The Modern Activist Toolkit
What this covers
Lauren Taylor Wolfe of Impactive Capital talks with Patrick about how activist investing has changed and how her firm practices it. Impactive tests each new position against four questions on quality, valuation, time, and activism. Once inside a company, it draws on a bespoke menu of capital structure changes, strategic moves such as M&A and divestitures, and operational efficiency. Wolfe contrasts this with the older approach of quick fixes at weak companies, and she describes a style of engagement that leads with facts and keeps a private-equity mindset toward management.
The middle of the conversation covers boardroom mechanics. Wolfe notes that fights over declassified boards and split CEO and chair roles are now settled, with staggered boards in the S&P 500 falling from about 70% to roughly 10%. She treats governance as both a cost-of-equity lever and an entry point that activist defense advisers warn companies about. She also describes why selling weaker segments can lift the multiple on what remains, why boards need outside data on capital allocation, and how 80 customer calls showed a software company it could raise subscription prices rather than discount them.
The most distinctive material concerns ESG. Wolfe's example is Asbury Automotive, where recruiting women, who are about 2% of mechanics, could lift utilization and enterprise value. She also describes pressing service providers to staff diverse teams. Some of her claims are contested: that low rates make public markets price large technology companies like venture investments, that dual-class structures carry long-term succession risk, and that scale favors the already dominant.
Lauren Taylor Wolfe argues modern activism should target high-quality, dominant businesses where time is an ally, and should pursue ESG change only when it is material and tied to a business case, using humble partnership with management instead of adversarial campaigns.
- Short-term quick-fix activism in low-quality businesses leaves illiquid stakes where time works against the investor
- ESG initiatives are accepted only where they are material to the business and increase profitability over the long run
- Constructive, private engagement with boards earns invitations to board seats without proxy fights
Boards and activists must demand better data and accountability on capital allocation.
- Share buybacks make sense when a company has confidence that today's price far discounts its long-term or intrinsic value, so buybacks should be judged by price relative to intrinsic value rather than applied automatically.
“Share buybacks make a ton of sense when the price is right.”
- Wolfe has advocated for boards to form capital allocation committees and to be equipped with data on alternatives that competitors or similar business models pursue, not only the options management presents.
“I've been an advocate in many different boardrooms for like a capital allocation committee.”
- Corporate boards lack access to the resources, such as Wall Street research and market analysis, needed to make strategic capital decisions, and although companies communicate better about capital allocation, boards are still not holding management accountable for optimal capital allocation.
“boardrooms in corporate America simply don't have access to the resources that would allow them to make really strategic capital decisions”
- The three core capital-allocation-oriented activist tools are capital structure changes (levered recaps, REIT or MLP restructurings), strategic initiatives (M&A, divestitures, sale of the company), and operational efficiency (margin improvement and returns on incremental capital), applied as a bespoke menu depending on company and market conditions.
“The three key capital allocation oriented activist tools were capital structure, strategic initiatives, and operational efficiencies.”
- HD Supply sold its waterworks business, reducing leverage from about 5.5 turns to just under three turns, leaving a recession-resistant facilities maintenance business with dominant multifamily MRO share and high cash conversion; it later sold its construction and industrial business to CD&R.
“a couple years ago they sold the waterworks business which helped the business de-lever from five and a half turns to just under three turns”
- Wolfe admits she does not understand why the market places such high multiples on top-line revenue of large technology companies as a value investor, and she is trying to understand the justification for these valuations.
“how the market is placing such a high multiple on sort of the top line”
- Value investors can find opportunity in pockets of the market outside large tech, particularly by investing in high-quality businesses and using activist levers to accelerate returns and gain control of their own return path.
“we think there are pockets of opportunity within our market.”
- Asbury Automotive, one of Impactive's largest positions, has shifted from cyclical new-car sales toward a razor-and-blade model in which parts and services drive two-thirds of profitability, yet the market has not appreciated the change.
“it's become more of a razor-razorblade model and the parts and services segment of the business drives two thirds of the profitability”
- Impactive is willing to back management investments that may diminish margins by a couple hundred basis points in the first few quarters, because it has confidence in the long-term IRR, which differentiates it from short-term-focused hedge funds.
