What this covers
Ami Vitale is a photojournalist who has documented conflict and wildlife across a hundred countries, and in this conversation she weaves together lessons from war zones, conservation frontiers, and the craft of photography to argue that wildlife protection and human flourishing are inseparable. The core insight runs against isolated interventions: conservation succeeds when local communities understand wild animals as essential to their own survival—for income, ecosystem health, cultural identity—rather than as burdens imposed by outside decree. Vitale draws on decades of reporting to show how keystone species restore entire ecosystems, how community-led sanctuaries outperform top-down policing, and how environmental scarcity and climate change are the true engines of human conflict.
The conversation ranges across specific, often surprising examples: Kenya's shift from rampant poaching to zero rhino deaths during the pandemic because communities internalized the animals' value; the Samburu's Reteti Elephant Sanctuary, which improved orphan survival from fifty to ninety-eight percent by substituting goat milk for imported formula; Steve Winter's decade-long camera trap pursuit of a cougar that sparked the world's largest wildlife overpass. Vitale also contends with harder terrain: the role of zoos and captive breeding in species survival, the ethics and power dynamics of photojournalism (particularly the risk of exploitation), and the obligation of journalists to spotlight solutions alongside crises rather than perpetuate parachute journalism. She addresses the erosion of image trust in an age of digital manipulation, the importance of indigenous voices and consent in storytelling, and argues that Western audiences have grown disconnected from the knowledge of communities living alongside dangerous wildlife—a gap that conservation strategy must close.
Vitale argues that conservation succeeds only when the communities living closest to wild animals understand they need those animals for their own survival, and that storytelling and ecological interconnection — not isolated interventions — are the levers for protecting both wildlife and humanity.
- Community engagement, not just policing, explains Kenya's conservation success
- Keystone species restore whole ecosystems, showing nature's resilience
- Environmental scarcity and climate change underlie human conflict
Communities protecting wildlife for their own survival and economic benefit provide durable conservation more reliable than enforcement alone.
- Kenya transformed from rampant poaching to extinction 20-30 years ago into a conservation success story such that the greatest threat to its rhinos and elephants today is climate change rather than poaching, achieved through stricter laws, better policing, and above all community engagement so that people living closest to the animals understand the animals' value to them.
“Today, the greatest threat to these species is not poaching. It is actually climate change.”
- Where foreign tourists choose to spend their tourism dollars has a large impact on whether local communities take care of wildlife, so visitors should deliberately direct their spending toward conservation efforts and communities — Kenya being a prime example — to reinforce the community incentive to protect wild animals.
“if you take the time to figure out where your tourism dollars are going to support communities, that is going to have a huge impact on how the communities take care of the wildlife”
- During the pandemic, when tourism collapsed and poaching surged elsewhere (over 400 rhinos poached in South Africa), Kenya recorded zero rhino poaching because local communities understand they need the wild animals for their own survival — for tourism income and healthy ecosystems — demonstrating that community self-interest is a more durable protection than enforcement alone.
“in South Africa during the pandemic, over 400 rhinos were poached. Guess how many rhinos were poached in Kenya? Zero.”
- The Samburu built Reteti, the first indigenous-owned elephant sanctuary in Africa and the first to hire indigenous women as elephant keepers in a patriarchal society, changing not only how people relate to wildlife but how they relate to each other — embodied in the community saying that the elephants are saving them rather than the reverse.
“it’s the first elephant sanctuary that hires indigenous women to be elephant keepers in a very patriarchal society, and it’s transforming a lot”
- People in the West no longer understand what it means to live alongside dangerous wild animals that destroy crops and threaten lives, whereas communities in places like Kenya retain this knowledge and Westerners need to start listening to the generational wisdom of people living closest to wildlife.
“I think in the West, we no longer understand what it means to live with wild animals. People in many places around the world understand what it is to live with wild animals.”
- The orphaned elephant transition from mother's milk to powdered human-baby formula kills about 50% of orphans; fearing pandemic supply-chain breakdowns, the Samburu-run Reteti Elephant Sanctuary looked to nature and discovered goats browse the same vegetation as elephants, leading to a goat-milk solution that raised survival from 50% to 98%, while keeping milk-purchase money within the community instead of sending it to multinational milk companies.
“They went from a 50 percent survival rate to a 98 percent survival rate.”
Photographers and storytellers must obtain informed consent, empower subjects to tell their own stories, and recognize the colonial power of the camera.
