NextEra Energy: The Renewable Leader
What this covers
Mark walks Zack through NextEra by starting with history. By the 1930s eight holding companies controlled almost 75% of US electricity, and after a bankruptcy hurt small investors, Franklin Delano Roosevelt's 1935 rules forced them into integrated monopolies, which became today's utilities. He then explains the Regulated Utility Rate-Base Model: profit is the allowed return times the asset base, which rewards capital spending, and cost savings can be split with the regulator. He covers the late-1980s quality-control overhaul at Florida Power & Light that halved outages. He also describes how the Yieldco Capital Recycling Loop works, and how a PPA lets lenders finance projects with high debt.
The range is wide. Mark describes generation shifting from centralized plants to decentralized wind and solar, and the push to build transmission from the windy, sunny middle of the country to the coasts. He uses the Texas freeze to show how retail providers were wiped out by spot prices. He argues that rivals who tried the regulated-plus-renewables model failed by betting on nuclear in their deregulated arms.
The contested parts are mostly forecasts. He expects hydrocarbon prices to rise while renewable power stays cheap, even at negative prices. He expects a possible commodity supercycle in minerals and rare earths. He names China-concentrated supply chains as the biggest risk. He also warns of a shale-style Over-Your-Skis Overextension in the race for prime acreage. He closes on the soft-cost software opportunity that Energize Ventures targets.
Mark Tomasovic argues NextEra's advantage comes from pairing a regulated Florida utility that generates steady cash with a renewables developer that gets a low cost of capital, and that the same economics favor renewables over fossil and nuclear generation.
- Regulated utilities earn an allowed return on asset base, so they are biased toward capital investment and low operating costs
- Solar and wind hardware costs have fallen sharply, making them cheaper than fossil and nuclear in many geographies
- NextEra's regulated cash flow and yieldco structure lower its cost of capital and fund renewable growth
Today's renewables businesses may not be structurally different from the failed prior clean energy cycle.
- A prior clean energy cycle did not end well for investors and operators, with SunEdison a prominent bankruptcy, and the question is whether today's renewables businesses are structurally different.
“We had called it a clean energy cycle, not all that long ago, that did not end particularly well for both investors and operators. What is different... look back at SunEdison”