What this covers

Andrew Sullivan sits down with Tyler Cowen to discuss why public intellectuals have grown risk-averse and what that costs liberal democracy. Sullivan argues that professional peer networks—the narrow socioeconomic circles that journalists and academics inhabit—create invisible pressure to conform, making genuine independence rare. He draws on his own experience: being gay gave him a social world outside his profession, forcing a different perspective than those fully embedded in their class. The conversation traces this insight across recent political history, examining how liberalism perpetually struggles against tribalism's pull, whether from the woke left or the right-wing nationalism that has surged in Britain and America since the 1960s.

The discussion moves across British and American politics with unusual specificity. Sullivan explains why Boris Johnson is not a Trump-like outsider but an elite co-opting populism for elitism—a historic Tory move—and how Margaret Thatcher transformed Britain without the gendered backlash that Hillary Clinton faced. He reflects on what he underestimated about President Obama: Americans elected a Black president but resisted being governed by one, a rupture he ties to deeper psychological dynamics. Sullivan also contests the idea that Joe Biden is less divisive than his predecessor, arguing Biden has inflamed the culture war through his embrace of critical race theory and diversity mandates. Throughout, he returns to a core claim: that woke ideology and crude racism both exploit humans' natural tribalism, offering the comfort of instant group identification, whereas liberalism's demand to see individuals apart from their demographics remains counterintuitive and perpetually on the defensive.

Sharpest takeaway

Sullivan argues that genuine intellectual independence comes from living outside one's professional peer-network, and that liberalism's hard discipline of seeing individuals apart from their groups is perpetually losing to the more natural, tribal appeal of both woke and right-wing ideologies.

  • Public intellectuals lack courage because they are captured by a narrow socioeconomic peer group whose approval they fear losing
  • Being gay gave Sullivan a social network independent of his profession, generating a different perspective
  • Wokeness and right-wing racism both succeed because tribalism is more natural to humans than liberal individualism

The argument · threads8 threads · 31 claims
0.63

Liberalism's achievement of seeing individuals independent of group identity is hard, counterintuitive, and perpetually defensive against tribalism's comforting appeal.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Both woke left-wing neo-racism and crude right-wing racism succeed because they appeal to humans' natural tribalism — the comforting ability to instantly identify someone as in-group or out-group and feel morally righteous about it — whereas liberalism's achievement of seeing the individual independently of his group is hard, counterintuitive, and perpetually on the defensive.

    “It’s also much more conducive to human nature to see people in terms of groups rather than individuals... We are essentially tribal. What wokeness appeals to, in the way that the far right also appeals — it appeals to tribalism.”

  • The liberal system is the best, least divisive, and most psychologically productive way to give previously marginalized minorities full opportunities to become contributing members of society, and the means by which equality for women and gay people is achieved matters as much as the goal.

    “You can do that through a liberal system. In fact, I think the liberal system is the best way to do that, the least divisive and the more psychologically productive.”

  • Sullivan rejects separatism and loves when gay culture is embraced by straight people and vice versa, valuing the creative energy that comes from cultural mixture — exemplified by football fans chanting songs by the openly gay Freddie Mercury.

    “I hate the separatism. I love when gay stuff is embraced by straight people and vice versa. I love the possibility of cultural mixture and energy that comes from that.”

0.63

Wokeness is elite-driven ideology fundamentally distinct from genuine social progress and incompatible with liberal equality.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Wokeness is not the same as being socially advanced or progressive; it holds a specific view that the West is essentially a construction of oppression rather than liberation, defined specifically by white oppression — so generalizing woke influence globally would imply a major, near-zero-sum global racial conflict rather than improved treatment of marginalized people.

    “wokedoes not mean socially advanced or progressive... It has a very clear view that the West is essentially — has been a construction of oppression rather than liberation.”

  • Wokeness passed a market test along the coasts through the elite market rather than a grassroots wellspring; suburbanites did not demand struggle sessions on white supremacy. Elites adopted it because they have a 'Martin Luther King Jr. envy' — a generational need to feel they are bending the moral arc of history.

    “it’s less the market than the elite market, because it’s the elites that have made these decisions. This isn’t coming from a wellspring of American suburbanites”

  • Biden is more at fault than Obama for inflaming the culture war because of his complete embrace of critical race theory and the diversity-equity-inclusion agenda across government, whereas Obama was hostile to and resisted those things despite facing far more ferocious opposition.

    “I think Biden is more at fault than Obama... because of his complete embrace of critical race theory and the diversity-equity inclusion agenda across the government and elsewhere, whereas Obama was really very hostile to those things”

0.46

Meritocratic mechanisms like standardized testing identify talented poor children and should be preserved despite ideological pressure against them.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Standardized IQ tests like the eleven-plus and the SAT are valuable because they identify talented children from poorer backgrounds who would otherwise be missed, as happened to Sullivan, whose parents could not have afforded private schooling but whose test score sent him to a magnet school.

