What this covers

Oak Thorne takes Gogo's business-aviation unit apart as a market, starting with its size. Of roughly 220,000 FAA general aviation aircraft, about 24,000 are US business aircraft, and only around 30% have in-flight WiFi. The customer base is fragmented: the top ten, including NetJets and Wheels Up, supply about 20% of revenue, and some 4,000 others each account for under 1%. Oak also covers how installations happen. The aftermarket now delivers over 60% of new installs, against under 40% through line fit. Gogo ships about 1,300 units a year but expects only about 600 net additions, because of upgrades, deactivations, and a four-to-five month lag between shipping and activation.

The middle of the discussion is technical. Oak compares ATG with GEO satellite service on cost and latency, then explains why LEO constellations need less power and lose less signal. He contrasts Starlink's roughly 350-mile orbit, which needs about 11,000 satellites in phase one and laser links to cover oceans, with OneWeb's higher orbit and Airbus's two-satellites-a-day factory. Starlink's reliance on regional jets such as JSX's 35-seat Embrarers follows from that ocean limitation. Oak's reading of this comparison is labeled contested.

The forecasts and risks are the most debatable material. Oak cites NBAA and GAMA targets of full connectivity in 10 to 15 years to support a long unit-growth runway before the business turns annuity-like. He gives a probabilistic view of SmartSky's four-patent suit, including how hard a preliminary injunction is to win. He also points to COVID, when about 20% of customers paused service but service revenue fell only about 4%, and to younger owners who expect internet on board.

Sharpest takeaway

Oak Thorne argues Gogo's business-aviation in-flight connectivity works like digital infrastructure: equipment installed once on long-lived aircraft creates high switching costs, and licensed spectrum, dealer certification, and ATG-plus-LEO aggregation keep competitors out.

  • Equipment stays on aircraft for about 20 years across multiple owners, so acquisition cost is paid once and service revenue recurs at about 75% margin
  • Licensed 4 MHz air-to-ground spectrum bought for $31 million cannot be replicated, and unlicensed-spectrum rivals face interference
  • Adding LEO antennas to existing ATG systems is meant to defend the North American base while opening the 14,000 non-US business aircraft

The argument · threads11 threads · 75 claims
0.71

Long-lived installed base and sticky recurring revenue persist across aircraft ownership changes.

15 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Gogo's 2021 service revenue was about $260 million, with most coming from ATG and a small portion from legacy Iridium and SwiftBroadband narrowband products.

    “Our service revenue for 21 was about 260 million.”

  • Gogo's recurring service revenue carries roughly 75% gross margin, with costs including backhaul, customer service staff and tower rent, some of which are fixed and so scale with volume.

    “That's about 75 percent-ish margin for us.”

  • Upgrading an existing AVANCE L5 to 5G requires roughly the same antenna footprint and a box swap costing well under half of a full install, so customers are unlikely to switch vendors.

    “And in terms of these upgrades where you're looking at something much less than half that cost, you're really not going to want to leave us”

  • Like a tower company, Gogo's network investment is sunk, so each additional aircraft carries almost no incremental capital and new customers are very profitable, with the country's roughly 250 towers functioning as the shared asset.

    “every time we add an aircraft, we don't have to add any investment. We've already made that investment.”

  • Gogo's network can support about three times its current number of aircraft, including 25% annual consumption growth, and maintenance capex is projected at $15 to $20 million per year, with some spend expanding capacity toward 5X.

    “So we can handle about three times as many as we have today.”

  • When an aircraft is sold, the previous owner turns off the Gogo equipment but the next owner turns it back on, and aircraft change hands about every seven years, so the installed hardware keeps generating service revenue across ownership changes.

    “But the equipment stays. So when one guy sells it, he turns it off. But the next guy, when they get it, they turn it back on.”

  • Gogo plans about $100 million of external spend on its 5G network, with about one third spent so far, two thirds capex and one third opex, roughly 90% spent by end of 2022, and the buildout is on time and on budget.

    “So we've said we're going to spend about a hundred million dollars in external spend on 5G.”

