What this covers
Michael, Matt, and Dom work through merchandise and brand building using concrete cases, most of them from Michael. The Masters anchors much of it: phones are banned, landlines stand in, scoreboards avoid digital displays, and a patron's guide written by Bobby Jones sets the tone. It has few premier sponsors, CBS works on one-year deals, and its merch is sold only in person. Patagonia is the values-side example, praised for pairing marketing skill with the nerve to act on its beliefs. Dom adds Rolex, whose brand comes from consistent engineering rather than explicit marketing.
The middle of the conversation is about what merch does. Michael traces it to private clubs and argues it sells affiliation, including to people who don't literally belong. Banker bags with a subtle logo show the insider version. On the practical side, golf vendors will embroider runs as small as 12 pieces, and Michael commissioned a private Shetland sweater after a favorite sold out. He also suggests asking brands what custom work they already do for others. Dom forecasts that guest-only podcast merch would spread by word of mouth. Michael's Shopify story is also here: a custom site needed about 60 hours of integration work, so he launched on native Shopify and it sold well.
The last stretch turns personal and more contested. Michael describes planning a quarter of his blog's posts to attract press, why a PR background hurts with journalists, and how the blog shortened client meetings. He and Matt argue for staying small on purpose. Michael's claim that flexibility matters more than a $30 million house is the most disputed point. Asides on UPS versus FedEx contractors and Alden's nine-month supply warehouse round it out.
Merch and brand building work as marketing only when a brand clearly stands for something and treats its customers as the priority. Scarcity, small-batch production, and insider signaling make merch valuable, but it should not be treated as a profit center.
- Brands that stand for a point of view are remembered, while brands that try to please everyone get forgotten
- Merch signals affiliation, and scarcity or insider access amplifies that signal
- Small-batch and niche operations preserve flexibility and let a business stay small on purpose
Staying small and patient yields control and access larger outsiders cannot obtain.
- Pitching journalists can work against you if the timing or relationship is wrong, since a journalist receiving an unsolicited pitch may see it as a reason to refuse future features, though journalists crave information at earlier stages of a story.
“if I got that e-mail, I'd be like, no. This is the last thing I'm going to feature.”
- Brands that grow fast without deep roots tend to decline quickly, so durability requires patience and deliberate pacing.
“I love the phrase trees that grow quickly, rot quickly.”
- Purposefully staying small can be more valuable than growing quickly, because a small operation keeps control, attracts exclusive opportunities such as press access, and can be happier, as illustrated by an ice cream shop owner who did not want to grow.
“I don't want to grow my store. I'm perfectly happy running it as I am doing what I do.”
- A podcaster named Kevin reportedly left ESPN to start No Laying Up because he could not get access to The Masters, illustrating how niche independent media can gain access that large organizations cannot.
“the reason why Kevin left ESPN for No Laying Up was because he couldn't go to The Masters.”
- Michael received a press pass to The Masters, which cameras are normally banned from, illustrating how a niche operator can obtain access that larger outsiders often cannot.
“So he got to take pictures and you're famously not allowed to bring cameras into The Masters.”
Merch should be quality or useful, since cheap discarded items damage brand perception.
- Cheap merch that people discard can damage brand perception, so the brand should spend its merch budget only on items that are reasonable quality or that people actually use.
“people will largely throw away unless you do something interesting with it.”
- Small enamel pins are a merch format that people can display as subtle trophies without the clutter of larger items, and they may be a better fit for a brand that wants understated recognition.
“It's small, it's subtle. It could be used. And you can think about where that can go.”
- A strong brand can sell lower-quality merch because people will wear and buy it for the brand association, whereas a weak brand's cheap merch gets thrown away.
“If your brand is good, people will actually look for s***** c***** quality, and that's fine with them and they'll wear it.”
Hosts signed off the episode while promoting the new Colossus merch shop launch.
- Hosts thanked the guest and signed off the episode.
“Michael, thank you for your time.”
- The Colossus merchandise shop is opening for business and is accessible via joincolossus.com.
“The Colossus merchandise shop is opening for business.”