Conversations with Tyler - Andrew Graham-Dixon
What this covers
Tyler Cowen talks with the art critic and historian Andrew Graham-Dixon, mostly about Johannes Vermeer and how such a painter came to be forgotten. Graham-Dixon's explanation is practical. Nearly all the great works stayed in one family for some twenty years after 1696, and were then resold under other names, Rembrandt's among them, because Vermeer's name had no market value. He then argues that the familiar titles are modern inventions, so the women in these pictures are embodiments of religious ideas rather than milkmaids or scale-holders. He reads many of the works as pairs, and The Concert as the close of a meeting where Psalms were sung.
The interpretive weight falls on the Collegiants and Remonstrants, whom Graham-Dixon describes as a church-less, largely female, pacifist circle. The contentious claims cluster here: that Vermeer's work is emphatically not Catholic, that a shared nail position proves two canvases hung together, that a paint splash on the pearl in Girl with a Pearl Earring undercuts the camera obscura theory, and that Carel Fabritius was the source of his tonal technique. He also faults the Met for leaving out the collector Hermann von Schwoll.
The talk then widens. Graham-Dixon compares the Church of England's destruction of medieval art to the Cultural Revolution. He argues that George Stubbs is underrated because of the Hierarchy of Genres, and that Stubbs's anatomical work anticipated Darwin. He also traces a line from Stubbs and Constable through to Cézanne's apple.
Graham-Dixon argues Vermeer's paintings were made for a tolerant Collegiant and Remonstrant circle in the Dutch Republic, so they can only be understood through that religious, political, and historical context, which the art-historical record has largely forgotten.
- Vermeer painted nearly all his great works for a single family's collection, and their survival and meaning depend on the patrons' beliefs.
- Vermeer's family, friends, and patrons are documented as Remonstrant or Collegiant, which makes the Catholic readings of his paintings mistaken.
- Paired paintings, shared nails, and the Collegiant meeting context reveal intended meanings that museum captions and exhibitions have ignored.
Vermeer's paintings are profoundly religious and embody moral ideas beyond their modern titles.
- Vermeer's paintings survived for about 400 years despite having no reputation, no advocate, and no famous name, which Graham-Dixon treats as a near-miraculous fact that points to what the paintings contain.
“a painting that has nothing—nothing on its side, no one fighting for it, no one rooting for it, no name, it's got nothing except itself—survives 400 years.”
- Vermeer painted essentially all of his great paintings for a single family, which kept them close, left them to their daughter, and then to her husband, who died in 1696, so the works entered the wider world only after 20 years and remained owned by one family until then.
“he painted basically all of these great paintings, the finest examples of his work, for one single family. They kept them very close.”
- Vermeer's paintings are most certainly not Catholic paintings, because the documentary evidence shows his friends, patrons, and the movement he belonged to were Remonstrant and Collegiant, and his marriage to a Catholic does not make him a convert.
“His pictures are most certainly not Catholic paintings.”
- The paintings survived because of what Vermeer put into them, namely faith, idealism, and beauty, which led owners to keep them even though they were neither valuable nor attributed to a famous artist.
“a painting that has nothing—nothing on its side, no one fighting for it, no one rooting for it, no name, it's got nothing except itself—survives 400 years.”
- Vermeer's children were raised as Catholics not from his belief but because Vermeer had no money, and his mother-in-law Maria Thins, a wealthy Catholic, paid the bills under her rules.
“his children are raised as Catholics because Vermeer has no money.”
- Vermeer's paintings are profoundly religious and he was profoundly religious, so the lukewarm-believer reading that treats him as a commercial painter misreads the work.
“I think the paintings are profoundly religious. I think he was profoundly religious.”
- The Met's Allegory of the Catholic Faith is an allegory of how hard it is to reach God as a Catholic, with its cluttered doctrinal emblems representing the complexity that Remonstrants and Collegiants rejected in favor of reading the New Testament directly.
“The Allegory of the Catholic Faith, in my opinion, is an allegory of how hard it is to get to God if you are a Catholic.”
- The sewing cushion's red threads in The Lacemaker are a visual metaphor for the placenta nourishing the baby, so the painting is about maternal love, and the thrown red threads anticipate Jackson Pollock.
“I say that the sewing cushion with all its red threads is a visual metaphor placed there by Vermeer for the woman's placenta, nourishing the baby.”
