What this covers

The conversation is between Tyler Cowen and historian Joanne Paul. It centers on Thomas More and Utopia, then widens to the Tudor world around him. Paul reads Utopia as layered and deliberately unsettled. Its narrator, Raphael Hythloday, has a name that can mean either peddler of nonsense or exposer of it. The book grows out of a debate over whether an educated person should counsel a king. Its Utopians use gold for chamber pots and prisoners' chains, which Paul takes as satire aimed at courtiers whose gold chains of office signify servitude. More ends by saying such a place could never exist, and leaves the reader to draw the lessons.

The discussion of More's life is more contentious. Paul says his hostility to heretics came from fear that Lutheranism would break society apart. She also says the popular image of him burning hundreds is exaggerated: only three burnings occurred while he was Lord Chancellor. She notes that Robert Bolt's A Man for All Seasons makes More a champion of individual conscience, which he opposed. She also covers how Henry VIII's regime tried to get him to submit, and how his execution was scheduled to avoid a feast of Thomas Becket. Along the way she describes how Erasmus wrote Praise of Folly with More in mind and how his criticisms of the church were so sharp that readers mistook Luther's for his.

The wider range includes the retrospective "Tudor" label, the lower-born administrators the early Tudor kings relied on, and women's exclusion from formal governance. It also takes in Tudor racial attitudes, alchemy's role in experimental science, the grammar schools behind Shakespeare, and Canadian political thought and Indigenous influence.

Sharpest takeaway

Paul argues that the 16th-century Tudor world sits in a transitional seam between medieval and modern, and that figures like Thomas More, and texts like Utopia, resist simple hero-or-villain readings and must be understood through their fears, contradictions, and the paths not taken.

  • More's Utopia is a deliberate riddle whose satire and reversals of value (gold, property, hierarchy) make its authority unstable, and its lessons are left to the reader
  • More's persecution of heretics was driven by fear of social fragmentation and has been overstated in popular accounts, so contradictions should be studied rather than moralized
  • The 16th century combined medieval and modern elements, including mysticism within the scientific revolution and religious reform within the Catholic Church, so the period cannot be read as a simple triumph of modernity

The argument · threads11 threads · 58 claims
0.85

More's views are contradictory and cannot be reduced to a single verdict on heresy or Utopia.

10 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Utopia is intentionally enigmatic and works as a riddle with many layers, so its meaning cannot be settled by reading it as a single statement of More's views, and its ongoing discussion 500 years later reflects that the puzzle remains open.

    “I think Utopia is intentionally enigmatic. I think it's a riddle. It's a lot of different things.”

  • The passage in which Utopians use gold as chamber pots and chains for prisoners and laugh at arrivals adorned in jewels is a deliberate satire suggesting that European courtiers who display wealth should be mocked, and the gold chains of office signify servitude to the king.

    “The idea that gold chains, in particular, signify servitude, I think is something he's specifically suggesting in the text.”

  • More presents Utopia as fantastic yet more real than 16th-century Europe because money, property, and social hierarchy are artificial constructs, while the Utopians reject these falsities and value what is useful and truly valuable such as virtue, food, water, and clothing.

    “Utopia is more real than the real world itself.”

  • Post-Enlightenment liberal culture, which prizes individual rights, makes readers see the darker elements of Utopia, and many of those elements were not intended by More, so modern dystopian thinking undermines the very concept of utopia when reading More.

    “We live in a post-enlightenment liberal world where individual rights, individuality is so important to us that we can't look at a utopia like More's without seeing the darker elements of it.”

  • After describing Utopia, More returns in the final framing to say that such a place could never exist, that its institutions are wished for but unexpected, which leaves the reader to decide what lessons to draw from the text.

    “Thomas More comes back at the end, after the description of Utopia, to say, well, this could never, ever happen.”

  • The Utopia text is framed by Raphael Hythloday, whose name can mean peddler of nonsense or someone who exposes nonsense, and by a debate about whether an educated person should serve a prince; this layered framing makes the reader question who the authority in the text really is.

