What this covers

Elisa New opens by dismantling the idea that poetry requires special training or credentials. The conversation moves across what makes poems endure, how readers should approach them, and why poetry matters differently from other forms of knowledge. New argues that the greatest poets stay alive in culture because literary knowledge is Cumulative vs Superseded Knowledge—unlike scientific progress, where newer work displaces the old, Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman are never surpassed, only continually rediscovered. She traces how Whitman emerged from the roiling democracy of nineteenth-century Brooklyn, and how Dickinson and Whitman established the two foundational lineages of American poetry that poets still acknowledge as ancestors.

The conversation ranges across American literary history and the conditions that sustain it. New revisits Robert Frost as a radical thinker rather than a platitude-dispenser, redefines Puritanism as a psychologically intense rather than repressed tradition, and reads Herman Melville's poetry as genuinely great rather than secondary to his novels. She addresses how poetry was historically performed aloud and sung—suggesting that song lyrics belong within poetry's pageantry—and why the silent, solitary page-reader became the modern norm only a century ago. On the economics of poetry, she notes the arts have never sustained a healthy middle market; poets survive by teaching, which she frames as culturally valuable work. Finally, she argues that applying machine learning to poetry is largely futile, since poetry's meaning lies in serving distinctly human intelligence rather than algorithmic pattern-matching.

Sharpest takeaway

New argues that poetry is an accessible, deeply human pleasure rather than an elite specialty, and that the greatest poets endure because literary knowledge is cumulative and reflects enduring human experience back to us; reading poetry well requires casual engagement and wisdom-seeking, not technical credentials.

  • Anyone can have a blast reading a poem with the right framing and casual approach
  • Literary canons are cumulative so early poets are never superseded the way scientific knowledge is
  • Poetry's value lies in serving human intelligence, making it a dead end for AI

The argument · threads8 threads · 33 claims
0.80

Reading poetry is an accessible, pleasurable cerebral activity that requires no special knowledge or equipment.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • New's distinctive contribution is a belief that any person can have a blast reading a poem because human language is intrinsically fascinating to humans, and she persuades others that the developing understanding gained over fifteen or twenty lines is a cerebral kind of fun comparable to a crossword puzzle.

    “I think I bring a belief in the capacity of any person sitting across from me to have a blast reading a poem.”

  • Rather than memorizing whole poems, it is more rewarding to memorize two to four lines and walk around with that fragment as a 'talisman'—like Frost's 'Nature's first green is gold'—ready to extend and salute the world when the moment fits, which is a deeply pleasurable practice.

    “I like memorizing two to four lines of a poem and just walking around with that little fragment. I have talismanic poems”

  • Parents seduce children into poetry not by coercion but by reading aloud to them until told to stop and by visibly caring about it themselves, because children pay attention to what adults do and care about—if we read, they read; if we read to them, they'll read to their children—and children love poetry, including poems they can't understand, for the puzzle in it.

    “I think children, whether they acknowledge it or not, when they're young, they really do pay attention to what we do and what we care about. If we read, they read.”

  • A smart beginner should buy any poetry anthology and open it at random rather than starting at the beginning, reread anything that grabs them, and physically print a single appealing poem to carry in a back pocket and read casually while waiting in line—treating the poem casually, as Whitman recommended ('Loafe with me on the grass'), so it can nudge up against one's life.

    “Buy any poetry anthology, and don't try to start at the beginning and work your way through. Just open it up and see if something grabs you.”

  • Academics in the humanities ought to get out into the world; New herself stepped out by adopting a televised format with the constraint of 24-minute segments to speak with doctors, lawyers, postal workers, and delivery people, learning that one needs no special equipment or technical knowledge to read even a difficult poem with deep understanding.

    “I have said, 'We who have lived in the academy ought to get out a bit.'”

0.75

Great poets achieve enduring power by capturing universal human experience with language that resonates across centuries.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Unlike scientific or economic knowledge—where we don't consult Adam Smith to understand Bitcoin because that knowledge is superseded—literary knowledge is cumulative: the earliest great poets are never superseded, we continue to learn from predecessors, and we feel awe at how they recognized enduringly human phenomena, which is why the best poets so often appear at the beginnings of eras.

    “those who are there first, they're never superseded — unlike, say, for economists who would say, 'Adam Smith is a really smart guy, but it's not like we go to Adam Smith to understand Bitcoin.'”

  • What we love most about the greatest poets, as Emerson said, is that they echo back our own thoughts with 'alienated majesty'—it is the most familiar things they say that move us most.

    “as Emerson says, they echo back our own thoughts with 'alienated majesty.'”

  • Dickinson and Whitman invented the two fundamental modes of American poetry that subsequent poets acknowledge as ancestors: Whitman's lineage runs through Hart Crane, Ginsberg, Sandburg, O'Hara and others, while Dickinson's runs through Susan Howe, Marianne Moore, Bishop, and Plath, such that these later poets would not exist without them.

