What this covers

This episode of Business Breakdowns has Kyle Wailes and Jesse working through SmileDirectClub's economics. The starting point is Invisalign, which sells aligners to orthodontists for about $1,200-1,300. Orthodontists mark that up at least threefold. SmileDirectClub sells at $1,950 and still reports a 25-30% adjusted EBITDA margin. Kyle also explains why orthodontists lean toward metal braces, since brackets and wires cost pennies. He argues competitors with small aligner businesses struggle to copy the product because each case needs around 30 custom, precisely fitting stages. That requires a vertically integrated manufacturing backend.

Much of the middle is about the acquisition funnel. All traffic goes to the website, which then offers an impression kit, a Smile shop, or a GP practice, a form of omni-channel choice. Kyle says shops only convert demand the site has already created, yet opening them lifted conversion 15-20% in a market. Before COVID about 90% of demand ran through shops, and the split is now near 50/50. Closing the shops in March 2020 cut marketing spend about 90%, while demand fell only about 60%. He also covers lead timing: about 60% buy within a few months, others take over two years, and same-day conversion matters most.

The contested material concerns teledentistry, which Kyle says treats about 90% of cases with outcomes similar to in-person care. He frames orthodontists' resistance and the early Corporate Practice of Dentistry challenges as incumbents protecting their pocketbooks. Growth is expected from the roughly 4 million in-practice case starts and from teens, who are about 75% of global starts but only about 10% of the company's business. International entry needs country-by-country regulatory gating. Kyle closes on agility and A/B testing as the lesson for startup builders.

Sharpest takeaway

Kyle Wailes argues SmileDirectClub undercuts the traditional clear-aligner market by removing a roughly threefold provider markup, funding a low price through direct-to-consumer marketing and a hybrid online and physical acquisition funnel that its A/B testing keeps optimizing.

  • Invisalign's roughly $1,200-1,300 wholesale price becomes $5,000-8,000 retail after a 3x-plus orthodontist markup, which SmileDirectClub eliminates
  • Shops lift conversion 15-20% per market, and omni-channel choice (kits, shops, GP practices) is the core acquisition strategy
  • Remote teledentistry is claimed to match in-office clinical outcomes for about 90% of cases, with expansion targeted at teens and international markets

The argument · threads9 threads · 80 claims
0.71

Physical shops and multichannel reach convert demand that online-only comparisons miss.

21 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Because a shop raises the share of leads who book, the same acquisition dollar produces more booked customers in shop markets, so a lead-level cost comparison understates shops' value.

    “for the same dollar, it's going 15% to 20% farther by getting someone ultimately to book”

  • Opening Smile shops in a designated market area (DMA) lifted website conversion to impression kits or scan bookings by roughly 15-20 percent compared with markets offering only home impression kits.

    “we saw about a 15% to 20% lift in conversion”

  • Smile shops, often located in shared salons, do not generate demand by foot traffic; they only convert demand that the website has already created.

    “So that shop isn't actually driving any demand. No one's walking by a shared salon and saying, "Hey, I want to straighten my teeth today."”

  • Consumers split into three behavioral groups: those who will only use impression kits, those who will only visit a Smile shop, and a blend who use both.

    “you have a group of consumers that will only do impression kits, you have a group that will only go into a Smile shop, and you've got a blend that will do both”

  • Before COVID, about 90 percent of demand came through Smile shops and 10-15 percent through impression kits; post-reopening the split is near 50/50, with GP partnerships a growing third channel.

    “We shifted kind of pre-COVID to a model that was 90% of demand going through our Smile shops and only about 10% to 15% that was coming through impression kits. If you look at that today, that's much closer to 50/50”

  • Acquired leads must convert quickly because the likelihood of purchase drops significantly after two or three days, so the company optimizes for same-day conversion.

    “So if two days goes by or three days go by or more, the likelihood for them to ultimately convert is significantly less”

  • Smile shops were not part of the original plan; the company started as impression-kit only and added shops after an idea surfaced in executive meetings and tests showed incremental lift.