- The Art of Painting and Vermeer's other works show a Collegiant-influenced ideal, and the scene of heaven on earth depicted in View of Delft reflects a belief that peace would come through spreading education, reading, and spiritual love rather than messianic intervention.
“They actually believed that the spirit of Christ, by which they meant the spirit of love and the spirit of peace, would inhabit people automatically.”
- Many Vermeer paintings were made in pairs, and Woman Holding a Balance is the pendant to The Milkmaid, representing the contemplative and active lives through matching compositions and a nail placed in the same spot above each woman.
“a lot of them were painted in twos. The Woman Holding a Balance is clearly, without any doubt, the pair to the famous painting in the Rijksmuseum called The Milkmaid.”
- Woman Holding a Balance depicts a woman weighing her conscience rather than gold, with empty scales as a sign of a clean conscience under the Last Judgment scene behind her, while The Milkmaid depicts charity in bread pudding for the infirm.
“She's not weighing gold. She's weighing her conscience.”
- The titles of Vermeer's paintings, such as The Milkmaid and Woman Holding a Balance, are all modern inventions unrelated to Vermeer, so the female figures are not milkmaids or simple balance-holders but embodiments of religious ideas.
“All of the painting's titles are nothing to do with Vermeer. They're all modern inventions.”
Remonstrant and Collegiant pacifist toleration, not Catholic militancy, shaped the Dutch Republic and Vermeer's milieu.
- Vermeer was among the very first pioneers of what is now called the liberal tradition, emerging from the Dutch contribution to the Enlightenment, a contribution that has been largely forgotten and should be remembered now more than ever.
“the main discovery of my book is that Vermeer was among the very first pioneers of what we now call the liberal tradition.”
- The Remonstrants and their more extreme offshoot, the Collegiants, were unique among Christian denominations of the period in opposing division, hostility, and enmity, and they aimed to unite all people, including Jews and Muslims, around the essentials of Jesus's teaching in the Sermon on the Mount.
“they were unique among all Christian denominations of that time in being utterly opposed to division, hostility, enmity.”
- The Collegiants formed the first pacifist movement in European history, arising during the Thirty Years' War, which killed roughly 15 million out of 20 million Germans and left survivors violated or maimed.
“They formed the first pacifist movement in European history.”
- For about 20 years the Dutch Republic lived by these tolerant beliefs to a great extent and was the only tolerant country in Europe.
“For about 20 years, the Dutch Republic actually lives by these codes of belief to a great extent. It's the only tolerant country in Europe.”
- Vermeer's tolerant Remonstrant circle, in which a Protestant could marry a Catholic, existed in a country where Catholics in England would be tortured publicly, so the Collegiant meetings were comparable to Catholic and Protestant mothers of shot sons meeting together in Northern Ireland.
“It's the difference between... Catholic mothers of sons who've been shot in the conflict deciding to meet in their houses with Protestant mothers”
- The Remonstrant and Collegiant beliefs were a direct response to the Thirty Years' War, which Graham-Dixon describes as the worst war in the history of the modern West, with German population losses that he puts at fifteen million out of twenty million.
“They're responding to real traumatic historical events... Fifteen million out of 20 million German people died in the course of 30 years”
- The Collegiants formed the first pacifist movement in European history, arguing that true following of Jesus made war, persecution and picking on people for different beliefs impossible.
“They formed the first pacifist movement in European history.”
- The owner of the Allegory, Hermann von Schwoll, head of the Hamburg post office, was a rich, free-thinking dissident and early popular liberal journalist who wrote in favor of the Collegiants and proto-feminist tracts, so he was not a militant Catholic.
“Hermann von Schwoll, who was the head of the Hamburg post office and a very, very rich man, free-thinking, dissident.”
- The Vermeer-era meetings of Catholic and Protestant women, where people of any faith could join, were a more radical message of toleration than political negotiations, comparable to Catholic and Protestant mothers in Northern Ireland meeting, hugging and talking in their homes.
“That's completely different than if you've got Catholic mothers of sons who've been shot in the conflict deciding to meet in their houses with Protestant mothers”
- Vermeer's scenes of a woman writing are charged with meaning that cannot be recovered without knowing the context: in an era of wartime plunder and assault across Europe, a calm domestic interior signals safety and peace.
