What this covers
Tyler Cowen interviews Camille Paglia on her critique of contemporary intellectual life, her philosophy of art and criticism, and her unconventional positions within feminist thought. The conversation ranges widely—from David Bowie to architecture to Star Wars—but organizes around several core arguments: that academic theory, particularly poststructuralism, has degraded scholarship and produced ignorant graduates; that second-wave feminism under Gloria Steinem's influence wrongly rejected biology and antagonized men, suppressing Paglia's own Equal-Opportunity Feminism; and that vitality in thought and art comes from Close Reading of actual works, Constant Observation of ordinary life, and refusal to withdraw into elite institutions.
The discussion moves through her methods—why writers need real jobs, why boredom signals personal failure rather than circumstance, her research into the decline of art scholarship across centuries—alongside specific cultural judgments. She argues that Cultural Cycles render current decadence cyclical rather than terminal, that the Stones and Beatles drew from fundamentally different musical traditions, and that art can be both great and morally troubling. On gender and sexuality, she traces how David Bowie and Madonna opened space for her suppressed wing of feminism, contrasts early career women like Amelia Earhart (who admired men) with second-wave rhetoric of complaint, and indicts the modern technological world—not patriarchy—for extending an unnatural limbo of female dependence. She critiques how animism and metaphysical vision get erased when ethnic studies becomes politicized narrative, and warns that visual fragmentation is reshaping children's capacity for sequential reasoning. Throughout, she emphasizes Aesthetic Autonomy and the primacy of direct engagement with the work itself over theoretical apparatus.
Paglia argues that contemporary elite culture has flattened intellectual and artistic life through theory-driven academia, the politicization of feminism, and the denial of biological/natural reality, and that vitality comes instead from close observation, ordinary life, metaphysical vision, and engagement with the actual artwork.
- Academic theory (Foucault, poststructuralism) has destroyed scholarship and produced graduates who know nothing
- Second-wave 'Steinem' feminism wrongly denied biology and bad-mouthed men, suppressing her pro-sex equal-opportunity wing
- Writers and thinkers should keep real jobs and observe ordinary life rather than withdraw into elite cocoons
Educational institutions and parenting have failed to prepare young people for real life and adversity.
- A failure of parenting that raises children in a bourgeois pampered cocoon, unprepared for real life, is the reason campuses are full of hypersensitive young people who run shrieking from offense or stage protest spectacles.
“the reason we have that is because the parents have not prepared them for real life. In other words, they’ve been raised in this bourgeois, pampered cocoon.”
- Sending young people abroad to be exposed to the world is a valuable use of education money, but online education fails because students need a live person who can talk extemporaneously and respond to the moment rather than reading the same lecture repeatedly.
“I think that you need a live person, and you need a live person who can talk extemporaneously and respond to the moment. Not just people who are reading the same old damn lecture over and over again.”
- Universities erode masculinity and label anything masculine as toxic and intrinsic to rape culture because diminishing strong men allows women to be weak; strong women are needed to deal with masculine men, so demolishing masculinity produces weak men and weak women alike.
“That is why masculinity is constantly being eroded, diminished, and dissolved on university campuses because it allows women to be weak. If you have weak men, then you can have weak women.”
- The upper-middle-class graduates of the Ivy League are like the bland, idea-less Eloi of The Time Machine, getting along because they are nothing and being fed by the industrial Morlock class.
“That’s how I see the upper middle class graduates of the Ivy League. They’re the Eloi. They’re completely bland. They have no ideas.”
- Ivy League teaching trains students to talk pretentiously and impress one another in small seminars, packaging them for the bourgeoisie and producing polished, witless clones who know nothing.
“They’re so proud of themselves as they produce all these clones, these polished, bourgeois clones, witless, knowing nothing.”
- The volcano planet climax of Revenge of the Sith is one of the greatest sequences in all of modern art, but critics dismiss the prequels because they gave up on the films before seeing this scene.
