What this covers

Tyler Cowen talks with novelist Emily St. John Mandel about how fiction operates on readers and what it reveals about how we navigate crisis. Mandel discusses the architecture of her novels—particularly Station Eleven and The Glass Hotel—and explores how narrative functions psychologically during times of uncertainty. The conversation ranges across the craft of writing, the psychology of reading, and the sociology of moral compromise, grounded in specific examples from her work and the real world.

Mandel argues that fiction's power lies in exploring Inversion, the permeability of moral boundaries, and the texture of ordinary modern life. Station Eleven was conceived as a valentine to civilization itself, illuminating what we take for granted—electricity, antibiotics, plane travel—by imagining their absence. The Glass Hotel examines how ordinary people, without being monsters, slide into participating in something terrible like a Ponzi scheme, a phenomenon she connects to Bernie Madoff's puzzling refusal to flee. On why readers turn to narrative during actual crises, she contends that people seek the comfort of knowing how things end, not to be wounded by uncertainty. She contests Franz Kafka's dictum that books should wound us, arguing readers benefit from escapism in crisis, though writers arguably should push to the edge of their talent. The conversation also takes up screenwriting as a distinct skill from novel-writing, the influence of television on contemporary fiction's fragmented form, how luck underlies "earned" success, and the cognitive freedom that comes from not constantly calculating purchases. Mandel reflects on her own Canadian literary standing relative to her American reception, and on how accumulated new experiences make subjective time expand while routine compresses it.

Sharpest takeaway

Mandel argues that fiction works by exploring contingency, the permeability of moral boundaries, and the value of the ordinary modern world, and that in times of crisis people turn to narrative for the comfort of knowing how it ends rather than to be wounded by it.

  • Station Eleven was conceived as a 'valentine to the modern world' that illuminates civilization by depicting its absence
  • The Glass Hotel explores how ordinary, non-monstrous people can slide into participating in fraud
  • People read or watch pandemic narratives during a real pandemic for the soothing certainty of resolution, not to be stabbed in the heart

The argument · threads7 threads · 25 claims
0.73

Narrative provides resolution and soothing comfort that real life withholds, especially during crises of uncertainty.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • In times of uncertainty there is a strong longing to see how things end, which is why people are drawn to pandemic narratives like Station Eleven or Contagion during a real pandemic — narrative is soothing precisely because it offers the resolution that real life withholds.

    “there’s just such a longing in times of uncertainty to see how it ends. We just don’t know what the world will look like in three weeks, so there’s something soothing about narrative in these moments.”

  • Kafka's claim that we should only read books that wound or stab us is wrong for readers, who benefit from transporting escapism especially in a crisis, but may be right when flipped onto writers, who arguably should not write books that fail to knock them over and push them to the furthest edge of their talent.

    “I’m going to disagree with Kafka on this one. Why does reading have to be something that stabs you in the heart every time you pick up a book?”

  • Chaotic times produce a longing for familiarity, which explains rising sales of long classic fiction in the UK and is mirrored in a child repeatedly choosing the same movie after losing school and normal routines.

    “There’s this longing for familiarity in really chaotic times. I think that’s what that’s about.”

0.71

Contingency and chance govern outcomes far more than effort, from book sales to class mobility to faking death.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • There is an incredible level of luck even in 'earned money' — a successful book is like winning a lottery ticket among many equally good books that didn't sell, and upper-middle-class kids who 'earn' their way through SAT tutoring, good colleges, and well-paying jobs also held lottery tickets, so earning money may not feel very different from inheriting it.

    “There’s just an incredible level of luck, even in “earned money.” Yeah, it did always feel like a lottery ticket to me.”

  • Station Eleven was conceived to set a novel in a post-technological world in order to illuminate and celebrate the modern world by contemplating its absence — like describing a person through a eulogy — so it functions as a love letter to electricity, plane travel, antibiotics, insulin, and the trappings of civilization we take for granted.

    “I wanted to set a novel in a post-technological world because I thought it might be interesting to think about and write about the modern world by contemplating its absence in the same way that you can talk about a person by delivering a eulogy.”

  • In a normal world faking one's own death is hard because we live in an era requiring a body to be convincing, but a spectacular catastrophe like 9/11 can provide a rare opportunity to disappear without one.

    “I feel like we live in an era where you need a body for that to be convincing.”

  • Contingency — the what-if of how everything would differ had you gone right instead of left at an intersection — is the fundamental, recurring theme of Mandel's novels, which she structures as parallel universes where the same characters recur across different realities.

    “I’m fascinated in the what-if. You went right instead of left in the intersection. How would everything be different if you’d made that choice?”

  • Mandel has a markedly better literary career in the US than in Canada — shortlisted for major American awards but never even longlisted for Canada's three big awards — possibly reflecting a sense that she is not seen as 'Canadian enough' a writer.

    “I’ve been short-listed for major American awards, but there are three big awards in Canada every year, and I never even made the long list.”

0.65

High-quality television now rivals the novel as narrative medium and influences literary form toward fragmentation and visuals.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The quality of television is now so high that one can experience an equally complex, deep, and artistic narrative through a screen as on the page, making TV (and 'going to sleep') the novel's chief competitor rather than an inferior medium.

    “The quality of TV is so high now that there’s a great argument to be made that you’re experiencing an equally complex and deep and artistic narrative through the medium of your laptop as you are on the page.”

