What this covers
This conversation between Anna Keay and Tyler Cowen ranges across three centuries of English and British history, architecture, and politics, held together by a single interpretive claim: that understanding Britain requires attending to religious conviction and material continuity rather than class struggle. Keay, a historian and director of the Landmark Trust—a charity that rescues derelict buildings and rents them to the public—moves fluidly between grand historical arguments and precise architectural detail. The discussion opens on monarchy and symbolic continuity of authority, moves through the English Civil War and the role of religious conviction in shaping it, touches on figures like William Petty and the origins of empiricism, and settles into practical questions about preserving the existing building stock.
The substance turns notably contentious in several directions. Keay argues that the English Civil War was overwhelmingly about religion—specifically Charles I's wish to catholicize Protestant worship—rather than economics or class, a position that contests mid-20th-century Marxist historiography. She contends that the 1650s republic under Oliver Cromwell failed not because republicanism and religious turmoil were incompatible, but because the political nation lacked genuine buy-in, a claim supported by the Dutch counterexample. On preservation, she urges adaptive reuse of Britain's stock of empty historic buildings over new development on green fields, framing it as both an environmental imperative and a matter of cultural custodianship. The conversation also covers why Britain's monarchy has endured—a "non-obvious" separation of ceremonial head of state from executive power—and includes a pointed argument against returning the Koh-i-Noor diamond, along with practical observations about how poverty can preserve historic character as effectively as wealth, and why the House of Lords should be abolished.
Keay argues that British history—especially the 17th century—is best understood through religious conviction and material/architectural continuity rather than Marxist class struggle, and that preserving the existing stock of historic buildings is both an environmental and cultural imperative.
- The English Civil War was overwhelmingly about religion, not class or economics
- Monarchical symbols and crowns persist via anthropological continuity that transmits authority across generations
- Britain should reuse its vast stock of empty historic buildings rather than build new on green fields
Hereditary monarchy endures because it solves the succession problem by transferring authority through ceremony and regalia, not executive power.
- The British monarchy's success stems from a non-obvious but satisfying separation: keeping a nonexecutive head of state with all the ceremonial 'bling' while stripping away executive power, which provides political reassurance precisely because the monarchy is apolitical—an arrangement that was not obviously going to work but turned out to be very stable.
“the balance that’s been struck between a nonexecutive head of state... but without dialing down much of the bling and the splendor... has turned out to be a very successful formulation.”
- Monarchs wear crowns not for any practical function but because of an almost universal anthropological impulse—seen across unconnected cultures and even Iron Age graves—to mark someone as set apart, and because regalia solves the core problem of hereditary monarchy: transmitting authority and aura beyond a single mortal body so that power continues to a successor on the wearer's death.
“There seems to be an almost anthropological universality of the idea that doing something special on your head is a way of setting you apart.”
- Whether monarchs build palaces is mainly determined by two practical factors—available money and the scale of the court—rather than randomness; Henry VIII built ~60 palaces funded by the dissolution of the monasteries and needed them for a large family, while later 'singleton sovereigns' like Edward VI, Mary, and Elizabeth inherited a sated patrimony and lacked large families, with status-display building (à la Louis XIV) being an additional layer on top.
“One is to do with money, and one is to do with the scale of your court.”
- The Crown Jewels made in the 1660s were not born of a desire for novelty but of necessity—because the originals had been melted down—and they were instructed to be exact replicas of the destroyed pieces, reflecting the value placed on ancientness of lineage; consequently it is unlikely new pieces will be made today.
“they produced new ones because the old ones had been melted down. It was a bit more of a necessity than a desire for novelty.”
Republican experiments fail without genuine buy-in from the political nation; armies impose change that people fundamentally reject.
- The English republic of the 1650s could have endured had Cromwell lived longer or named a better successor than his son Richard, but it was fundamentally fragile because it was brought about by an army coup rather than genuine buy-in from the political nation, and the people fundamentally did not want a republic.