“after the great volcano planet climax of Revenge of the Sith. I think it’s one of the greatest sequences in all of modern art.”
- Persisting through adversity and rejection while continuing to develop one's craft is essential; her own Sexual Personae was rejected by seven publishers and five agents and only published when she was 43, making her a role model for perseverance.
“Sexual Personae was rejected by seven publishers and five agents. By the time it was published, I was 43 years old. I’m a great role model... for people to just soldier through adversity and rejection.”
- LSD gave people genuine vision but deprived them of the ability to translate that vision into material form for the present and posterity, so those who took it never attained the level of accomplishment they should have.
“I think LSD gave vision. It gave vision, but then it deprived people of the ability to translate that vision into material form for the present and for posterity.”
- Claiming that climate change is causing the end of the world reflects a failure to understand the grandeur and power of nature, and the idea that humans can make a meaningful change in nature is absurd.
“Anyone who talks like that does not understand the grandeur and the power of nature. To imagine that we can make a change in it is so absolutely absurd.”
- The 1920s-30s career women like Amelia Earhart, Dorothy Parker, and Clare Boothe Luce did not bad-mouth men; they admired men and demanded equal opportunity to achieve at the same level, which is fundamentally different from second-wave feminism's tone of complaining about men and patriarchy.
“These women, like Amelia Earhart, they did not bad mouth men. They admired men. They admired what men had done. What they said was, “We demand equal opportunity for women.””
Current culture suffers visual fragmentation, formulaic production, and pallid mediocrity that stifles genuine artistic development.
- The avalanche of fragmented, disconnected, badly designed visual impressions that young people grow up in is reshaping children's brains, eroding their capacity for logic, sequential information, and reasoning.
“I think it really is true that children’s brains are being reshaped. The standard forms for logic and for sequential information and for reasoning, everything’s kind of disappearing.”
- We are in a retro period of tremendous cultural flattening where little of substance or interest is being produced, and everything from the past is being chopped up and run through the grinder again.
“We’re in a retro period. We’re chopping up everything, putting everything from the past through the grinder again.”
- Football has become more boring and technocratic, replacing hard hits and the art of defense with constant throwing and ballerina-like catching, and television no longer shows the great defensive plays.
“Now, football is getting more and more boring. It’s gotten more and more technocratic.”
- Large arena rock concerts with their light shows have become social experiences rather than musical experiences.
“They’re not musical experiences. They’re social experiences now.”
- The contemporary music industry is so formulaic that young people cannot study their instruments and develop their chops over time, and they lack a rooted tradition like folk music to draw on, leaving talented artists like Rihanna undeveloped.
“It’s because our music industry is now very formulaic. Young people can’t really move along studying their instruments and getting their chops over a period of time.”
- Androgyny historically carried imaginative complexity, embodied by the artist, shaman, and prophet, and David Bowie at his height was brilliant and electrifying, but today's pallid androgynes are boring and have nothing creative about them.
“David Bowie, at his height, was absolutely brilliant, electrifying, kabuki... Now, all these pallid androgynes of today, there’s nothing creative about them whatever.”
- Cultures organized around an ideal of consensus, as in Canada and Norway, are very civilized but make it impossible to rise above the herd, since any big gesture or independent opinion is regarded as antisocial.
“Everyone is very civilized in Canada, but it’s impossible to rise above the herd, also. You can’t make any big gestures; you’re thought to be antisocial.”
- The Rolling Stones were animated by the dark blues tradition while the Beatles drew on British music hall, Tin Pan Alley, and musical comedy, making the Beatles tremendous songsmiths but never dark in the way the Stones were.
“The Rolling Stones are inspired by, animated by, to this day, by the blues tradition. The Beatles really were more almost Broadway and musical comedy.”
Ideological politicization and moral purity tests damage cultural discourse by obscuring genuine insight and artistic judgment.
- The Marxist approach is useful for attending to social context but lacks a larger vision of the universe and cannot even see nature; it can only see society, leaving fundamental questions about human life unaddressed.
