed edition omitted the 'deposition scene' because it was so controversial, as the parallels between Richard II's reign and the 1590s—a childless aging Elizabeth refusing to name an heir, problems in Ireland, and unrest culminating in the Earl of Essex's 1601 rebellion—were becoming uncomfortably close.
“what is not included in the printed edition is what’s called thedeposition scene, and that’s because it’s so controversial... the parallels with Richard II’s reign — almost exactly 200 years before — were becoming uncomfortably close.”
Parliament could refuse taxation by judging spending not in their interest, trapping kings within the same system that usually benefited them.
- If a king could demonstrate that money was needed to defend the realm—a concept that could be defined broadly—he could obtain taxation, which was a great strength; but Parliament (both Commons and Lords) sometimes refused when they judged the spending not in their interest, so the king was caught within the same system that benefited him at other times, making the definition of 'defense of the realm' a recurring point of argument and dissent.
“if they can demonstrate that it is in the interest of the realm, that they need this money in order to defend the realm... they can then take taxation... But if the representatives of the realm say, 'Hang on. We don’t agree.'... The king is therefore caught within the system that benefits him at other times.”
- Although the Hundred Years' War was almost entirely fought in France and might not look defensive to modern eyes, in terms of England's interests it claimed territory the English king regarded as rightfully his, produced booty and reward for fighting men, and had a defensive element in that war fought 'over there' was not fought 'over here'—so England's broad interpretation of defense of the realm was not as liberal as it might appear.
“This was a war that was almost entirely being fought in France. We might not see that as a defensive war, but in terms of England’s interests... it did have a defensive element in the sense that if the war’s being fought over there, it’s not being fought over here.”
- England had held continental territory since 1066, and after losing Normandy under King John in 1204 still retained the vast Duchy of Aquitaine (Gascony) in southwestern France acquired through Eleanor of Aquitaine; combined with set-piece victories under Edward III at Crécy (1346) and Poitiers (1356) and the capture of Calais, the idea that England could hold French territory or claim the whole kingdom of France was not implausible to contemporaries.
“thanks to King John’s mother,Eleanor of Aquitaine, the English crown had acquired a vast territory in southwestern France, the Duchy of Aquitaine, sometimes known as Gascony... The idea that England should hold territory in France... was not itself a bizarre one”
Richard II and Henry IV forced their subjects to confront what kingship meant and when it became tyranny, establishing destabilizing precedents about removing tyrants.
- Richard II and Henry IV are significant beyond their truncated reigns because they made their subjects confront what kingship was and when it shaded into tyranny: the working definition was that kingship is rule according to law in the interests of the people, so a tyrant rules by arbitrary will and not in the people's interest; the hard problem is what can be done about a tyrant, and whether defending the law and constitution may require going beyond them—which itself sets a destabilizing precedent.
“they make us confront... the question of what was kingship and where and when might it shade into tyranny... kingship was rule according to the law in the interests of the people... a tyrant was someone who ruled not according to the law but by his own arbitrary will... If you are trying to defend the law... you may well have to go beyond the law and beyond the Constitution in the effort to defend them.”
- The deposition of 1399 set two precedents at once: that a tyrannical king can be removed, but also that what is needed to remove him may push beyond current consensus about what the constitution actually is—both of which are destabilizing for the future.
“they make us confront... the question of what was kingship and where and when might it shade into tyranny... kingship was rule according to the law in the interests of the people... a tyrant was someone who ruled not according to the law but by his own arbitrary will... If you are trying to defend the law... you may well have to go beyond the law and beyond the Constitution in the effort to defend them.”
- The English constitution works by a sedimentary process of evolution: you try something, and if it takes, it gets built in—so the 1399 justifications became a precedent under active discussion by the 1640s among men standing up against Charles I.
“Those justifications in 1399 become a precedent in the sedimentary process of evolution of the English Constitution... This is, really, how the English Constitution works. You try something, and if it takes, then it gets built in.”
Henry IV went to elaborate lengths to justify deposing Richard, using historical precedent and abdication strategy rather than simple seizure of power.
- Henry IV's will was unusual and remarkable: unlike formal royal wills in French or Latin using the royal 'we,' his was in English and first-person singular, beginning 'I, Henry, sinful wretch...who has never been worthy to be man, but by God’s grace, and my life I have misspent,' suggesting he was racked by guilt about what he had done; he left no instructions for elaborate funeral or monument, and the alabaster tomb his widow commissioned depicts a man weighed down by his deeds despite having been a celebrated chivalric golden boy.
“Henry’s is in English, and it is written in the first-person singular. It begins, 'I, Henry, sinful wretch, King of England...who has never been worthy to be man, but by God’s grace, and my life I have misspent.' I think he was racked by guilt about what he had done.”
- Rather than simply seizing power, Henry IV went to enormous lengths to justify deposing Richard II: he convened a committee that searched every record for historical precedents to draw up 33 Articles of Deposition documenting Richard's perjury in breaking his coronation oath to uphold the law (citing claims that the law was 'in his own mouth' or 'breast' and that subjects' lives and property were his at will), made Richard abdicate as a both/and strategy to cover all bases, and then claimed the throne through a fudged series of assertions because he was not the straightforward legitimate male heir.