“When you see a radiant painting by Vermeer of peace, it's not just a painting of a woman in a room.”
- Wherever one looks in Vermeer's life one finds members of the Remonstrant or Collegiant movement, which had only about one in 500 Dutch people, and Graham-Dixon counts eight such figures including the movement's leader, so Vermeer's membership is effectively certain.
“Only one in 500 people in Holland is a Collegiant. If I find eight in Vermeer's life, including the leader of the movement, we know that he's part of it.”
- Vermeer's pictures are most certainly not Catholic paintings, and the Remonstrants' main opponents were militant Jesuits who wanted to extinguish them, which makes the problem of toleration concrete: how to tolerate people who want to destroy you.
“How do you tolerate someone who actually wants to snuff you out?”
- Collegiant meetings brought together people of different faiths, including Jews and Muslims, with the only requirement being belief that Christ's Sermon on the Mount holds salvation, which Graham-Dixon compares to Catholic and Protestant mothers in Northern Ireland meeting and embracing.
“You don't have to believe in God. You can be Jewish. You can be a Muslim.”
- The Remonstrant preacher's image that faith is a house everyone must add a brick to is embodied in the mended joins between neighboring houses in The Little Street, showing that good communities depend on shared contribution rather than one builder.
“it's not a house one person makes and everyone else worships in. Everyone has to put a brick in.”
Reputation and market forces, not merit alone, shape which artists gain esteem, and reputations remain unsettled.
- Vermeer was forgotten because his paintings were resold in the later 17th century under the names of other artists such as Rembrandt, Gerard Dou and Pieter de Hooch, since Vermeer's name had no market value.
“Vermeer, if it gets sold, it gets sold as a Rembrandt or as a Gerard Douw, as even a Pieter de Hooch. His work is being sold under false currency”
- Théophile Thoré, a French revolutionary exiled in Belgium, discovered Vermeer and recognized that paintings sold under other names were by him; within 50 to 60 years Proust placed a Vermeer-obsessed character at the center of his novel, starting Vermeer's rise to fame.
“Théophile Thoré, who's a French revolutionary exiled from France, goes to Belgium... he discovers Vermeer and puts together the fact that all these paintings... are actually by Vermeer.”
- British artists such as Stubbs had to paint what aristocrats would commission, since wealthy patrons bought history painting from Italy and Titian while commissioning Stubbs for racehorse portraits.
“that's all the aristocrats are going to commission. They look down on people like Stubbs”
- Howard Hodgkin's pictures are lovely and will eventually be as expensive as the pictures of Matisse, Vuillard and Bonnard, even though his prices remain reasonable today.
“Eventually, they will be just as expensive as the pictures of Matisse or Vuillard or Bonnard”
- Delacroix idolized Constable, and Géricault, who spent formative years in London, brought the spirit of English revolution into French art, creating a relationship of intense jealousy and mutual admiration between French and British painters.
“Géricault spent some of his formative years in the early 19th century in London.”
- Elevated reputations in contemporary art persist because institutions are rigid and copy one another: if one museum holds many Richters, others follow, so prices and esteem are sustained by institutional herding rather than by merit.
“Because the modern art world seems to be so institutionally rigid. If Museum X has lots of paintings by Richter, Museum Y also does”
- If his Vermeer book is taken seriously, museum captions for Vermeer paintings across the world would have to change, which Graham-Dixon expects will happen in about 20 years but not soon because institutions resist change.
“Now, I personally think that in 20 years' time they will be, but I know it's not going to happen this week or next.”
- One should not call time on any artist's reputation, since Vermeer had no reputation for 400 years and was later recognized, so present reputations remain unsettled.
“I wouldn't call time on anybody's reputation. Vermeer's a pretty good case. Vermeer had no reputation at all for 400 years.”
- George Stubbs has been underrated because of his subject matter of animals, since the French academic hierarchy ranked history painting highest and animal or still-life painting lowest, a ranking that Britain's aristocratic patronage reinforced.
“I blame the French. The French in the 17th century invented a system for ranking works of art by their subject matter.”
- Howard Hodgkin extended and deepened a painting tradition he had no national or historical connection to, and belongs in the lineage of Matisse, Vuillard, Bonnard, and Degas, and his prices are likely to rise to their level eventually.
