What this covers

Keith Wasserman of Gelt talks with host Patrick about his path from buying distressed fourplexes to running large apartment buildings and manufactured housing communities. The first 15 fourplexes were bought for $100,000 to $150,000 each after selling for $400,000 to $500,000 at the 2005-2006 peak. They also sat in rough neighborhoods and brought more vacancy and repair cost than expected. That experience pushed him toward better areas and toward Scale Economics: a 200-unit building supports on-site staff and 95 to 96 percent occupancy. He also explains why apartments hold up better than office or retail, and walks through a 78-unit purchase from December 2009 that was improved with a gym, washers and dryers, and pet fees.

The middle of the conversation is about where and how to buy. Wasserman favors markets with Barriers to Entry such as California's CEQA review, Los Angeles's scarce land, and Phoenix's sprawl limits. He sees Houston as an Oversupply risk. Debt comes mostly from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, at roughly 65 percent leverage on ten-year fixed-rate, interest-only loans. He contrasts this with floating-rate LIBOR borrowing that burned peers. He describes shifting to manufactured housing after one apartment deal drew 39 offers, and he explains why ground-up development carries more risk, with over four years before cash flow.

The last stretch covers tax and investor economics: cost segregation, Accelerated Depreciation that produces paper losses on K-1s, and the 1031 Exchange. He also lays out the preferred-return and 70/30 profit split. Two claims are marked contested: that illiquidity protects investors from panic selling, and that falling homeownership, from about 69 to 61-62 percent, adds roughly a million renter households per point.

Sharpest takeaway

Wasserman argues that small-scale, long-held, professionally managed workforce housing bought below replacement cost and run conservatively is a durable way to build wealth, with the edge coming from buying well, adding value without over-improving, and using tax deferral.

  • Apartments and manufactured housing are recession-resilient when bought below replacement cost and financed conservatively with fixed-rate, interest-only debt
  • Returns come from making money on the buy, operational value-add, and depreciation plus 1031 exchanges rather than from market timing
  • Reputation with brokers and sellers and word-of-mouth investor capital are the scaling engines

The argument · threads12 threads · 85 claims
0.85

Buying well below replacement cost creates a built-in margin of safety and value.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Buying below what the market value is creates an immediate built-in profit margin and margin of safety, which Wasserman treats as the core of making money on the buy, while avoiding taking the trade so aggressively that sellers or brokers are alienated.

    “if you buy something right, and you buy it below market where you think it's below market, you're going to have an immediate profit margin built-in”

  • Gelt's market framework is to study markets, get boots on the ground, and prefer markets with higher barriers to entry, major growing employers such as schools and hospitals, and older 1970s to 1990s buildings whose below-replacement-cost rents avoid competition with new supply.

    “try to find markets that if possible have higher barriers to entry, that's always a good thing”

  • In apartment acquisitions the broker controls the process, so being a reliable closer who does not retrade or nickel-and-dime sellers builds reputation that brings repeat off-market deals, such as eight of the last nine San Antonio purchases coming from the same seller.

    “We bought eight of the last nine properties, we bought from the same seller”

  • Phoenix apartment rents fell about 20 percent from peak to trough during the housing bust and many buildings were half vacant, which Wasserman saw as a buying opportunity because he expected the city, the fifth largest in the US, to recover.

    “Literally, rents dropped 20% from peak to trough in the apartment space”

  • Gelt bought a 415-unit Camelback property in Phoenix for 16 million dollars from a major REIT after the housing bust, sold it for 27 million dollars, and a later investor who put in 8 million for renovation sold it for around 45 million, showing that a low cost basis is valuable and that undercapitalized owners leave value on the table.

    “We paid 16 million for the property, it was 415 units”

  • Gelt's first 15 fourplexes were bought for 100,000 to 150,000 dollars each after they had sold for 400,000 to 500,000 dollars at the 2005-2006 peak, so they were well below replacement cost, and buying below replacement cost is the first criterion Gelt uses.

    “We purchased these for a $100,000 to $150,000. So immediately, it was well below replacement costs.”

