Chuck Klosterman
What this covers
Chuck Klosterman and Tyler Cowen conduct a wide-ranging conversation that uses the 1990s as a lens for understanding how the internet has fundamentally altered cultural production and identity. Klosterman argues that the 1990s were the last decade when culture evolved visibly over time—when the past was lost enough that distinct aesthetic eras could crystallize—and that since then we have entered a state of Slow Cancellation of the Future in which everything becomes somewhat retro, subcultures dissolve into buffets of choice, and the shallow ocean of culture replaces depth. The argument draws on Mark Fisher's concept and moves outward into sports, psychology, music journalism, and economics, with both speakers testing these claims against counterexamples and nuance.
The conversation divides into several territories. Klosterman explains how scarcity once forced musical devotion—buying one CD per week created intensifying subcultures—while streaming flattened consumption into undifferentiated choice. He contrasts the aesthetic distance between 1965 and 1980 with the near-indistinguishability of 2005 and 2020 as evidence of stalled cultural evolution. In sports, he traces how the one-and-done rule transformed college basketball, how the spread created unexpected vulnerabilities in professional betting integrity, and how championship rings have become a distorted proxy for individual greatness. On psychology, both speakers wrestle with nature versus nurture, discussing whether siblings' differences point to genetic destinies and whether peers matter more than parents over time. Klosterman also argues that the 1990s possessed a distinct cultural texture—evident in mainstream television and anxiety about genetic engineering—that no recent decade has matched, and that voice in writing cannot be taught, only excavated.
Klosterman argues that the 1990s were the last era when culture evolved recognizably over time, and that since then the internet has produced a 'slow cancellation of the future' in which aesthetics, subcultures, and historical periods no longer distinguish themselves.
- Easy access to the recent past via the internet flattens cultural evolution into a 'shallow ocean' rather than deep distinct eras
- Physical mass musical subcultures depended on scarcity, which file-sharing and streaming eliminated
- Films and music from 2005 vs 2020 are aesthetically indistinguishable in a way 1965 vs 1980 never were
Scarcity of access forced deeper engagement and created genuine subcultures with shared default values.
- Coming from a place of extreme artistic scarcity—where one had only six cassettes to play repeatedly and read liner notes over and over—forced a different, deeper kind of thinking about art, and this limitation was a key reason Klosterman succeeded as a critic, because he had to extract maximum meaning from minimal material (viewing Axl Rose with the seriousness others reserved for David Byrne).
“I think part of the reason I was able to succeed as a critic was because I came from a place where I was so limited in the art I was consuming that I had to think about it differently.”
- Physical mass musical subcultures formed because of scarcity: teens with limited funds could only buy one CD a week, forcing them down a single intensifying path (e.g. The Cure leading to Sisters of Mercy, Nine Inch Nails, and shopping at Hot Topic), whereas file-sharing and streaming turned music into a buffet with no pressure to follow one path, dissolving the shared-by-default values that subcultures require.
“part of that had to do with the fact of scarcity — not that the records didn’t exist, but that you had to pay for them, and people in teen culture had a limited amount of funds.”
- Subcultures depend on people having shared values by default, where what is deemed cool or uncool is determined not purely by individual taste but by what peers and the artists those peers listen to seem to think, so that group perception calcifies and galvanizes the meaning of cultural signifiers like being a goth or a metalhead.
“what you need are the people who have shared values by default. In other words, what they decide is cool or uncool is not totally just based on what they think, but what their peers seem to think and what the artists that these peers are listening to seem to think.”
- Music magazines like Spin mattered because you would read about a band before its record was even out, building a whole imaginative superstructure of anticipation before finally hearing the music; once you can instantly hear the song at the same moment you hear about the band, the descriptive function of a magazine collapses, which is a major reason print music journalism declined.
“you would be reading this review of someone trying to describe what the music was... Then you’d wait for the record and finally hear it, and you would’ve had this whole built-in superstructure in your mind over what this music was”
Cultural stasis now makes everything partially retro and prevents the natural evolution that once occurred.
- Mark Fisher's idea of the 'slow cancellation of the future' is increasingly palpable: whereas obscure films from 1965 and 1980 can be instantly ordered in time by anyone, films from 2005 and 2020 are nearly impossible to distinguish aesthetically, because everything is now somewhat retro and the natural cultural evolution that occurred when the past was lost or forgotten no longer happens.