“Eventually, they will be just as expensive as the pictures of Matisse or Vuillard or Bonnard”
- Basil Taylor's friendship with Paul Mellon, the richest collector who loved art more than anyone, led to the Mellon Stubbs collection at Yale, illustrating that reputations and collections depend on personal relationships.
“It's all about who you know and when you know them.”
Vermeer's paintings can only be understood by recovering the beliefs and context behind them.
- Malevich's Black Square can still move Graham-Dixon when he thinks of the revolution's hopes and the millions who died when those dreams were crushed, showing that historical context restores emotional force to a seemingly exhausted image.
“When I look at Malevich, I just see the Black Square... This is a revolution... and that's going to be crushed.”
- Paintings cannot be understood without knowing what their makers believed, so Graham-Dixon's books aim to recover the thinking behind works like Vermeer's, since you cannot understand what is in the pictures without that context.
“If you don't understand what they were thinking about, how on earth can you understand what's in these pictures?”
- Graham-Dixon visited the Rijksmuseum Vermeer exhibition perhaps 30 to 40 times, by his own estimate, and found that the show lacked a strong narrative drive, which let its paintings be seen as pure painting.
“It was a very interesting exhibition from the point of view of looking at the pictures purely as paintings because there was no strong narrative drive to it.”
Vermeer painted for conviction rather than money, and market value misjudges genuine art.
- Vermeer did not paint for money because his wealthy mother-in-law Maria Thins supported the household, so he could have been rich if he had wanted, and he accepted a devil's bargain to remain free to paint for his heart's community.
“He didn't need to paint for money because his mother-in-law, Maria Thins, was one of the richest women in Delft.”
- Identifying national artistic traits becomes harder in the 20th and 21st centuries because of international imitation and herd behavior among modern artists, as 19th-century Russian art often imitated French models.
“People are very good at imitating other people. You can look at Russian art in the 19th century. An awful lot of it looks very French”
- Rembrandt prints have risen two to three times in price in a few years, but Rembrandt paintings appear underpriced relative to other artists, since a monochrome Nativity sold for about $10 million, matching the last two self-portraits, while Warhol screen prints sell for around $100 million.
“When you think an Andy Warhol, which is essentially a screen print, is selling for maybe $100 million, it does seem really weird and underpriced.”
- An artist who says 'Do you not know who I am?' has lost the art, because a serious artist must care only about the work and not about who likes it or what it sells for, and this difference is discernible in the work itself.
“As soon as that happens, you know it's over. You have to be thinking about the art that you're making, and you have to be caring about it.”
- Gerhard Richter's work of the last 20 years is almost worthless, uninteresting and coasting, and its $20 million prices are almost like printing money because its museum presence is institutionally self-reinforcing.
“In my opinion, Richter's work of the last 20 years is almost worthless. I think it's just not interesting. I think it's coasting.”
- De Kooning's late exhibition seemed skeptically received, but its quality shows an artist talking to himself, painting only what he cares about, which Graham-Dixon treats as the criterion distinguishing real art from market-driven work.
“I felt that he was talking to himself. When I feel that an artist is talking to themselves, when it's real, this is what I love about Vermeer.”
- Textiles are grossly underpriced relative to their aesthetic quality, as shown by a Mennonite quilt Graham-Dixon bought for about $1,000 that resembles an abstract artwork.
“Textiles are grossly underpriced, I think, relative to aesthetic quality.”
- A rich fund manager who collects only female artists has bought 25 works by a forgotten British prewar woman painter, Phoebe, for about £5 each, and says museums are not buying women artists even though they could buy such work cheaply.
“He tells me that they're so unknown that once he's discovered one, he can then find their work in other sales”
Collegiant meeting practices, including music and mixed-gender gatherings, shaped the subjects and feel of Vermeer's paintings.
- A Collegiant meeting could run five hours, with members reading scripture, discussing its meaning, planning charity, and arguing about prophecy before singing together, and this process was itself a demonstration of harmony between people.
“The meeting might go on for five hours. These women are all there together, and they're talking, talking, talking, talking.”
- Dutch music did not flourish because orthodox Calvinism, the official faith of the Republic, considered music dangerous to the soul, much as it treated images, while Collegiants, who thought music brought people to God, were the exception.
“Dutch music essentially doesn't blossom because Dutch Calvinism, orthodox Calvinism that is, the official faith of the Republic, considers music to be dangerous to the soul.”