  • The early fourplexes were in rougher parts of town and had higher vacancy, turnover, and repair costs than expected, so Wasserman concluded that paying more for better areas yields healthier operations than buying cheap in weak neighborhoods.

    “these were in the rougher parts of town and they had a little bit higher vacancy and higher turnover, higher repair and maintenance costs”

0.67

Large apartment communities are more stable than commercial, hotel, or single-family rental assets.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Apartments are more stable and recession-proof than commercial office or retail because vacant units can be filled by lowering rent slightly, whereas commercial vacancies sit for long periods and require broker fees, tenant improvement dollars, and free rent, making commercial cash flows lumpy and concentrated in single large tenants.

    “apartments, it's more stable and pretty recession-proof, if you buy it without over-leveraging it”

  • A 200-unit building can support five to seven on-site staff and maintain 95 to 96 percent occupancy, whereas a fourplex with one vacancy is 75 percent occupied, and buying a 200-unit building takes the same effort as a 20-unit building while facing less competition, so larger assets provide better economies of scale and more stable cash flows.

    “it takes the same amount of time and energy to buy a 20 unit building as a 200 unit building. There's less competition for the larger assets”

  • Hotels are the first asset class to be hit in a recession because room rates reset daily, but they are also the first to recover strongly; their higher potential returns are offset by heavy, recurring FF&E capital expenditures that make hotels essentially an operating business.

    “hotel changes the rates daily, essentially. So it's the first one to really get hit”

  • Supply constraints vary by market: California's CEQA review, LA's lack of available land, Phoenix's outward sprawl, and mountains or oceans as geographic boundaries limit supply, while Houston has almost no zoning, high property taxes, and could build as many as 20,000 units a year, so Houston's oversupply risk makes it unattractive.

    “They don't really have zoning. You could have industrial building next to an apartment building”

  • Co-living in dense urban areas could charge more per square foot because units are smaller yet more affordable in total, and its communal design meets millennials' craving for social interaction, with age-restricted 55-plus co-living communities as an extension.

    “I'd really buy in really dense urban areas where the millennials want to be”

  • Aggregating scattered single-family rental homes is operationally difficult compared with owning a single professionally managed apartment complex, so Wasserman prefers large apartment communities and has not favored single-family rental REITs.

    “I'd rather have 100 units in one complex that's professionally managed”

0.58

Renovating and holding properties raises net operating income and value over time.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Gelt follows a run-it-like-a-Honda philosophy of taking good care of properties without over-improving them, because renovation spending that exceeds the rent lift cannot be recovered in ROI, so they spend about 2,000 to 8,000 dollars per unit to lift rents by 100 to 250 dollars on workforce housing built in the 1970s through 1990s.

    “Don't over-improve them. We have a saying, Run it like a Honda.”

  • Gelt has bought roughly 7,500 to 8,000 apartment units over ten years and sold about 2,500, primarily to create a track record and return capital, and nearly everything sold has been regretted because it appreciated far more afterward, so the philosophy is to build a portfolio, hold, refinance, and sell only for offers well above market.

    “Everything and anything we've sold, we've essentially regretted selling because they've gone up in value so much more”

  • On a 78-unit property bought in December 2009 for 3.9 million dollars, Gelt raised 1.3 million dollars of equity from about eight investors, spent around 300,000 dollars on upgrades including converting a closed clubhouse into a gym, adding washers and dryers, fencing, paint, and allowing pets at 25 dollars a month, and lifted rents and net operating income.

    “we bought a 78 unit property for 3.9 million. We raised 1.3 million of equity from around eight investors”

  • Real estate is valued using comparables and the income approach, so any increase in net operating income from upgrades or fees directly raises the property's value.

    “real estate is based on comps and the income approach. So if you have higher income, the property's worth more”

0.49

Long-term holding, partnership, and continual bold reinvention drive durable business success.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Early-stage entrepreneurs should start small and advance the ball every day, and Gelt reinvested its early acquisition fees into the fourplexes while living at home, letting small wins snowball into a larger business.

