What this covers
Ada Palmer argues that the shape of history owes far less to inevitable intellectual currents than to specific contingencies—decisions by obscure people, the mechanics of fear, and deliberate cultural performance. This conversation covers the Renaissance and Enlightenment through episodes where individuals altered the course of ideas: a near-exile that never happened, marginal notes in recovered texts, the infrastructure of underground printing networks. Palmer works as a historian and a novelist, and much of her inquiry turns on what becomes visible only when you trace individual lives or read the material traces ordinary people left behind—annotations in books, patterns of what actually got censored versus what merely looked censored.
The conversation moves across several linked territories. One vein concerns how historical contingency actually operates: not through world-changing genius but through the uncanny thinness of events. Voltaire's father nearly banished him to South America; had he succeeded, the Enlightenment proceeds differently. Another strand examines the Renaissance through economics and epidemiology—why cities boomed after plague, why Florentine patrons chose not to industrialize textile production, how living standards and mortality trade off in ways that mock simple narratives of progress. A third focuses on self-censorship as a deliberately weaponized tool: authorities stage visible punishment to terrify the many into never writing what they would otherwise attempt, a mechanism Palmer traces from early modern Rome through modern China. Palmer also addresses gender performativity, arguing that roughly ninety percent of gender differences are cultural construction, and contends that reducing conflict requires not erasing gender but rather elevating the consensus-building and crisis-management behaviors that are coded feminine. Throughout, she marshals unexpected evidence: how Marquis de Sade and Denis Diderot explored philosophical questions through formal choices in their writing, how World War II bombing spared Florence while destroying other Renaissance cities, and how women historians redirected into marginalized fields like weaving ended up discovering meanings their male predecessors had dismissed.
Palmer argues that historical periods like the Renaissance and Enlightenment were shaped less by grand inevitabilities than by contingent decisions, cultural performance, and the dynamics of censorship—and that understanding this contingency reveals how ordinary individuals shape history and how cultural constructs like gender are largely invented rather than innate.
- Tiny decisions by non-famous people (like Voltaire's father) could have radically altered intellectual history
- Censorship's primary mechanism is cultivated self-censorship, not destruction of books
- Roughly 90 percent of gender performance is cultural construction rather than biology
Judgments of historical 'progress' depend entirely on which metric you choose; different dimensions trade off against each other, making singular narratives of golden ages meaningless.
- Living in the Renaissance was worse than the Middle Ages in many respects because economic regeneration after the Black Death increased travel and town-to-town circulation, which spread deadly diseases faster and skyrocketed the child death rate (ages 2-12); simultaneously, advances in military technology, larger cities, and centralized tax extraction by kings enabled larger, deadlier wars—making the Renaissance 'the Middle Ages, only slightly bigger and more so.'
“as Europe's economy regenerated after the Black Death and merchants started traveling farther, people started circulating from town to town more. That meant that diseases circulated more quickly”
- Whether the Renaissance was 'better' than the Middle Ages depends entirely on which metric you choose—life expectancy, quality of clothing and consumer goods, beauty of cities and art, or freedom from the constant fear of plague exposure—and these dimensions trade off against each other, so no single judgment of 'golden age' is meaningful.
“The question is, what do we mean bybetter? Do we measure better by life expectancy? Do we measure better by how you're spending your days?”
- In Renaissance Florence, day laborers—the bottom of the economic ladder—earned enough to live on by working only three days a week, spending the remaining days enjoying themselves and looking at art, which contradicts modern expectations about pre-modern poverty.
“most sorts of day laborers — which is the bottom of the economic totem pole in the city — earned enough to live on working three days a week and spent the other several days of the week enjoying themselves and looking at art”
- When Naples, a city of nearly 200,000, was emptied by a resurgence of the Black Death (Yersinia pestis) in 1494-1496, it was repopulated to over 250,000 within just 20 years, demonstrating how strongly people flooded into cities for economic opportunity despite shorter life expectancies.
