What this covers
David Robertson discusses musical leadership and the craft of conducting with Tyler Cowen, centering on how great conducting operates as an act of deep listening rather than will-imposition. Robertson draws on his work with Pierre Boulez and his experience building the Ensemble Intercontemporain to argue that a conductor's primary task is to harness collective artistry by listening precisely to what each player brings, then synthesizing those voices into clarity. The conversation weaves together practical conducting technique, cognitive science, and the sociology of how listeners encounter music, grounded throughout in specific examples from contemporary classical music and the history of twentieth-century composition.
The conversation ranges widely across how music actually works in the brain and body. Robertson explains that what sounds "contemporary" is not fixed to a work but depends entirely on each listener's prior experience, and that a performer's job is therefore to create structures open enough for individuals to find themselves in the music. He traces how Stravinsky revised his own pieces opportunistically for copyright reasons, and how Boulez structured orchestral ensembles as groups of soloists maintaining peak form through private practice. Robertson applies Kahneman's distinction between fast and slow thinking to show how much of conducting is handled by intuition arriving before conscious awareness. He also explores the tension between classical music's demand for sustained attention and the smartphone era's fragmentation of time, and argues that comfort with looking slightly ridiculous—captured in the Moon View thought experiment—is essential to the role. Throughout, the conversation treats questions of emotional legibility, contemporary discomfort with unfamiliar musical rules, and the relationship between written notation and performed sound as genuinely open rather than settled.
Robertson argues that great conducting and musical leadership are fundamentally acts of deep listening and self-effacement—synthesizing many equally valid voices into a clear whole—which requires a willingness to look ridiculous and a recognition that emotion, complexity, and contemporaneity in music are negotiated between performer, composer, and each individual listener.
- A conductor's core job is to listen deeply and harness collective artistry rather than impose will.
- Clarity of sound comes from hearing precisely what you want internally and instinctively doing what produces it.
- What counts as 'contemporary' or emotionally legible is determined by each listener's prior experience, not by the work alone.
Conductors must listen deeply to synthesize each ensemble member's equally valid viewpoint into unified clarity.
- Achieving clarity rests on the fundamental principle that every person in the orchestra, like every soloist in an ensemble, is equally important and their viewpoints equally valid, so the conductor's job is to synthesize all of it into a unified whole with maximum clarity—faithfully surfacing even parts that seem destined to be drowned out unless the composer deliberately omitted them.
“every person in the orchestra, like every person in an ensemble of soloists, is equally important, and their viewpoints are equally valid”
- Boulez's method for achieving orchestral clarity—'make sure that you have very clearly what you want to hear in your head, and then, even without realizing it, you will instinctively do what is necessary to make sure that you hear it'—means the conductor's internal auditory image automatically produces the balancing actions (bringing trombones down, bassoons up) needed to surface every part the composer wrote.
“You make sure that you have very clearly what you want to hear in your head, and then, even without realizing it, you will instinctively do what is necessary to make sure that you hear it.”
- Because an unwritten orchestral rule forbids players from turning to look at a colleague who played beautifully, the conductor's job is to be the one who reflects that recognition outward to the whole ensemble—and to grant flexibility (letting an inspired oboist or soprano linger) so players feel acknowledged in magical moments.
“the recognition of that, I feel, falls principally to the conductor to reflect that out to the rest of the musicians”
- What managers can learn from conductors is that you can only do the job by listening; although it looks like imposing your will, you are actually harnessing the collective artistry in front of you and getting it to move in one direction—decisions range from short-term (tomorrow's rehearsal order) to multi-decade (granting a player tenure), and their efficacy rests on deeply listening to different points of view.
“you can only do your job by listening. That’s the only way to do the job.”
- A conductor tends to have the most trouble with the instrument group in which they have the least practical experience—Robertson at 21 found it easier to tell brass and woodwind to 'breathe here' than to advise the first violins—but deep exposure (as with the Ensemble Intercontemporain's soloists, who showed him fingerings, string positions, and circular breathing) functions as a master class in every instrument, transferable to other orchestras.
“you tend to have the most trouble with the instrument or the group of instruments with whom you have the least practical experience”
- Every orchestral player looks up at a different, personal moment, but almost all instinctively and subconsciously look up after finishing a passage to check whether they are in the right place; a conductor must quickly memorize each player's look-up timing—their open 'window'—to send useful information, and the after-playing glance is the ideal moment to convey 'that was incredible,' building trust.
“almost every player looks up after they’ve finished playing something. I think it’s to just check in to see, “Am I in the right place?””
Every musician's distinctive sensory experience and perceptual emphasis—like overtone sensitivity or instrumental background—shapes their unique artistic vision.
- The case for listening to a composer like Boulez is that every artist has a unique way of viewing the world shaped by their history, their handling of that history, and what they perceive around them—each composer draws on distinctive personal sensory experiences (e.g., perfect pitch, or hearing overtone structure) and their imagination to say something not said before.