    “The first few years I was living at home, we weren't making any money on those little fourplexes, all the acquisition fees we made, we kept rolling back into the properties”

  • Wasserman's father's kindest act was not providing money but opening doors to his clients as investors, handling legal work, and lending money at interest so that Wasserman learned accountability, which he now passes on by mentoring others.

    “He didn't just give us money. And anytime I borrowed money from him, it was with interest”

  • Wasserman argues that solo founders can succeed but he thrives with a complementary counterpart, pairing a technical or operations partner with a sales or marketing partner, and he believes every business is now a technology business requiring owners to understand how to apply technology.

    “I thrive on having a good counterpart and a lot of businesses are like that”

  • Wealth is built by holding good companies for the long run because compounding works best without trading, and most investors chase quick returns, which is why Wasserman says he regrets selling stocks like Netflix that rose 80 to 100 times.

    “people are into making the quick buck and not wanting to put the time and energy and hold onto something”

  • Netflix survived the threat from Blockbuster by moving from DVDs by mail to streaming and then to original content, and Wasserman argues successful companies must continually bet the company on the future rather than milking the business.

    “You got to continually bet the company kind of events and build to what you think the future is going to be”

0.49

Manufactured housing offers higher returns and lower supply risk than apartments.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Manufactured housing parks offer higher cash flow and better risk-adjusted returns than apartments, can use the same Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac debt, and have produced cash-on-cash returns of 8 to 10 percent at the low end and 15 to 16 percent for a Foley, Alabama park.

    “We have one park in Foley, Alabama throwing off 15, 16% cash on cash return, just phenomenal return, the lowest ones throwing off eight to 10%”

  • Competition for apartments grew after the recession, with one deal drawing 39 offers, so Gelt shifted into manufactured housing where institutional players such as Brookfield, Carlyle, and Blackstone had not yet piled in when Gelt started.

    “We had one deal that there was literally, I think 39 offers on”

  • In manufactured housing communities the operator rents only the land pad while residents own and maintain the homes, so the operator avoids structural repair costs and gets affordable lot rent of roughly 300 to 500 dollars a month, which is positioned as affordable housing that benefits when home and rent prices rise.

    “you're renting a space, a pad, they call it, and you don't own any of the actual structures, the homes”

  • Gelt lacked operational experience in manufactured housing, so it made a partner of the top regional manager poached from Sun Communities, the second largest owner-operator of manufactured housing, who now oversees management and acquisitions while Gelt helps with fundraising and underwriting.

    “We poached the top regional manager for Sun Communities, which is a publicly traded company”

  • Only about 10 manufactured housing communities were built last year, cities resist them because they generate less tax revenue and neighbors fear lower property values, so supply risk is far lower than in multifamily.

    “There was only 10 manufactured housing communities built last year. We don't have the same supply issues.”

0.49

Depreciation and 1031 exchanges defer taxes and shelter investor income.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • A 1031 exchange lets an owner roll capital gains from a sold building into a new building and defer taxes, so an owner can keep rolling the gain forward for decades, which Wasserman describes as an amazing way to build compounding wealth, though Gelt only exchanges when the target deal stands on its own merits.

    “you could keep kicking the can down the road and not have to pay that tax either”

  • Gelt bought a Salt Lake City building for 25 million dollars and sold it four years later for 40 million dollars, with investors earning 8 to 10 percent cash flow annually, but because no suitable exchange property could be found the proceeds were distributed and taxed as long-term capital gains.

    “We just sold a building we bought four years ago for 25 million in Salt Lake City. We sold it for $40 million”

  • Accelerated depreciation creates phantom paper expenses that offset early property income, so investors receive K-1s showing paper losses while still earning cash-on-cash returns of roughly 6 to 10 percent, which Wasserman says is like earning double in a high tax bracket compared with ordinary income.

    “you have the depreciation, which is a Phantom expense which essentially it all offset all the income in the beginning years”

  • Cost segregation separates personal property with 10-year amortization schedules from real property on 27-year (residential) or 33-year (commercial) straight-line schedules, which front-loads depreciation so investors pay little or no income tax in early years.