“When Naples was emptied by a resurgence of the Black Death... in 1494 through 1496 — this was a city of nearly 200,000 — it became completely empty, and within 20 years, it was over 250,000 again.”
Censorship—whether state-enforced, self-imposed, or taboo-based—is durable and gets repurposed for worse ends, making it a structural danger to free thought.
- After the Encyclopédie was banned, smugglers wrapped even more dangerous banned books (like de Sade or Jansenist treatises) inside copies of the Encyclopédie, because border interceptors would see merely the familiar banned Encyclopédie, accept a small bribe, and let it through—so the banned book provided cover for an even more banned book.
“you smuggle them into France by wrapping them in copies of theEncyclopédiebecause if you're intercepted at the border... "Oh, it's just theEncyclopédie. Pay me a small bribe, and I'll let it through."”
- French Enlightenment censorship was delegated by Rome to a royal bureaucracy staffed largely by fresh-out-of-college aspiring authors and professors who were sympathetic to the radical ideas they reviewed and let many through, being more concerned with criticism of the king than with theology—so Rome only banned famous works years later (as with the Encyclopédie at volume H), making the actual censorship system permeable and slow.
“this is a first job out of college for a lit major... they are actually very sympathetic to the radical ideas that are circulating because they are fresh-out-of-college intelligentsia who are also excited by these new ideas, and they tend to let through a lot of things”
- The most common and effective form of censorship is self-censorship, the majority of which is intentionally cultivated by an outside power: rather than silencing one famous target (Galileo could have been quietly poisoned), authorities stage visible punishment to scare the dozens who witness it into never writing the works they otherwise would—and modern China replicates this with deliberately unpredictable enforcement against bloggers to maximize fear.
“the most common form of censorship is self-censorship. But the majority of self-censorship is intentionally cultivated by an outside power.”
- The absence of menstruation from great books is a form of censorship in that taboo is a kind of censorship—censorship is not exclusively practiced by state or organized actors but includes bottom-up, grassroots discomfort about topics, and taboos are part of that.
“a taboo is akindof censorship because censorship isn't exclusively state actors or organized actors. There's a lot of bottom-up, grassroots censorship as well, and taboos are part of that.”
- Censoring pornography is politically dangerous because censorship is a blunt, durable instrument that bad actors will later repurpose: almost all censorship works by repurposing an existing institution rather than creating a new one, so apparatus built to censor pornography (or movie 'bad words') gets reused to censor same-sex content, communism during the Red Scare, and free-thinking socialist authors—meaning one should refuse to build tools that will inevitably be turned to worse ends.
“we must always imagine how a tool we set up to censor something will be used in the future by bad actors we disagree with. If you create a tool capable of censoring something, it will still exist and still be there later”
Small decisions by often unfamous people shape enormous historical outcomes, reminding us that contingency, not inevitability, governs what comes after.
- To do the most good by changing history, one should go back to preclassical Egypt and teach Imhotep germ theory and handwashing, because he is the earliest medical authority with the correct background to understand germ theory and sufficient authority to teach it, potentially increasing the number of people who have ever lived by billions.
“I need to go back to preclassical Egypt and teachImhotepthe germ theory of disease and handwashing practices because he is the earliest medical authority who has the correct background”
- History is profoundly contingent: tiny decisions made by often unfamous people—like Voltaire's father nearly arranging to banish him to South America, or the improbable circumstances that produced Machiavelli's The Prince—shape enormous amounts of what comes after, which reminds us that everyone, not just famous figures, shapes history.
“a tiny decision, made by somebody often unfamous — and Voltaire's father isnotfamous the way Voltaire is — nonetheless shapes enormous amounts of what comes after”
Biography reveals that period boundaries are artificial because long-lived figures experienced multiple eras, exposing the continuity historians forget when treating eras as discrete.
- Biography is the most underrated method of history today because it was reactively pushed away after being fashionable in the 19th and early 20th centuries, and because it became an almost gendered practice—disproportionately written by women pushed out of the academy who could support themselves by selling biographies recreationally—which lowered its scholarly respect.
