What this covers
Fuchsia Dunlop returns to Tyler Cowen's table for a meal and conversation that moves fluidly between the plate and the broader forces that shape what ends up on it. The discussion treats Chinese cuisine not as a fixed tradition to be preserved but as a living economic and cultural system. Dunlop argues that Chinese food has always followed the money—clustering in prosperous trade centers from Song-dynasty Kaifeng to modern Shanghai—and that the notion of culinary authenticity misses how regional cuisines constantly mix and recreate themselves. She traces how etymology itself records trade history: pepper became hújiāo ("barbarian pepper"), tomato fānqié ("barbarian eggplant"), marking routes and eras of arrival. The conversation includes practical instruction on building a balanced meal, on why steaming rather than stir-frying deserves recognition as the classical Chinese cooking method, and on how Dao Gong knife skills function like grammar in cuisine as a language.
Dunlop challenges Western frameworks for evaluating Chinese food, arguing that Michelin's single-inspector model cannot properly judge a cuisine meant to be eaten family-style with shared dishes offering contrasting flavors and textures. She explores how ma la numbing-spice spread globally through immigration patterns and market intensity, why hot pot proliferated despite showcasing only a narrow slice of Chinese cooking, and how the rise of regional cookbooks reflects a sea change in Western appetite for detailed cultural food writing. She also addresses how deprivation during the Great Famine shaped contemporary Chinese dining's abundance, how London restaurants once hid their best dishes behind separate menus, and how contemporary arrivals and air-freighted ingredients have transformed Chinese food abroad from an isolated immigrant cuisine into a fluid exchange.
Dunlop argues that Chinese cuisine is a living, economically-driven culture—shaped by trade, migration, deprivation, and competition—so debates about 'authenticity' miss the point, and Western arbiters like Michelin are structurally unable to judge it because they ignore how Chinese food is meant to be eaten communally.
- Chinese cuisine has always 'followed the money,' with great food clustering where wealth and trade concentrated
- Michelin's single-inspector model fails because Chinese meals require variety eaten family-style
- Cuisine is recreated daily and constantly mixing, making rigid notions of authenticity misguided
Chinese culinary technique rests on mastering fundamental building blocks like knife skills and cooking methods that combine to create countless dishes.
- In Chinese culinary education, particularly in Sichuan, learning the building blocks of a cuisine is like learning the grammar of a language—basic components, processes, and flavors combined to make many dishes—and knife skills (Dao Gong) are absolutely fundamental, with almost all sophisticated cutting done with a single light, versatile cleaver rather than specialized knives.
“when you go to cooking school, you are learning the building blocks of a cuisine, which is like the grammar of a language. So the basic components, the basic processes and flavors, which you then put together to make a multitude of dishes.”
- People wrongly think of stir-fry as the quintessential Chinese cooking method, but it is just one of many; steaming has been practiced in China since the Neolithic Age and can be considered the classic Chinese method, and an entire exquisite restaurant meal (as at Yu Zhi Lan) can be made with essentially no wok at all, drawing on steamed dishes, braises, soups, and cold dressed dishes.
“when people think about Chinese cuisine, they often think about stir-fry astheChinese method par excellence. But it’s one of many different cooking methods, and certainly steaming has been done in China since the Neolithic Age.”
- A Cantonese-style steamed fish is one of the easiest dishes to make yet wins disproportionate praise: marinate a really fresh fish with a bit of Shaoxing wine, ginger, and scallion, steam it, strew with slivered ginger and scallion, sizzle hot oil over it, and baste with a little soy sauce—it is sublime and offers a nice contrast to hotter Sichuanese dishes.
“a steamed fish, Cantonese style. It’ssoeasy to make, and I almost feel embarrassed that it wins so much praise...you just marinate it, a bit of Shaoxing wine, ginger, and scallion, steam it, strew over some slivered ginger and scallion, sizzle over some hot oil, and then baste it in a little soy sauce. And that’sit.”
Chinese cuisine has always concentrated where wealth and power centered, from imperial capitals to treaty ports to overseas diaspora communities.
