What this covers

Tyler Cowen interviews Claire Lehmann, Australian editor and cultural critic, on the nature and reach of political correctness in American intellectual life. Lehmann argues that PC operates not as an enforcement of civility but as a selective suppression of inquiry—a system in which certain identity groups hold asymmetric rights to offense while others do not. The conversation moves across the institutional roots of this restraint: the rapid establishment of studies departments in the 1970s without scholarly grounding, the spread of postmodernism through elite universities and into journalism and law, and how internet publishing flattened hierarchies and enabled anti-PC voices to flourish outside coastal, credentialed gatekeepers. Lehmann contrasts American and Australian approaches to these questions, attributing differences to structural factors: public universities with low fees, on-campus versus off-campus student life, and the absence of affirmative action policies.

The discussion draws on psychological frameworks—Empathizing-Systemizing Theory to explain gender disparities in libertarianism, Jonathan Haidt's work on moral foundations, and Narrative Persuasion to show why emotionally inert arguments fail. Lehmann treats Progressivism as a Belief System in its moderate and fundamentalist forms, and observes that right-wing political correctness—taboos against questioning patriotism or economic orthodoxy—likely causes more national damage than its left-wing variant, even if the latter dominates urban academia. She advocates not reform of existing institutions but construction of new ones: independent publications, reading lists, and learning spaces built by those disenchanted with captured ones. The conversation also includes practical editorial advice on writing, the limits of pseudonymous publishing, and how scientific literacy can confer advantage in media and policy work.

Sharpest takeaway

Lehmann argues that political correctness is not about basic civility but a hyperactive restraint on inquiry rooted in unevenly applied identity rules, and that the cure is building new institutions for open, scientifically literate discourse rather than reforming captured ones.

  • Political correctness is distinct from civility norms and functions to suppress questioning rather than enforce decency
  • Offense entitlement is asymmetric and tied to membership in a fixed set of victim groups
  • Internet platforms have flattened publishing hierarchies and enabled non-academic, anti-PC discourse to flourish

The argument · threads7 threads · 29 claims
0.64

Political correctness punishes questioning and inquiry rather than promoting civility or respectful debate.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Political correctness is not the same as civility or politeness; it is a restraint on inquiry whereby people are punished for asking questions, expressing doubt, and questioning simplistic narratives around gender and race, with norms that are hyperactive and overactive.

    “I think political correctness is the restraint on inquiry.”

  • Lehmann agrees with civility, politeness, and respect, and is against being aggressively provocative or overly polemical with political opponents.

    “I’m on the side of not being aggressively provocative and overly polemical with one’s perceived political opponents.”

0.58

Building independent institutions and platforms creates learning environments without attacking existing captured academic and media structures.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The real constraint on growing Quillette is the irreplaceable time and judgment of Lehmann and her two co-editors—editorial judgment for selecting submissions and refining authors' work cannot be easily replicated by hiring more people—and scaling to something like 20 editors would fail both because there wouldn't be enough quality submissions and because internal communication would break down into power plays.

    “The real constraint is the talent and the time of the individuals that I have at the moment.”

  • Building social capital—developing loose friendships and affiliations over years that can be drawn upon when a news story breaks (as with the James Damore controversy, enabling immediate publication)—was central to Lehmann's ability to start and run Quillette, alongside recognizing the limits of her own competence and outsourcing weaknesses like proofreading.

    “Building up social capital is a big part of it. I have developed friendships with people, sort of loose affiliations with people over the years”

  • Disenchanted contrarians should pursue creative rather than destructive solutions: rather than only working within or attacking captured media and universities, they should build their own institutions—book clubs, reading lists, websites encouraging academic material—and create the learning environment they want to see in the world.

    “I think that creative solutions are always superior to destructive solutions.”

  • Being from the smaller city of Adelaide—founded by social experimenters and the first Australian state to give women the vote—enabled greater social mobility than competitive cities like Sydney and Melbourne, where private schooling and family networks matter; in Adelaide doing well in school and getting into university sufficed, allowing Lehmann to be ambitious without feeling constrained.

    “Adelaide—because it was smaller—all you really had to do was do well in school, get into university, and you could quiteeasilybe socially mobile.”