  • Gogo's equipment has been on aircraft for about 20 years on average and is almost never removed, because replacing a competitor requires a new system with new boxes, wiring, access points and antennas costing hundreds of thousands of dollars, so switching costs are high.

    “So like almost nobody's ever taken it off. And that's because the switching costs are high”

  • Gogo netted over 600 ATG systems last year and expects about 600 net additions per year going forward, even though it ships about 1,300 units annually, because of upgrades, equipment turned off and a four-to-five month lag between shipping and activation.

    “so we'll ship 1,300 this year, but they're not all going to be installed”

  • Gogo reinvests in improving service and products, which makes customers happier, drives more sign-ups for equipment, and generates more service plan cash, forming a self-reinforcing loop.

    “there's sort of a virtuous circle, which is the more we can invest in improving the service”

  • Gogo expects about $125 million of free cash flow next year before its GBB investment and projected around $200 million by 2025 on the baseline plan, helped by lower interest payments after deleveraging.

    “$125 million in free cash flow next year, that does not include our GBB investment however.”

  • The host argues Gogo fits the digital infrastructure model of build once and monetize for decades with recurring, low-churn, low-capital revenue, and Oak agrees the long equipment lifetimes and negative acquisition costs make it resemble digital infrastructure.

    “I think the other big feature is, we have these long equipment on an aircraft lifetimes.”

  • Gogo's founders and private equity owner GTCR together hold over 40% of the company, and Oak says the company is valued for its long-term prospects but would consider a sale at the right price.

    “I've sold two companies in the past and if somebody comes along with the right price, we'd certainly be open to an exit”

  • During COVID about 20% of Gogo customers briefly suspended service, but service revenue declined only about 4%, showing that connectivity revenue is sticky even when aircraft cannot fly.

    “COVID, about 20% of our customer suspended service briefly. And we had about a 4% decline in service revenue.”

  • Gogo's top 10 customers, including Flexjet, NetJets and Wheels Up, account for about 20% of revenue, and the remaining 80% comes from about 4,000 customers with none above 1%, a fragmented base Oak considers healthy.

    “Our top 10 customers, which includes Flexjet obviously, and NetJets, and Wheels Up, they account for about 20% of revenue.”

0.69

Spectrum licensing, certifications, and regulatory approvals create entry barriers rivals cannot practically overcome.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Gogo bought 4 MHz of FCC air-to-ground licensed spectrum for $31 million, and this spectrum is unlikely ever to be auctioned again, so it is a durable competitive advantage that no new entrant can practically acquire.

    “We managed to get that spectrum for $31 million, which is a real song when you think about what spectrum costs today.”

  • Competitors relying on unlicensed 2.4 GHz spectrum face severe interference over dense coastal areas, because consumer WiFi, Bluetooth and similar devices build up noise that overwhelms aircraft-to-tower signals, which makes unlicensed-only service structurally harder than licensed service.

    “There's a lot of parts of the United States, especially on the coast where there's a tremendous amount of interference.”

  • Gogo's roughly 120 dealers develop engineering designs and hold STCs, which take about a year to obtain from the FAA and can be licensed to other dealers, so STCs create a barrier to entry that rivals must overcome.

    “That's important and it's a barrier to entry. You've got to get STC done, all these planes.”

  • Gogo uses large ground antennas and small airborne antennas, with two 13-inch aircraft antennas versus SmartSky's 30-inch and 15-inch units, because transmit power can be shifted between ground and air, and an inverse relationship between antenna size and required power lets Gogo put the power burden on towers.

    “We made the decision, we're going to have really big antennas on the ground.”

  • A new entrant cannot practically build a licensed-spectrum air-to-ground service because no licensed spectrum is for sale, so a competitor must build on unlicensed spectrum, which is the barrier protecting Gogo's position.

    “I can't, practically speaking, build a licensed spectrum service. There is no licensed spectrum for sale.”

  • Getting new antenna designs approved requires meeting industry standards and regulatory hurdles, which Gogo manages by designing products that are likely to be approved, since investing heavily in something unapprovable is the main risk.

    “You design your products in such a way that you know they're going to get approved.”