“you might have to sacrifice a couple hundred basis points of margin in the first couple quarters, but we have confidence in the long term IRR of this project.”
- Wolfe used to send all her CEOs Will Thorndike's book The Outsiders, and now they all have it and their other investors send it too, showing that communication about capital allocation has improved.
“I used to send all of my CEOs Thorndike's book The Outsiders.”
- A strong board should combine investment experience, prior CEO-level experience, HR, audit, risk, and capital allocation expertise, with open discussion and the ability to challenge management and one another constructively.
“I think on a board it would be a combination of folks with investment experience, folks with prior CEO level experience, folks with HR experience”
- Hedge funds with maniacal focus on each quarter have plagued the market with short-termism, which blocks productive conversations about long-term strategic investments that may dent margins for a few quarters.
“the market has been plagued with so much short-termism and hedge funds who are so maniacally focused on each quarter”
- Companies have caught on that activists used governance weaknesses as a wedge, so corporate governance has been largely fixed and activists must now find other angles, such as operating and capital allocation issues.
“most activists in the past have used general governance weaknesses as sort of the wedge in the door to the boardroom”
Overlooked women and diversity improve productivity and business outcomes, so build them into commercial cases.
- Women made up only about 2% of mechanics even though many women were interested in becoming mechanics, making them an overlooked candidate pool that could address Asbury's labor shortage.
“Women were only 2% of mechanics but there was a big interest and a growing interest from women”
- Greater labor force participation by women raises productivity, output, and growth, a pattern Wolfe says has been observed in construction and healthcare.
“women participate in the labor force in a greater rate, productivity improves, output improves, growth improves”
- Asbury's measures to attract women, including paid maternity leave, four-day or dual-shift schedules, and changing rooms, could lift utilization from 50% to 55%, a roughly 15% uplift in enterprise value.
“If they can attract and retain more mechanics and more women, and they take their utilization from 50% to 55%, that's about a 15% uplift for their overall enterprise value.”
- US auto dealers and collision centers operate at about 50% utilization because of an industry-wide shortage of mechanics, creating a utilization problem Impactive targeted with Asbury Automotive.
“throughout auto dealers in the US and collision centers in the US, they're operating at about 50% utilization”
- To break self-replicating hiring, managers, HR, and boards should ensure candidate pools are diverse and actively plan succession and leadership development so diversity exists throughout the ranks, rather than waiting decades for education pipelines to change.
“my view is if you want to fill the funnel, managers and HR departments, and boards frankly, need to be very thoughtful about exploring the succession planning”
- Impactive required its service providers, including investment banks, law firms, and accountants, to staff its coverage with diverse teams, and noted that if $100 billion or more of asset-owner demand did the same, the demand would drive hiring and advancement for underrepresented groups.
“imagine if there were $100 billion or more of asset owners demanding coverage from an adequately diverse team of their service providers”
- Quotas and forced diversity can produce some unintended negatives, but the few highly successful promoted individuals inspire many others, so the longer-term returns will outweigh the drawbacks.
“those three, four, or five individuals in those positions of leadership inspire”
- Representation problems in the auto mechanic field closely resemble those of women in investment management, and Wolfe founded Impactive partly to show that there should be more multi-billion-dollar hedge funds run by women and minorities.
“there was striking similarity with representation of women in the investment management business”
- Wolfe rejects the excuse that a qualified female candidate's resume is not as strong, arguing that activists and investors have to fill their own talent funnel because they have had a decade to build the pipeline.
“The problem I always pushback is that you need to fill your own funnel.”
- Women dominate spending in the auto services field, spending $200 billion annually on parts, services, and automobiles, which makes them a commercially important customer base for dealers.
“They spend $200 billion annually on parts and services and automobiles.”
- If Asbury's labor retention and access to a new labor pool lift utilization from 50% to 55%, that is roughly a 15% uplift to the enterprise value, and the management team was persuaded by showing them that business case.
“If they can attract and retain more mechanics and more women, and they take their utilization from 50% to 55%, that's about a 15% uplift for their overall enterprise value.”
