What this covers

In this conversation, David Salle discusses the condition of contemporary art and how institutional, critical, and cultural forces have narrowed the experience of viewing. He argues that art has shifted from offering genuine aesthetic experience toward what he calls "aboutness"—the reduction of a work to a legible subject or message. This degradation, Salle contends, stems from museum economics (the need to move bodies through turnstiles), curatorial incentives that reward safety over discovery, and art writing that functions more as journalism than criticism. The conversation touches philosophy, psychology, and art history as Salle traces how modernism operated as a persuasive cultural narrative from roughly 1900 to 1990, and what happens to artistic practice once that argument loses force.

The range extends from technical matters—how the loss of the apprentice guild system altered painters' training and what contemporary artists can do—to broader institutional critique. Salle examines why museum architecture has consumed resources better spent on collections, and why Institutional Risk-Aversion across curators and directors produces predictable rather than challenging exhibitions. He addresses the role of individual judgment, arguing viewers should trust First-Impression Analogy over deference to wall label commentary, and explores how Iterative Taste Cultivation actually works in practice. Salle also considers Individual Plus Technology—how artistic breakthroughs require both personal gift and historical circumstance—and reflects on the difference between artists who evolve (like Jasper Johns) and those who remain consistent. A striking late claim concerns intellectual property: that good work needs no legal protection, only open cultural access.

Sharpest takeaway

Salle argues that art's value lies in non-literal aesthetic experience and individual sensibility, and that contemporary art culture, criticism, and institutions have degraded this by favoring literal 'aboutness,' journalism, and risk-aversion over genuine imaginative experience.

  • The shift toward treating art as being 'about' something short-circuits the aesthetic experience
  • Viewers should trust their own immediate reactions rather than defer to wall labels and received opinion
  • Institutional incentives (curators, museums, building booms) push toward risk-aversion and away from genuine art experience

The argument · threads8 threads · 30 claims
0.64

Immediate visual experience and personal judgment must override deference to institutional authority and historical consensus.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • One's immediate reaction to a work of art is like meeting a new person — you know within a millisecond whether it's for you — but unlike meeting people, viewers distrust this feeling and defer to the wall label, which confuses them; the better practice is to ask what you actually find yourself thinking about when looking, even if the honest answer is boredom or nothing.

    “when you meet somebody, you know within a millisecond whether that person is likely for you or not”

  • One should not default to trusting the judgments of history about which artists are great, but should make one's own judgment, which may differ greatly from accepted opinion.

    “I think one should make one’s own judgment, and it might differ greatly from accepted opinion.”

  • In a museum, artists are simultaneously more impatient and more patient than non-artists: they refuse to linger before things that don't interest them regardless of provenance or backstory, but when they find the visual hit of insight, they can stay before a single painting for hours, long after others have moved on.

    “artists are both more patient and more impatient than the nonartist in a museum setting.”

0.64

Art's primary function is decorative and emotional, not conceptual; overemphasis on what art is 'about' short-circuits genuine aesthetic experience.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • A painting's first and historically important function is decorative — to make the wall and room it hangs on look better and to quicken viewers' emotional temperature — and this function, though often dismissed, is real and significant, even if good painting also does more.

    “The first obligation of a painting is to make the wall look better that it’s hanging on.”

  • Since roughly the mid-20th century, the experience of culture shifted toward something closer to journalism than aesthetic experience — works of art came to be valued for being 'about' something easily grasped, and this 'aboutness' short-circuits the genuine art experience, which should instead leave room for metaphor, invention, imagination, and fun.

    “the nature of the experience shifted to something that had more in common with journalism than with what we might call “an aesthetic experience,” that works of art were thought to be about something.”

  • Because making a coherent painting — with colors in the right intervals and all formal and subject-matter elements working — is an enormous amount of work, going to all that trouble merely to be a smart-ass is not worth it; anyone making a painting on any level is trying to communicate something complex and bound up with human emotions, and the gap between how a work is perceived and how its maker perceives it may narrow over time as the 'acid' in the paintings leaks out.

    “To go to all that trouble just to be a smart-ass — it’s not worth it. You have to have a little bit bigger game in mind.”

0.53

Institutional and economic pressures on museums and curators push toward safe, popular, journalistic exhibition rather than genuine critical risk-taking.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • When artists collectively sought to leave the 'art ghetto' and enter the broader culture, they got their wish but at the cost of a dumbing-down; the expanded audience created demand for interpreters, and art writing degenerated into journalism that catalogs identity and subject-matter markers rather than offering genuine criticism.