    “They invent two ways of being a poet, and two of the ways that so many poets who have followed them also acknowledge.”

  • Dickinson is fundamentally a poet of trauma—a sensibility without boundaries, filters, or protections who tunes up sensory experience so high that ordinary stimuli like robins or daffodils 'mangle' her, producing 'brain poems' that take the reader to a place of unbearable imagery and thoughts crashing into thoughts.

    “she's a poet who will say that the sound of the robins or the look of the daffodils mangles her, that she's sometimes without boundaries, without filters, without protections”

0.71

Dickinson's dashes and technical choices create openness and intensity that capture unbearable internal experience.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Martha Nell Smith argues that because Dickinson never published except in handmade 'fascicle' manuscripts, those manuscripts should be read as visual texts—almost works of visual art—where the calligraphy and page layout matter like choreography, which leads her to scorch critics who rely on standardized punctuation added by later editors.

    “Martha Nell Smith is one of those critics who says that we should think of these manuscripts as visual texts, as almost texts in the visual arts.”

  • Dickinson's dashes are interpretively open: they can give the poetry a spasmodic gait, evoke stitches of pain or effort, foreground the act of composition, recall the thread she used to sew her booklets, or function like accent marks and musical notation, and New deliberately remains agnostic about pinning them to one fixed meaning.

    “Sometimes they give the poetry an appropriately spasmodic gait. Sometimes they feel like stitches of pain or of effort. They remind us that the poem is being written, is being composed.”

  • Dickinson's 'I felt a Funeral in my Brain' exemplifies her brain poems that depict unbearable internal experience.

    “she tunes up sensory experience so, so high that 'I felt a Funeral in my Brain,' she says.”

  • Each Dickinson poem constitutes an existential 'leap' in the Kierkegaardian sense—an experience that has never happened before in quite that way, where everything is at risk in every second, and the dashes act as brackets insisting on 'this word, and no other.'

    “The poem is an experience that has never happened before in quite this way, and there is a leap, as Kierkegaard would have said, that every single Dickinson poem somehow constitutes.”

  • Helen Vendler, as the longest-lasting New Critic, stresses the exquisite craft of individual Dickinson poems and her extraordinary metaphors—such as light that feels like the weight of cathedral music—where synesthetic comparison is more adequate to how great language feels 'where the meanings are' than literal description could be.

    “The exquisite craft of the individual poems. The extraordinary metaphors that just pay off and pay off and pay off.”

  • Dickinson was likely a lifelong virgin who lived in her head, and since much of the erotic life is mental regardless of whom one touches, reading her poems too literally for homoeroticism actually subtracts from rather than adds to understanding them.

    “I am of those who think Emily Dickinson was a lifelong virgin who lived in her head. Much of the erotic life is in our heads, no matter who we touch.”

0.66

Poetry matters because it models how to navigate contradictions, pain, and compromises inherent in human living.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The notion of poets doing harm to poetry (as T.S. Eliot claimed of Milton) is too fastidious—poetry survived Milton just fine—so the more productive question is what poetry can do for the world and why we need it, namely as a way of thinking about the wrenching complexities and compromises we make every day.

    “I think T. S. Eliot was too fastidious about such matters. Poetry survived John Milton just fine.”

  • Robert Frost is not a doddering platitude-mumbler but a radical poet who repeatedly shows how much joy is mixed with pain, how work is charged with integrated or repressed eroticism, and how hard lifelong partnership is—his husbands and wives mismatched and maladapted—inheriting the Puritan tradition of acknowledging pain despite being born in California.

    “he's not a doddering old fart mumbling platitudes. He's a radical.”

  • The Scarlet Letter is well known but poorly read, and it remains deeply relevant in the #MeToo era because it exposes a recurring social dynamic in which we both revere those who may not deserve reverence and hunger to topple and pull down the mighty whenever they become available.

    “I think The Scarlet Letter is as relevant today in the #MeToo era, and has been for decades informative and enlightening for me as I've watched a social hunger for the toppling of the mighty”

  • It is unsurprising that few people excel at both poetry and the novel because they call on different skill sets: lyric poetry requires distillation and asocial concentration, while the novel requires a crowded, cacophonous, socially alert set of faculties—and events like the death of a spouse (Hardy) or war (Melville's 'Battle Pieces') can deliver a writer into the lyric loneliness that produces great poetry.

    “The sort of distillation and often asocial concentration that it takes to be a lyric poet is quite different from the crowded, cacophonous, socially alert set of faculties one needs to write a great novel.”

  • Gwendolyn Brooks embodies a mature knowledge of how communities and individuals muddle along—some bound for jail, others caring for each other and eking out happiness eating beans—and her achievement is making readers care about people in straitened social circumstances to whom undeserved things happen.