    “Not on the roadmap when the company first started. It was really impression kit only, it came as a result of sort of an idea.”

  • SmileDirectClub tested shop openings market by market, measuring incrementality in each designated market area before scaling, and used the same method to reopen shops after COVID.

    “We A/B test everything, and shops were no exception to that.”

  • When SmileDirectClub closed all Smile shops in March 2020, it cut marketing spend by about 90 percent, but revenue demand fell only about 60 percent, with nearly all remaining demand coming through impression kits.

    “We brought marketing spend down by about 90%, but our demand was only down about 60% in terms of revenue, almost all of that was through impression kits.”

  • Pop-up events lasting two to three days, held monthly in cities of around 500,000 people with dental partners, draw incremental demand without a permanent storefront.

    “we might go in there once a month for three days, partner with a dental practice and draw an incremental demand from that city”

  • Shop visit rates and booking show-up rates were largely unaffected by distance between 5 and 35 minutes, so the company can operate fewer shops and still sustain demand within a 30-40 minute drive radius.

    “it didn't matter if we were say five to 10 minutes away from where they were, or if we were 35 minutes away”

  • About 60 percent of leads buy within a few months, while the remainder can take up to a year or more, with about 15 percent of recent purchasers having been leads for over 24 months.

    “You've got about 60% or so of those leads that convert pretty quickly”

  • SmileDirectClub drives all traffic to its website and offers consumers three paths to start treatment (home impression kit, Smile shop, or GP practice), believing that consumers want choice across channels.

    “We believe in giving them a choice, impression kit, Smile shop, or a GP practice.”

  • SmileDirectClub uses a multi-touch marketing approach spanning dozens of online platforms and offline channels, because consumers often need several exposures before deciding to straighten their teeth.

    “we use what's called a "multi-touch approach"”

  • SmileDirectClub sells through general dental practices at the same consumer price, with unit economics initially modeled as similar to the core business, and dental practices can earn an estimated $3,000-5,000 lifetime value per new patient.

    “the lifetime value of that is say $3,000 to $5,000”

  • SmileDirectClub launched its GP pilot in summer 2020, scaled it in fall 2020, and is already in over 1,500 dental practices.

    “we're already in over 1500 practices to date”

  • Invisalign once owned just under 20 percent of SmileDirectClub, sued over opening its own retail locations in alleged violation of agreements, and SmileDirectClub won and bought back the equity stake.

    “they owned about just under 20% of the company. And there was, obviously, a lawsuit where they were opening retail locations”

  • CEO David Katzman, father of co-founder Jordan Katzman, previously spent his career as an executive at Quicken Loans, building highly disruptive direct-to-consumer businesses, which Kyle presents as a source of the playbook.

    “His entire career was one of the executives with Quicken loans as well”

  • The company was initially impression-kit only, and the 2017 decision to open Smile shops was a key pivot that catapulted growth after the company saw demand rise in markets with physical locations.

    “So that was a key pivot-point as well, and sort of catapulted the growth as well back in 2017.”

  • Kyle frames the competitive choice for consumers as whether to see a doctor in person or use a teledentistry platform, rather than a head-to-head contest over the same product.

    “I think the choice that consumers are making today is, "Do I want to go in-person to see my doctor, be it an ortho or a dentist, or do I want to use a teledentistry platform?"”

  • SmileDirectClub's omnichannel approach offers consumers kits, shops, and GP practices, and the company is relatively indifferent among channels financially because the final purchase rate is similar across them, though conversion timing differs.

    “from everyone who orders an impression kit to booking a scan, the ultimate number of people that would purchase aligners from that is relatively similar across those channels, different sort of time horizons”

0.64

Removing orthodontist markup lets aligners be priced far below traditional braces.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • SmileDirectClub's core disruption is removing the roughly three-times markup that orthodontists add on top of the wholesale price of clear aligners, so the company can sell at $1,950 while still earning a 25-30% adjusted EBITDA margin.

    “we're removing what we call "the three times markup" that's associated with Invisalign or traditional metal braces”

  • Founders Alex Fenkell and Jordan Katzman concluded that a piece of plastic should not cost $5,000-8,000, and traced the cost to a massive orthodontic markup, which became the founding opportunity.