- Asbury became the first publicly listed auto dealer to offer paid maternity leave and moved to a four-day or dual-shift workweek, plus changing rooms and female-led workshops, to attract and retain female mechanics.
“they're the first publicly listed auto dealer to offer paid maternity leave.”
Long-held high-quality businesses outperform quick fixes like sales or buybacks.
- Looking back at a decade of activism, Wolfe concluded that some lower-quality businesses delivered great returns through quick fixes such as a sale or buybacks, but holding them long would have risked impairment, so Impactive now invests exclusively in high-quality businesses.
“But had we held those companies over the long run, there would have been really a greater risk of impairment of value.”
- Impactive's review of its own returns and those of other activists found that most of the best returns came from higher-quality businesses held long enough to compound and be enhanced by activist levers.
“the majority of the best returns were in higher quality businesses and when there was investing over the long run”
- Impactive evaluates every new business against four questions covering quality, valuation, time, and activism, with the most important being that it backs a high-quality business where time is its friend.
“we ask ourselves the four key questions. They're around quality, valuation, time, and activism.”
- The old activist paradigm pursued change at low-quality businesses or with low-quality management, seeking a short-term quick fix; this often failed, leaving the activist with a large illiquid stake where time is not a friend and diminished portfolio returns.
“The old paradigm of activism had investors pursuing change at very low-quality business or low-quality management teams”
ESG and governance improvements are becoming standard, unavoidable, and value-raising for companies.
- Governance reforms that were battles 10 to 15 years ago, such as declassifying boards, splitting CEO and chair roles, and moving to majority voting, are now standard, as staggered boards in the S&P 500 fell from about 70% seven years ago to roughly 10% three years ago.
“If you look back about seven years ago, something like 70% of S&P 500 companies had staggered or classified boards and three years ago it was only like 10%”
- Venture capitalists often have to accommodate entrepreneurs, so many private companies have governance structures that would be substandard if they had been raised in public markets.
“a lot of venture capitalists that unfortunately have to kowtow to the entrepreneurs”
- ESG improvements make companies more competitive by attracting and retaining stickier employees, customers, and shareholders, which lowers customer acquisition costs, human capital costs, and cost of capital, and ultimately raises profitability and valuation.
“Improved ESG ultimately allows companies to attract and retain stickier customers, stickier employees, and stickier shareholders.”
- Compensation committees can link incentives to environmental, social, and governance goals, and Wolfe expects such ESG metrics to appear increasingly in executive and line-manager compensation packages.
“there's an opportunity for compensation committees on boards to actually link some incentives and rewards to achieving certain environmental, social, and governance goals”
- Mandatory UK disclosure of gender pay gaps is coming, and companies that get ahead of these disclosure requirements on diversity will avoid being caught off guard by later questions.
“We already see in the UK market there's mandatory disclosure around gender pay gaps.”
- The COVID pandemic accelerated two ESG trends Impactive has engaged on since its founding, climate and environmental footprint on the environmental side and diversity and inclusion on the social side, with companies increasingly forced to disclose emissions via CDP and TCFD and diversity data over time.
“within ESG it's really accelerated two key trends that we've been engaged with companies on since the inception of the firm”
- Wolfe's friends with college-age kids or teenagers see climate change and diversity and inclusion as their defining movements, and she expects that they will allocate time and money in ways that advance both.
“these are their defining movements. Climate change and diversity and inclusion.”
- Wolfe is still working out how to accelerate stakeholder primacy and get ESG efforts front and center in a way that commands immediate action, since the case has to be made in business terms.
“trying to understand how to accelerate pushing stakeholder primacy”
- Employee walkouts such as those at Facebook over ads and professional athletes refusing to play to protest racism, along with customer boycotts such as those of Walmart and Dick's over assault weapons, show stakeholders are acting as activists.
“We've seen the employee walk out at Facebook over false ads and political ads and civil rights abuses.”
Governance quality drives activist vulnerability, cost of equity, and board performance.
- A pristine, healthy board has substantial cognitive diversity, with members bringing complementary skills and backgrounds (investing, prior CEO, HR, audit, risk, capital allocation), and cognitively diverse teams tend to perform better.