    “the cost was a dumbing down and simplification”

  • Curators answer to directors who answer to boards, so no one wants to make an unpopular or wrongly controversial show; because major shows are planned five-plus years ahead at enormous cost, no one wants to make a mistake, and the way curators are educated and promoted does not encourage or reward maverick risk-taking — a situation that is not always healthy.

    “the curators answer to the director, and the director answers to the board of directors”

  • American museums require a great deal of money to operate, and since that money comes not from the government but from ticket sales, private individuals, and corporations, the institutional imperative becomes 'bodies through turnstiles' — a fact of life that is neither inherently good nor bad but shapes museum behavior.

    “Oh, no, you have to understand, what we want is bodies through turnstiles.”

  • Over the last 50 years museums have been caught up in an architecture bonanza in which a museum must claim architectural singularity to get press, attendance, and donors; so much money and attention has gone into making striking buildings, many of which are not hospitable places to look at art — and it would be better to direct less money to vast buildings and more toward showing the collection.

    “The architecture bonanza has been great for architects, where a museum has to claim architectural singularity to get press, to get attendance, to get donors.”

0.47

Taste is a learnable skill developed through iterative practice of sustained looking and attending to one's own reactions.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Taste can be acquired through a concrete practice: buy a cheap object like a $5 vase at a flea market, live with it and look at it until you 'use it up,' then trade up to a slightly better object and repeat — and through this iterative process of attending to your own reactions, taste develops.

    “Just go to the flea market and buy a vase for 5 bucks. Bring it back to your room, live with it, and look at it.”

  • Following the Wittgensteinian principle that for the meaning of something you should consider its use, art objects have varying uses over time — short-term, long-term, coming in and out of focus — so there is no single durable 'test of time' that all great works pass and that judges an object's quality permanently.

    “the Wittgenstein dictum that for the meaning of something, consider its use.”

0.44

Collectors and curators who engage deeply with art create its context and meaning; artists collect differently from other collectors.

10 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Great collectors are hard to generalize about but share that the work speaks to them and they arrange their lives to be defined by their collection; though they didn't create the work, they created its context — a producerial transference — which is why many great collectors have been movie or theatrical producers, driven by a will to make meaning and say something about their time, while some collect simply out of love or possessive greed.

    “They didn’t create the work, but they created the context of the work. It’s a kind of transference, a kind of produceorial arrangement.”

  • Artists divide into those who constantly evolve, change, and take on new identities versus those who don't; the non-evolving artists aren't necessarily lesser or less profound, but they're less rewarding as retrospective material because their work is more all of a piece, whereas an evolving artist like Jasper Johns — whose work changed greatly yet remains unmistakably his — produces an exhilarating retrospective experience, also dependent on the curator providing a road map.

    “they’re definitely less rewarding as retrospective material because the work is more all of a piece.”

  • Artists collect differently from other collectors: an artist's collection is a private matter, like a library, owing nothing to the art world and making no public statement; artists typically collect work very different from their own (Jeff Koons collects Courbet), using others' work as a touchstone, a reminder, or a link to another world rather than as a public identity.

    “the artist owes nothing to the art world vis-à-vis their collection... Their collection is really a private matter. It’s more like a library.”

  • Answering his own hypothetical posed to his teacher John Baldessari, Salle holds that it is much better for an artist to be loved than feared, though he acknowledges he has known artists who would choose to be feared.

    “I think to be loved is much better, but I’ve known artists who would choose the other option.”

  • Frank O'Hara is the painter's poet par excellence — the poet of nouns, things, appearances, and the connections between things — whose work is at once a list of names and more than that, capturing what happened at the party while also addressing mortality, beauty, and degradation, which is why so many painters are drawn to him; for Alex Katz he mattered as a contemporary, friend, and fellow connoisseur of New York School poetry.

    “He is the certain kind of painter’s poet par excellence. He is the poet of nouns, poet of things, the poet of appearances, and the poet of connections between things.”

  • Everything that exists exists in the present tense and can be material for someone else without violating its original status; one thing does not impinge on the other, and a work doesn't need legal protection because if it's any good it protects itself — implying intellectual property restrictions on appropriating images are too strong and there should be more open access.

    “everything that exists, exists in the present tense, and that everything can be material for someone else without violating its original status”

  • Writing about art is harder than writing about literature or sociology because art is visual while language is language; when writing about most non-visual subjects the descriptive medium aligns with the experience, but with visual art there is always a challenging approximation or translation between the visual experience and verbal description.

    “Art is visual; language is language.”

  • Salle's earlier claim that one of the principal cultural alliances is between the avant-garde and sexual libertinism was wrong wishful thinking; the avant-garde is no more protected from puritanicalism than any other segment of society.