    “there's no way the piece of plastic that goes into your mouth should cost $5,000 to $8,000”

  • Invisalign sells aligners to orthodontists for about $1,200-1,300, and orthodontists typically mark that up at least threefold, producing retail prices of $5,000-8,000 for clear aligners or braces.

    “Invisalign would sell on average, say $1200 to $1,300 somewhere in that range”

  • The core customer base is about 60 percent female and 40 percent male, with household incomes ranging from about $30,000 to over $120,000 and a sweet spot near $70,000.

    “we're about 60% female, we're about 40% male on average”

  • SmilePay requires $250 down with no credit check and $89 per month over 24 months, and the company says this makes treatment affordable to almost anyone, with a card kept on file for the payments.

    “that's $250 down, no credit check, everyone is approved for the program. And then it's $89 a month over a 24 month period”

  • SmileDirectClub charges $1,950 for single-pay treatment, versus $5,000-8,000 typically charged for traditional braces and Invisalign.

    “$1,950. So we have two ways to pay. We have single-pay, which has $1950.”

0.43

Lower prices and global or teen segments expand the untapped aligner market.

11 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The next growth phase is taking share from the roughly 4 million in-practice case starts, whose patients can afford $5,000-8,000, by convincing them that a remote teledentistry route gives the same safe outcome at lower cost.

    “that's a group of consumers that can afford to pay the $5,000 to $8,000”

  • Lower price and installment financing bring treatment within reach of consumers who could not previously afford $5,000-8,000, expanding the total market rather than only shifting existing patients.

    “So it's truly a consumer that likely couldn't afford Invisalign”

  • Co-founders Alex Fenkell and Jordan Katzman met at a summer camp in Michigan at age 14 while both had braces, and later developed the idea from pain points they experienced in youth.

    “Alex and Jordan actually met at a summer camp back in Michigan when they were 14 and both had braces at the time”

  • Only a very small percentage of people with crowding or spacing are treated annually, so the company believes adoption is in very early stages with a long runway.

    “So our belief is we're in the very, very early stages of adoption from a market perspective”

  • About 75 percent of the global opportunity lies outside the U.S., and the company plans to add five to seven countries per year, pushing harder internationally unless U.S. competition changes.

    “we're expecting to add, call it, five to seven countries per year”

  • Clear aligners were enabled by treatment planning software, which has improved over time to handle more complex cases, and better scanning and AI will continue to make adoption easier for consumers.

    “It's been an industry that's been built on technology, right? If you think about what's enabled clear aligners, it's been the treatment planning software”

  • Roughly 90 percent of people globally have some crowding or spacing problem; about 500 million of them can afford SmileDirectClub's $89 monthly payment, implying a market close to $1 trillion, with about 75 percent of the opportunity outside the U.S.

    “there's about 500 million people globally that can actually afford to pay that as well. So if you do the math on that, it's pretty close to a trillion dollar market opportunity”

  • Teens account for about 75 percent of all orthodontic case starts globally, yet teens are only about 10 percent of SmileDirectClub's business, making the teen market a major growth opportunity.

    “the teen market, we haven't talked a lot about that, but it's actually about 75% of all case starts”

  • International markets, launched in April 2019 with the UK, account for about 20 percent of revenue after roughly two years, while being close to half of global clear aligner case starts.

    “it's already about 20% of our revenue. So we are growing very quickly.”

  • SmileDirectClub is innovating to address parental concerns about teen compliance, such as teens removing aligners at school, because solving the parent problem is key to capturing the large teen market.

    “how do we solve that problem for parents of teens?”

  • SmileDirectClub has treated well over one million patients since inception, operates in 13 countries, and generates roughly 20% of its revenue from outside the U.S. and Canada, despite launching its first non-North American country only in April 2019.

    “Since inception, we treated well over a million patients to date.”