- Photography is powerful enough to amplify people's stories but can also be tremendously exploitative and colonial, as illustrated by the traumatic experience of the Afghan green-eyed girl, so photographers — especially when working outside their own cultures — must first obtain the blessing and informed consent of subjects, treating the camera as something that can be a weapon.
“It can also be tremendously exploitative and colonial, and all of these horrific things come with photography.”
- While outsiders can offer valuable perspective and it is not wrong for them to tell stories with permission, in today's world of accessible platforms the people whose stories are told should be empowered to tell their own, because an equitable, balanced world requires a multitude of voices sharing their own stories — which is why Vitale brings cameras to the communities she works in.
“why shouldn’t the people whose stories you’re telling be able to tell their own stories?”
- Parachute journalism — hopping from one conflict to the next — is inadequate for understanding stories; truly hearing people requires living with them over time, as Vitale did spending four years in Kashmir, because the people met in brutal places, who represent the best of humanity, are what give the work depth and meaning.
“I immediately understood that I could not do parachute journalism. It is really important to take time to understand these stories that we’re covering.”
- Despite the flood of images on social media, the proliferation has not changed how Vitale composes because audiences are bored with merely beautiful or advertising-like images and are hungry for trustworthy storytellers who go deep; visual images have never had more reach and power, reaching people both intellectually and emotionally.
“I think people are bored with just beautiful images. Or sometimes it feels like advertising, and it doesn’t captivate me.”
Species survive extinction through captive breeding programs, scientific innovation, and habitat restoration that reconnect ecosystems.
- Despite the discomfort of keeping animals in captivity, some species survive today only because of zoos and far-sighted scientists; the northern white rhino would already be extinct had the Dvůr Králové Zoo not brought them from the wild into captivity decades ago.
“the Dvůr Králové Zoo brought northern white rhinos from the wild into the zoo, and if it were not for them, they would now be extinct”
- While de-extinction projects like reviving the woolly mammoth may not succeed within our lifetime, the more valuable application of the technology is rescuing species currently near extinction — for example Colossal's BioRescue project, which has created 29 viable northern white rhino embryos from one living female's eggs and can add genetic diversity from museum specimens, using southern white rhino surrogates.
“the BioRescue project has created 29 viable embryos, and they’ll use southern white rhino surrogates to restore these species”
- The idea that pandas lack a sex drive is largely a myth; they are simply elusive with a tiny fertility window, and captive breeding failed for two decades until scientists realized two things: the narrow breeding window and that females require mate choice rather than being paired with any male, after which breeding became very successful.
“they have this tiny window, and two, that the females need choice to breed, so you just can’t put any old male panda together with them. Once they realized these two things, they have a very successful breeding program”
- Panda survival rose dramatically (cub survival from ~30% to ~90%) because conservation made the world and local people fall in love with pandas, harsher anti-poaching laws were enacted, a captive breeding program cracked the breeding code, and China became one of the few countries actually increasing forest coverage by connecting habitat corridors so pandas can move during droughts and bamboo die-offs.
“China is one of the few countries in the world where forest coverage is actually growing. They are reforesting areas, connecting existing corridors where pandas live so that they can move when there are droughts and there are bamboo die-offs”
- Removing keystone species causes whole ecosystems to suffer and decline (observed in northern Kenya after ~30 years of local extinction), but reintroducing them restores balance with remarkable speed — within five to ten years, as seen in Yellowstone and Kenya, because animals like elephants act as mobile composting units that trample and fertilize grass, allowing vegetation and other species to return.
“When you take out the keystone species, the whole land starts to suffer, and it trickles down to all the different species”
- Captive-born pandas being trained for release wear human keepers in panda costumes scented with panda urine because pandas navigate by smell not sight, and the goal is to prevent the animals from becoming comfortable around humans, who are among the biggest threats to wild animals.
“pandas go by smell, not sight, so the panda costumes were actually scented with panda urine because the thought was that they should not know that humans were around them”
Journalists and conflict photographers must highlight solutions and systemic causes—especially ecological scarcity—not only violence and immediate suffering.
- Journalists do a disservice by being asked to focus only on violence and a single piece of a story while never being asked to tell where solutions lie; since every conflict story contains people working toward answers, journalists must do a better job of highlighting those efforts and where we go from here, not only the challenges.
“Never was I asked to tell the stories that acknowledge where we go, what do we do, where are the solutions?”