“if Oliver Cromwell had lived longer or named a better successor than his son, Richard, it could have endured. Fundamentally, it was before its time”
- The Dutch Revolt of the 1560s, which rejected both Catholicism and monarchy and established a States General, demonstrates that religious turmoil and republicanism were not inherently irreconcilable; England's failure was due to insufficient buy-in from the political nation, not an intrinsic incompatibility.
“It wasn’t so much that religious turmoil and republicanism were irreconcilable, but in the case of England, the revolution... didn’t have sufficient buy-in from the political nation”
- The English Civil War of the 1640s was overwhelmingly about religion—specifically Charles I's wish to make the Protestant liturgy more elaborate and Catholic-like—rather than about class struggle or economic forces; the Marxist interpretation prevalent among mid-20th-century historians does a disservice to people who held genuine, strongly felt religious convictions.
“it was really, in my view, overwhelmingly about religion... It’s really one of the last wars of religion.”
Historic buildings and landscapes deserve preservation because their local materials, age, and character are irreplaceable assets.
- Excessive money can be a killer of historic buildings, as seen in wealthy parts of London where owners repeatedly strip out and re-do interiors every decade, destroying original character and pattern—so poverty can act as a preserver of authentic historic fabric just as much as wealth.
“sometimes too much money is an absolute killer of historic buildings.”
- Britain's listing system, which designates important buildings and prevents owners from altering them without permission, exists to take the long view by distinguishing the fashion of the moment from things future generations would regret losing—since demolished heritage like Euston Station can never be retrieved.
“you have to be really careful... to make a distinction between the fashion of the moment and things which we are going to regret”
- Our ancestors cared intensely about warmth because they had to chop every log, and the methods they used—very thick lined curtains and shutters used in conjunction with windows, and thick thatch with excellent thermal properties—remain effective today and should be retained rather than discarding handmade-glass sash windows for UPVC under the otherwise correct push for insulation.
“really thick curtains with lining, which means that when you draw them, they really exclude all the heat... A lot of old buildings have shutters, which are also very, very good.”
- Norfolk was the wealthiest part of England throughout the Middle Ages because of sheep farming and wool exports (the source of England's medieval wealth), but it largely missed the 19th-century Industrial Revolution that enriched the northern cotton towns, so it declined in affluence and consequently remains very beautiful, unurbanized, and still bearing its medieval and early modern landscape.
“It was the wealthiest part of England all the way through the Middle Ages because it was where all the sheep farming happened, and all of England’s wealth in the Middle Ages really came from the export of wool.”
- Because Britain has remarkably varied bands of geology packed close together and buildings were overwhelmingly made from locally available materials (since transport was expensive), places only fifteen to twenty miles apart can look completely different—Norfolk being red brick with napped flint due to lacking building stone, while nearby Northamptonshire has honeyed limestone—producing strong local distinctiveness in the old building stock.
“places are built overwhelmingly from the materials that you find locally... It’s expensive to transport materials”
Reusing existing buildings and preventing demolition requires imagination but preserves embedded carbon and community life better than new development.
- Rather than building millions of new homes on green fields, Britain should reuse its incredible stock of unoccupied buildings—the empty upper floors above market-town shops—because doing so leverages already-embedded carbon, requires less environmental cost, and brings people to live within existing communities, even though this demands more imagination than the easy developer choice of a field.
“we have an incredible stock of buildings which are unoccupied. You go into any British market town, and you will see half the shops are empty.”
- The mid-20th-century wave of demolitions and questionable urban planning in Britain stemmed not from a taste for ugliness but from a generation traumatized by two catastrophic world wars who sincerely believed society had to be remade to be more egalitarian, democratic, and healthier—mirroring the 17th-century Civil War sense that something fundamental had to change—so these decisions deserve historical empathy rather than scorn.
“you have to think of what it was like for people in the 1950s and ’60s, who had experienced... two catastrophic world wars”
- Few beautiful new neighborhoods have been built in the Western world since World War II because the philanthropic neighborhood development model—where industrialists like the founder of Port Sunlight built beautiful housing for workers out of a sense of responsibility—has largely disappeared, leaving the state (building as cheaply as possible) or developers (also minimizing cost) without an aspiration to beauty.