- The great Chinese cuisines have always followed the money: a flourishing restaurant scene existed in the Song capital Kaifeng; when the dynasty fled south the court made Hangzhou a culinary and cultural center; the Jiangnan salt trade made Yangzhou's rich salt merchants the hosts of lavish dinners; later treaty ports like Shanghai and Ningbo developed early fusion cuisines; and during the Cultural Revolution, Taiwan and Hong Kong became custodians of traditional gastronomy where the elite money had fled.
“it’s very conspicuous that the great Chinese cuisines have always followed the money.”
- The big difference with Chinese food in the West today is that you no longer have an isolated community of mainly Cantonese cooks catering to Western tastes with limited access to local ingredients; instead there is a fluid interaction between food in China and Chinese communities abroad, with many customers being recent Chinese arrivals who want authentic home-style food, supported by fresh Chinese produce now grown locally or air-freighted in.
“You now have a fluid interaction between food in China and food in Chinese communities abroad. And many of thecustomers, as you’ve said here, are actually Chinese, and they’re recent arrivals or temporary residents in the States, and they don’t want to eat Americanized Chinese food.”
- Chinese restaurants in London historically maintained separate menus—an English-language menu for English speakers and a 'secret' Chinese menu with the really good and interesting funkier dishes Chinese people wanted—but this has changed completely, as adventurous foodies now want to try new dishes and restaurants no longer need to cater to different audiences; today non-Chinese customers may even be more open to new dishes than Chinese regulars.
“they had the English-language menu intended for English speakers, and they would have secret Chinese menus with all the really good and interesting dishes that the Chinese people wanted to eat.”
Chinese food is poorly served by Western evaluation systems and formats that ignore its social, family-style nature and temperature demands.
- Chinese food is poorly represented by international arbiters of taste like the Michelin Guide because their evaluation system relies on a single inspector sampling alone, whereas Chinese food should be eaten family-style with a group sharing a wide variety of dishes—making proper assessment by one diner very difficult.
“Chinese food is very poorly represented by the international arbiters of taste, for example, theMichelin Guide. Their system is based on one inspector going out on their own and sampling what a restaurant has to offer. For most Chinese restaurants, that’s very, very difficult because the way youshouldeat is with a group”
- Chinese food is generally not well suited to the tasting-menu format because most of it—especially stir-fries—must be consumed extremely hot at its peak temperature; some chefs nonetheless adopt tasting menus partly to gain international recognition and to present each dish beautifully on its own plate rather than on shared dishes mussed up as they pass around the table.
“generally, Chinese food is not the best for a tasting menu because everything needs to be consumed super, super hot.”
- When hosting a Chinese meal at home, one should avoid an all-last-minute-stir-fry menu and instead build by contrast: several easy-in-advance cold dishes, a slow-cooked stew like red-braised pork, a strong dish like mapo tofu balanced by a lightly stir-fried vegetable, and an easy steamed fish—deliberately balancing dry versus soupy dishes, different mouthfeels, shapes, and cuts so the dishes taste good in sequence and relation to one another.
“I would not choose a menu that’s all last-minute stir-fried dishes...So I would always do a spread of cold dishes...I would also do a slow-cooked stew...That’s a strong dish, so I would also always have a lightly stir-fried vegetable.”
Chinese cuisine offers distinctive solutions to vegetarian, soup, spice varieties, dessert, and ingredient etymology that differ fundamentally from Western approaches.
- Soup is more necessary to Chinese cuisine than to Western cuisine, with almost every Chinese meal including some sort of soup even if rudimentary—such as the leftover water from parboiling rice (Mi Tang) or pumpkin boiled in water as a palate cleanser—and when cooking for Chinese friends one puts great effort into a beautiful broth because it will be deeply appreciated.
“soup is so important in Chinese meals. Almost every Chinese meal will have some sort of soup, even if it’s really rudimentary.”