    “the avant-garde is no more protected from puritanicalism than any other segment of society, so I think I was wrong on that one. I think it was wishful thinking.”

  • Paintings fail in several ways: the most disheartening is when the whole pictorial conception was wrong despite proper execution — revealing the concept as stupid, insincere, juvenile, or a lapse in taste; a more honorable failure is a gamble that didn't pay off (betting that juxtaposing two things would catch fire); and the most embarrassing is simple inattention, like using the wrong blue.

    “Probably the most disheartening is when the whole pictorial conception was wrong.”

  • The Sopranos is a model for what art can do: David Chase took the conventions of gangster/mafia/cop drama — givens with which most viewers have no real experience — and made out of them a psychologically dense work whose granular realism turned a crime family into a metaphor for nearly every dilemma in American society, demonstrating that art works by engaging with certain givens and then going somewhere unpredictable.

    “someone who took the conventions of the day of gangsters, mafia, cops, and made out of it something which hadn’t existed, just psychological realism that had a texture”

0.40

Artistic ability is constrained by individual body, training, and historical moment; painters today cannot replicate old-master techniques or motivation.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Art is not a menu in a Chinese restaurant where an artist freely picks styles (paint like Rembrandt in the morning, Titian in the afternoon); the reality is that an artist is stuck with what their own body, aptitude, coordination, and control can do — more like athletics than like free choice.

    “We think that art is like a menu in a Chinese restaurant for the artist.”

  • Artistic breakthroughs like Cézanne's are always the individual plus the cultural and technological context: the technology of painting in an artist's lifetime is X, and the artist adds Y to it; part of this remains unknowable because the secret resides with the individual, and breakthroughs are slow, torturous, and not immediately rewarded.

    “It is always the individual plus the cultural and the technological, you could say. The technology of painting in his lifetime was X, and he added Y to the X.”

  • Today's painters cannot paint in the style of Velázquez or Rubens largely because they are trained in professional art schools starting around age 18-22 and in a hurry, rather than in the early-starting apprentice guild system that produced old-master technical proficiency; additionally there was no cultural motivation to step back two centuries while modernism remained such a persuasive, inclusive, dynamic argument from roughly 1900 to 1990.

    “We’re not trained in an apprentice guild situation where the apprenticeship starts very early in life”

  • Painting is a physical activity requiring not just mental concentration but physical stamina, especially at large scale; it is one of the things in life you can get better at with age rather than worse, but you eventually reach a point where the physical body becomes a limitation on how many hours and how big you can work.

    “It is one of the things in life that you can get better at with the age, instead of worse, but you do reach a point where the physical body is a limitation”

0.34

First-generation abstract expressionists achieved unrepeatable historical breakthroughs; their successors faded because they advanced nothing further.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The first-generation abstract expressionists are foundational and irreplaceable in 20th- and 21st-century painting because an unrepeatable historical set of events produced in those specific people an unprecedented, long-lasting response; such genuine needle-moving by artists stays moved, whereas second-generation followers who didn't advance further have faded and were often overrated in their time.

    “I find them foundational in 20th- and 21st-century painting. They’re irreplaceable, and they are so for very specific reasons having to do with an unrepeatable historical set of events”

  • John Currin represents a generation for whom modernism was no big deal; having started with credible abstract paintings, he realized he was at the tail end rather than the beginning of something, and being one of the few with the talent and acquired skill to paint representationally, he exemplifies the beginning of a next phase of artists going back past modernism.

    “First thing I thought when I saw John’s painting is, “Oh, this guy owes nothing to modernism. He just doesn’t care.””

0.34

Art's meaning and value vary over time and use; no single durable test permanently judges a work's quality.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Being an artist requires many self-delusions, often encouraged by dealers and collectors; Salle once believed a painting was 'museum only' and his dealer even listed likely museums, yet no museum or major collector wanted it and it bounced through auctions and collections — illustrating that the artist may be the last to know a work's actual standing, and that happy outcomes usually depend on a personal relationship with an attuned collector or curator.

    “In artist parlance it’s “museum only.” She even made a list of which museums would be likely. No museum was interested in this painting.”

  • Contemporary art favors the documentary as a meaningful expression of our time because of the centrality and deluge of photography; past painters could do what they did precisely because they had no cameras and were required to document the world, an obligation no longer placed on painters, and this documentary mood would not have prevailed in 1940-1960.

    “we’re in a documentary mode, and I’m sure the rise of photography — not just the rise — let’s say, the deluge of photography.”