- Across nearly every conflict Vitale covered as a war photographer, the natural world was the backdrop — scarcity of basic resources like water, changing climate, and loss of fertile land — so that the demands placed on ecosystems almost always drive human conflict and suffering, and ignoring this connection (evidenced by recent waves of coups in Africa) is willfully ignorant.
“Almost always, it is the demands placed on our ecosystem that drive conflict and human suffering.”
- Conflict photographers risk death when they fail to recognize burnout and take breaks, because the work demands being 100 percent present and clear about what's happening in front of you; a broken, depressed photographer cannot maintain that clarity, which is how many colleagues end up killed.
“that is how so many of my colleagues end up getting killed, because you don’t know when to stop and take a break, because you need to be 100 percent present and clear”
- Rather than relax or put one's head in the sand about the state of the world, the right response is to stay engaged — to walk toward the things and people that scare you and that you don't understand — because the world urgently needs more genuine listening and understanding across difference.
“Walk towards the things that scare you. Embrace them, embrace fear, walk towards communities and people that you don’t understand.”
Losing wild species represents an existential human loss, eroding wonder and connection to the living world during an entirely human-caused extinction event.
- Animals such as dolphins and elephants may have evolved to understand that another individual's suffering is their own suffering, and humanity's survival depends on us similarly evolving to feel one another's suffering and joy as part of a shared web of life.
“she believes that they actually understand that another dolphin’s suffering is their own suffering”
- The extinction of wild species like the northern white rhino is not merely an ecological loss but an existential one — because humans are animals too, losing wild creatures means losing the wild and the sense of wonder within ourselves during what is a purely human-driven sixth mass extinction.
“We are animals too. When we lose all these wild animals, we’re losing what it means to be wild.”
Shy, empathetic people with low ego and strong ethics make the best photographers and storytellers despite lacking conventional confidence.
- National Geographic still has major cultural footprint and reach, but it is in transition after being bought by Disney, and one should distinguish the nonprofit National Geographic Society from the for-profit National Geographic, which will pursue slightly different missions and work.
“It’s important to differentiate between National Geographic Society and National Geographic. One is a nonprofit leg of it, and one is a for-profit side.”
- Pandas function as a symbol of international relations, having originally been gifted by China as a diplomatic tool (the first to Nixon), and because China owns the bears and chooses to loan them, panda distribution reflects the state of relations between nations.
“the panda was gifted in the beginning. They were gifted to countries and used as a diplomatic tool. The first one was gifted to Nixon”
- Vitale was able to enter photojournalism partly because the film-to-digital shift let her submit images remotely and editors often assumed she was a man, addressing her as 'Dear Sir,' in an era when many told her a woman didn't belong — though the field has since shifted to have more female than male journalism graduates.
“very often people thought I was a man. In the beginning, I was able to do the work that I do because people didn’t really know that I was a woman.”
- Vitale overcame her shyness not through innate change but by being forced onto stage and in front of the camera as a speaker; realizing that audiences wanted the stories and that she was merely the messenger — never the subject — gave her the confidence she lacked, suggesting introverts can become effective public communicators when the focus is the story rather than the self.
“To remember that it was never about me, that I’m just the messenger — that gave me great confidence.”
- The non-obvious qualities that mark a photographer worth investing in are ethics and empathy — often found in shy, low-ego, sensitive people who don't make the work about themselves — rather than confidence or self-promotion, which is why Vitale champions underdogs who were, like her, written off as too shy.
“Ethics and empathy. Sometimes, it’s the really shy people that may not have a lot of self-confidence.”
Trust and authenticity in visual media are increasingly threatened by digital manipulation and misinformation in an era of proliferating imagery.
- Photographs can be catalysts for positive change, exemplified by Steve Winter's image of the cougar P22 below the Hollywood sign — dreamed a decade before he captured it via year-long camera traps despite scientists insisting no cougars were there — which became the catalyst for the world's largest wildlife overpass.
“His one image is what actually was the catalyst to create the world’s largest wildlife overpass.”
- The real danger of the film-to-digital and AI transition is not the lost texture of film but the erosion of trust — the inability to know what is real amid misinformation and manipulated images — which is why camera and post-processing companies like Adobe are working on authenticity stamps to certify unmanipulated images.
“I worry more about AI and what it’s doing to the trust of how do we know what’s real and misinformation. We’re entering new waters right now that are terrifying.”