“He convened a committee, who went through every record they could find... to draw up 33 Articles of Deposition to show exactly what Richard had done and why he should be removed... They also made Richard abdicate. This was very much a both/and situation... he claims the throne through a complicated and slightly fudged series of assertions because he isn’t straightforwardly the legitimate male heir”
- England could plausibly have held far more of France had Henry V not died unexpectedly of dysentery in 1422 at age 35; the able men who succeeded him—especially his brother John, Duke of Bedford—lacked the authority to vary Henry V's maximalist terms (that he was king of France as well as England), and his infant son grew into a complete nonentity who also could not vary them, whereas a competent king might, like Edward III, have negotiated to keep much territory in return for dropping the claim to the French crown.
“If Henry V hadn’t died in 1422 very unexpectedly — he got dysentery on campaign; he died very young; he was only 35 — the course of the war thereafter could have been very different... did not have the authority to vary the terms that Henry V had agreed.”
Shakespeare dramatized Richard and Henry by making Richard articulate and insightful while aging Henry, shaping centuries of understanding their reigns.
- Shakespeare's sense of Richard and Henry as people derived largely from his historical sources—Raphael Holinshed's chronicle and Edmund Hall's chronicle—which themselves drew on medieval chronicles and parliamentary records; Shakespeare made Richard far more articulate and insightful than the real Richard appears in the record, while Henry got the short straw, being reduced from the commanding Bolingbroke of Richard II to a gray careworn figure aged to match Northumberland (though the real Hotspur was three years older than Henry IV) so that Hal and Hotspur could be the young rivals.
“he’s using Raphael Holinshed’s chronicle, and Holinshed’s chronicle does use those sources. Then he’s usingEdmund Hall’s chronicle... Shakespeare makes him much more articulate and insightful than I can see the real Richard being in the historical record... Shakespeare’s played with the generations. He’s made Henry IV the same age as the Earl of Northumberland”
- The medium is key in adaptation: if it's television do what works on television, if it's film do what works on film, and do what can uniquely be done in that medium—that is where new insight comes—so one should not be afraid to grab a text by the scruff of the neck and make it something new, as Orson Welles's unfaithful Chimes at Midnight made Shakespeare work visually.
“If it’s television, do what works on television. If it’s film, do what works on film, and do what can uniquely be done in that medium. That’s where new insight comes. And don’t be afraid to grab a text by the scruff of the neck and make it something new.”
- Castor discovered why Shakespeare did what he did because once Richard—the melodramatic figure—is gone, it is very difficult to keep momentum and narrative arc going; Henry IV's reign becomes a series of challenges, revolts, and difficulties as his health collapses, making the story tend toward a 'dying fall' that requires great effort to keep the narrative alive.
“it’s very difficult to keep the momentum and the arc of the story going once Richard has gone... Henry’s reign becomes this series of challenges and revolts and difficulties, and his health collapses. It’s very hard to avoid the story becoming a dying fall.”
Late medieval English vernacular literature emerged from Norman French elites bedding in and cultural conflict with France making English a flexible language.
- Before Gutenberg, any text had to be copied by hand on parchment with quill pens, and writing was a difficult professional skill that far fewer people possessed than could read, so copying a long manuscript like Canterbury Tales was an elite form of production for an elite consumer and would have been expensive.
“Copies of any text have to be copied by hand. Writing is a professional skill. Lots more people can read than can write... it’s an elite form of production for an elite consumer.”
- A Chaucer became possible in the late 14th century because English developed into a language used flexibly across all classes from bottom to top; after the Conquest a Norman French-speaking elite ruled an English-speaking country with French and Latin as languages of government, but as the elite bedded in—aided by the war with France drawing cultural battle lines and causing the French spoken in England to 'go native'—English grew enough to feed a vernacular literature, giving genius poets like Chaucer, Gower, and Langland the opportunity to write in their own language.
“the development of English as a language spoken across all classes of society really flexibly... French has gone native, but at the same time, English has grown and developed into a language that is used throughout society from the bottom right to the top. That then gives the opportunity for that vernacular to feed into the growth of literature”
Social and economic upheaval from the Black Death created mobility and tension the political classes resisted while sustaining expensive military campaigns.
- The Black Death, which arrived in England in 1348 and killed perhaps a third to a half of the population, squeezed elite incomes and living standards because the cheap labor they had always depended on became scarce, while suddenly expanding opportunity for social mobility among the lower orders—a development the political classes desperately tried to keep a lid on; notably, the war machine in the 1340s and 1350s carried on regardless, so these huge social and economic changes took time to work through politically even though the personal trauma was immediate.
“elite incomes and standards of living are being squeezed because the cheap labor on which they’ve always depended is no longer there in abundance. Meanwhile, theopportunity for social mobilityis suddenly vastly expanded because labor is in suddenly short supply”