“every artist has a unique way of viewing the world, and they express it through music”
- Robertson, as a recovering horn player, realized he hears the overtone structure of pitches far more than many of his musical colleagues—not that they cannot hear overtones, but that it does not enter into their calculation of what matters in music—illustrating that each musician's distinctive perceptual emphasis shapes their art.
“I hear the overtone structure of pitches, I have realized, much more than many of my musical colleagues”
- A listener's openness to contemporary classical music is shaped by their instrumental history: those who, as children, enjoyed making strange or 'funny' sounds on their instrument to annoy siblings tend to be closer to contemporary music, while those who stuck only to the Tune A Day method book bring more conventional expectations into the concert hall.
“If they’re the person who liked to honk and make strange sounds to annoy their siblings, they’re probably going to be closer to contemporary music, and they bring that with them into the concert hall.”
Music collapses time and distance between souls, triggering unexpected neural connections across individual listeners' personal histories.
- The curious power of music—whether popular or 'serious'—is to collapse time, space, and the distance between souls; a randomly heard song or even ambient street sound can trigger a butterfly effect, firing neurons that suddenly retrieve a long-forgotten piece, which is why Robertson refuses to wall himself off from environmental sound with earbuds.
“the curious thing that music can do, which is to collapse time and collapse space and collapse distance between souls”
- Although orchestras gather 2,000 listeners at once for purely economic, cost-effective reasons, a concert is really played for one individual at a time; every audience member arrives with their own experiences (bereavement, new love, disturbing news, instrumental background), so the performer's task is to create the most open structure possible so each person can find themselves within the music.
“an audience anywhere is a collection of individuals. We play a concert for one individual, but for economic reasons, we just get 2,000 individuals together at the same time because it’s cost effective”
- Whether a piece sounds 'contemporary' is not a fixed property of the work but a movable feast determined by each listener's prior experience—a 1950s Boulez sonata can feel cutting-edge to one person and dated to a longtime new-music listener—so the performer's task is to make any work, regardless of when written, speak to us now because we are the contemporary ones.
“contemporary is a very movable feast, and it has to do with what it is you’ve experienced”
- European concert audiences applaud markedly longer than American ones—Robertson had to tell American soloists in Lyon, who had already returned for a seventh curtain call and played an encore, that the audience still wanted more, whereas at Carnegie Hall a standing ovation typically ends after two bows.
“The amount of applause you get from European audiences is sometimes surprising to Americans.”
Contemporary classical music requires listeners to embrace discomfort with unfamiliar rules while performers make any work speak to present moment.
- The smartphone era—a supercomputer in every pocket—is a fundamental societal shift whose effects are unknown, and it poses a particular challenge to classical music's long-form rewards, which depend on the increasingly scarce resources of attention and time; young conductors therefore need to learn to slow down and engage in sustained contemplation of the score.
“the challenge for us in what we call classical music...is the idea of long form. That has phenomenal rewards, but it is dealing with what is seen as a very scarce resource, which is attention, and its concomitant aspect, time.”
- Contemporary classical music confronts listeners with the breakdown of familiar rules, turning listening into a question of one's comfort with discomfort; some composers and listeners prefer consonance, while others view consonant music as a cop-out that fails to use a language adequate to reality's trickier, nastier nature.
“different people’s comfort with discomfort is something that I think contemporary classical music really deals with”
Stravinsky and other composers revised works for economic copyright reasons, illustrating tension between artistic purity and practical survival.
- Stravinsky lost rights to early works like the original Firebird (he received payment but no ongoing royalties despite it being his most-played piece), so after finding refuge in the US during World War II he revised numerous works to obtain copyright—sometimes trivially (one changed note in Persephone's second bassoon part) and sometimes substantially, with the 1947 Petrushka reducing woodwinds and harps and simplifying tempo relations to make it easier (and more lucrative) for him to conduct.
“When the Second World War came along, and he had found refuge in the United States, he realized, “I need to revise a number of my works so that I can get the copyright.””
- When Boulez founded the Ensemble Intercontemporain, he structured it as 31 soloists, each contracted like an orchestral soloist to play roughly two-thirds of the time so they could maintain peak form like a tennis player or gymnast through extensive private practice.
“It was an ensemble of 31 soloists, and their contract was modeled on the soloist’s contract in an orchestra, which is usually closer to two-thirds of the time”
- Boulez nominated Robertson as music director of the Ensemble Intercontemporain in 1991 despite Robertson never having conducted the ensemble before, meaning Robertson's first Le Marteau sans maître was the ensemble's 293rd performance of it—an experience he describes as 'drinking from a fire hydrant.'
“he nominated me and gave me the job as music director. I had never conducted the ensemble before.”
- Composers who combine electroacoustic sounds with live performers often feel the live players continually inflect and develop the music with something new, whereas the worked-out electronic material, however sophisticated, lies inert while the living musicians move forward.
“the thing that has been worked out, however sophisticated, in the electronic area, lies there inert while the living musicians move along”
- Much of what a conductor does is real, hard data-crunching handled by System 1 (fast, intuitive thinking), while System 2—which believes it is in charge—actually arrives about 50 milliseconds late to the party, making Kahneman's Thinking, Fast and Slow essential reading for understanding the craft.