    “They break out personal property versus real property. And some of this personal property has shorter-term amortization schedules like 10 years”

  • Long-term owners who have fully used their straight-line depreciation face income that cannot be sheltered, which creates a motive to sell and 1031 into a new building, so Gelt can find sellers willing to transact at better prices for this reason.

    “now all the income cannot be sheltered and literally, they could sell that building and exchange it into a new building and then have that depreciation”

0.45

Renting gains as homeownership falls and rent burdens favor apartment demand.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Apartment turnover in Gelt's markets can reach 50 percent annually because residents are transient, whereas in rent-controlled markets like California and New York turnover can drop to about 25 percent because tenants stay to avoid market rents, eventually paying half the market rate.

    “In markets like California, New York, you might see it lower because you have rent control. So maybe 25%”

  • The average renter in San Antonio spends about 22 percent of income on rent while California renters spend up to 50 percent or more, so San Antonio has room for rent increases and renting is especially attractive where ownership is expensive.

    “The average renter is only spending 22% of their income to rent. Whereas in California, it's up to maybe 50 plus percent”

  • The US homeownership rate has fallen from about 69 percent to roughly 61 to 62 percent, and each one-point decline represents about one million new renter households, a structural shift that supports apartment demand as people value mobility and avoid mortgage lock-in.

    “Every 1% drop is like a million new renter households”

  • Hotel-apartment hybrids with minimum 30-day stays, furnished units, and hotel amenities, such as those run by Sonder, could become very large, and boutique conversion hotels can still earn good money because travelers value the experience of hotels over Airbnb.

    “living the sort of hotel apartment kind of concept. You have companies like Sonder that are going big into that”

0.35

Delivery, autonomous vehicles, and online retail reshape commercial and industrial property uses.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Delivery platforms let restaurants operate without physical footprints, so buildings repurposed as industrial commercial kitchens, like CloudKitchens, located near concentrated delivery demand, could become a real estate play, and Wasserman predicts the next major restaurant chain will be built on delivery.

    “I believe the next McDonald's the next large, huge restaurant hall is going to be built upon just delivery and not having a physical footprint”

  • Autonomous vehicles could shift residential location toward more land farther out, free up large surface parking lots as parking requirements fall, and reduce total car ownership, since private cars are used only about 4 percent of the time, with fleets owned by ride-hail companies or automakers replacing personal vehicles.

    “you're only utilizing your vehicle 4% of the time”

  • Traditional big-box and neighborhood retail is being pressured by Amazon and online ad costs, so successful retail will be smaller, experiential, and omnichannel, illustrated by Rick Caruso's Pacific Palisades center that has a tenth of the square footage of The Grove yet astronomical sales per foot.

    “He built another shopping center with the same number of tenants, but it's literally a tenth of the size, and the sales per foot are astronomical”

  • Wasserman no longer visits CVS, Walgreens, or Target and orders medications through Amazon-owned PillPack at about the same price, so he is bearish on traditional neighborhood grocery and pharmacy storefronts while bullish on infill industrial distribution.

    “I just don't see it”

  • Amazon and omnichannel retailers create insatiable demand for infill industrial space within about an hour of customers, so industrial infill is expensive but attractive, and multi-tenant industrial is preferred because it avoids reliance on one large tenant.

    “Amazon has an insatiable demand for more and more infill centers that could deliver within an hour or less”

0.31

Ground-up development carries cycle-sensitive risk requiring conservative, equity-heavy financing.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Ground-up development carries much more risk than buying stabilized assets because an unentitled site can take about 1.5 years to entitle, then 1 to 1.5 years to build and roughly a year to lease, leaving over four years without cash flow and exposing the project to interest rate and rent uncertainty, but it offers more potential reward.

    “So, you have no cashflow for four plus years”

  • Development is very cyclical: buy land when it is cheap and build when contractors have little work and raw materials and labor are cheaper, and avoid building late in the cycle when costs are inflated, because construction costs have been rising astronomically.