    “This is set up to really get us, I think, to question who the authority in the text really is.”

  • More was not especially concerned with surveillance or individual freedom in Utopia; he saw individuality as the sin of pride, and Utopia emphasizes the public and shared over the private and personal, which is why it has no private property.

    “If anything, More was really troubled by the concept of individuality. He saw pride in that, the sin of pride.”

  • As a historian, Paul's principle is not to sort people into boxes of good or evil; instead, the contradictions of an educated and intelligent person who held condemnable beliefs should be studied to understand the complexity of human experience.

    “I think you should be interested in these contradictions. I think you should be interested in the complexity that is the human experience.”

  • More advocated burning heretics and imprisoned and interrogated them, but as Lord Chancellor he oversaw only three cases of burning at the stake, and the popular claim that hundreds were burned by him personally is an exaggeration; whether he tortured heretics is unknown.

    “There were three cases that he oversaw as Lord Chancellor of those who were burned at the stake.”

  • More came to his beliefs about heresy out of fear that Lutheranism would break down society, and he was persuaded by people who held that view; this shows how a group can come to be seen as a threat to society, and how that fear can lead to hatred and violence.

    “I think, he comes to these beliefs out of a place of fear. He was afraid of what he would consider the Lutheran heresy.”

0.62

Studying unrealized 16th-century paths lets us question and rebuild the present.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Paul's next book, Tyrant, will be a portrait of tyranny under Henry VIII and will examine the character of tyranny as well as the strategies, successes, and failures of those who sought to prevent, mitigate, or oppose it in the 16th century.

    “It will be called Tyrant, and it will be a portrait of tyranny in the reign of Henry VIII.”

  • Studying paths not taken in the 16th century, such as the options that could have been realized but were not, is valuable as counterfactual history because it gives distance from the world we created, lets us question and possibly dismantle it, and reveals lessons that remain relevant now.

    “Paths not taken are options we might have now or ways that we can sit at a distance and think about the world that we did create and question that”

  • The 16th century is compelling because it sits in a liminal, transitional space between what looks medieval and foreign and what looks modern and familiar, so one can watch the movement from one to the other and see the paths that could have been taken.

    “the 16th century sits in this liminal and very transitional space between what we can recognize as medieval”

  • Quentin Skinner argues that the contingency of history gives people agency because they are not bound by the world as they find it, so history inspires questioning and rebuilding of existing institutions.

    “My PhD supervisor, Quentin Skinner, often talks about history and the contingency in history as providing a sense of agency.”

  • Both Erasmus and More used satire as a stick to prod the prideful and powerful, aiming to bring them down and show them how silly their pride was.

    “using satire as almost a stick to prod the prideful and powerful with”

  • Book 2 of Utopia arises from a debate about whether an educated person should give counsel to a king, and the Utopian institutions are offered as an example of a place without pride, greed or hierarchy where counsel could be given, while More at the end says such a place could never exist.

    “Raphael only comes to the description of Utopia because of a debate that he's having with this character of Thomas More about whether one, as an educated, experienced person, ought to give their advice, their service to a king, to a prince.”

  • Quentin Skinner gave junior scholars, especially women in a male-dominated field, the space to try ideas and question them, which Paul credits as decisive for her development.

    “he really empowered me to have the space to try things out, to say things, to question things.”

0.48

Popular films, art, and portrayals invert hero and villain roles and misrepresent real 16th-century people.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Robert Bolt's A Man for All Seasons needed a figure to embody freedom of conscience and resistance to an oppressive state, and he found those principles in More, even though More himself opposed individual conscience and would not have endorsed the Act of Succession and Act of Supremacy stance the play celebrates.

    “More himself would not have advocated for those. As I said, he's someone who actually is very worried about this idea of individual authority and individual conscience.”

  • Popular portrayals cast More as hero and Cromwell as villain in A Man for All Seasons, then reverse them in Wolf Hall, even though the two men had known each other for decades before the 1530s conflicts and had more in common than either production shows.