  • Even in a loss, patent cases of this kind usually award a royalty of a couple of percentage points of revenue for the infringed component, so the downside is bounded.

    “they usually end up being a couple of percentages, or points of revenue, or whatever.”

0.57

Gogo's 5G and aggregated LEO platform technically outperforms rival connectivity architectures.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Gogo's 5G network will run on unlicensed spectrum but be aggregated with its licensed 4G network so customers always keep licensed coverage, delivering about 25 Mbit/s average and peaks of 75 to 80 Mbit/s when it launches in the second half of 2022.

    “That 5G network will run on unlicensed spectrum, but it will be aggregated with our 4G network”

  • Starlink's approach at about 350 miles requires far more satellites, around 11,000 in phase one, suffers higher drag-driven fall-out and maintenance costs, and needs expensive laser inter-satellite links to cover ocean routes that lack ground stations.

    “They fall out of the sky a lot more often because they're actually not high enough”

  • Just over half of Gogo's installed base remains on its legacy classic product, which runs on 3G and 4G networks at about 1 Mbit/s but keeps very low latency because the antennas are close to towers.

    “Our classic product, it's just over half of our install bases still on our old product lines.”

  • Inmarsat and Viasat, the two geostationary satellite competitors, are merging or in process of merging; Inmarsat has the only pseudo-global system but thin coverage and expensive, heavy equipment, while Viasat's coverage is regional with its KA network.

    “There are two geo satellite competitors today, Inmarsat and Viasat, and they're going to merge”

  • Gogo's AVANCE platform can combine multiple networks such as 4G, 5G and LEO into one aggregated link, so a user might get 50 Mbit/s on LEO plus 25 Mbit/s on ATG for about 75 combined in North America, and the platform uses common componentry across L3 and L5 variants.

    “So if you're getting 50 Mbit/s on your LEO antenna, and you're getting 25 Mbit/s on your ATG antenna, now you can get 75 combined”

  • LEO satellites orbit at roughly 350 miles for Starlink and 750 to 800 miles for OneWeb, so they need much less power, have much lower latency and less path loss than geosynchronous satellites at 22,000 miles.

    “You're going, in Elon's case, 350 miles. And in OneWeb's case, 750 or 800 miles.”

  • Customers report 2 to 8 Mbit/s on Gogo L3 and L5, while Gogo's internal city-route tests show about 25 Mbit/s average for 5G, with peaks of 75 to 80 Mbit/s, and SmartSky's claim of 8 Mbit/s average was later revised downward once Gogo announced its 25 Mbit/s figure.

    “Now SmartSky, right before the NBAA conference, they were in a magazine article”

  • Unlike the 4G cone-based network where aircraft pass through overlapping cones and are handed tower to tower, 5G uses beamforming to point a beam at and track each specific plane through the sky.

    “It's all based on beamforming. So the antennas in 5G, they're pointing a beam at that plane and they're actually tracking the plane through the sky.”

0.47

Large, under-penetrated business aircraft base offers a long growth runway among wealthy flyers.

10 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Gogo has about 1,800 of the roughly 4,000 US heavy business jets, with its geosynchronous competitors combined having about 100 fewer, and Gogo has about 6,600 ATG systems installed out of roughly 8,000 US business planes with connectivity.

    “We've got about 1,800 of those, maybe a little more. And our competitors, combined, have about a 100 less than we do.”

  • Aftermarket WiFi adoption is slow because aircraft average about 20 years old and owners typically install systems only during large maintenance events that occur every five to six years, so each aircraft offers few installation opportunities.

    “So typically, people don't install the systems until it goes in for a large maintenance event”

  • Of roughly 220,000 FAA general aviation aircraft, about 24,000 are business aircraft in the US, and only about 30% of them currently have in-flight WiFi, so penetration is low relative to the addressable base.

    “Of those 220,000, 24,000 are considered business aircraft.”

  • Aftermarket installs flex quickly because operators can rent hangar space and handle more aircraft, while OEM production takes longer to ramp, so the aftermarket now accounts for over 60% of new Gogo installs, versus under 40% through OEM line fit.

    “But when there's flex in the market, it's the aftermarket they can flex. The OEMs can't flex as much.”