    “you want to buy when you can buy something really cheap to land and build when these contractors don't have a lot of work”

  • About 90 percent of Gelt's borrowing comes from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, with leverage between 65 and 80 percent underwritten to a 1.25 debt service coverage ratio, and Gelt often takes 65 percent leverage for 10-year interest-only fixed-rate loans near 4.5 percent rather than floating-rate LIBOR debt that peers got burned by.

    “I'd say 90% of the borrowing we do is from Fannie and Freddie, the quasi government agencies”

  • Lenders are gun shy after the cycle and generally lend only up to about 65 percent loan-to-cost on development projects, with higher leverage possible only with personal recourse, and Gelt prefers non-recourse loans, which means it must bring significantly more equity to new developments.

    “The lenders are very gun shy now, they're only lending up to maybe 65% tops on a project”

0.31

Track record and word of mouth grow investor and resident bases.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The most effective way to fill units is drive-by curb appeal on major thoroughfares with signage and flags, followed by online SEO and paid resident referrals, which keep residents longer because referred neighbors have social ties to the community.

    “drive parks, still remarkably in this age with computer”

  • Entrepreneurs should win a small group of passionate first customers who spread word of mouth, which is how Lambda School grows as graduates share success stories with friends and family.

    “find a small group of passionate first customers, I'd say that will really stick to what you're doing and spread the word like gospel”

  • Gelt's equity raises grew from one to five million dollars per deal to 15 to 30 million dollars, and a 107-million-dollar two-property portfolio raised over 30 million from about 120 investors, with the most common check size around 100,000 dollars and growth driven entirely by word of mouth among 600 accredited investors.

    “Our largest purchase was a two property portfolio for 107 million. We raised north of $30 million from probably around 120 investors”

  • Selling early buildings was intended to create a track record by going full-cycle and returning capital to investors, which then led those investors to reinvest and recruit friends and family, enabling Gelt to grow to about 600 accredited investors.

    “We sold them primarily to create a track record. We went full cycle on these buildings to return capital to investors”

0.27

Gelt's returns depend on fees and a promote taken from investor profits.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Gelt's deals offer investors a preferred return of usually 6 to 8 percent on cash flow, accruing if unpaid, then return of full capital on sale, and then a 70/30 split of profits in investors' favor, with the 30 percent promote to the Gelt team being where the large money is made.

    “we offer a preferred rate of return between usually six and 8%, meaning the investors get the first six to 8% of cashflow”

  • Real estate's illiquidity and lack of visible daily price swings protects investors from panic selling, which is the worst mistake, so Wasserman argues investors should only commit money they will not need, while Gelt's buy-out mechanism offers a small discount on fractional interests when a limited partner needs cash.

    “You're not inclined to see your stock go down or your real estate go down in value quickly and say, Oh, I need to click the button and sell this thing”

  • Gelt charges an acquisition fee of 1 to 2 percent of purchase price and an asset management fee of 2 percent of gross revenue, outsources day-to-day management to large third-party managers paid 2 to 3 percent of gross revenue, and makes its main money on the promote.

    “we charge like an acquisition fee, one to two percent of the purchase price and an asset management fee of 2% of the gross revenues”

0.09

Income share agreements align incentives better than government-backed tuition debt.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Gelt's small early-stage fund, about 5 million dollars with roughly 1.5 million from Gelt, is run by a former Bay Area VC attorney, and its most-favored holding, Lambda School, uses income share agreements where students pay nothing upfront and repay only if they earn above a threshold, making it a potentially very large business.

    “We closed it out at five million bucks. We put around 1.5 of our own money”

  • University tuition funded by government-backed debt is a bloated model that can leave graduates with 200,000 dollars of debt while earning 40,000 to 50,000 dollars, whereas Lambda School's income share agreement, with no upfront cost and repayment only above a salary threshold, aligns incentives and could become as big as Uber.

    “why get yourself into $200,000 of debt if you're going to be making 50,000, $40,000 a year”