- Many Chinese ingredient names encode the era and place from which they were imported: pepper is hújiāo ('barbarian pepper') because it came from the northwest where the hú lived; ingredients arriving by sea in the Ming and early Qing carry fān (another word for barbarian), so tomato is fānqié ('barbarian eggplant') and an early name for chili was fānjiāo, still called hǎijiāo ('sea pepper') in Sichuan—revealing trade history through etymology.
“pepper in Chinese is calledhújiāo, barbarian pepper, because it was an imported pepper from the northwest where thehú, barbarians, lived.”
- Chinese meals do not normally have a separate dessert course; instead they finish with fruit (cut seasonal fruit such as tangerines in winter or lychee in season), and Dunlop argues that if Western guests want a sugar hit it need not be Chinese—it is fine to serve a chocolate cake—since for a long time fine-dining Chinese restaurants in the US defaulted to chocolate mousse cake or crème brûlée.
“In China, you don’t normally have a separate dessert course. You normally have fruit, so either cut fruit”
- Chinese cuisine offers excellent meatless solutions because the Chinese are brilliant at using fermented foods—soy sauce, black beans, Sichuan chili bean paste, fermented tofu—that provide meaty, cheesy, or creamy umami flavors and mouthfeels, making vegetable dishes satisfying to meat-eaters and vegetarians alike.
“the Chinese are brilliant at using fermented foods like soy sauce, black beans, Sichuan chili bean paste, and fermented tofu, all of which have almost meaty or cheesy or creamy umami flavors, to cook with vegetables.”
- There are many varieties of Sichuan pepper; the classic red pepper varies by region and is thought to express its terroir like wine grapes, with boutique producers now labeling place of origin, while green Sichuan pepper—a formerly wild variety licensed as food in the late 1990s—offers a zesty, lime-like flavor particularly good with fish and light soupy dishes.
“The classic red Sichuan pepper — there are actually different varieties from different parts of China, and it’s thought to express its terroir, like wine grapes.”
- The Chinese approach to vegetarian eating differs fundamentally from the Western one: Chinese distinguish Su Shi (vegetarian food eaten occasionally, e.g. at temples or on holy days) from Su Shi Zhu Yi (committed vegetarianism), so vegetarian travelers often receive food containing meat, lard, or stock; pure vegetarian and vegan food is traditionally found only in Buddhist and Taoist monasteries, which developed elaborate Fang Hun Cai imitation-meat dishes centuries before modern meat substitutes.
“in China, people often make a distinction between ChineseSu Shi素食, vegetarian eating, vegetarian food, andSu Shi Zhu Yi素食主义, vegetarianism.”
- Lao Gan Ma, a chili sauce from Guizhou province invented by a woman of that name, became mass-produced and long-popular in China and is now gaining addicted Western fans, to the point that Sichuan Airlines stewards offer to spoon it onto passengers' in-flight food for extra heat.
“it’s from Guizhou province, another spice-eating province in southwest China. It was invented by a woman,Lao Gan Ma, and it’s now...There’s mass production”
- Becoming a famous cookbook writer carries a social cost: after Dunlop's first book, friends became scared to cook for her, and she herself experienced a total cooking paralysis at home for a long time, fearing she would only disappoint guests who expected professional-level results—a dynamic she eventually overcame by ceasing to care.
“after my first book was published, I had a total cooking paralysis at home for ages. I was too scared to cook for people because I thought everyone was going to be thinking, “Oh, she’s a professional cookbook writer. It’s got to be really good.””
- The food writing world has changed dramatically: in the late 1990s all six publishers rejected Dunlop's first regional Sichuan cookbook as too niche and narrow, but there is now a huge appetite for detailed cultural information about food and a hunger for specialized, local, regional cookbooks, alongside an explosion of food writing across books, the internet, and indie magazines.
“When I sent a proposal for my first Sichuan cookbook in the late ’90s, it was rejected by all six publishers. They all said that, well, British readers would not be interested in a regional Chinese cookbook because it was too niche and too narrow.”
- China has rapidly mastered Western patisserie and coffee culture in just five to ten years—producing world-class croissants in cities like Chengdu and Xi'an made by Paris-trained chefs—paralleling how Japan cracked patisserie, while coffee culture (Starbucks, the imitator Luckin Coffee, and small specialty cafés) has spread astonishingly fast across a traditionally tea-drinking nation.
