What this covers
Brian Koppelman, screenwriter and novelist, walks through the conditions that make great storytelling work across film and television, treating the subject as part craft analysis and part philosophy. He argues that the alchemy of successful art depends on a rare alignment: a concept that captures its moment, a writer with authentic purpose and genuine talent, and then the ineffable chemistry among actors, camera, and words that may or may not ignite even when all the ingredients are present. The conversation centers on how audiences encounter and appreciate difficult or demanding work—what separates those who engage with challenging cinema from those who don't, and whether the capacity to be moved by art is something that can be learned or must be met with openness.
Koppelman ranges across specific artistic decisions: why Wes Anderson keeps his films to ninety minutes while Tarantino and Paul Thomas Anderson expand their vision across longer canvases, how Rian Johnson specifies the exact technical conditions under which his films should be viewed, and why shows like Mad Men reward weekly watching over bingeing. He returns often to the relationship between artist and audience, drawing on figures like Bob Dylan and Haruki Murakami to illustrate how the greatest artists serve only their inner voice while remaining attentive to whether the audience can follow. A thread about impermanence and mortality runs through major works—particularly those that genuinely endure—and appears connected to why some viewers instinctively resist certain kinds of art. The conversation also touches on poker as a discipline, South Korean cinema's particular charge, and the logistics of movie theater sound and picture.
Koppelman argues that great storytelling art across film, TV, and literature is a 'magical alchemy' that depends on talented makers serving their own authentic voice while never forgetting the audience, and that appreciating it is partly a matter of openness and the willingness to confront impermanence.
- Great television and film require a rare convergence of concept, writer's purpose, and on-set chemistry that cannot be reliably engineered
- The artists who endure (Dylan, Murakami) serve only their inner voice while still entertaining the audience
- Whether smart people 'get' difficult art depends on openness and willingness to engage with impermanence and death
Creating great television and film requires rare alignment of concept, writer purpose, and magical execution among words, camera, and actors.
- Truly great television is rare because so much must align at once: a concept that captures the moment in time, a writer with an incredibly clear sense of purpose and the talent and readiness to deliver, and then a magical alchemy among the words, the camera, and the actors that may or may not take flight even with talented people.
“It needs to have a writer or writers with an incredibly clear sense of purpose, and they have to be talented enough and ready to give what it takes. Then the magical alchemy of their words, the camera, and that group of actors has to take flight.”
- Television's modern Golden Age grew out of network high points like Hill Street Blues and NYPD Blue, where showrunners borrowed techniques from theater, cinema, and novels; once those innovations connected commercially, the industry recognized what was possible and the showrunner-driven revolution followed.
“Hill Street Blues shows up in the ’80s and, I think, figures out how to use certain techniques of theater and cinema and novels to tell these TV stories. Like any other business, when that started to connect, then people in the business started to become aware of what was possible.”
- Television is fundamentally a writer's medium, so to get great work you must incentivize and reward writers enough that they are willing to turn themselves inside out to create amazing stuff.
“I do think, on the whole, television is a writer’s medium, and that you need to incentivize and reward writers to be willing to turn themselves inside out to create amazing stuff.”
Artists must protect their inner voice and artistic integrity against external pressures, commercial trends, and audience expectation.
- The right kind of artistic reinvention is not changing yourself to fit the times (the Bowie model), but reinventing yourself because your inner voice tells you that's what you need to do to stay an artist.
“not reinvent yourself to fit the times, but be willing to reinvent yourself because it’s what your inner voice is telling you you need to do to stay an artist”
- The core lesson of Bob Dylan's six-decade career is that none of the externalities matter: he always found a way to hear only his own voice, took pressure off himself from any external force, and had the confidence to produce that voice only for the audience willing to try to hear it—a discipline almost impossible to sustain, matched only by figures like Miles Davis and Chuck Berry.
“at core, he is this writer who always found a way to hear only his own voice and to have the confidence and comfort to then serve and produce that voice only for those people who were willing to try to hear it.”
- People in the movie business aren't necessarily happier than average and the field may not draw happy people, but the joy and 'taking flight' happens specifically in the act of making something you care about—on set doing the work—rather than in the surrounding pressures of the career.
“When engaged in the work. On set, doing the work — that’s the time that people are really taking flight.”
Experiencing art fully requires the right conditions: solo, attentive viewing or listening that lets audiences notice details and reflect privately.
- Watching a film a second time alone is uniquely valuable because the first time you're swept up sharing reactions with a companion, but the second solo viewing—knowing the story already—lets you privately notice details, take your time with them, and pursue specific questions about how the filmmaker achieved effects.
“Then the next time, when I’m alone, I’ve seen it, so it’s not about just being swept away, and it’s not about being analytical. It is about allowing myself, in a very private way, to notice things and then take my time noticing them”
- Whether a show rewards bingeing depends on its construction: shows like The Crown accrete and are built to binge, while shows full of quiet moments, visual symbolism, and semiotics like Mad Men reward weekly watching with time to walk away and reflect.
“I feel like The Crown is built to binge, and the way that it accretes really works in a binge model.”
- Modern televisions are high quality but people get screwed up by the default settings, which are tuned for watching sports; you should consult cinematographers' recommendations (e.g., Rian Johnson's published specs) and turn off the sports-oriented processing to restore the picture to how filmmakers intended.
“Where people get screwed up is in the settings. You’ve got to go in there, you’ve got to read, go pull up a cinematography magazine, and just pull up what cinematographers tell you.”