    “There is a mature knowledge in Gwendolyn Brooks of how communities and the individuals within them muddle along”

0.56

Poetry has always depended on patronage and teaching rather than market economics since poets cannot support themselves by writing.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Unlike restaurants which have a top, bottom, and healthy middle, the arts have never had a healthy middle market: artists have always depended on patronage or on people driven by love of something other than the art itself, since one does not become a poet to earn a living and essentially no poet can support themselves by writing poetry.

    “In the arts, has there ever been a healthy middle of the market? Arts are not restaurants, right?”

  • Her advice to a young person who wants to follow her path is to teach the young, because teaching is learning to converse with others and to experience a topic growing richer under the attentions of a community—a classroom that works is an ever-rewarding community.

    “what teaching is, is learning to converse with others. It's to experience a topic as it grows richer and richer under the attentions of a community.”

  • Because virtually no poet can earn a living writing poetry, the great poets in our culture teach, which is fortunately a culturally important role for creative people.

    “Happily for our culture, what many of the great poets in the culture do is they teach, which I think is a really important role for creative people.”

0.47

American poetry reflects its historical and geographical contexts; urbanization, immigration, and regional conditions shape poetic consciousness.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Contrary to their repressed reputation, being a Puritan was actually a way to live a psychologically candid, un-repressed life of intense attention to one's insecurities and a high-octane experience of extremes—including aesthetic exultation at nature as God's eloquent creation—making it a good religion for people who crave intensity rather than moderation or serenity.

    “We think of the Puritans as very repressed, but instead, you want to be marinating in and giving a lot of attention to all of your own insecurities”

  • New England is expensive to live in, which contributes to its depopulation, echoing the 1890s when the region depopulated as the textile industry and mills shut down and moved out.

    “It's expensive to live here, but I actually have no idea.”

  • Willa Cather's My Antonia shows that ethnic 'pandemonium' and unease about difference were present in the Midwest itself when Norwegians, Bohemians, and other middle and northern Europeans settled it, demonstrating that American disagreements about difference have always been with us and are not regionally specific—there aren't really red states and blue states, only states that are currently redder and bluer.

    “she writes about the Midwest when it was being populated by Norwegians, Bohemians, who were Austro-Hungarians... and there was ethnic pandemonium right there in the middle.”

  • Whitman's democratic consciousness and language were educated by coming of age in Brooklyn during the birth of the modern urban metropolis, where the vast architectural sprawl and the flooding influx of diverse peoples—northern Europeans, runaway slaves, famine-fleeing Irish—made a democratic sensibility almost inevitable, giving him an original understanding of how a city wants to be a locus of democracy.

    “Whitman's consciousness is educated by the vast architectural sprawl of his city, and then by all of the people who came flooding into this city”

0.47

Poetry should be performed, sung, and spoken aloud rather than read silently; treating it as oral and musical tradition restores its power.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Applying artificial intelligence and machine learning to poetry is largely a dead end because poetry most meaningfully serves our humanity and our unique intelligence as held in language; we should instead cherish and regather the things about us that are distinctly human.

    “I do view it as a dead end. Certainly we will learn something, but it is our humanity that poetry most meaningfully serves.”

  • Poe argued no poem should be longer than 108 lines because that was the maximum readable in one sitting, since poetry should deliver an experiential, explosive 'pow' effect that longer works cannot sustain—a criterion that would exclude Dante and Whitman.

    “Poe said that no poem should be longer than 108 lines; 108 lines, Poe calculated, was exactly the maximum amount that you could read in one sitting.”

  • We made a mistake roughly a hundred years ago in deciding that poems are things read silently on a page by oneself, rather than things read aloud around a fire, recited in pageants, or sung with music; for most of poetry's history there were music and jesters, so treating song lyrics like Dylan's or Sondheim's as part of poetry's pageantry makes perfect sense.

    “we made a mistake when we decided that poems were things we read on a page by ourselves silently, rather than poems were things we read around a fire to each other or recited after school in a pageant or sang with music and jesters.”

  • The right question about American English is not whether it is better or worse than 19th-century English but whether it is moving and refreshing itself; slang, mass culture, and technological limits constantly inject potency and ingenuity into language, and a difficult poet like John Ashbery may become crystal clear to future generations accustomed to his cut-up, media-fied way of thinking.

    “for me, it's not 'Is it better or worse?' but 'Is it moving? Is the language refreshing itself?'”

0.38

An artist's personal character or flaws do not diminish the value of their great work or our right to engage it.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Rather than striking objectionable artists off reading lists, we should recognize that great art is often fertilized by bad character—Hemingway wasn't nice but wrote killer sentences—while still being entitled to personal taste, such as New's distaste for Pound's anti-Semitism and her sense that Eliot, despite 'The Waste Land's' magnificence, lacked wisdom.

    “For whatever reason, great art is often fertilized by bad character.”

  • Contrary to the assumption that Melville fell short as a poet, his 'Battle Pieces' is great poetry because he lets the deforming, torqueing energies of the war and of his own psyche fall as they may on the page, and 'Clarel' is comparable to 'Paradise Lost.'

    “He's a great poet. I think Melville's a great poet.”