Wyndham Hotels: Loyalty Matters
What this covers
This episode of Business Breakdowns features Lauren Taylor Wolfe, who runs a concentrated portfolio of 10 to 12 names, explaining Wyndham as a business and as an investment her firm made. She starts with history: Howard Johnson became the first franchise hotel in 1954, and the 1956 highway act helped create roadside mid-scale brands. She then explains how a Franchisor operates, covering 10-to-20-year contracts, 94% to 95% retention, and 99% renewal among eligible hotels. Growth comes mostly from Conversion of independents, which costs roughly $25,000 to $40,000, and from international master franchisees who keep 70% to 80% of the economics.
The middle of the conversation tests the threats. Online travel agencies, once 10% to 20% of hotel traffic, now drive 60% to 70% of independents' traffic. Oyo, backed by SoftBank, aimed for 100,000 US rooms in 2019 and finished with just over 20,000. Airbnb gets a segment-by-segment look: its roughly $120 nightly rate sits above Wyndham's economy and mid-scale rates, and about 40% of Wyndham bookings are same-day. Lauren still flags a long-term risk if hosts learn to turn rooms around quickly. A survey of about 130 franchisees found Wyndham wrongly perceived as expensive, which she reads as a messaging problem. She also covers energy retrofits as a margin lever.
The last stretch is about investing. Her firm bought near 10 times EBITDA after the La Quinta merger scared off Wall Street, a Go Where They Ain't bet. Since May 2021, economy through upper mid-scale RevPAR has run above 2019 levels, while luxury remains 30% to 40% below. She stresses resilience and capital allocation as the real sources of step-change growth.
Wyndham's value rests on an asset-light franchise royalty stream with roughly 80% margins, sticky 10-to-20-year contracts, and an 89-million-member loyalty program that makes branded conversion more economical than running an independent hotel, so its growth depends on net room growth and capital allocation rather than non-linear upside.
- Franchise royalties of 4-5.5% of room revenue carry about 80% margins, including through the 2020 pandemic year
- Loyalty program and brand trust drive traffic, and OTA fees of 20-30% make branded franchising roughly economically equivalent to or better than independence
- Growth is modeled as about 3-4% net room growth plus low-to-mid single digit RevPAR growth, with the economy segment acting as a cash cow
Wyndham's franchise and cash-flow model is protected, stable, and steady rather than explosive.
- Wyndham has had no bankruptcies or foreclosures among its franchisees, and the franchise model is described as a protected, stable model, supported by the low breakeven occupancy of economy properties.
“They've had no bankruptcies and foreclosure, so it's a very protected, stable, tried and true business model to franchisees.”
- Beyond steady cash flows, the key value driver is capital allocation, since the business generates a large amount of cash with limited reinvestment needs, and the management team's choices about buying brands or entering segments represent the main source of step-change growth.
“the real kicker, I think, will come through capital allocation. This is a business that throws off a ton of cash”
- Wyndham prefers its management model to Marriott and Hilton because very little of its profit depends on owners' operating profit, whereas those peers earn incentive fees tied to hotel operating profit and food and beverage.
“more of their profitability depends on the operating profit of the franchisee or of the hotel owner... And we liked the fact that very little of their profitability relied on this.”
- The investment was made in 2019 when the economic cycle was late stage, and the firm chose Wyndham for its resilience and stability, viewing it as a protected-downside holding rather than a high-growth business.
“it wasn't lost on us that we were very late stage into a market cycle and an economic cycle. And one of the key elements of this business that attracted us to it was the business resilience and the stability”
- As a franchisee, the key is understanding brand value and the franchisor's support, and Wyndham's flexibility on fee timing and relief during the pandemic exemplified a partnership model that makes franchisees resilient.
“Wyndham was extremely flexible with their franchisee partners, provided a lot of relief in terms of fee payments”
- Wyndham is a stable, cash-cow-like business whose profitability and free cash flow can be forecast within tight bands, and the company has little exposure to non-linear breakthroughs or disruptions, meaning its growth is steady rather than explosive.
“We pretty much know within certain tight bands, what that business is going to throw off in terms of profitability and free cash flow.”
Brand trust and market structure, not new entrants, limit disruptive competition in hotels.
- Wyndham and Choice each had about 30 to 50 salespeople in the economy segment, far fewer than the hundreds Oyo hired, indicating that sales headcount alone does not determine share in this segment.
“the two key competitors who dominate the market Wyndham and Choice in the economy segment had, call it between 30 and 50 salespeople, not hundreds of salespeople.”
- Luxury and upscale hotels still run 30 to 40 percent below 2019 levels because much of their business travel has not returned, with less than 30 percent of their business coming from travel that is mostly by workers.
“They have a lot of travel based business that hasn't come back when it has very little less than 30% travel business and most of that are workers.”
- US franchisees already have wide choice and trust established brands, so a well-funded new entrant like Oyo could not sign hotels at the rate it did in India and Southeast Asia, showing that brand trust limits disruptive competition in the US.
“competing in the US were franchisees already have a broad range of choices and they had these substantial brands... where they had developed a significant amount of trust with the franchisee customer base”
- There are about 180,000 hotels globally with 16.5 million rooms, split about one-third US, one-third Europe, 20% Asia, and the rest Latin America and the Middle East, while Airbnb already has about 5.5 million listings.
“there are about 180,000 hotels globally representing 16.5 million rooms.”
Loyalty points and green programs should draw more guests and franchisees into Wyndham.
- Green and energy efficiency programs should drive more franchisees into the Wyndham system because they improve franchisee return metrics, and the company's green certification toolbox is being rolled out after being delayed during the pandemic.
“It should also be able to drive more franchisees to the Wyndham system because they have better overall return metrics.”
- Loyalty points redeemable across roughly 15 to 20 brands help guests discover that brands like Travelodge belong to Wyndham, which Lauren argues drives traffic throughout the system.
“it's hard to know that a Travelodge is actually owned by Wyndham and you can use your Wyndham reward points for Travelodge.”