“biography has come to be an almost gendered practice of history, associated with those women who got pushed out of the academy and are trying to support themselves as scholars independently. That has meant that there's been a move away from respecting biography as a practice.”
- Biography uniquely reveals that historical period boundaries are artificial: when you trace a long-lived figure like Titian (who lived into his 90s through three different periodization 'lines'), you realize there was no actual line, because people who lived through one era remained alive for the next—a continuity we forget unless we approach lives beginning to end.
“you do a biography of somebody like Titian who lives into his 90s, and you realize there was no line. He lived through three different places where we would draw a line.”
Studying history's clutter cultivates empathy with predecessors and enables learning from their mistakes without moral superiority or condemnation.
- Studying history's clutter cultivates empathy with the past—understanding that predecessors were trying their best and that our efforts to build the future are 'in no way ethically superior' to theirs—and this empathy is vital both for forgiving the past and for learning the reasons people made mistakes so we can avoid similar ones.
“howourefforts to do our best in setting up the future are in no way ethically superior to the efforts of our predecessors”
- History doesn't repeat itself but it rhymes, and going through its layers to understand the past builds empathy—whether with one's own self of ten years ago who made a regretted decision, or with someone 200 years ago whose choices are hard to understand—and this empathy is what enables people to work with and forgive one another.
“History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme.”
Authorities and institutions are messier and more locally contingent than grand narratives suggest; Rome did not centrally control the Inquisition, and Viking metaphysics became unstudied due to Nazi associations.
- Viking metaphysics became a 'poisoned field' that nobody wanted to study after World War II because Hitler's minister of culture had written his dissertation on the topic, making it impossible to work on the subject without citing him.
“during World War II, Hitler's minister of culture was somebody who had done his dissertation on Viking metaphysics, and you couldn't work on Viking metaphysics without citing him. So, it made it sort of a poisoned field for a while.”
- Women scholars entering academia in the late 1960s-70s, pushed into overlooked feminine-coded research areas like weaving, recognized that objects previously dismissed as weaving shuttles in Viking tombs were actually staffs of sorcery described in the sagas, because Viking metaphysics is dominated by ideas of threads of fate spun and woven by the Norns.
“wait a minute, this isn't a weaving shuttle; this is a staff of sorcery, as described in the sagas that very clearly described these staffs of sorcery that look like weaving shuttles because Viking metaphysics is dominated by ideas of threads of fate”
- There was no single unified 'Inquisition'—the word in the singular perpetuates an intentional illusion of centralized decision-making; in reality these were local authorities making local decisions in Rome's name, with Rome struggling to catch up (it took six months for messages from New World colonies), even printing manuals teaching inquisitors how to fake that Rome had known about local bans.
“I like to avoid using the wordinquisitionever in the singular because it creates the illusion that there was an actual unified... it perpetrates the intentional illusion that there was a central, unified decision-making.”
- The Inquisition functioned as a blunt instrument of local power rather than a government: it owned no prisons and had no police, so it borrowed them locally, meaning it persecuted whatever the local authority wanted—Spain lavished money on persecuting converted Jews and Muslims, Goa destroyed indigenous texts, while Mexico City simultaneously built indigenous dictionaries to proselytize via translation.
“the Inquisition is a blunt instrument and usually a tool of local power. It isn't a government... It doesn't own its own prisons. It doesn't have its own police. It has to borrow them locally.”
Material and cultural artifacts—art, cloth, scholarly institutions—emerge from specific economic and political pressures, not inevitable progress or cultural superiority.
- Italian Renaissance city-states produced extraordinary art as a military defense mechanism: being rich but militarily weak and friendless, they were tempting conquest targets, so they made themselves so culturally indispensable—through recovered classical art, architecture, and Greek scholarship—that powerful kings would rather ally with them to import their culture than destroy them.
“they are helpless on the military game, but they are so ahead on the culture game that you don't want to hurt them. You want to befriend them so that you can have the art.”