    “this is why I’m a pretty passionate defender of SATs and IQ tests in general, to find kids who otherwise would be missed, especially kids from poorer backgrounds who have native ability but haven’t had a chance to show that”

  • Coming from a non-college-educated family, Sullivan learned not to mistake credentials for intelligence and to recognize that people outside the system may be more perceptive about its failings than those buried within it.

    “you get used to real conversations about people, and you don’t mistake credentials for intelligence. You realize that people outside of the system may be more perceptive about what’s going wrong with it than people buried within it.”

0.46

Deep structural forces—regional divides, boomer-postboomer splits, gerrymandering—constrain any single leader's ability to heal cultural rifts.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • An individual president cannot unravel the deep Right-Left, somewhere-nowhere, heartland-coast forces that have propelled the culture war since the 1960s; the thesis behind supporting Obama was that as the first post-boomer he could pragmatically slice through that divide, but those forces exceed any single leader's power.

    “the individual president can’t unravel these forces that have been propelling us now since the 1960s, really.”

  • Gerrymandering has made it more important for incumbents to worry about primary opponents than general-election opponents, which reduces the number of pragmatic, non-ideological Oakeshottian legislators, though more such practical, administratively skilled politicians exist at the state level than one might imagine.

    “because of the way in which the gerrymandering particularly has made it more important for incumbents to worry about primary opponents than their general election opponents”

0.44

Communities offering meaning, belonging, and shared purpose are essential antidotes to atomization and alienation in modern life.

12 pointscentrality 2/5
  • One of the great crises affecting America is atomization, a lack of meaning, and a lack of community, and the Mormons demonstrate that you don't have to live that way — making Mormonism a model worth praising despite Sullivan's own conflicts with it over gay issues.

    “One of the great crises affecting America is this atomization, this lack of meaning, this lack of community. Then the Mormons have shown you don’t have to do that.”

  • Sullivan favors getting back to normal life quickly with reasonable precautions and, as someone vulnerable to COVID, cannot understand why people would refuse a free vaccine that could save their life — speculating the resistance comes from people unaccustomed to a medicalized body subjecting themselves to a needle for the first time.

    “I don’t understand why you wouldn’t take a prudential measure to save your own life when it’s available to you for free.”

  • Having an opportunity to avoid a catastrophe and then walking right into it is potentially much more emotionally and psychologically traumatizing than a disaster that strikes without warning and could not have been prepared for, which is why the pandemic-late Southeast could end up more traumatized than regions hit by sudden shocks like 9/11.

    “having had an opportunity to avoid a catastrophe and then walking right into it is potentially much more emotionally and psychologically traumatizing than just having something happen to you that you had no warning for”

  • Believing he had only a few years to live after his HIV seroconversion propelled Sullivan to write more, including Virtually Normal, because he wanted to leave behind his best argument for gay civil rights reform before dying.

    “It obviously didn’t. In fact, it propelled me to write more.”

  • Without the AIDS epidemic devastating the gay community and changing public hearts and minds, the United States would not have marriage equality today.

    “I don’t believe that without AIDS, we would have marriage equality today. I just don’t.”

  • Although Sullivan predicted 20 years ago that Scotland could not remain in the UK, in practice the arguments for Scottish independence are incredibly weak — the EU would not recognize an independent Scotland because it would then have to recognize Catalonia, which Spain would veto — so Scots keep pulling back from independence.

    “the arguments for Scottish independence are incredibly weak. First of all, the EU would not recognize it... because they’d have to do it with Catalonia and other elements in Europe which the Spanish, for example, would veto.”

  • Northern Ireland has effectively been turned into non-UK territory by the trade barrier in the Irish Sea that Boris Johnson negotiated, taking a step away from full union membership in a way that Scotland and Wales have not.

    “Northern Ireland has been effectively turned into non-UK by the trade barrier in the Irish Sea which Boris negotiated.”

  • Margaret Thatcher profoundly shifted Britain from a stultified, class-based, socialistic country to a more entrepreneurial, dynamic, capitalistic one without emollience, and the intensity of residual hatred toward her stems from the fact that a thrice-reelected woman Tory who transformed the country was too much for her enemies to absorb.

    “she did it in a way that profoundly shifted Britain from a socialistic to a much more capitalistic country. From what I felt was an incredibly stultified, class-based country to a much more entrepreneurial and dynamic country.”

  • Unlike other Etonians at Oxford who downplayed their background, Boris Johnson chose to turn himself into a knowing, ironic caricature of an upper-class twit, and this same charming, deliberately self-aware act is the source of his political success.