  • Business aircraft OEMs currently have book-to-bill ratios around two, versus historically around one, indicating a sharp order surge, though they remain cautious about a possible economic downturn slowing orders.

    “they've got bill-to-book ratios that are... Or, book-to-bill I should say... around two.”

  • Gogo announced a global product with OneWeb and Hughes using a small fuselage antenna to access the OneWeb LEO constellation, targeting the roughly 14,000 non-US business aircraft and lifting its total addressable aircraft count from about 24,000 to 38,000.

    “So it's a nice expansion to our TAM. If you think of it, U.S. TAM's about 24,000. And then we'll add 14,000 to that for a total of 38,000.”

  • Gogo sees a 10 to 15 year unit growth runway because NBAA projects 100% of business aircraft will have in-flight connectivity in about 10 years and GAMA targets about 15 years, after which the business becomes more annuity-like.

    “I believe NBAA, which is the National Business Aviation Association projects that 100% of business aircraft will have in-flight connectivity in 10 years time.”

  • The main barometer of demand for private aviation connectivity is the number of high net worth individuals, with membership programs suggesting those above about $30 million net worth fly privately, and a large group of these flyers still lacks WiFi.

    “The main barometer in terms of drivers, it's the number of high net worth individuals.”

  • About 67% of Gogo customers are now Gen X, Y or Z rather than baby boomers, and these younger flyers expect internet, so secondhand buyers who lack it are likely to install it.

    “67% of our customers now are gen X, Y, and Z, as opposed to baby boomers.”

  • About 70 to 75 percent of new business aviation deliveries go to the US, and about 60 of those 70 have Gogo installed at delivery, while heavy jets going abroad carry geo satellite systems, with Gulfstream adding Gogo post-delivery.

    “About 70% of those aircraft are destined for the U.S., 70%-75%.”

0.40

SmartSky's threat is weak given spectrum protection, weak patents, and unproven speeds at similar pricing.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • SmartSky is a 4G network that started building in 2014, has still not delivered a working network or product, and relies only on unlicensed spectrum, so Oak does not view it as a real 5G competitor.

    “First of all, they're not a 5G competitor. They're a 4G network. They started in 2014 building this”

  • Gogo's licensed spectrum is paid for and can be renewed as long as it is used, so absent major legal changes the spectrum license is relatively protected.

    “We paid for the spectrum. And as long as we use it, we can renew it.”

  • SmartSky has sued Gogo over four patents, Gogo claims it does not infringe them, and a preliminary injunction against the 5G launch is a hard bar for plaintiffs, who must show a likelihood of success around 70 to 80 percent plus irreparable harm, while any eventual royalty would likely be a few percentage points of revenue.

    “And then it has 70, 80% chance that they will prevail.”

  • Oak says SmartSky claimed in AIN magazine it would average 8 Mbps, a figure testers in Las Vegas roughly reproduced, but when Gogo announced 25 Mbps for its 5G product, SmartSky's expected speed moved to 15 Mbps, which Oak says reflects an unproven product.

    “But then when we said, 'Okay, well, we're getting 25. Now they're going to get 15.' I can't really tell you what they're going to get.”

  • SmartSky has published pricing only slightly below Gogo's, so there is not a large price gap between the two products.

    “Well, they've published pricing and it's just a little bit less than ours.”

  • SmartSky started building its network in 2014 but has still not delivered a working network or product, and its flagship antenna setup (30-inch and 15-inch antennas) is too large and heavy for most aircraft.

    “They started in 2014 building this and they still haven't really delivered the networks.”

0.40

ATG combined with satellite aggregation lets Gogo defend North America against Starlink.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Over the US, ATG is cheaper and has much lower latency than geosynchronous satellite because signals travel only about a couple hundred miles to a tower rather than 22,000 miles up and back, so airlines and owners switch to Gogo while over the US and to geo abroad.

    “And we have much lower latency because we're not going 22,000 miles up and back.”

  • Starlink's business entry is coming through regional jets because without inter-satellite links it cannot serve transoceanic airline routes, and its first announced deal was with JSX, a scheduled service flying 35-seat Embraer regional jets over North America.