“this guy, Mark Fisher, who’s dead now, had this idea about theslow cancellation of the future. I feel like that’s one of the most profound ideas that I’ve come across in the last 10 years of my life”
- Music from 1991-93 (Nevermind, Blood Sugar Sex Magik) would have sounded dissident, unsongful, and 'not like music at all' to a 1971 rock listener, but music made today would not seem meaningfully different to someone who was into music at the turn of the 21st century—direct evidence of the slow cancellation of the future, since it is now nearly impossible to create something not at least partially retro.
“Had you played them to someone from 1971, it would not have seemed even like music.”
Significance we assign to past events depends entirely on whether later events validate them retroactively.
- It is common to amplify fears in the moment and then, retroactively, look at anything that didn't happen and reframe it as overblown; the significance we assign to past events depends heavily on later events, so a precursor like the first World Trade Center attack only becomes a meaningful signpost if 9/11 later occurs.
“that is common, I think, to amplify fears in the moment, and then retroactively look at anything that didn’t happen and perceive it as, “Well, I guess maybe we were amplifying that too much at the time.” If 9/11 doesn’t happen, we look at the attacking of the USSColevery differently.”
- Y2K is interpretively ambiguous: it can be read either as a problem correctly diagnosed and successfully prevented (resulting in a nonevent), or as a fear that was never going to materialize, evidenced by countries that did little yet had the same result.
“whether or not that didn’t come to fruition, I suppose, depends on if you’re the kind of person who thinks, “Well, this is an example of them seeing a problem, diagnosing it correctly, taking all the steps of stopping it from happening, and then having a nonevent.””
- 1990s popular culture portrayed science with a palpable combination of fear and excitement, exemplified by the cloning of Dolly the sheep and Jurassic Park, where the anxiety was not anti-science per se but that scientists had 'gone too far'—prompting even Clinton to seek pre-emptive legislation against human cloning.
“It was this strange combination of anxiety and excitement. It was thrilling that this was occurring, and yet also seemed like the recipe for disaster. It was like you had to embrace the idea while also stopping it.”
Mainstream widely-consumed products, not outlier apex works, determine the actual texture and values of an era.
- What was historically important about Seinfeld was not that it was more rude or adversarial than classic sitcoms, but that those values were simply 'on' and consumed by enormous audiences as normative entertainment; the things that truly set the texture of an era are the widely-consumed mainstream products, not the incongruous outlier 'apex' works we retroactively celebrate.
“I always sense that the thing that really mattered was the thing that we did not even view as having that ancillary secondary meaning. They were just what was being consumed, and the ideas and the morals and the values within that.”
- Young people today tend to prefer Friends over Seinfeld, seeing Friends as timeless and dealing with universal problems, while Seinfeld feels rooted in a worldview that no longer exists.
“young people is that they tend to likeFriendsmore thanSeinfeld.They seeFriendsalmost as this timeless situation dealing with problems that everyone goes through, whereSeinfeldseems more rooted in this worldview that doesn’t exist as much anymore.”
- The 1990s were not a golden age of television (closer to the 1980s), and the second golden age in terms of content value actually came in the early 21st century with The Sopranos, The Wire, Mad Men, and Breaking Bad—shows that became generally superior to cinema, an unthinkable proposition at the start of the 1990s.
“the second golden age of television actually probably comes post ’90s, if we’re looking at the value of the content.”
Instant digital access and machine-driven cultural recall replaced human depth with vast shallow consumption.
- The post-2001 rise of social media and instant access means cultural recall (once the job of human 'minutiae rememberers') is now outsourced to machines, so instead of culture having depth, it becomes a shallow ocean that is vast but easy to wade into and scoop from without going deep.
“Now that it’s all so available, instead of culture having depth, it’s more like a real shallow ocean that’s very easy to wade into and scoop up whatever you need. It’s vast, but it doesn’t go deep.”
Reputation distortions and political positioning retroactively obscure genuine artistic significance and accomplishment.
- Žižek may be both overrated and underrated: his fame far exceeds that of most philosophers, but his ideas themselves may be underrated because his notoriety—and his habit of discussing commercial culture like Titanic or reviewing The Matrix without seeing it—is used against him, building the assumption that attention-grabbing ideas cannot be genuinely meaningful, much as Evan Dando's obvious good looks led people to dismiss his songwriting.