“But what Marxism lacks is that larger vision of the universe. There are all kinds of questions and issues about human life that Marxism has no answers for. It doesn’t even see it. It doesn’t see nature.”
- The politicization of ethnic and racial studies has been very limiting, projecting an eternal narrative of genocide and disaster onto Native American studies and obscuring the actual religious, metaphysical, animistic vision of Native American culture.
“What I’m trying to do is show how the politicization of ethnic studies, of racial studies, and so on has actually been very limiting.”
- The feminist position that nothing which demeans women can be art is a Stalinist view of art; a song like the Stones' 'Under My Thumb' can be both sexist and a great work of art.
“These women, they said to me... “Art! Art! Nothing that demeans women can be art!” Now that is a Stalinist view of art!”
- Kate Millett and philistine feminists in the early 1970s caused a sweeping away of major male literary figures including Faulkner, Hemingway, and D.H. Lawrence from the cultural canon, so young people no longer read the great authors.
“Thanks to Kate Millett and all these philistine feminist types in the early ’70s, there was a great sweeping away of many, many major male figures in the history of literature including Ernest Hemingway, D. H. Lawrence.”
- The mission of criticism is paying minute attention to the actual work itself, going through a film or text scene by scene, rather than forcing theory onto students before they encounter what is imaginative in the history of art.
“I believe that paying minute attention to the actual work itself is the mission of criticism. I am hopelessly old-fashioned.”
- Spenser's The Faerie Queene, long taught in a moralistic way and now forgotten, is in fact entirely a work of pornography equal to the Marquis de Sade, despite its enormous impact on Shakespeare and the Romantic poets.
“The Faerie Queene had been taught in this very moralistic way. But in my chapter, I showed that it was entirely a work of pornography, equal to the Marquis de Sade.”
- One should keep a respectful distance from great artists because what they represent on screen is an artificial construction, the temenos or sacred precinct of art, distinct from the fallible mundane real self; encountering Catherine Deneuve in person nearly ruined Paglia's interest because the magical creation, not the real woman, was what she admired.
“I completely understand the difference between the fallible real self, the mundane real self, and the artistic self suddenly emerges within what I call the temenos, which is the sacred precinct that I regard as art.”
- Contemporary fiction writers are off in another world, do not see the world as it exists now, and use stale, cloistered English, making their work unreadable to her.
“The fiction writers are off in another world. They don’t see the world as it exists now. They don’t use the language of the contemporary world. Their English is utterly stale and cloistered.”
Artistic greatness depends on historical timing and confluence; it cannot be manufactured at will in any era.
- Culture always moves in cycles, alternating between periods that esteem the colossal (Renaissance, Baroque) and periods of the small and evanescent (Rococo), suggesting current decadence is part of a recurring pattern rather than permanent decline.
“I would say that a culture always moves in cycles. You have periods that esteem the colossal, like the Bernini Renaissance and Baroque periods. Then you get the small, the art of the small.”
- Certain magic moments of fertility and creativity occur when a confluence of influences and richness coincide; Shakespeare would not be Shakespeare today because he arrived in London during a brief flourishing of theater, so artistic greatness depends on being the right person at the right time.
“Shakespeare would not be Shakespeare if he were alive today. As it happens, he left Stratford... went to London at a magic moment when theater was flourishing, which was only for a few decades, and then it was out again.”
True intellectuals must transcend partisanship and maintain independent judgment even against their own allies.
- A true intellectual should always be beyond partisanship, freely critiquing the premises of one's own friends and allies; she identifies as a libertarian Democrat who criticizes both liberals and conservatives.
“I think a true intellectual should be always beyond partisanship.”
- The basis of her work is constant 24/7 observation of ordinary life rather than academic insulation, including listening to working-class voices on sports radio talk shows, which shapes her high-impact writing voice rather than recherché novelistic lingo.