    “Man for All Seasons, it's More as the hero, Cromwell as the villain. That's swapped in Wolf Hall.”

  • English visual art lagged in the 16th century because the English looked to Italy, Germany, and the Netherlands for Renaissance art and gave little support to homegrown artists, with an idea that art was no good unless it came from the continent, despite Holbein's unmatched realism.

    “We don't see the same support for homegrown art in England at the time.”

  • Living in the UK gives access to archives with boxes of material on the 16th century that are not available in Canada, which Paul sees as a privilege that deepens her dedication to archival work, while she also perceives the darker side of monarchy in England compared with Canada's view of it from afar.

    “It's such a joy and a real privilege to be able to walk into an archive here in the UK and just be handed boxes and boxes of material”

  • Paul does not have a good answer about who should play More in a remake, though Paul Scofield's performance is hard to replace and James McAvoy has been suggested.

    “People have suggested to me James McAvoy.”

  • Holbein's naturalism and realism were unmatched at the time, which is why he stood out in a context where English art was otherwise weak.

    “Yes, Holbein's naturalism, realism is unmatched at the time.”

  • Historical films tend to paint figures as heroes or villains and to make events sexier and more violent than they were, which smooths over the contradictory complexity of real people.

    “There's a temptation always to paint figures as heroes or villains”

0.46

The Tudor regime treated More's refusal as a political problem to manage, not simply punish.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Henry VIII's regime knew that More's execution would upset people within England and beyond, so they tried to get him to submit to the royal supremacy and considered compromise, and scheduled the execution to avoid a feast marking Thomas Becket's birth because of parallels between the two Thomases and two kings named Henry.

    “they want to make sure it doesn't happen on a feast marking the birth of Thomas Becket”

  • London had a mayor and court of aldermen and was nominally democratic, with the franchise limited to freemen who belonged to trading guilds, but conflicts between the city and the Crown were constant in the 16th century, and More was caught in them as undersheriff and later as a Crown representative whose Crown payments would undermine his trust in the city.

    “There's all sorts of conflicts that happen between the city and the Crown in the 16th century.”

  • More was accused of torturing heretics but denied it, and Paul believes the historical evidence will never settle the question either way.

    “We don't know if he tortured them. That was something he was accused of at the time. He said he didn't.”

  • The Tudors had a weak claim to the throne and their Welsh roots were used against them, with Richard III mocking Henry Tudor as Henry Tydder to portray him as a foreign upstart.

    “Richard III calls him Henry Tydder, as, I think, a way of undermining him as a leader”

  • Upward mobility in the Tudor period required education in Latin and law, so that the non-noble men who rose to power, such as More, Cromwell, Cranmer and Wolsey, had to be educated to be useful.

    “You still needed, though, to have an education. Without that education, you couldn't be useful”

  • Henry VIII's government saw More's refusal to accept royal supremacy as a public relations problem, and Cranmer proposed getting More to accept part of the arrangement so others would follow, since visible resistance would reveal the regime's compromises.

    “In many ways, it's a bit of a PR disaster that they're not able to get him to submit.”

0.43

Tudor identities, power structures, and prejudices differed from modern categories of race, religion, and state.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The name Tudor was not used during the Tudor period, which was something the dynasty was ashamed of; Henry was known as Henry of Richmond until he became Henry VII, and the dynastic label came much later, so it is a retrospective imposition, while Richard III mocked the family's Welsh name as Henry Tydder to undermine their claim.

    “they didn't use the name Tudor in the Tudor period. That's us doing that.”

  • Henry VII deliberately employed capable administrators from lower backgrounds to keep the nobility in check and to form a disposable bureaucratic class he could tear down without political cost, a strategy Henry VIII continued, so few prominent figures survived long at court.