0.57

Social justice functions well in moderate form but becomes destructive as fundamentalist belief system, like any ideology.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Progressivism and social justice can be understood as a belief system that functions well in its moderate form, but social justice warriors represent the fundamentalist extreme of this 'progressive faith,' which is where the trouble arises—just as moderate religious faith is benign while fundamentalism causes problems.

    “I think what we call social justice warriors are like the fundamentalists of the progressive faith.”

  • Being left-wing and being politically correct are distinct: in Australia, left-wing simply means favoring redistributive policies and egalitarianism, and there are many left-wing Australians who are not politically correct, so the American dichotomy where being anti-PC implies being right-wing does not hold.

    “I think there’s a difference between political correctness and being left-wing. I think one can be left-wing and not be politically correct.”

  • Americans display a paradoxical combination of celebrating risk-taking and courage in business and entrepreneurship while exhibiting general timidity about expressing honest views publicly—people who take career risks become very timid about political or socially dissenting opinions for fear of rocking the boat and offending friends or coworkers.

    “You celebrate entrepreneurs and courage in making money and that kind of thing, but there is a general timidity when it comes to expressing one’s honest views about things.”

  • The difference between New Zealand's earlier, milder accommodation of indigenous status and Australia's slower process is rooted in founding: New Zealand's colonial settlers signed a treaty with the Maori early, setting the stage for better relations, whereas Australia involved stealing land, atrocities against indigenous people, and still has no treaty.

    “The colonial settlers signed a treaty with the Maorisstraight away, so that set the stage for better relations from their inception.”

  • Following John Howard's thesis, a voting public will accept very high immigration if they feel the border is controlled; Australia combines high, high-skilled immigration with tough border control (turning back boats), which—along with skilled immigrants quickly entering high income brackets and professions—accounts for Australians' acceptance of immigration and successful assimilation.

    “the people of Australia will accept very high immigration if they feel that their border is controlled.”

  • Australian culture has a tradition of gruff, manly figures because Australia is a dangerous country whose colonizers had to be tough, with the harsh outback nearby and a strong sporting and beach culture, so that masculinity is bound up with being physically competent.

    “The people who colonized and settled Australia had to be tough. The outback is right there.”

  • Affirmative action policies for Aboriginal people in Australia are largely a nonissue politically because the Aboriginal population is so small that when an individual receives some benefit, no one else effectively misses out—for instance, no one loses a university place because of it.

    “if an Aboriginal individual receives some kind of affirmative action, no is missing out. No one is going to miss out on their university place because of it because it’s such a tiny minority population”

0.54

Internet publishing's clickbait model and rapid expansion of theoretical departments drove PC's rise by promoting simplistic oppression narratives.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The rise of political correctness around 2007 is linked to the clickbait business model of internet publishing (e.g. Gawker, Jezebel), which required driving massive traffic and therefore promoted simplistic black-and-white narratives of oppression that could influence young people lacking critical thinking skills.

    “I thought it had something to do with the business model of Internet publishing.”

  • Setting up women's studies departments in the 1970s was a mistake because, unlike older humanities disciplines (history with its dialectic, philosophy, English literature) developed over centuries with solid scholarly foundations, departments created virtually overnight lacked that grounding, allowing faddish theories like poststructuralism and deconstruction to take root much more quickly and easily.

    “I think the setting up of women’s studies departments in the 1970s was a big mistake”

  • Postmodernism matters not because young people vote on it but because students passing through elite colleges into the professions—especially journalism and law—are inculcated with theories that make them skeptical of objective methods and trained to view social phenomena through simplistic narratives of oppression, producing a toxic effect now visible in major media institutions and contributing to polarization.

    “people who go through elite colleges and go into the professions, particularly in journalism and law, are often trained and inculcated with these theories.”

0.50

Political correctness operates selectively, protecting specific identity groups while excluding others from its protections.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Whether someone can legitimately claim offense under social justice culture depends on which identity group they belong to; Jonathan Haidt identified roughly seven groups (women, blacks, Muslims, indigenous peoples, LGBT, immigrants) entitled to feel offended, and people outside those groups, such as Mormons, are not covered by these rules.

    “Whether or not you can be offended by something depends on what identity group you belong to, and being a Mormon would not qualify”

  • On a national scale in the United States, right-wing political correctness (such as taboos against questioning patriotism, religious orthodoxies, or free-market dogmas) is probably a bigger and more destructive problem than left-wing political correctness, even though left-wing PC dominates academia and the urban centers Lehmann inhabits.