- The Collegiants were Christians without a church, about 80 percent of them women, and this is why nearly all of Vermeer's paintings depict women: he painted for a predominantly female group meeting in his patrons' house.
“Most of them are women, 80 percent. This, by the way, is why all of Vermeer's paintings are of women”
- The painting called The Concert is a misnomer: it depicts the end of a Collegiant meeting, when members sang Psalms in multivocal harmony, and it was paired with a companion painting now owned by the British king.
“That painting, The Concert, as it's called, which is a misnomer, it's not a concert; it's a painting of a Collegiant meeting taking place.”
Museums and history have edited out the violent and iconoclastic context behind Dutch and British art.
- The Met's interpretive text omits the painting's owner, Hermann von Schwoll, a rich Hamburg post office head and free-thinking liberal journalist who supported Collegiant ideas and proto-feminist writing, so the museum's reading ignores decisive context.
“they don't mention at all the owner of the painting, who was a very interesting man indeed, called Hermann von Schwoll”
- The Church of England was as astonishingly destructive as the Chinese Cultural Revolution, destroying the entirety of British medieval art, leaving church buildings but removing their art, sculpture, and stained glass.
“In Britain, the Church of England was as astonishingly destructive as the Chinese Cultural Revolution. They destroyed the entirety of British art.”
- Museums such as the National Gallery of Art in Washington present Dutch Golden Age painting without mentioning the war, death, and violent context behind it, so this troubled background has been edited out of public consciousness.
“this context, this troubled context behind it, the war, the death, it's just been edited out.”
Beautiful, cooperative communities depend on shared belief and can be rebuilt.
- Fabritius died young when a candle ignited Delft's gunpowder store, destroying a third of the city, a consequence of an ongoing culture at war.
“Somebody goes in with a candle, and it blows up, and a third of the whole city is destroyed.”
- You cannot make anything beautiful or a good community without beliefs, and people have lost their beliefs and therefore their belief in cooperation, though this loss can be reversed.
“you can't make anything beautiful, you can't make a good community unless you have beliefs.”
- Vermeer's The Little Street shows the house where his paintings hung, and its join between two houses, with each owner mending a bit of the wall, depicts a neighborhood built through cooperation, tolerance, and love.
“That painting is about what it is that makes a beautiful neighborhood, and it's belief and it's cooperation, it's toleration, it's love, it's all the things.”
- Western societies no longer build beautiful neighborhoods because they are living through a crisis of confidence in their own ability to make the world better, which shows up as agonizing over problems without building.
“Generally speaking, we appear to be living through a crisis of confidence in our own ability to make the world a better place.”
- Scandinavia undertook a project to build five million houses that were beautiful and made for ordinary people, and similar utopian schemes in 1950s America produced very beautiful neighborhoods.
“There was that amazing project in Scandinavia where they decided they were just going to build 5 million houses, and they did it.”
- James Fenton's poem about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict ends with lines of mutual destruction, while Vermeer's painting offers the opposite: mutual repair of each other's homes.
“I have destroyed your home, you have destroyed my home. Vermeer's painting is the opposite of that”
The Milkmaid and Woman Holding a Balance were made as a pair with shared Christian meaning.
- A nail placed in exactly the same position above and to the left of each woman in the two paintings shows that Vermeer intended them to hang as a pair, which the Rijksmuseum exhibition did not recognize.
“you'll see that there's a nail in the wall. Just above and to the left of each woman in exactly the same place.”
- In traditional Christian terms the two women are Martha and Mary, representing the active and contemplative life, so the pair presents the two aspects of Christian practice: think well and do well.
“If you're seeing them in traditional Christian terms, they are Martha and Mary. They are the contemplative life and the active life.”
- The milkmaid crumbling bread into milk is making bread pudding, the pap given as charity to the old, the infirm and very young, so the pair pictures charity as the active Christian life.
“She's making what the Dutch call bread pudding, which was the food that you gave when you administered charity to the old and to the very young”
- The Rijksmuseum exhibition hung The Milkmaid and The Woman Holding a Balance around 120 yards apart and did not present them as a pair, because the curators were unaware of the context Graham-Dixon discovered.
“the paintings were actually hung 120 yards apart, because when they put on that exhibition, they obviously weren't aware of the context”
- Attribution questions can be settled by knowing why paintings were made and who owned them, since the Woman Holding a Balance is clearly the pair of The Milkmaid and this resolution depends on the owners' beliefs rather than on connoisseurship alone.