    “employing capable administrators, smart, smart men from lower backgrounds in these roles in government largely as a way of keeping the nobility down”

  • European antisemitism in the 16th century is tentatively linked to the Inquisition, the Reformation, and a drive to isolate and eliminate heterodoxy, with the Iberian reconquest and the push for Catholic conformity as key drivers, though Paul has not researched this deeply.

    “a lot of it has to do with the Inquisition, with the Reformation, with a desire to isolate and eliminate any heterodoxy”

  • Racism in 16th-century England functioned differently from modern scientific racism, because one's social status could transcend race, as with a Black duke in Italy and a Black trumpeter at Henry VII's court, though Black people were still associated with moral darkness and their skin color was noted as expressing character.

    “There was a sense in which one's social status could, in some sense, transcend one's race.”

  • Few people in 16th-century England openly professed Islam, though some had Moorish ancestry, and much ancient knowledge reached the English in the period through Islamic scholarship from the early Middle Ages, with direct Persian ambassadorial contact only arriving in the late 16th century.

    “a lot of ancient knowledge of which they're very interested in the period is transported, in some sense, through Islamic scholarship in the early Middle Ages.”

0.40

Institutions define heresy and orthodoxy, and have excluded women from authority.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Church of England should fully embrace women in the clergy because churches are closing where they refuse female vicars, and women now make up more than half of those entering the clergy, so excluding them leaves parishes without clergy.

    “That churches are closing down who won't even consider a female vicar.”

  • The Lollards were treated as heretics in the period even though they did not think of themselves as heretics, and reform criticism more broadly was attempted from within a Catholic identity that few considered optional.

    “There were certainly heretics known as Lollards. They didn't think of themselves as heretics, of course, but they were treated as heretics.”

  • Heresy labels such as Lollard are imposed by authorities on people who see themselves as reformers within the church, so the category of heretic reflects the power of the institution to define orthodoxy rather than the self-understanding of the accused.

    “They didn't think of themselves as heretics, of course, but they were treated as heretics.”

  • Women in the 16th century were considered unable to reason, to have prudence, or to control themselves emotionally, which excluded them from formal governance, although some women held great power and were scholars, that being the rare exception rather than the rule.

    “Women were not considered able to reason, to have prudence, to control themselves emotionally, and were excluded from formal governance.”

0.32

More's relationships with Erasmus and Holbein, amid reform, shaped how he is remembered.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The years-long falling out between Thomas More and Erasmus had nothing to do with dogmatism or the Reformation; it was caused by More becoming Lord Chancellor and giving up his scholarly reputation to serve Henry VIII, after which no surviving letters were exchanged.

    “It has nothing to do really with dogmatism. Both are defenders of the Catholic Church.”

  • The title Praise of Folly can mean praise of More in Latin, and More serves as the embodiment of the wise folly Erasmus wants to articulate, which is why Erasmus dedicated the work to him and may have written parts while staying at More's home.

    “The title itself, Praise of Folly, can actually in Latin mean praise of More.”

  • Holbein's portrait of More conveys intimacy and respect because Holbein knew More well, having lived at Chelsea when he painted it, while his portrait of Cromwell lacks that personal connection and looks pallid by comparison.

    “Holbein was a friend of Thomas More's. He knew him. He knew him intimately.”

  • Holbein's family portrait of More is unusual for its time because it shows More within his larger family, and the women of the family are given a strong role, which is rare for Tudor portraiture.

    “It's a very unique portrait for the time. We don't get many presentations of Tudor figures in that sort of setting.”

  • Erasmus's sharp criticisms of the church were so harsh that when Luther began publishing his own criticisms, many readers assumed they came from Erasmus, believing the two were the same person.

    “people think they're actually coming from Erasmus. They think Erasmus and Luther are the same person”

  • Almost all 16th-century reformers, including More and Erasmus, assumed reform had to happen from within the Catholic Church, with no alternative; people were heavily criticized for church abuses, and the fragmentation of the church was terrifying to More and many others.

    “There was no question in the minds of most of these reformers that change had to happen inside the church.”