0.36

Lower prices stay profitable, with margins and early EBITDA showing a sustainable model.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The long-term plan targets an 85 percent gross margin, 40-45 percent sales and marketing, and 15 percent G&A, producing a 25-30 percent adjusted EBITDA margin, with gross margin currently in the mid-70s.

    “It really kind of an 85% gross margin, 40 to 45% of revenue spent on sales and marketing and 15% GNA, all that driving about 25 to 30% even on margin.”

  • SmileDirectClub turned EBITDA positive in Q3 2020, about one quarter earlier than expected.

    “we turned EBITDA positive, actually one quarter ahead of expectations, so if you go back to Q3 of 2020”

  • Trailing twelve-month revenue approached $700 million and pre-COVID 2019 revenue was about $750 million, with over one million patients treated since inception.

    “approaching 700 million in revenue. Pre-COVID going back to 2019, we did about 750 million in revenue.”

  • The company's five-year plan calls for 20-30 percent annualized top-line growth and a ramp to 25-30 percent EBITDA margins.

    “it calls for 20 to 30% annualized top-line growth over the next five years and ramping the 25% to 30% EBITDA margins over that time period”

  • Investors should take a long-term view rather than focus on quarter-to-quarter results, because the company believes it can repeat its first five years of growth over the next ten years.

    “have the opportunity and the platform and the barriers to entry to do the same over the next 10 years that we've done in the last five”

  • Acquisition costs of 40-45 percent of revenue are acceptable because the company still expects a 25-30 percent adjusted EBITDA margin after removing the orthodontic markup, making the consumer price lower without sacrificing profitability.

    “So we've built the P&L in a way that we can get back to that same 25% to 30% adjusted EBITDA margin”

0.36

Proprietary manufacturing and fit precision form a moat rivals struggle to copy.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • SmileDirectClub's combination of in-house manufacturing across millions of aligners per month and patents on its Smile shop process creates a moat that competitors will find difficult to replicate.

    “Our Smile shop patent is a great example of strong IP that we have around the process of our Smile shops”

  • Competitors with small clear-aligner businesses have struggled to replicate the product because aligners are individually customized and must fit precisely across around 30 sequential stages, requiring a complex vertically integrated manufacturing backend.

    “Every single one is a little bit different. And let's say you've got, on average, 30 different aligners throughout the course of your treatment”

  • Customers can start treatment with a home impression kit that is shipped to them; they take a mold and return it, after which SmileDirectClub manufactures aligners and ships them in one batch.

    “We could order an impression kit. We would ship that directly to your home.”

  • Gross margin is currently in the mid-70s percent, similar to Invisalign's low-to-mid 70s, with a target of about 85 percent as automation is implemented.

    “Our gross margin over time, we expect that to be closer to 85%. We have a lot of automation”

  • Large companies with small clear aligner businesses and thousands of dental practices in their networks have found it difficult to drive adoption, partly because of the complexity of running the aligner business.

    “there's a lot of other big companies that have small, clear aligner businesses that have thousands of dental practices that are in their network that they could sell into. And I think they've found it difficult to get adoption.”

  • A typical treatment uses about 30 aligners, and if one does not fit when switched to the next, the patient will be very upset, so fit accuracy across dozens of unique parts is a critical operational requirement.

    “let's say you've got, on average, 30 different aligners throughout the course of your treatment, if you switch to your next one, as part of your treatment, and it doesn't fit, you're going to be extremely upset.”

0.33

Teledentistry can handle most cases within a large orthodontic market.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • About 15 million orthodontic case starts occur globally each year, about 4 million in the U.S., and roughly one-third of case starts use clear aligners while two-thirds still use metal brackets and wires.

    “there's about 15 million case starts on a global basis. About 4 million of those are in the U.S. Today, globally about a third of the case starts are done through clear aligners”

  • SmileDirectClub cannot yet treat teens with mixed dentition, such as partially erupted baby teeth, and this is a small subset of cases on the company's roadmap.

    “someone has mixed dentition which could be a baby tooth that hasn't fully erupted”

  • SmileDirectClub adds roughly 500,000 treated case starts annually on top of the 4 million in-practice U.S. case starts, bringing its U.S. volume to about 4.5 million.