“The thing that’s really remarkable about that is the speed, because it’s happened in five years, ten years?...It’s just like lightning. Suddenly they’ve cracked patisserie, in the way that the Japanese have.”
Certain Chinese ingredients and flavors spread globally through immigration patterns and market dominance rather than culinary merit alone.
- The proliferation of hot pot in China is partly driven by economics: it is cheap and easy for consumers but also cheap and easy for restaurateurs because it requires no skilled chefs—just one master broth and people to slice ingredients—allowing operators to make a lot of money, but it showcases only a narrow aspect of Chinese cuisine.
“the spread of hot pot is partly because it’s very cheap and easy for consumers, but also it’s very cheap and easy for restaurateurs because you don’t need skilled chefs. You need one master broth, and you need people to slice up a whole load of ingredients, and then you can make a lot of money.”
- Sichuan cuisine has grown slowly in Southeast Asia—rarely seen in Thailand or Singapore—because Chinese immigration to those regions was dominated by Teochew, Cantonese, Hakka, and Fujian people with completely different flavor profiles, and because local Thai cuisines already provide their own spicy food, whereas Sichuan food is more available in Hong Kong and the rest of China.
“in Thailand, for some reason you just don’t find a whole lot of Sichuan restaurants, and the same thing in Singapore.”
- The spread of ma la (numbing-spicy) flavor is governed first by immigration patterns—Sichuan being an inland province that historically did not send people out en masse—but its rapid current spread is because ma la is an intensely stimulating flavor bomb that holds its own in a crowded marketplace and can be applied to anything, whereas more delicate cuisines like Jiangnan's speak quietly and get drowned out.
“it’s just concerned with patterns of immigration. So themataste, the tingly taste...thatmaflavor is very particular to Sichuan. Sichuan is an inland province and did not send people out into the world en masse until comparatively recently.”
Historical deprivation and suppression profoundly shaped Chinese food culture and its recovery after political trauma.
- The experience of acute deprivation during the Great Famine deeply shaped Chinese food culture: people fantasized about pork and wiped fatty pork around the wok to reuse it; the resulting excess of contemporary Chinese dining—tables laden with dishes—is a reaction to that deprivation, which the Chinese government is now trying to curb with anti-waste campaigns.
“people who lived through those years told me that they used to dream and fantasize about pork because they never had it. Some people used to, for example, have a small piece of fatty pork and use it to wipe around the wok”
- It is extraordinary that refined Chinese cuisine recovered after the Cultural Revolution, which was an assault on bourgeois and elite culture during which fancy food and elegant restaurants were attacked and forced to become more proletarian; one elderly chef said the movement's effect on permitted dishes was the least of their problems, the main problem being that there simply wasn't enough of everything.
“the Cultural Revolution, which was an assault on bourgeois and elite culture, when fancy food and elegant restaurants were attacked and forced to change their ways and become more proletarian”
Authenticity in cuisine is a mistake; living cuisines constantly evolve and adapt while remaining rooted in regional identity.
- A cuisine is always a living form of culture recreated on a daily basis rather than something static, so getting hung up on notions of authenticity is a mistake; this is especially clear in places like Sichuan with feverish restaurant competition where many restaurants constantly chase new ideas and concepts.
“a cuisine is always a living form of culture that’s recreated on a daily basis. It’s just not something static, and that’s where you trip up when you start getting hung up about notions of authenticity.”
- The current extraordinary mixing of regional Chinese cuisines is not entirely new; a 1908 guide to Chengdu, the Chengdu Tong Lan, already lists cosmopolitan dishes from the Jiangnan region and even Western dishes like pork chops and curry brought by foreign missionaries, while the 20th century saw China close in on itself before the current period of flowering accelerated by transport links.
“going back to the guide to Chengdu written in 1908, called theChengdu Tong Lan(成都通览). This has a list of restaurants and dishes and snacks, and you can see from that period that it was already quite cosmopolitan”