0.26

Humanist recovery of classical learning widened educational access across Tudor society.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Social mobility in Tudor England depended on education in Latin and law, and as government became more formalized and institutionalized through the 16th century, women were increasingly excluded from formal governance, although earlier they had held informal power more frequently.

    “I say formal there because it's worth noting that what we see in the 16th century is an increasing formalization of positions.”

  • The precursors of the scientific revolution lie in the Renaissance recovery of classical texts, especially Greek texts and Greek mathematics and science, which humanists advocated learning in the original language.

    “A lot of it comes from an engagement with Greek mathematics and science.”

  • Thomas More advocated education for girls and women as part of the humanist movement's push for wider access to learning, which is an example of how humanists sought broader accessibility than was typical.

    “Thomas More even advocated for the education of girls, women.”

  • Shakespeare's sophistication came from a 16th-century explosion in education and literacy, produced by humanism's push for wider access to learning and the Reformation's demand that people read scripture, which expanded free grammar schools that taught Latin through Cicero, Ovid, and rhetoric.

    “We can see Shakespeare using these tools in telling his stories, in writing his soliloquies, in writing his poetry.”

0.26

Brexit and short-termist policy caused the UK's stagnation and undermined its greatest assets.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Racism and xenophobia in Britain sit beneath Brexit and have kept the country stuck on divisive topics that divide people and therefore allow them to be conquered, preventing bigger conversations about the nation's future.

    “We've gotten stuck on these topics, which are designed to divide and therefore, conquer.”

  • The UK's stagnation stems from Brexit, which caused a standard-of-living crisis and damaged its identity and economic position, combined with short-termist investment decisions such as cuts to higher education funding, attacks on expertise, and disinvestment in the humanities and languages that undermine one of Britain's greatest assets.

    “I think there's a lot of very short-termist thinking when it comes to investments.”

  • Paul argues Brexit posed a huge problem for the UK in both identity and economic position and led to a standard-of-living crisis that the country has not fully recovered from.

    “I'll say explicitly that I think that Brexit posed a huge problem for the UK, both in terms of its identity and its economic position in the globe.”

  • UK policymakers show short-termist thinking by cutting higher education funding and attacking expertise, especially the humanities, history and languages, even though the country's universities are among its greatest assets and reputation sources.

    “There's been a lot of very short-termist thinking when it comes to investments.”

0.23

Science, mysticism and faith developed alongside reason rather than being displaced by it.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The scientific revolution did not triumph over religion or mysticism; the methodology of experimentation grew out of alchemy's search for the philosopher's stone, and figures like John Dee and Francis Bacon combined scientific and occult interests, so science and mysticism developed together through the 16th and 17th centuries.

    “The scientific method, for instance, comes from alchemy, which we might think of as an occult science.”

  • It became unfashionable for academics to be religious in any way, and Paul has been mocked in academic contexts for her faith, which leads her to avoid talking about it because faith beyond reason draws criticism.

    “it became very unfashionable many years ago for academics to be religious in any way.”

  • Paul suspects belief in the Trinity and resurrection is limited among the English, since many who attend Anglican services at Christmas and Easter do not actively believe or have not examined their beliefs in a long time, though she has not seen survey data.

    “there are a lot of people in England and probably elsewhere as well who participate in Anglican communion”

0.06

Canadian political thought has distinctive, underexplored Indigenous and federal intellectual roots.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Canadian political thought was influenced by Native confederations and Indigenous political ideas, and this influence is an underexplored puzzle that Paul would like to investigate, especially from the period around Confederation, and it has grown more visible in recent decades.

    “they're influenced and they are influenced by Native confederations and Native thoughts and how that flows into what is Canadian political thought.”

  • Canadian political thought has produced a distinctive intellectual history drawing on republican, federal, and federation thinking, and Canadian theorists have been among the leading contributors to theories of multiculturalism that influenced other schools of thought worldwide.

    “Some of the leading theorists on multiculturalism have come from Canada.”