    “If you’re talking about on a national scale, it’s probably right-wing political correctness that is a bigger problem.”

0.45

Structural factors shape ideology adoption: cognitive styles, institutional design, and publishing barriers drive political polarization.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Any political message can be communicated effectively if framed within a narrative structure that elicits an emotional reaction (such as the hero overcoming obstacles); libertarians struggle to attract empathetic audiences because, being rationalist and systematizing, they are skeptical of using narratives and of manipulating people's emotions.

    “If you want to present a political argument, you have to be able to put your argument into some kind of narrative structure that elicits an emotional reaction.”

  • There are relatively few female libertarians because libertarians tend toward a more systematizing cognitive profile, while women on average tend to be more empathizing and agreeable, so political arguments based on quantitative reasoning, facts, and logic without an emotional layer are less appealing to women.

    “they tend towards being more systematizing in their cognitive profile. Women, on average, tend to be more empathizing and agreeable”

  • Australian universities have less political correctness than American ones because they are public (so students paying low fees have less power to make complaints heard), students typically live at home rather than on campus (avoiding the hothouse compression of life into the campus environment), and there is no history of affirmative action since entry is based solely on a tertiary entrance rank from final-year academic results.

    “the fact that they’re public makes a big difference because students are not paying vast sums to go to university in the first place, so students have less power.”

  • The internet has removed barriers to entry in publishing—anyone with talent can be read as widely as a New York Times columnist without a PhD—which flattened the intellectual hierarchy and, by enabling non-urban, non-coastal coordination, has made the political right (especially among younger people) the new counterculture.

    “Because there’s no barrier to entry, you don’t have to have a PhD. You can just have some talent, be a good writer with some insights, and you can be viewed or read just as much as aNew York Timescolumnist.”

0.44

Writing quality depends on narrative structure, clarity, courage to express ideas, and scientific literacy over formal credentials.

7 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Casting Scarlett Johansson as a transgender character is defensible (unlike historical blackface) because being transgender is itself performative and theatrical, allowing for gender fluidity and experimentation, whereas being black is not a performance, and there are also fewer trans actors to choose from.

    “Being transgender is in itself a performance. It’s a theatrical act. However, being black is not a performance.”

  • Students who want to become clinical psychologists should start working in a mental health setting much earlier than the current Australian model, where three to four years of coursework heavy on statistics precede clinical exposure until the fifth or sixth year, which is too late.

    “for people who want to be clinical psychologists, they should start working in a mental health setting much earlier on.”

  • Someone wanting impact in media should not study journalism or media but instead get scientific training (economics, psychology, or biology), because people who can understand statistics, read scientific papers, and couch arguments in a scientifically literate way have an edge over journalism-school graduates and are in demand given the current scarcity of such skills.

    “probably not study journalism or media but study something where you get some scientific training. It might be economics. It might be psychology. It might be biology.”

  • To produce more good writers in the Anglo-American world, Lehmann would defund and clear out studies departments (cultural studies, gender studies, critical race studies) not because the content shouldn't be taught but because these schools train students in poor writing techniques and opaque postmodernist jargon rather than clear, logical thought.

    “I would defund departments that encouraged students to use too much postmodernist jargon. I would clear out a lot of the studies courses”

  • Writing published under pseudonyms or anonymously is, on average, probably better than writing under real names, with some of the best current writing coming from people under pen names, though each piece must be assessed case by case.

    “I actually think it’s probably better writing.”

  • The instant indicator of a winning writer is the ability to give an article a story arc or narrative structure; many people have good prose style and interesting ideas but their articles ramble without structure, so along with courage to express ideas without hedging weasel words and clarity of prose, structuring an article is extremely important.

    “if anyone has the ability to have a story arc in their article, that’s an instant indicator that that person, that writer, is a winner.”

  • While cognitive behavioral therapy is known to be effective partly because it can be standardized and measured, other therapies like extended talk therapy may be quite effective but remain unproven simply because they are hard to standardize and measure—so absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, and we should be more aware that something can work even without measurable proof.

    “because it’s much more difficult to standardize other therapies, like extendedtalk therapy, because we can’t standardize them, it’s hard to measure their effectiveness.”