  • Screenwriting is a fundamentally different skill from novel writing because every scene must drive the plot forward in a way novels do not require, which explains why film adaptations diverge so much from their source material.

    “In screenwriting, every scene has to drive the plot forward in a way that it just doesn’t really have to in novels.”

  • Novels in recent years have become more fragmented — with very short chapters, strong visuals, and a more staccato rhythm — which is a clear influence from the high-quality television of recent years rather than necessarily a sign of shortened attention spans.

    “I see novels being much more fragmented... where you have really short chapters, really strong visuals, where you read the little fragment of text and you feel like you can see it.”

  • Choosing a book purely by its cover would match badly to one's tastes because art departments produce gorgeous covers for many mediocre books; a striking or simple cover that grabs attention can be a better signal than a merely beautiful one designed to appeal to many people.

    “There are a lot of seriously mediocre books with gorgeous covers because there’s a lot of talent in the art departments.”

0.53

Moral character is permeable; ordinary people drift into complicity through gradual compromise rather than inherent corruption.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Bernie Madoff said it never occurred to him to flee even as his Ponzi scheme collapsed, which is baffling given how easy escape would have been, possibly reflecting a subconscious desire to be caught, the bias of routine, or a self-image of invulnerability among white-collar criminals who have always gotten away with it.

    “What Madoff says is that it never occurred to him to flee, which I find absolutely baffling.”

  • Most people are corruptible and you do not have to be an entirely horrible person to find yourself participating in something terrible like a Ponzi scheme; the interesting subject of The Glass Hotel is this permeability of our moral borders and the gradual moral slide of otherwise ordinary people.

    “It seems to me that, probably, most of us are corruptible and that you probably don’t have to be an entirely horrible person to find yourself participating in a Ponzi scheme, even though that is a horrible thing to do.”

0.52

Writers benefit from rigorous discipline and apprenticeship; readers should freely abandon unrewarding work without guilt.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Readers should put down and abandon books they don't enjoy rather than following rigid rules about finishing every book, because life is short and time spent reading uninteresting work is wasted.

    “Life is pretty short. I don’t want to spend a lot of time reading work that doesn’t interest me. Yeah, that is underrated. You should put down a book if you don’t like it.”

  • A 'first novel' that is actually a writer's fourth or fifth manuscript, with earlier ones consigned to a drawer, should be seen not as wasted years but as a valuable apprenticeship through which one learns to write a novel.

    “that was how you were learning how to write a novel, so I would see that as a valuable experience.”

  • A background in contemporary dance instills extreme discipline that transfers to any career, and because dance is a much harder, more dehumanizing profession than writing, everything afterward feels easier by contrast.

    “dance requires the most incredible discipline, and I think that that’s helpful for writing. Actually, it would be helpful for anything.”

  • Infinite Jest is overrated — it is a profound exploration of boredom that nonetheless reads as a boring book — while David Foster Wallace's unfinished The Pale King is underrated, a chaotic but rewarding work in fragments.

    “I just found Infinite Jest to be really overrated. That being said, I loved The Pale King, even though he never finished that novel.”

0.46

Subjective experience of time, money, and access shape consciousness and quality of life in measurable ways.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The way to make subjective time slow down is to accumulate many new experiences, travel, and meet new people, which makes each day feel longer; the inverse strategy — making every day as similar as possible — speeds time up, as prisoners deliberately do.

    “My feeling is that the way to slow down time is to have a lot of experiences, to see different places, to meet new people. That makes every day feel longer.”

  • Growing up without money forces the brain to run endless tedious calculations all day about every small purchase, and not having to run that constant calculation feels like freedom, making 'not having to think about money' a huge happiness benefit.

    “so much of your brain is taken over through all of every day with these endless tedious calculations. If I buy a metro card this week, can I afford groceries?”

  • A civilization understood only through an airport-as-museum would acquire the bias that everybody flew regularly, when in fact only a fairly small percentage of the population flies regularly.

    “I think you would just assume that everybody flew... I think it’s actually a fairly small percentage of the population that flies regularly.”

0.38

Population size and scale determine available variation, weirdness, and capacity for pandemic response.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • In an intermediate pandemic the dangerous variable is not population density but the amount of medical equipment available; New York's problem with COVID-19 is not that there are too many people but that there aren't enough ventilators.

    “The problem in New York with COVID-19 — it’s not that there are too many of us. It’s that there aren’t enough ventilators. I see it as more an equipment problem than a population density issue.”

  • Canada lacks a 'Florida man' equivalent and is less weird than the United States because weirdness emerges from a large population base, and with roughly ten Americans for every Canadian there is a smaller pool to draw extremes from.

    “you get weirdness in a big population that you just don’t see where there’s a smaller pool to draw from. Yeah, there really is no Canadian Florida.”

  • Despite researching pandemics for Station Eleven, the most surprising real-world feature was the atmosphere of anticipatory dread — a long period where everyone intellectually knew the pandemic was coming yet it didn't feel real, so people failed to prepare.

    “something I never really thought about was the dread of waiting for a pandemic to arrive.”

  • Congregating in large groups during the pandemic is not just reckless but unethical, because if you end up needing a ventilator due to reckless mingling, that is a ventilator someone else will not get.

    “if you need a ventilator because you recklessly mingled with a crowd of people, that’s a ventilator that somebody else won’t get. It’s reckless and crazy.”