    “And the reason for that is without the Inter-Satellite Links, they really can't serve airlines that go over the ocean.”

  • After its 2020 strategic planning, Gogo judged Starlink to be the highest risk among threats to its business, and much of its strategy is designed to dig a deeper moat so that Starlink either stays out or Gogo can compete effectively.

    “And as we look at the risks out there to the business of Starlink probably are the highest risk that we saw.”

  • Satellite (LEO) service will be a managed variable-pricing model paid by the megabit with lower margins than ATG, while Gogo owns the equipment but does not build the satellite network.

    “But remember, we're not paying for fixed beams in that business, so variable pricing.”

  • Adding an ESA LEO antenna to an AVANCE aircraft with ATG gives combined capacity exceeding what a LEO-only competitor offers, and this aggregation is how Gogo expects to protect its North American market from Starlink.

    “the argument goes that ATG plus LEO is going to be greater than LEO alone.”

  • Gogo is building electronically steerable flat-panel antennas with Hughes that switch beams with no moving parts in seconds, while competitors use mechanical antennas that wear out under constant turning and struggle to keep up with rapid satellite switching.

    “And it has no moving parts, so it should be very durable. And it can switch the beams very quickly.”

0.38

Gogo's U.S. air-to-ground business rests on tower coverage, installation economics, and Textron jet placement.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Gogo's service revenue grew quickly during 2009 to 2011, though this is an imperfect comparison because ATG was a relatively new product at that time.

    “'09, '10, '11 actually was a good era for us.”

  • A first-time ATG system install costs about $300,000 on an aircraft, and a satellite install costs $400,000 to $700,000, with Gogo capturing less than list price after discounts to dealers who handle labor and parts.

    “it's probably like 300,000 the first time you put somebody in, if it's a ATG system. For satellite, it's 400,000 to 700,000.”

  • The new 5G antennas are roughly the same size as the old 4G antennas and screw into the same mounting holes on the aircraft, requiring only a small adapter plate, so the swap from 4G to 5G is not very difficult.

    “So it's not a very difficult switch out to go from the 4G network antennas to the 5G network.”

  • Textron's jets are Gogo's sweet spot, with Gogo appearing on almost every plane delivered and kept in the U.S., while Gulfstreams typically receive Gogo after leaving the factory rather than as line-fit.

    “At Textron, that's our sweet spot. Those kinds of jets, we come out on almost every plane that's staying in the U.S.”

  • The U.S. is divided into overlapping ATG cones that intersect at about 3,000 feet, which is Gogo's service altitude, and aircraft are handed from tower to tower as they pass through.

    “They intersect at about 3,000 ft, which is why that's our service altitude.”

0.26

Global LEO broadband can displace heavy, limited geostationary satellite products on large jets worldwide.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Customers of geo satellite providers report typically 2 to 17 Mbps, with Inmarsat and the older Viasat Ku product at the low end and Viasat's newer Ka-band products at the high end, according to Gogo's customer survey.

    “they think they're getting typically 2 to 17 Mbit/s with Inmarsat kind of down at the bottom of that”

  • Global broadband is offensive as well as defensive: beyond the 14,000 non-U.S. aircraft, it lets large jets that fly globally replace geo satellite products with Gogo's LEO product, displacing geo providers.

    “And we can go after that geo product and replace with our LEO product.”

  • Geostationary satellite equipment is heavy, bulky, expensive to install, and costly to service, so it fits only large jets, and geo operators Inmarsat and Viasat face limited global coverage and high prices.

    “geo satellites are 22,000 miles above the Earth. That means that they need a lot of power and pretty big antennas on the plane to reach that.”

  • Many aircraft carry both ATG and geo equipment, flipping to Gogo's ATG inside the U.S. and to geo abroad, because geo data is more expensive per megabyte once overages apply.

    “And when they get outside the U.S., they flip on the geo satellite service. And when they're over the U.S., they use us.”

  • Viasat's ViaSat-3 satellite, expected to launch around the end of the year or into the next, will provide about a third of Earth coverage, but Viasat currently has no true global product.