- The Renaissance could have switched to cheap mass-production looms—sketches of machines like Brunelleschi's show they essentially figured out industrial looms—but chose not to, instead wanting super high-end cloth so costly that a fine Florentine brocade outfit cost as much as a luxury sports car, because fabric's purpose was to display social status by showing off high-end goods on one's person daily.
“they pretty much did figure out how to make industrial mass-production looms. They could have switched over to making cheap cloth at enormous volume the way we did in the 19th century, but that wasn't what the Renaissance did or wanted. The Renaissance wanted super high-end cloth.”
- Science fiction lacks literary status because it crystallized as a named genre in the 1920s-30s alongside cheap pulp printing: in the US, pulp paperbacks were sold not in elite bookstores (which preferred profitable hardcovers) but in grocery and hardware store racks competing with candy bars, so the genre was born as a democratizing but low-status commodity—a fate shared by fantasy, horror, and Westerns that crystallized at the same moment.
“thesepulp paperbacks, as we now call them, were of a different social status because they weren't sold in bookstores... They were sold at hardware stores in little magazine racks, where they competed with Hershey's candy bars rather than competing with fellow books”
History disseminates through fiction and popular media, not scholarship, so historical understanding is fundamentally shaped by narrative choices made outside academia.
- Florence seems to have more Renaissance art than elsewhere partly because more of it survived—a result of later centuries (18th-19th) valuing Florence as a Grand Tour destination and protecting it, such that even in World War II both Axis and Allies were under orders not to damage Florence's artistic legacy while freely bombing the historic centers of Milan, Genoa, and Naples.
“both AxisandAllies were under strict orders never to damage the artistic legacy in Florence, even as they were allowed to bomb the heck out of Milan and its historic center, Genoa and its historic center, Naples and its historic center”
- Anglophone histories of science overrepresent figures from the British Isles (Berkeley, Swift, Burke) because they were embraced by the anglophone scientific tradition, while two dozen or more equally innovative people from Spain or Italy in the same era remain obscure simply because anglophone history nationalistically centers the British Isles.
“there are certainly two dozen equally innovative and important people from Spain or Italy in the same moment — if not more — who aren't famous in the anglophone histories of science because we center the nationalistically celebrated British Isles area more”
- Academic paywalls block valuable new research from reaching the fiction writers who would disseminate it: cutting-edge Viking myth scholarship sits behind paywalls and prohibitively expensive volumes (the Oxford annotated Poetic Edda costs ~$300 per volume across three volumes), so science fiction and fantasy writers cannot access the latest research to tell better-informed stories.
“This is one of the big problems with paywalls, because all of this is in journals that are behind paywalls or the ridiculous Oxford annotatedPoetic Edda. Three volumes, $300 a volume. No wonder nobody has this book.”
- Renaissance marginal annotations of Lucretius are more interesting than Lucretius himself because they preserve, live, the moment of 'first contact' between Renaissance readers (who had only mythologized notions of Roman Epicureanism preserved through authorities like Lactantius and Cicero) and the real ideas—revealing which passages excited or shocked them, such as marginal notes reading 'opinio non Christiana' beside claims that there is no afterlife.
“It lets us see what it was like for that world to encounter a different world. It's sort of like alien first contact, and there it is, preserved live for us in the margins of a book.”
- Historical knowledge disseminates through an hourglass shape: thousands of PhD dissertations at the bottom feed several hundred synthesizing scholarly books, which narrow to a couple dozen popular history books, which then widen out to hundreds of TV series, video games, and novels—and since people always encounter history through fiction before scholarship, fiction is really where we form our ideas of history.
“actually, it's not a pyramid; it's more of an hourglass — several hundred television series, video games, and novels, which are really where we form our ideas of history”
Intellectual history turns on specific contingencies like Descartes's self-censorship after Galileo's condemnation, which altered the split between French rationalism and British empiricism.