    “Of the 4 million, we have approximately 500,000.”

  • Remote teledentistry can treat about 90 percent of the cases that come to SmileDirectClub, and Kyle asserts it achieves similar clinical outcomes and efficacy as in-person orthodontic care.

    “You're very similar standards of care or similar clinical outcomes and efficacy that you can expect to receive”

0.27

Incumbents, regulators, and country-by-country rules obstruct disruptive expansion.

9 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Incumbents resist disruptive dental models when those models threaten their revenue, especially orthodontic practices where the markup is concentrated.

    “anytime you do something disruptive, the status quo is certainly going to push back on that, especially if it's going to impact their pocket book”

  • Brackets and wires cost pennies compared with the roughly $1,200-1,300 wholesale price of aligners, so orthodontists see metal braces as a more profitable treatment to deliver.

    “the cost of brackets and wires are pennies on the dollar compared to the $1,200 to $1,300 on average”

  • State regulators and dental boards initially challenged SmileDirectClub on corporate practice of dentistry grounds, and the company responded by meeting with boards to explain its dental service organization model.

    “initially it was really around sort of Corporate Practice of Dentistry. I think we've sat in front of the boards”

  • Parents and orthodontists slow clear aligner adoption for teens because of compliance concerns that teens will not wear or reinsert aligners, plus orthodontists' preference for the more profitable brackets-and-wires business.

    “I also think there's a concept of parents being concerned around compliance, where they're concerned if their teens are actually going to wear their aligners”

  • Consumers choose between in-person orthodontic care and teledentistry, and SmileDirectClub wins the remote segment on brand and scale while Invisalign wins the in-person segment.

    “if they're choosing to go in-person to an ortho, today Invisalign is winning that”

  • Each country requires its own regulatory, legal, and medical device marketing review, and consumer preferences differ; in Germany the company placed a dentist in shops even though this was not legally required.

    “In Germany, we actually put a doctor in our shops, and that's not necessarily a regulatory requirement”

  • The current legal fight is in states like Alabama and Georgia, where old laws or new bills try to require a doctor's involvement in intraoral scanning, which SmileDirectClub contests.

    “around the use of intraoral scanners, and whether or not a doctor has to be involved in that”

  • Entering each new country requires a gating process covering regulatory structure, legal setup, and whether and how a medical device can be marketed on TV or social media, and each market needs adaptation.

    “We go through a gating process where we spend a lot of time on the front-end looking at, not only the regulatory set up and the legal setup as well, but also can you market a medical device?”

  • Early state challenges to SmileDirectClub centered on Corporate Practice of Dentistry rules, which Kyle attributes to status-quo pushback from incumbents protecting their pocketbooks, especially on the orthodontic side.

    “anytime you do something disruptive, the status quo is certainly going to push back on that, especially if it's going to impact their pocket book as well.”

0.18

Blended online acquisition spending is the main cost of the direct-to-consumer model.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Sales and marketing costs run at 40-45 percent of revenue, and this blended figure combines marketing and selling, which the company does not separate, and is the main acquisition cost of its direct-to-consumer model.

    “That's a blended number. It's both marketing and selling together”

  • SmileDirectClub has not disclosed its cost per lead.

    “It's actually not something that we've disclosed. We haven't broken it out.”

  • About 60 percent of marketing spend is online across many platforms, and about 40 percent is offline, with roughly 30 percent of the offline share going to TV.

    “So we've got about 60% of our spend that's online today. We've got about 40% of our spend that's offline.”

0.03

Startups must balance agile testing against execution risk across many initiatives.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • For startup builders, the critical lesson is agility: running A/B tests, learning from results, and adapting continuously, which Kyle argues is what let the company weather storms in a disruptive industry.

    “I think the agility aspect is something that we do very well as an organization and is critical for any company”

  • For a young company with many simultaneous initiatives (international, teens, GP channel, R&D), the biggest risk is execution, which has already caused volatility in recent quarters.

    “that's sort of the biggest risk that we see as a business”