“A pristine, healthy board would have a substantial amount of cognitive diversity.”
- Where governance weaknesses remain in public companies, they are fairly strongly correlated with lower-quality businesses and lower-quality management teams.
“where you do, I would say there's probably a decent correlation with lower quality businesses and lower quality management teams”
- Investment banks' activist defense departments tell companies that activists have historically used governance weaknesses as the wedge into the boardroom, so companies that fix governance reduce their vulnerability to hostile campaigns.
“most activists in the past have used general governance weaknesses as sort of the wedge in the door to the boardroom”
- Growing pools of capital are allocated based on ISS governance ratings, so improving governance (Wolfe's HD Supply board moved from 9 out of 10 to 3 out of 10) can strategically lower a company's cost of equity.
“So we took our ISS rating from nine out of 10, 10 being the worst on governance, to 3 out of 10.”
- Management incentive design is idiosyncratic, but where the CEO is also chair there should be a very strong lead independent director, and compensation should emphasize ROIC, total shareholder return, and earnings growth tied to strategy.
“where there are situations where the CEO is also the chairman, you also want to have a very strong lead independent director”
- Dual-class share structures performed well so far, but over decades there is no guarantee that founders' heirs with permanent super-voting power will be the best leaders, so checks and balances may be a backward step that needs shareholder engagement to mitigate.
“are you definitely guaranteed that for instance the grandchildren of the founders who have permanent super voting power today are going to be the best leaders”
Activists win by influencing people and simplifying narratives the market rewards.
- Impactive leads with the facts and substance behind its ideas, making them as indisputable as possible, while engaging management and boards with a private-equity-style mindset aimed at partnership.
“It is extremely important at Impactive that we lead with the fact and the substance underlying our ideas.”
- Activists identify a few core value creation drivers and strip away noise, and they also help companies tell a simplified narrative of their strategy, because the market rewards predictable, unsurprising execution with higher multiples.
“the more surprises the market gets, the lower your multiple will be”
- Impactive seeks its own unique spots within companies that dominate their end markets, where they can grow in a near-secular manner, and aims to be in the driver's seat of its own return outcome through the ideas it brings to management.
“We are looking to find our unique spots in companies that dominate their end market where they can grow almost in a secular manner.”
- Patrick's observation that subscription businesses trade at high prices because they are steady and predictable matches Wolfe's view that lack of surprises supports high multiples and that Impactive pushes companies to add recurring revenue components.
“we engage with all of our companies thinking about how can we re-price the business or how can we restructure the business in a way where there can be some component of it that is recurring in nature.”
- Activism is fundamentally about influence: companies are evolving organisms of people and culture, so effective activists must choose the right tools to influence different people and constituents within a boardroom and management team.
“Ultimately we're in the business of influence. If you want to garner influence, you have to figure out what tools to use to influence different people”
- Large technology companies are being priced in public markets the way venture capitalists price companies, because low interest rates let distant cash flows be discounted at very low rates, making far-off cash flows worth extremely high values today.
“a lot of these large technology companies are being priced in the public market the way that venture capitalists price these companies”
Constructive, humble engagement beats hostile activism for all constituents.
- Hostile activists a decade ago wrote public whitepapers, skipped engagement with management and boards, and triggered automatic defensiveness and battle mode, whereas early constructive solutions benefit all constituents.
“Hostile activists 10 years ago would write a big whitepaper, not engage with management”
- Impactive has been invited onto boards of companies where it holds seats, and engages regularly with others where it has none, without running proxy contests, because it leads with humility and substance.
“We didn't have to run a proxy contest to access those boards.”
- When a large investor publicly supports a business-model transition, it gives management cover to accept a near-term hit to EBITDA and cash flow in exchange for accelerating cash flow growth later.
“If as a large investor we are willing to support this transition which might entail a hit to cash flows in the near term”
- When a board decision looked obvious from a spreadsheet, Wolfe found that understanding management's emotional loyalty to its team (a CEO who saw himself as captain after shared crisis experience) was necessary to craft a strategy and conduct behind-the-scenes shuttle diplomacy to reach the right answer.