“I feel that the basis of my work is not only the care I take with writing... but also my observation. It’s 24/7. I’m always observing. I don’t sit in a university. I never go to conferences.”
Intellectual vitality requires remaining rooted in ordinary life and material reality rather than elite detachment.
- Aspiring writers and thinkers should keep a real job that confronts them with constant frustrations and problems, because withdrawing from the world to be a writer is a terrible mistake and the frustrations of real work keep one in touch with reality as everybody lives it.
“Get a job. Have a job... This thing of withdrawing from the world to be a writer, I think, is a terrible mistake.”
- Susan Sontag became a detached luminary floating from lecture to lecture and dinner party to dinner party, and as a result her work grew less and less meaningful over time and she is essentially unquotable, the lone exception being a sentence she regretted; her best work was early and engaged with actual material.
“Susan Sontag over time, her work got less and less meaningful, even though people worship at the shrine of Sontag. You try to quote her on anything. What can you quote her on? There’s nothing important.”
- After becoming known at 43 she deliberately changed nothing about her ordinary life, staying a 'schoolmarm' dealing with janitors and infrastructure rather than chasing elite party life, because the closeness with which she lives to ordinary life is the basis of her work.
“I didn’t change one thing about my life... Because I know that the basis of my work is the closeness with which I live to ordinary life.”
- Marshall McLuhan was a prophetic tech guru with insight into what was about to happen with media, serving as the patron saint of her early work on the web from Salon's first issue in 1995.
“My last big tech guru was probably Marshall McLuhan. Had a prophetic insight into what was about to happen.”
Women's career and life choices stem from biological maternal ties and voluntary trade-offs, not systemic discrimination.
- The reported gender pay gap does not reflect unequal pay for the same work, which has been illegal since JFK, but rather women's own voluntary choices toward more flexible jobs closer to their children and away from high-earning commission and on-the-road jobs, and these choices are ultimately based in biological differences and the maternal tie.
“if women are earning 72 cents or 75 cents on the dollar, it’s not for the same job. This is the lie that’s being told... the averages of women, of their own volition... are taking jobs that have more flexibility.”
- Humans evolved over tens of thousands of years to mate early and form households young, but the modern technological professional world that replaced the multigenerational agrarian period imposes an unnaturally long limbo before women can attain a sense of who they are, and this mechanical system, not men or patriarchy, is the source of much female unhappiness.
“we have lived as a species for tens of thousands of year, where mating occurred early... In this life, we have a very long, an unnaturally long period here, before women can attain some sense of who they are as women.”
- There is an ineffable biological tie between an infant and the mother in whose body it developed, so infants want the mother not the father; from this Paglia observes that mothers biologically become the master strategist 'generalissimo' of the household while fathers become hopeless secondary helpers, meaning asking men to do equal infant care asks something they are not biologically prepared for.
“there is an ineffable, indefinable, biological tie between a child and the mother in whose body the child has developed into a full being... An infant doesn’t want the father, hello. The infant wants the mother.”
- Assimilation is always a loss; gay male culture once had a distinct flamboyant aesthetic, style, and voice that is disappearing as it assimilates and domesticates, just as Italian-American culture has vanished.
“I don’t know. Assimilation is always a loss. Certainly, my culture experienced it. Italian-American culture has kind of vanished, too.”
Scholarship and cultural commentary have declined sharply in erudition and quality since the early twentieth century.
- Researching prior commentary on each artwork in Glittering Images chronologically revealed an objective, demonstrable fall in the quality of scholarship from the 1980s on, declining from erudite, beautifully written art commentary of the late 19th and early 20th century to the work of present-day 'pygmies' at elite schools.
“could you see the fall in the quality of scholarship in our time from the 1980s on. I would move from these incredibly erudite and wonderful sentences... to about the ’60s. And then the ’70s... All of a sudden comes the ’80s, ’90s, 2000s. All these people are pygmies.”
- Foucault was not an innovative figure but merely a collection of influences, one of the biggest being the sociologist Erving Goffman's The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life; the worship of Foucault in every gender studies department is a disease that produces graduates who know nothing.