“once you actually know why the paintings were made, once you know the beliefs of the people for whom they were painted”
Any subject, including animals, can carry the highest ideas in painting.
- Stubbs and Constable paved the way for modernism because they showed that any subject, even mud or a river, could carry the highest ideas, making subject matter irrelevant, a lesson Cézanne picked up when he said he would stun Paris with an apple.
“they showed that anything could be painted, anything at all, like a piece of mud or a piece of a river could be painted in such a way as to touch on the very highest thoughts”
- Stubbs's painting of the racehorse Hambletonian, flecked with blood after being driven to the limit, expresses sympathy with the animal's suffering, as if he were asking how anyone could treat such a wonderful creature that way.
“Stubbs paints the picture almost as if he's painting a concentration camp victim or something.”
- Géricault painted horses as self-portraits expressing himself, whereas Stubbs painted horses to understand how the world works and to see the miracle of existence, so the two approaches to animal painting differ fundamentally.
“Géricault horses are self-portraits. Stubbs is trying to understand how the world works”
- Stubbs's late engravings, informed by dissection and comparisons of chicken and human hips, moved toward the idea of contiguity among animal species, which Graham-Dixon sees as a contributing current to Darwinian evolution about 50 years later.
“He's beginning to wonder whether there might not be some contiguity of relationship between the different animal species.”
Vermeer's art grew from a shared network of Dutch painters and religious circles, including Rembrandt.
- The conventional contrast between Vermeer and Rembrandt is misleading, because Vermeer's documented network of Remonstrant and Collegiant figures shows that Rembrandt also knew and portrayed the same religious circles.
“people always say Vermeer and Rembrandt are the opposite.”
- Rembrandt is a nondoctrinaire painter full of love for the world, friends with Mennonites and painter of Remonstrant church head Uytenbogaert, which is why the liberal West adopted him as its favorite artist.
“I think it's not a coincidence that the liberal West adopted Rembrandt as its favorite artist.”
- Carel Fabritius was the likely source of Vermeer's tonal painting technique, which no one else practiced, and Vermeer could not have painted as he did without him, and Fabritius was killed when Delft's gunpowder store exploded.
“He's definitely, in my opinion, the source for Vermeer's wonderful technique. ... Without Fabritius, Vermeer couldn't paint the way he does.”
Aspiring critics and documentary makers must self-fund and build networks, since institutions no longer support them.
- The BBC no longer commissions art documentaries because it is no longer interested in culture, so aspiring creators must self-fund their work now, unlike Graham-Dixon's own early career when The Independent hired him and the BBC employed him.
“The BBC doesn't do that anymore. They're not interested in culture anymore, which is weird, but they're not.”
- The most important advice for a young aspiring art critic or documentary maker is never to try to be a version of someone else, and to build networks of friends rather than depend on corporations, doing it yourself and self-financing.
“My first advice is never, ever, ever try to be a version of someone else.”
- Graham-Dixon got his start as an art critic because a new national newspaper, The Independent, hired him when the existing art critic jobs at six national papers were occupied by people over 60 who had held them for 20 years, a path that will not be available to most people.
“a new newspaper was founded called The Independent, and they hired me to be the art critic. That's not going to happen for most people.”
Vermeer painted by hand within Flemish tradition, not with a camera obscura.
- Vermeer's early Diana and Her Companions borrows the foot-washing scene from Flemish altarpieces, so the nymph washing Diana's feet with basin and cloth echoes Mary Magdalene washing Christ's feet, implying he saw such altarpieces.
“one of Diana's nymphs is washing her feet, much as Mary Magdalene washes the feet of Christ in Flemish altarpieces.”
- A close look at the highlight on the pearl in Girl with a Pearl Earring reveals a splash where Vermeer dropped paint, which refutes the claim that the works were built with a camera obscura.
“If you look closely, as Jørg showed me, at the highlight in the pearl, in the Girl with a Pearl Earring, there's a splash. He's dropped the paint.”
- Vermeer's paintings are in fantastically good condition and need almost no retouching, with no controversial filling in of lost areas as is common with Renaissance paintings, according to restorer Jørgen Wadum.
“The minimal retouching necessary in a Vermeer, almost nothing wrong with the painting.”