“it was so important to understand where that management team and where that decision was coming from”
ESG change pays only when it is material and aligned with business economics.
- Impactive only pursues ESG change in the overlap between ESG initiatives and NPV-positive projects, and only when the ESG issue is material to the business and will drive long-run profitability and value, because boards are skeptical and need a business case.
“We only operate where those two circles overlap.”
- Impactive's long-term vision is to make one company the most sustainable in its industry and, if it becomes the most competitive, profitable, and valuable, competitors will be forced to follow, effectively changing the whole industry over a 10 to 20 year period.
“not only have we changed one company, we've effectively changed an industry”
- Employees and customers now act as activists, and the companies that attract the stickiest employees and customers are those whose communicated internal values match their actions, because both groups vote with their time and money for value-aligned firms.
“customers and employees have two key assets, their time and their money”
- Impactive worked with Wyndham to have its franchisees install green upgrades such as motion-sensor detectors and smart HVAC systems with one-year paybacks, using Wyndham's 9,000-hotel buying power for preferred pricing so franchisees earn higher cash-on-cash returns and Wyndham attracts franchisees.
“Wyndham could flex its muscle representing 9,000 hotels globally to get preferred pricing on things like motion sensor detectors and smart HVAC systems, which have one year paybacks”
Concentrated bets on dominant small-cap businesses offer high expected returns.
- Impactive holds eight to 12 positions, each 8% to 12% of AUM at cost, and because of this concentration it excludes binary-outcome businesses such as biotech and pharma where an FDA decision can move the stock tenfold or to zero.
“Because of our concentration we can't really have any investment that has an extreme binary outcome”
- Impactive's valuation screen requires an expected IRR in the high teens to low 20s, which reduces a universe of a couple hundred companies to just a few handfuls of actionable ideas.
“We're looking to target high teens to low 20s IRRs”
- Impactive focuses on companies that dominate their end markets because it sees a trend toward the big getting bigger, where scale allows dominant firms to take over market segments.
“we think there's a trend towards the big getting bigger”
- Impactive targets small-to-mid-cap companies, roughly from $500 million up to $7–8 billion in market cap, mostly in North America, because it sees the greatest alpha opportunity in the small-cap space.
“Figure a 500 million at the very low end of market cap, up to seven or eight billion at the very high end.”
Business quality and segment focus, not cyclicality, determine valuation multiples.
- Auto dealers have shifted from a cyclical new-car sales model to a razor-and-blade model in which parts and services generate about two-thirds of profitability, with 26% EBITDA margins and the highest return on incremental invested capital.
“it's become more of a razor-razorblade model and the parts and services segment of the business drives two thirds of the profitability”
- Separating or selling lower-quality segments can raise the multiple on the remaining high-quality business, since the weaker segments were dragging down the valuation of the whole company.
“the company could be more valuable separated than as united with its five segments”
- A portfolio company planning to move from perpetual to subscription licensing assumed it needed a big discount, but Impactive's 80 customer calls showed that existing subscription pricing could rise 20% to 25% because of the company's monopoly-like position and customers' replacement costs.
“on the existing subscription products you could almost take the pricing up 20% or 25%”
- Misunderstood high-quality businesses, such as Avid, can carry extremely low multiples when complexity, management turnover, and opaque segment disclosure make the market unable to see recurring quality, so the company must demonstrate consistent performance and clear framing.
“the quality and recurring nature of the business is misunderstood by the market and particularly because it was very complex”
Personal mentors shaped her career, and she is committed to paying it forward.
- Wolfe moved from dot-com-era consulting to a family office, then to SIAR Capital from 2003 to 2007, then to Blue Harbour for about a decade, where the firm grew from about $600 million to about $3.5 billion.
“I watched that business grow from about $600 million to about $3.5 billion by the time we left.”
- Wolfe credits her fifth-grade teacher, Mrs. Hannin, for urging her into the accelerated track, and her later mentors who believed in her before she believed in herself, and she is committed to paying that forward.
“my fifth grade teacher, Mrs. Hannin, urged me and my parents to get me into the accelerated track”