    “Boris came and said, 'Instead of fighting it, I’m going to just turn into a caricature of an upper-class twit.'... but did so with such a knowing irony that we all kind of got the joke.”

  • Americans misunderstand Brexit by conflating it with Trump and Boris Johnson with Trump; in fact Johnson is the insider's insider (editor of The Spectator, Oxford, Eton, mayor of London) rather than a crazy outsider, and the Tory strategy is the historic one of co-opting populism for elitism to prevent revolution.

    “I think Brexit has been terribly misunderstood by Americans because they conflated it, for understandable reasons, with Trump, and they conflated Boris Johnson with Trump. Simply not the case.”

  • Thatcher, Theresa May, and Angela Merkel were not understood through a gendered lens the way Hillary Clinton was in American politics; in Britain there is almost no gender gap between Labour and Tory voting, so the idea of a woman in politics as a symbol of feminism and breaking the glass ceiling is a distinctively American phenomenon.

    “they were not understood within their own politics in the way that Hillary Clinton was understood within American politics. It’s just not that big a gendered gap.”

  • Sullivan underestimated some deep racial dynamics: Americans were willing to elect a Black president but were far less willing to be governed by one, which surfaced as Obama's surprising unpopularity in many parts of the country despite his self-evident core decency.

    “I always believed Americans would be willing to elect a Black president. I underestimated how willing they would be to be governed by one.”

0.38

Personal crises and altered consciousness can improve creative and intellectual work by reducing ego-attachment and enabling self-critical perspective.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • There is a difference between a life of doing and a life of being, and because the default-mode network kicks in, people spend far too much time doing things rather than being something; mortality crisply restores the perspective that the mundane erodes.

    “We know that there’s a difference between a life of doing and a life of being, and sometimes because our default-mode network kicks in, as it were, we spend much too much time doing things than being something”

  • After finishing the cerebral core of Virtually Normal, taking MDMA while dancing made Sullivan realize he had been too abstract and had never explained why the subject mattered to him, prompting him to write the more experiential introduction and epilogue that became the book's most popular parts.

    “In the middle of the dance floor, I was like, 'You know what? I haven’t put in this book at all why I care about this subject, why it matters to me. I’m being too abstract here.'”

  • Sullivan records ideas conceived while high in a notebook called Highdeas, then reviews them sober, discarding about three-quarters as nuts and keeping roughly a quarter — a deliberate process for separating genuine insight from substance-induced bias.

    “I literally have a little book calledHighdeas, which is ideas I’ve had when I’m high. And I write them down — but then I make sure I look at them totally sober. I would say about three-quarters of them are nuts and I throw them out, and a quarter —”

  • Marijuana, mushrooms, MDMA, and meditation suppress and weaken the ego, allowing a writer to look at his own finished work with dispassion as if it were someone else's, making him less attached to his pride and better able to recognize errors and bad judgments.

    “What I find that marijuana does, and to some extent — mushrooms definitely do, meditation does as well — is that they suppress the ego. They weaken the ego.”

0.33

Pragmatic, institutionally skilled Oakeshottian conservatives who balance radical change with prudent judgment are rarer and less rewarded than they should be.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Boris Johnson's strategy has caused the far-right parties to collapse so the Tories own the entire right-of-center vote, while the Left is split among Liberal Democrats, Labour, and the Greens, giving the Tories a constant structural advantage that is poorly understood.

    “the far-right parties that were gaining strength have collapsed and the Tories basically own the entire right-of-center vote. Whereas the Left is split between Liberal Democrats and the Labour Party and the Greens”

  • In Oakeshottian conservatism, a radical ideological act can itself be a form of balancing — as when Thatcher's radical agenda of shrinking the state was pragmatically necessary to return a Britain that had drifted to a nadir of socialism back to its center — so sometimes radicalism is a necessary part of moderation, with the timing left to prudential judgment that cannot be prescribed in advance.

    “So sometimes radicalism is a necessary part of moderation.”

0.33

Demographic change and cultural mixture can be broadly beneficial but excessive speed and scale generate legitimate feelings of displacement.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Multiracial immigration to Britain has been broadly successful, but the speed and scale of demographic change in London — where 40 percent of residents were not born in the UK and English accents are rare in service industries — happened too fast, leaving native Britons feeling London is no longer their capital city.

    “What they were responding to, I think, is the speed of change... 40 percent of Londoners were not born in the United Kingdom... that’s never happened to England before.”

  • Being gay inevitably produces a social network independent of one's professional network, because sexual and romantic attraction acts as a 'great equalizer' that throws together people from totally different socioeconomic groups, generating a different and more questioning perspective than that of professional peers.

    “Part of it is being gay, because you inevitably develop a social network that is independent of your professional network because that’s how you socialize in many ways, and from that, you generate a different kind of perspective.”