“the idea of the philanthropic neighborhood development scheme has really gone, but there was a lot of that that happened in the late 19th, early 20th century”
- The Landmark Trust is a self-financing historic-buildings charity that rescues and restores 200 derelict buildings across the British Isles, funds itself by renting them out to anyone (not just the rich), and plows the revenue back into acquiring and restoring more buildings.
“we are self-financing. The money that runs the charity comes from letting the buildings.”
Scientific empiricism and self-selecting communities of interest produce better outcomes than systems based on hereditary privilege or grading mechanisms.
- The House of Lords is past its sell-by date as an institution and should be abolished, since it still includes nearly a hundred hereditary peers who are by definition all men nominated from a hereditary pool—an absurd basis for participating in legislation—even though a second chamber on some better basis would be desirable.
“I’m all for abolishing the House of Lords myself, personally. I think it’s totally past its sell-by date as an institution.”
- The Landmark Trust's renters rarely trash the properties because the buildings attract a self-selecting group of people genuinely interested in heritage, and the sense of specialness and personal care from staff produces good behavior—obviating the need for a grading system like Airbnb's.
“it is a self-selecting group of people... it would be a counterintuitive thing then to trash it.”
- William Petty was excellent at empirically diagnosing Ireland's situation—mapping its population and dispossession—because his scientific mind ignored traditional English anti-Irish and anti-Catholic prejudice, but he was temperamentally unsuited to actually govern because he was rude, abrasive and bad with people.
“He was hopeless with people. He was rude and abrasive and direct... I don’t think he was temperamentally in any position to be a good governor.”
- Robert Boyle learned the revolutionary new method of experimental scientific inquiry from William Petty in 1650s Oxford—learning about blood circulation, vacuums and human organs—replacing the prior practice of deferring to classical authorities like Aristotle with direct empirical observation; Boyle brought money and patronage while Petty brought experimental expertise.
“Boyle learned from William Petty all sorts of things about the circulation of the blood, about vacuums, about the different characteristics of the human organs”
Scotland and regional geology produce extraordinary cultural distinctiveness and global influence unequally celebrated in British historical memory.
- Great Britain as a political unit is historically recent; England and Scotland have shared a sovereign since 1603 and been a political union since 1707, but the union was never complete—legal and education systems remained entirely separate—reflecting deep independent national identities that long predate the union.
“although England and Scotland have been part of Great Britain as a political union since 1707, it was never a complete one. The legal systems have always been completely separate”
- Scotland, a tiny country with a minuscule population, exerted extraordinary global influence in science, technology, thought, politics, music and more from the mid-17th century onward via the Scottish Enlightenment—a phenomenon under-celebrated and under-taught that deserves more preservation and education.
“this tiny little country... through the course of the early and into the later 18th century, had such incredible influence around the world.”
- The Koh-i-Noor diamond should not be returned because it passed through a long chain of conquests (Persia, Mughals, Ranjit Singh, the Anglo-Sikh wars), so there is no principled moment to which to return it; doing so would not solve problems but would open up the whole question of every other contested object and cause infinitely more conflict.
“the Koh-i-Noor diamond has been a stone that was taken in conquest through a whole series of conquests... Where do you choose your moment?”
- British houses tend to have little storage because most of the building stock predates the Second World War, built in an era when people lived less expensive, less wealthy lives and needed to store far fewer possessions such as garages full of sports equipment.
“houses in this country are, on the whole, very old houses... built... in a time when the amount of garages and skis and snowboards and things that everybody needed to keep was considerably less.”
- The aesthetic histories of jewelry/Crown Jewels and architecture run on parallel tracks, with each age's stylistic taste—whether art deco's rectilinear forms in the 1920s-30s or late-17th-century baroque floral motifs and massing—appearing simultaneously across architecture, jewelry, clothing, and other artistic forms.
“Whether it’s an age of ornament or an age of minimalism, you see that across different artistic forms in jewelry and architecture, like clothes and other things”