“his notoriety is very often used against him. The fact that he’ll talk aboutTitanicor whatever in this very commercial way builds in this assumption that these ideas must not be really meaningful as much as they are attention-grabbing.”
- Eric Clapton was overrated for decades but has now become underrated because his anti-lockdown political position has led people to retroactively decide that even Cream and Derek and the Dominos were bad, obscuring that he is probably the most significant white blues guitar player of all time—an example of how political reputation distorts artistic assessment.
“overrated forever, and now underrated because of his political position in the sense that people now have decided that not only do they not like him, but that somehowCreamwas bad and thatDerek and the Dominoswas bad.”
- Books about past decades typically feel obligated to contradict popular perception ('we thought the '70s were boring, actually there was tumult'), but for the 1990s this would produce a misshapen view; the harder and more valuable task is to describe what it felt like to experience the time without retrofitting present ideology onto it.
“My goal in this was to write a book that was not looking at the ’90s the way we think about the culture now, and jamming that retrospective view into a modern ideology, but to go back and try to capture what it actually felt like to experience that time.”
- Teaching American studies in East Germany revealed that German students perceived America as having essentially no culture, yet loved hip-hop while categorizing it as 'immigrant culture' rather than American culture—illustrating that the greatest value of travel is the deeper understanding you gain of your own home from how it is perceived elsewhere.
“they perceive America as having no culture, but it was crazy because they all loved hip-hop. I would be like, “Well, hip-hop is American culture.” And they’d be like, “Oh, no, that’s an immigrant culture.””
- Žižek wrote a good review of the new Matrix movie and admitted at the end that he had not seen it, claiming this proved his point—an epitome of his stance that one can find meaning in a cultural object that lies entirely outside the object itself, so much so that you need not engage with the thing directly.
“He recentlyreviewed the newMatrixmovie. It was this really good review, and then at the end, he’s like, “Also, I have not seenMatrix, and that proves my point.””
Sport changes due to structural incentives: one-and-done athletes, gambling integration, and championship obsession.
- College basketball declined because the best players now stay the shortest time (one-and-done), so coaches can no longer imprint a multi-year identity the way Wooden, Knight, Dean Smith, and Thompson did; Calipari's success at Kentucky proved that assembling the best high-school talent for a single year—making the college game an extension of AAU rather than high-school basketball—is now the optimal team-building strategy.
“Because the best players play the shortest amount of time, it is real difficult to get a sense of what these guys are like and what the coach is trying to do beyond succeed.”
- Faced with the fear that sports might splinter and recede from the culture, leagues embraced gambling as the solution because gambling makes people who don't otherwise care about a game care a lot, thereby keeping sports as popular as ever.
“there was this fear that sports might become so splintered that it could recede from the culture, and they had to find a way to keep it as popular as it ever was. And gambling was the answer because gambling makes people who don’t care, care a lot.”
- Pro basketball has adopted the curious perception that winning a championship matters almost too much, so that a player who has not won a title cannot be classified as great; because only five players are on the floor, the best player gets credited with team success or failure, which skews greatness assessments, fuels late-career 'ring chasing,' and even leads players like Wilt Chamberlain to be ranked outside the top five despite unthinkable statistics.
“pro basketball has also adopted this — maybe predictable but also curious — perception that winning a championship matters almost too much now. If you have not won a title, you can’t be classified as a great player.”
- The Tim Donaghy scandal revealed that a referee can dictate a game's outcome and manipulate the betting spread invisibly—not by inventing fouls, but simply by accurately calling rules that are normally ignored (traveling, lane violations on free throws)—making officiating the most dangerous fragility point for sports betting integrity.
“a referee can dictate the outcome of a game, simply by calling the game straight in the sense that they don’t have to create fouls”
- High player compensation now makes bribing pro athletes to throw games or manipulate spreads irrational, since the payment required to outweigh the risk against existing salaries is enormous; the real vulnerability lies with mid-major and small college teams, where players are unpaid and a modest sum could be worth their time.
“the amount of money you’d have to pay these guys to make it worth the risk is huge. At college, harder to say.”
Writers must develop unteachable voice by extracting maximum meaning from their own authentic constraints.
- The most important quality of writing is voice, which is unteachable because it already exists inside you and must be pulled out rather than found by imitating other writers; you only become a writer when you no longer want to be like other writers, and teaching can only move mechanical skill up one level (mediocre to okay, okay to good) but cannot transform the experience for readers.