- The Galileo condemnation altered intellectual history: Descartes, mid-publication of a major treatise, withdrew and spent years revising it to be more orthodox—had he 'let loose' he would have produced a more deist text, and absent that self-censorship the Enlightenment would have seen less of a split between French logic and British empiricism, with deism and Newtonian physics less tightly associated and more scientific laboratories developing in France.
“Descartes was in the middle of publishing one of his big treatises when he heard news of the Galileo trial's conclusion... and he actually withdrew that text from his publisher and then spent several years revising it to be more carefully orthodox.”
- De Sade used extreme pornography to interrogate the prevailing argument-from-design (articulated by Aquinas, drawing on Aristotle) that everything in nature is intelligently designed to fit its function, inviting reexamination of what is 'natural'—and in doing so he opened the very questions that Darwin would later answer.
“In that way, Sade is using pornography to open the questions that Darwin will later answer.”
Gender is roughly ninety percent cultural construction performed through language, clothing, physicality, and comportment, so erasing gender differences requires undoing ancient performative vocabularies.
- Roughly 90 percent of gender is cultural construction rather than biology: societies have spent thousands of years developing complex performative vocabularies of gender—in language, clothing, physicality, comportment, inflection, and gait—performed differently across societies, so even adopting genderless language would not erase this ancient performance vocabulary.
“our society has spent literal thousands of years developing complex ways to perform gender in not only language, but in clothing, in physicality and comportment, in patterns of inflection, in how we walk, which are performed differently in different societies”
- Eliminating differences between men and women is not what reduces war; rather, behaviors culturally coded female—consensus building, conflict management, team-building, non-zero-sum thinking—are very good at crisis avoidance (studies show women in political office handle crises better), so the goal should be to make these female-coded problem-solving behaviors welcome in positions of power, not to erase gender differences.
“I don't agree, except inasmuch as there are a lot of behavior patterns that we now culturally code female... which studies show are very good at crisis avoidance, consensus building, conflict management”
Underground publishing mixed pornography, philosophy, and radical theology because the same printers and audiences served all three, naturalizing their fusion.
- In the 18th century, underground bookshops sold pornography, Voltaire and Rousseau, anti-monarchy diatribes, and radical theological pamphlets all together because they were printed by the same printers and sold to the same audiences—analogous to how bookstores shelve science fiction and fantasy together—which is why authors like de Sade naturally fused extreme pornography with radical philosophy.
“an underground bookshop sells pornography, and it also sells Voltaire and Rousseau, and it also sells diatribes criticizing the king, and it also sells radical Jansenist theological pamphlets”
- Diderot's Jacques le Fataliste is an attempt to portray an atheistic, authorless cosmos: against the 18th-century convention of Providence as the author of the world sending players to enact moral lessons (as in Voltaire's Candide), Diderot deliberately breaks novelistic structure—random people without character arcs, interrupted stories, funerals you never identify—to make the book feel like a world that has no author.
“all of which is a complicated attempt to portray an atheistic cosmos because in the 18th century, one dominant way of thinking about Providence and of an intelligent designer... is as the author of the world”
Simulating historical decisions teaches participants belief in agency and democratic efficacy, a first step to preserving democracy.
- Running power simulations like a papal election simulation teaches participants—including young politicians and educational administrators—to believe they have power and can make a difference, which is the first and essential step to saving democracy by making people genuinely confident in democracy and in their own agency.
“we can save democracy by making people actually be confident in democracy. The first step to that is people being confident that what they do actually makes a difference.”
A novel's only genuine contract with readers is that each sentence compels them to read the next; other conventions like arcs and climax are dispensable.
- There is truly only one contract between author and reader—that when you finish each sentence, you will want to read the next one—and all the other apparent expectations of a novel (arcs, climax, denouement, recurring characters, complete development) are dispensable conventions, not genuine obligations.
“there's only one contract between the author and the reader, truly, which is, when you finish each sentence, you will want to read the subsequent sentence. So long as the author keeps that promise, the text succeeds”