“so much of what we do, I think, in conducting, is actually the real hard crunching of data that system one takes care of”
- A skill conductors need that great instrumentalists may lack is comfort with sometimes looking slightly foolish—captured in Janos Fürst's 'moon view' thought experiment, where an extraterrestrial observing an orchestra sees one person making no sound while waving a stick, revealing how ridiculous the role can appear and why not taking oneself too seriously matters.
“you need to feel comfortable with sometimes looking slightly foolish”
- Composers notate rhythm via two basic approaches: taking a span of time and subdividing it (a grid, as in jazz where push and pull against the grid generates energy), or building an underlying pulse from additive groups of small note values (as in Indian subcontinent traditions); Boulez's irregular phrases require shifting time signatures because forcing them onto a grid turns everything else into syncopation and crushes the music's expressive space.
“composers use two basic ideas when they’re going to notate their music. One is to take a certain amount of time and subdivide it...Then there’s the idea that you have, say, a group of eighth notes or sixteenth notes that form an underlying pulse.”
- Composers frequently get nervous when their own piece is performed—like sending a child onto the Little League field—which translates into a tendency to push the music faster or with more energy, whereas sitting and listening to the work as a non-performer yields a completely different and often better-judged experience of it.
“you get very nervous when your piece is being played. It’s almost like sending your child onto the Little League field”
- Robertson follows Boulez's advice that, when looking at a composer's works, you should always trust the original—he prefers the 1911 Petrushka because its colors and orchestration (rooted in the Rimsky-Korsakov Russian tradition) are clearer and more beautiful than the practically simplified 1947 revision—while noting the irony that Boulez constantly revised his own works yet would never advise returning to his originals.
“it will turn out, when you are looking at a composer’s works, always trust the original”
- A conductor can perform highly complex contemporary scores 'by heart' rather than merely 'from memory' because, like a deeply loved piece, the music carries volumes of experience, love, and connection that make it as impossible to forget as one's parents' names.
“I prefer by heart rather than from memory, because I think the notion is that, like any kind of music, it means so much to you that there’s no way you could forget it”
Audiences form snap judgments about music within seconds, so performers must frame difficult works with accessible context.
- Regardless of a listener's musical sophistication, the brain decides 'this is for me' or 'not for me' extremely quickly—Robertson's training mixtape uses clips of at most 2.5 seconds to demonstrate this—so performers and programmers must account for the speed of that initial judgment, which is why he frames difficult works (like Explosante-fixe) by starting with delicate, contextualizing material rather than the jarring opening.
“the speed with which your brain decides, “Ah, yes, for me. No, not for me,” is very, very quick”
- Robertson recommends a Boulez skeptic start with Mémoriale—a five-minute piece for solo flute, small string ensemble, and two horns, with a delightful sound world and strong emotional tenor, written as a memorial for the young flutist Lawrence Beauregard who had been developing the MIDI flute—because it is brief and rewarding rather than off-putting.
“I would say start gently with a piece like Mémoriale, where there the sound world...is delightful and at the same time, it is a piece that has a very strong emotional tenor.”
- Drawing on Maryanne Wolf's Proust and the Squid, Robertson notes that reading is a recent skill for Homo sapiens that most people perform via a typical neurological pathway, but some—like dyslexics, analogous to squid born unable to swim who survive by building entirely unique neural pathways to their muscles—must construct different routes to reading; his own difficulty was eased by reading plays, whose surrounding space let him process more easily.
“the relatively recent experience of reading text for Homo sapiens is something that the majority of people do in a certain neurological way, but there are others for whom...those neural pathways are not open to them, so they need to build something different”
Boulez's flexibility with his own works and others' interpretations, despite his severe reputation, shaped Robertson's conducting approach.
- Boulez had no problem when others put immense emotional intensity into his works—even doubling a slow tempo for sensual effect—but he was personally unable to express that emotion himself as a performer, which explains why his own recordings sound more rigorous than emotional interpretations by others.
“he has no problem when the emotion is put into his works in an immensely intense way, but he is not able to do that himself as a performer”
- Contrary to his severe reputation, Boulez showed great flexibility with his own works—accepting a clarinetist's suggestion that a tremolo didn't work well and revising it, and recalculating computer tempos on request during Explosante-fixe—and treated Robertson with a forgiving, 'grandfilial' warmth rather than combativeness.
“To see this kind of flexibility with his own works”
Composers draw inspiration from attentive listening to world sounds and lived experience rather than abstract theory alone.
- Boulez's incorporation of unusual sounds like steel drums and gamelan-derived rhythms stems from a lifelong habit of attentive listening during world travel (e.g., hearing steel drum players on a Caribbean beach while touring with the Renaud-Barrault Theater Company) rather than from abstract theory, paralleling how non-Western influences reshaped French composition and Cubist visual art.
“There’s so much in Pierre’s music that is about his paying attention and listening all the time”