“the most important quality of writing, in my view at least, is the unteachable element, which is voice... your voice exists inside of you. You just have to pull it out. You’re not finding it.”
- The paradoxical goal of accessible writing is to make the reader feel as if they are writing the book as they read it—but if you succeed at this, the prose hits so directly that readers assume they thought of the ideas themselves, and therefore conclude the writing is bad, so becoming accessible to a fault can undermine perceived skill.
“the weird goal is to make the person feel like they’re writing the book as they read it. But if you succeed at that goal, they’re going to think you’re a bad writer. It’s strange.”
Self-awareness of limitation can paradoxically become the belief system that destroys you.
- The Portland Trail Blazers collapsed because both the team and fan base internalized the belief that they could never win a title or escape the Western Conference; once that self-awareness of their limitation became the foundational idea of the team, it caused the collapse—illustrating the general principle that self-awareness of one's ceiling is often what destroys you.
“Once that belief became the foundational idea of the team, it just collapsed.”
- Klosterman feels trapped in a perpetual now, finding it hard to think about his life in the future but very easy to fixate on his past, and despite having achieved every dream many times over (12 books written), he is not satisfied because in some fundamental way a person stays the same.
“I feel like I’m almost trapped in this perpetual now, where it’s hard for me to think about my life in the future but very easy to fixate on my life in the past.”
Charisma is one of the realest human qualities, transmissible through some performers but not others.
- Despite being treated as an imaginary construct like 'grit' or 'authenticity,' charisma is one of the realest things in the experience of being alive: some people are completely different in person than on a screen or page, while a rare few can transmit charisma through the screen, and it is the most attractive and desirable quality a performer can have—analogous to how voice functions in writing.
“charisma is one of the realest things in the experience of being alive.”
- Grantland was an almost unrealistic environment for a writer because it told writers 'we want you to be you,' getting the best writers and letting them pursue stories with no obvious demand (like a three-on-five 1980s junior college game); this produced both forgettable junk and the most memorable best parts.
“From the perspective of being a writer,Grantlandis almost an unrealistic scenario. “We want you to be you.””
Institutional durability, not individual backgrounds, sustains genuine rivalry and identity across generations.
- Genuine pro sports rivalries like Celtics-Lakers in the 1980s required two dynastic teams that were simultaneously the best in the league and diametrically different (race, playing style, coast), which is nearly impossible now—especially in the NFL, which is engineered for parity—whereas college rivalries (Michigan-Ohio State, Auburn-Alabama) persist because they rest on durable institutional identities players adopt regardless of their own backgrounds.
“you had these two dynastic teams that were also completely different, even to the most casual viewer. Race was part of it, but also playing style.”
- Sports culture emotionally rewards players who are obnoxious or attention-seeking by perceiving them as more dedicated and intense, while quiet players are dismissed as lacking emotional leadership—a confused proxy, since trash-talkers like Baker Mayfield are read as committed while reserved players like Justin Herbert were doubted, even though Larry Bird was both a quiet-seeming icon and a relentless trash-talker.
“in sports, we actually reward people emotionally if they are obnoxious. I remember when Justin Herbert came out of college, people didn’t want to draft him because they were like, “He’s not an emotional leader.””
Names and intrinsic qualities shape life outcomes despite having no inherent meaning.
- A name is simultaneously the most and least important thing about a person: any name can work and means nothing intrinsically (you could name a kid 'Stick' and nothing would differ), yet whatever you choose follows that person for their entire life and may subtly shape how seriously they are taken (Charles vs Chuck).
“It’s themostandleastimportant thing about you. It really is.”
- Having kids seemingly resolves the nature-versus-nurture debate in favor of nature: siblings with the same parents and identical experiences turn out strikingly different, which suggests it is their nature that makes them different while the shared experience of society generally makes people more similar—though this is hard to say publicly without being accused of eugenics.
“having kids does seemingly solve the nature versus nurture thing. It seems like nature.”
- Cultural forms that seem foreign—British bands like the Beatles and Led Zeppelin, Japanese pop, Swedish pop, even General Tso's chicken—are so integrated into American culture that consuming them as 'the other' is actually consuming a form of ourselves; Led Zeppelin even seems more part of American culture than UK culture.
“Like the Beatles seem like part of American culture. Led Zeppelin seems like part of American culture. In fact, Led Zeppelin seems more like it’s part of American culture than UK culture.”