    “And that'll give them sort of a third of the Earth coverage. So they don't really have a global product right now.”

  • The FAA's general aviation category includes about 220,000 aircraft, of which about 24,000 are business aircraft used for business, charter, or fractional purposes, and Gogo's network covers only the United States and southern Canada.

    “there's about 220,000 aircraft in what the FAA labels general aviation... Of those 220,000, 24,000 are considered business aircraft.”

0.24

Cheaper launch and mass-produced satellites make LEO constellations cheaper and feasible.

5 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Starlink lacked inter-satellite links at first because it could not see land from some orbital positions, such as over the Pacific, so it needed to pass signals between satellites by laser; this costly complex technology makes its network expensive and unique, while OneWeb avoids it with more ground stations.

    “he can't always see land from the satellite. So he has to put in Inter-Satellite Links”

  • OneWeb, which has more ground stations and avoids expensive inter-satellite links, should have lower cost than Starlink; it was set back by the Ukraine war when launches from Kazakhstan were disrupted, but has relocated launches to the United States and expects to resume launching.

    “OneWeb can reach the Earth from any satellite, so it has more ground stations than Elon's got, but does not have the expensive Inter-Satellite Links.”

  • Mass production of satellites was pioneered by OneWeb and Airbus, which manufactures the OneWeb constellation at a factory producing about two satellites a day, shifting satellites away from one-off, bespoke geo builds.

    “The whole idea of actually having mass production of satellites was really pioneered by OneWeb and Airbus”

  • Cheaper launch is a big part of why LEO became feasible, but many other technological developments, especially in antennas, also enabled it, and the shift from one-off satellites to mass production was a key change in approach.

    “That's a big part of it. There's just a whole lot of technological developments around antennas and other things that enabled it.”

  • Starlink and OneWeb's lower-altitude architectures lead to lower latency, but a geo-equivalent system still requires more power, and geo services remain the only pseudo-global option, covering all but the poles.

    “Inmarsat is a classic old geo mobility satellite company... They have the only pseudo global system today.”

0.22

Gogo's past pivots and management experience inform its current strategy.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Gogo's original analog cellular network for business aircraft became unviable when analog backhaul disappeared around 1999 to 2000, and without money to build digital, the company moved customers to Iridium narrowband satellite.

    “the analog backhaul that we relied on for that network really started disappearing in '99, or 2000, or so.”

  • Building a complex product business requires a transparent, cross-functional culture where people across the value chain, including billing, talk openly about issues, and sometimes the smartest person on the team must be removed to move the team forward.

    “And sometimes the smartest guy in the room is the worst team member.”

  • Gogo entered commercial aviation around 2008 with ATG on airlines like Delta and American, then exited in 2020 because satellite-based commercial service, especially outside the US, was not profitable.

    “And ultimately, that didn't end up to be a very profitable business, especially the business outside the U.S. So we finally exited that in 2020.”

  • Oak previously led Commerce Clearing House through digitization in the late 1980s and 1990s, converting print loose-leaf publications to CD-ROM and online formats, and sold the business to Wolters Kluwer for about three times its value when he took over.

    “And we ended up selling that in the mid-'90s to Wolters Kluwer for about three times what it was worth when I took over”

0.06

Oak says new leaders should invite questions, since asking them helps leaders learn fast.

3 pointscentrality 1/5
  • New leaders should openly invite questions, even ones they think are stupid, because this lowers barriers for the team, which helps the leader learn fast in unfamiliar industries.

    “Don't ever be scared to ask questions, no matter how dumb you think the question is.”

  • Oak took eCollege public in December 1999 raising $55 million, saw its value fall to about $36 million within weeks, then saved it through a turnaround, and later sold it to Pearson for about 5X after six years.

    “I managed to get public at the end of the dot com bubble in December of '99 and raised $55 million.”

  • Oak joined Gogo knowing nothing about satellites, telecom, or airplanes and was hired because he could start on Monday, so he asks many questions and tells the team in advance that a question may be stupid, which encourages others to ask questions too.

    “Don't ever be scared to ask questions, no matter how dumb you think the question is.”