Quality and Innovation
What this covers
Patrick talks with Vaughn Tan, who studies innovation by watching restaurant R&D teams, partly because a dish can be developed in days at low cost of failure. The conversation starts from a distinction between risk, where outcomes and odds are known like a die roll, and Knightian Uncertainty, where the possible outcomes are themselves unknown. Tan says most people face the second kind most of the time.
From there it turns on strategy. