What this covers
Ashley Mears, a sociologist who worked as a fashion model, draws on fieldwork inside the VIP nightclub circuit to analyze how status operates in a specific corner of the economy. The conversation traces the structural arrangement through which beautiful women—recruited as unpaid labor by promoters—lend aesthetic value to clubs and restaurants catering to wealthy men, while receiving in return free meals, travel, access, and friendship rather than direct payment. Mears examines how this system persists not through coercion but through its opposite: participants find the arrangement pleasurable and socially meaningful, even as it generates substantial profits for clubs and exploits the unpaid bodily capital of the models themselves.
The conversation ranges across mechanisms of the party economy—how clubs manufacture collective effervescence through music and synchronized movement, how a promoter's cultivation of genuine intimacy makes the transaction feel like friendship, how the payment of cash would paradoxically destroy the desired experience by reframing leisure as labor. Mears also draws comparisons to academic life, arguing that universities reproduce similar patterns of uncompensated service work, disproportionate emotional labor from women, and structural inequity coexisting with subjective consent. She discusses how status consumption remains viable within a reference group regardless of outside judgment, traces the distinction between catwalk beauty and relatable commercial beauty, and revisits assumptions about the party circuit as a marriage market—it functions instead as a mechanism for building female social capital while simultaneously marking participants as unsuitable for serious partnerships. The discussion includes observations on how beauty standards shift between scarcity and plenty, and how the same structural dynamics appear across ostensibly meritocratic institutions.
Mears argues that the VIP party circuit is an organized economy in which the unpaid 'bodily capital' of fashion models is converted into status for wealthy men and profits for promoters, clubs, and adjacent industries—exploitation that persists precisely because it is made pleasurable and meaningful to its participants.
- Beautiful women function as status signals that clubs and restaurants deliberately stage through promoters
- Models accept non-cash perks because the arrangement is framed as leisure/friendship rather than labor
- Exploitation is most durable when consented to and experienced as fun, even as structural inequities remain
People participate willingly in exploitative systems when they find them pleasurable and meaningful, yet structural inequities persist even within subjective consent and can be challenged collectively.
- Bottle service rents a table with heavily marked-up alcohol, costing a single buyer $2,000-$3,000 or more, but for a group of five or six men splitting the cost the VIP treatment can actually be economical.
“There’s this huge price inflation on the bottles, so for a single person to do that, it could be a tab of $2,000, $3,000 on up.”
- The men who buy status in these clubs are predominantly young, affluent men whose money comes in quickly and goes out quickly—Wall Street bonus recipients, recent divorcees, and businesspeople using the clubs to bond—rather than all economic elites.
“People who get the bonus in Wall Street were a lot of the people that I met in these spaces. The people are in their 30s and their 40s, recent divorcees.”
- Critics correctly note that Bourdieu's framework reflects a dated 1970s-80s French notion of hierarchy that is itself hierarchical and addresses gender only belatedly, but it remains a huge contribution for inserting culture into class hierarchy, which is why cultural sociologists still pay homage.
“it was a huge contribution to insert culture into class hierarchy, so everybody pays homage for that reason.”
- Although academia is a winner-take-all field in terms of prestige, once you obtain a tenure-track job and especially tenure, it offers lifetime job security that cannot be revoked barring serious problems—making it far less volatile than cultural production fields like modeling where fortunes change day to day.
“Once you get a tenure-track job, and once you get tenure especially, you can’t be fired, barring some sort of real problems. It’s lifetime security”
- Mears's modeling and academic careers are not a rebellion but a continuation of the same pursuit: she was always first and foremost a student searching for status in winner-take-all hierarchies, and modeling functioned as a path toward the academic status she truly sought.
“In some ways, I’ve always been a student. First and foremost, my alignment was in academia. And I was always searching for the status and the winner-take-all hierarchy of academia.”
- The non-obvious signal of a promising young sociologist or anthropologist is having read a lot and read eclectic things, because that breadth indicates curiosity and the ability to bring diverse knowledge to whatever bizarre topic they end up studying.
“If somebody has read a lot, and if they’ve read eclectic things, and they have that kind of breadth, that strikes me because that means that they’re curious”
- The common reading that South Korean plastic surgery (e.g., world-leading double-eyelid surgery) reflects internalized white Western beauty hegemony is too simple; appearance modification is often experienced as validating and pleasurable, and within Asia people now look to K-Pop rather than the West as their beauty standard.
“This is often read as “Oh, this is like internalized white Western hegemony onto Asian people.” But I actually think it’s a bit more complicated than that.”
- The sociological finding that loose, arm's-length ties confer advantages is well-established and continually replicated within economic sociology, so it is neither overrated nor underrated but appropriately rated.
“it is one of the major findings within economic sociology that’s continually shown that there are all these advantages for having loose ties, arm’s-length ties.”
- The tenure clock overlaps badly with the biological clock for women who want families, so rather than abolishing tenure it could be lengthened, paused, or restarted; having kids in graduate school—where time is more flexible and the clock can be stretched—may actually be a more sensible plan than the conventional post-tenure timing.
“maybe change the terms of it so that the clock doesn’t completely overlap with the so-called biological clock for women who want to have families.”
- Rather than the individualistic advice typical of parenting literature, the best advice for parents in the US is to mobilize collectively, because the country is exceptionally unfriendly to family policy—lacking paid parental leave and state daycare support—a crisis the pandemic has made starkly visible.
“my advice for parents in this country is to mobilize. Because it’s a complete crisis that we don’t have paid parental leave”
Club girls perform disguised labor valuable to men and promoters by providing beauty-based status display while being systematically devalued as serious partners or professionals outside the venue.
- Women who look like fashion models are highly valuable inside the club for lending status but devalued outside it as 'party girls'—assumed to be unserious and just beautiful—so making the trade of beauty for access taints them as a pool of hookups rather than future wives or partners.
“they’re devalued for the assumption that they’re just beautiful... This is a pool of hookups.”
- Even if many party girls are smart, the physical setup of the club—low lights, loud music, the promoter keeping women at the table for status display—works against any woman trying to signal intellect or educational prestige, preventing the matching market from working.
“It becomes difficult to try to forge any kind of meaningful connection when the lights are low and the music is loud.”
- Trendy restaurants full of beautiful women have worse food because the women are brought in by hired promoters and fed free family-style leftovers (e.g., cucumber rolls, never sashimi) to set up an obligation to continue to the attached nightclub, validating the heuristic of avoiding such restaurants for food quality.
“there’s this whole organized system to bring them there. The restaurants and the clubs hire, on a contract basis, this group of people called promoters”
- The two things the club values most are money and beauty—specifically women's beauty and men's money—so any man with money is admitted, while celebrities may enter free because their mere presence adds value others can boast about.
“it’s women’s beauty and men’s money that make up the two things that the club wants inside”
- Despite cash being more economically efficient, women refuse to be paid to attend clubs because they want it to be fun leisure rather than work; accepting payment (e.g., $40-$80) is seen as desperate and ruins the night, so the labor is deliberately disguised as friendship and pleasure even though it generates large profits for promoters and clubs.
“the answer was always, “No, I don’t want it to be work. I want it to be fun. This is leisure, not labor.””
- Being a club girl most increases a woman's social capital and cosmopolitan friendship ties—especially to other women—convertible into future value, but it does not function as a marriage market for rich men, contrary to popular assumption.
“It might increase the most their social capital in the sense that they get more ties to people in different kinds of realms”
- In the VIP clubland catering to rich men, beautiful women function as a sign of high status, and the specific beauty valued is the rare fashion-industry standard: very tall, very thin, predominantly white, with a high-end magazine look.
“Beautiful women in the VIP clubland are a sign of status. And it’s a certain kind of beauty.”
The best promoters profit by cultivating genuine-seeming intimacy and friendship with women, making exploitation feel meaningful and voluntary rather than degrading.
- People participate in their own exploitation across many forms of work—including academics doing unpaid, uncompensated, unrecognized service work because they find it validating—and exploitation works best when it is pleasurable and made meaningful, yet structural inequities can still be challenged even when participants subjectively consent.
“exploitation works best when it’s pleasurable and when it’s made meaningful, but that doesn’t mean that the inequities can’t be challenged at a structural level”
- The best promoters avoid the experience feeling degrading by cultivating genuine-seeming intimacy and friendship with women—movies, bowling, picnics, sometimes romance—creating loyal relationships they then profit from, which is why women experience the arrangement as meaningful rather than exploitative.
“the promoters spend a lot of time developing intimacy and connections with the young women. They talk about each other as friends.”
- In this world there is a widespread assumption that everybody uses everybody else—women use the club and promoters, promoters use the women, clients use promoters—and mutual exploitation is accepted; the drawing line is abuse, specifically a promoter lying about exclusive romantic intentions while sleeping with multiple models.
“there’s a widespread assumption that everybody uses everybody else.”
Academia reproduces gender, class, and race inequities despite meritocratic ideals, demanding disproportionate emotional labor from women and people of color while favoring well-connected candidates.
- Women professors, especially younger ones, perform disproportionate emotional labor—fielding more requests for grade exceptions, more students opening up about problems, and keeping tissues for crying students—because they are seen as more relatable by virtue of gender and age.
“we’re more likely, I think, to keep tissues in our offices for crying students than our male colleagues”
- Looks matter everywhere including academia, where for women beauty is a double-edged sword: conforming to beauty norms helps (a halo effect easing emails, meetings, and how much people listen), but overdoing it reads as too sexual and unprofessional, so Mears was coached to dress drably to assert authority and distance herself from her modeling past.
“having beauty definitely eases the way for people to respond more favorably to me because of that halo effect of beauty.”
- Academia, especially sociology, portends to be meritocratic and is attuned to inequalities of gender, class, and race, yet it reproduces those very inequities—disproportionate emotional and service labor by women and people of color, and hiring biases that favor candidates tied to prominent people or Ivy universities.
“even though we’re supposedly all about equity, it’s just the fact that somebody who is tied to a prominent person or an Ivy university will catch our eye.”
Clubs engineer collective pleasure through loud music and rhythm to manufacture shared effervescence while making status-buying feel natural rather than narcissistic.
- Clubs play very loud music with a strong beat to manufacture what Durkheim called collective effervescence—losing oneself in the moment—by tuning out individual insecurities and synchronizing everyone into a shared vibe through the simple act of nodding to the beat.
“Clubs are also in this business of trying to manufacture and experience what Emile Durkheim would call this collective effervescence”
- VIP status-seeking is not a stable personality trait; most men, given the opportunity, could enjoy these spaces, because the club is engineered to make status-buying feel appropriate and good rather than because participants are uniquely narcissistic.
“I think that most men really could slide into that world.”
Models' low wages are subsidized by clubs providing free access to a glamorous world, while their unpaid labor consolidates male-dominated networks in finance and real estate.
- Unpaid or low-paid fashion models perform enormous unrecognized labor that generates untold profits not only for clubs but for finance and real estate, where networks of powerful businessmen are consolidated and softened by the women's presence, suggesting a case for redistribution from these male-dominated profits.
“unpaid fashion models or low-paid fashion models are doing enormous unpaid labor for all of these other hugely profitable industries, where disproportionately the profits are going to men. So I could see redistribution working in that direction.”
- Because most models earn little money and are recruited from the bottom of the fashion industry, the VIP promoter system subsidizes their low wages by providing free wining, dining, travel, and access to a glamorous world they otherwise couldn't afford.
“I think that the promoters in this VIP clubland do subsidize a lot of the low wages of the modeling industry.”
Models sell a captured look combining physicality and personality; digital tools now enable remote screening and casting that older scouting models could not accomplish.
- The traditional scouting model—a paid scout traveling to remote regions to pluck someone from obscurity—is declining because aspiring models with Wi-Fi and Instagram can email pictures directly to New York scouts, shifting scouting from physical hunting to remote photo screening.
“now there’s so many small modeling agencies, or even just women with Wi-Fi connections and Instagrams all around the world, that they can email their pictures directly to a scout”
- The Japanese modeling market produces unusual passivity in Western models because the language barrier removes their normal means of exerting control in castings—talking, showing personality, relating—forcing them into a system where a manager drives and introduces them while they stand silently.
“The way that models would usually have a little bit of control in the casting situation is to talk, to show their personalities, to connect, to relate. And it’s really difficult in the Japanese market”
- What models sell is called a 'look,' which is part physicality and part personality, captured not only in photographs but in a walk and conversation—and digital tools like video, Zoom, and Instagram can now capture much of what previously required physical presence.
“The thing that models sell in the market is called a look, but you’re definitely right that it’s part physicality, part personality.”
Elite status markers cycle through desirability as trends rise, diffuse downward, and exhaust themselves when mass adoption arrives.
- Status consumption is cyclical like fashion: the elite grab a new marker of status, it trickles down and becomes popular, and promoters recognize the VIP club moment will not be sustained in the long run as something else (e.g., Peloton riding) takes its place.
“there’s always some other thing that can denote status that the elite will grab onto. And then it’ll trickle down and become more popular.”
- The sustainability of status signaling depends on the relevant audience: people care about status relative to their own milieu, not the broader public, so a Wall Street banker's lifestyle remains fun and viable as long as his connected peers also participate, regardless of what outsiders think is tacky.
“people don’t really mind if the Donald Trumps out there are living in a gold-plated penthouse. What they care about are the people that are around them, in their milieu.”
Beauty in contemporary America signals class status primarily through thinness and grooming, reversing historical scarcity logic in an economy of plenty.
- In the contemporary US, upper-class beauty is distinguished from lower-class beauty primarily by thinness—because in an economy of plenty the wealthy can afford quality food and gym access while the poor cannot, reversing historical scarcity logic where a rotund belly signaled wealth—plus investable signals like straight teeth, clear skin, highlighted hair, and kept-up nails.
“That’s the economy of plenty: Whoever has money can afford quality food and getting to the gym, as opposed to an economy of scarcity”
- Catalog and commercial models smile and look relatable to connect with consumers, but editorial models on the catwalk and in Vogue almost never smile because they project an aspirational, distant beauty—a lesson from the art world that the more socially diverse the audience a work is meant to relate to, the lower its value.
“a lesson from the art world is that the more people and the more socially different types of people that a work of art is meant to relate to, the lesser its value.”