“he pretends to be such a mastermind, but in fact he’s just a collection of influences and one of the biggest influences on him was Erving Goffman... who wrote The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.”
- The truncated text and email formats and the blah-blah of blog writing are degrading the general respect for and ear for language, whereas the old space limits of newspapers and magazines imposed a format that forced condensation and gave crispness to language.
“It used to be with newspapers and magazines, there was a space limit, and that imposed a real kind of format. It forced you to condense, and it gave a crispness to language.”
Capitalism enabled women's independence while distinct cultural identities and multiculturalism have intrinsic value.
- The Western world powered by capitalism made women's emancipation possible by allowing women to be self-supporting and live independently, replacing the prior condition of total dependence on father, husband, or brother, yet university curricula habitually demean capitalism.
“Now, women can be self-supporting, can live totally on their own. It’s part of this whole Western world powered by capitalism that our university curricula are now habitually always demeaning. Capitalism made women’s emancipation possible.”
- True multiculturalism requires presenting world cultures including religion, because the great religions of the world are the most complex systems human beings have ever devised.
“if you want true multiculturalism, you have to present world cultures, including religion. Religion is extremely important — the most complex systems human beings have ever devised were the great religions of the world.”
- David Bowie was truly a creative artist and master creator of a staggering level, distinct from Deneuve and Elizabeth Taylor who are performers in other people's fictions, and his deep erudition about and influence from the visual arts has been little acknowledged.
“Bowie is different than Deneuve. Bowie is truly like a creative artist, whereas Deneuve and Taylor are performers in other people’s fictions. But Bowie was truly a master creator.”
- Her dissident pro-sex wing of feminism, suppressed and silenced for 25 years, finally broke through the over-control of the 'Steinem politburo' in the 1990s because Madonna's foregrounding of sexual themes opened the way, even though Madonna was not a feminist.
“Eventually, we won in the ’90s, the pro-sex wing of feminism, thanks to Madonna, who wasn’t a feminist. But because of Madonna’s foregrounding of sexual themes... it allowed us to break through the over-control by the Steinem politburo.”
- Given the demolition of Palmyra and ISIS destruction, her attitude has shifted to keeping contested antiquities like the Nefertiti bust in safe locations such as Berlin rather than repatriating them to their countries of origin.
“with what’s been happening with ISIS, and the demolition of Palmyra... my attitude now is keep Nefertiti in Berlin, please. Don’t send it back to Cairo.”
Gay male culture experienced catastrophic loss through AIDS and continues losing distinctive aesthetic identity through assimilation.
- AIDS functioned like a Holocaust for gay male culture, killing a generation of fascinating, talented men in fashion and the arts, so that gay culture is in many ways still recovering and in a holding pattern.
“I think that AIDS was like a Holocaust. The number of interesting, fascinating, talented men and artists and people in fashion and every level.”
- Brazil sits in its own world because it was not part of the world wars, lacks a huge militaristic superstructure, and lacks a messianic political self-image, with politics that are chaotic and operatic like grand opera.
“It’s not been part of the world wars. It doesn’t have this huge militaristic superstructure. It doesn’t have a messianic view of itself politically. The politics are always chaos and drama.”
- Established journalists did not take the web seriously in its early days, with one major Boston Globe political reporter pressuring her not to write for the web.
“There was a major political reporter at the Boston Globe... who tried to pressure me not to write for the web. He said, “Oh, no one takes the web seriously.””
- Nothing is boring; if you are bored you are boring, so every experience, even a canceled flight, contains something to absorb through observing others that can eventually be used in one's developing system of thought.
“nothing is boring. Nothing is boring. If you’re bored, you’re boring.”
- She is directly inspired by music, particularly epic film scores, which animate her to assert and conquer and which directly inspired her writing of Sexual Personae.
“It directly inspired my writing of Sexual Personae, absolutely. I’m directly inspired by music.”