- To improve the movie theater experience, the priority should be a large immersive screen and faithful reproduction of the exact sound and picture conditions the filmmaker last had when they approved the film—correct brightness, working speakers, and proper sound ratio—achieved by people in the theater genuinely caring.
“Whatever you need to do in the movie theater to recreate the experience that they last had when they approved it, sound and picture.”
- An author—especially one whose voice is familiar from a podcast—should insist on narrating their own audiobook, because listeners want to feel the author's intonation, and a professional reader can make the work sound alien even if it sells better.
“I really want authors reading their own books, and I want to feel the intonation from the author, particularly someone whose voice is so familiar to people now from the podcast.”
Form and length should serve the artist's vision and concept rather than commercial formula or arbitrary convention.
- Movies being long isn't inherently bad—like a double album, the extra material exists for a reason when the artist is masterful (Tarantino, PTA), and masterful filmmakers should be given room to fully exercise their vision; the issue is whether the concept supports the length, as Wes Anderson keeps his films to 90 minutes because his concepts don't support a longer journey.
“I think when somebody is a masterful artist, like PTA, let’s give them the room to do that.”
- Murakami's miraculous gift is that while he is completely consumed with the personal—making works fully live as expressions of how he feels and sees the world—he never forgets the reader, making every page entertaining; this combination is why Koppelman considers him the living writer who most captures his imagination.
“his incredible, magical, mysterious gift is that he makes every page entertaining for you, the reader.”
- Comedy stands the test of time less well than drama partly because it is of its time and the culture absorbs and normalizes its innovations (e.g., Steve Martin's albums now seem unsurprising because the world took what he did), though genuinely great comedy like The Thin Man, Stripes, and Trading Places still works decades later, suggesting only truly great comedy lasts.
“You could try those albums on some younger people because the world took a lot of what he did. No part of what he did seems stunning or surprising now.”
Success in demanding fields like poker requires relentless daily discipline and study; happiness comes from the work itself, not career rewards.
- What most people don't know about a casual home poker game is that at least two of the rotating players are actually taking it almost as seriously as their job, which is why casual players consistently lose.
“what you don’t know is that at least two of those people actually are taking it almost as seriously as their job. That’s the thing that most people don’t know.”
- A nonobvious truth about poker is that you probably can't win: unless you're a gifted freak, you must study and engage with materials on how to be better at poker at least a little every day, like chess; even Koppelman, who does this daily, tracks his results and is merely flat in competitive games, which itself counts as a gigantic victory.
“if you don’t study and think about poker at least a little bit every day... I think about poker every day, and I am not a world-class poker player. I track my results very closely, and I’m flat.”
- The Upper West Side has long been a culinary wasteland (with Tatiana now an exception) for the practical reason that it is a neighborhood people move to in order to raise kids, so they go out to eat less and stay home, unlike the West Village, Lower East Side, Midtown East, or Koreatown.
“There are practical reasons, because that’s a neighborhood people move to to raise kids, and they’re not going out to eat as much. They’re at home.”
- Daryl Morey should trade Joel Embiid to the Knicks for draft picks because it would solve Philadelphia's problems, though Morey will want Brunson in return which the Knicks can't do.
“just take some draft picks and give us Joel Embiid. I think it solves all your problems.”
- From his father, Koppelman learned an egalitarian belief that no one is better than anyone else combined with the discipline to keep your eyes open because greatness could show up at any given moment in anyone.
“he had a really egalitarian idea about people’s capacity and that you had to keep your eyes open because greatness could show up at any given moment.”
- A wave of great South Korean films a decade ago was potent because, although the films never mentioned it, they were suffused with the unspoken psychic presence of North Korea as a bullying neighbor, giving them a charge of yearning for freedom and a sense of encroaching doom.
“part of why they were so potent was that they were suffused with that idea somewhere in the consciousness of the people making it. So, it had that kind of effect because you felt this need for freedom.”
- Listeners who have spent a lot of time with a podcast genuinely know a part of the host because the things that animate the host are so much a part of who they are.
“The things that animate me are so much a part of who I am that, in a sense, they do really know me, or they know a part of me, or they know me when I’m trying to access the part of me that’s most alive”
Great art engages profound human truths like impermanence and mortality, which audiences resist because the effect is genuinely mysterious and moving.
- Because we don't understand why certain frequencies or stories affect us, the effect that storytelling art has on us is effectively 'magic'; a great work can hit a naive listener as powerfully as an expert, so prior knowledge is not strictly required to be moved.
“the effect that storytelling art has is, in a sense — because we don’t understand why — it’s magic.”
- All the great works of art are in some way about impermanence and death (Bergman especially), and many people don't want to deal with impermanence, so they draw a line and resist art that affects them that deeply—distinct from a film like Heat, which has death but is really about consequences rather than impermanence.
“All the great works of art, in some way or another, are about impermanence, and people often don’t want to deal with impermanence.”
- What separates smart people who get movies from those who don't is openness and the ability not to analyze in real time; Casablanca works as a 'gateway' film because, unlike the portentous and slow Citizen Kane, it's fun from moment one and irresistible, so showing someone ten minutes of it hooks them into appreciating great cinema.
“Citizen Kane is portentous — not pretentious, but portentous, right? From the moment it starts, you understand you’re supposed to take something very seriously... Casablanca is a delight. I have never met anyone immune to Casablanca’s charms, so it’s a gateway into understanding what makes great cinema”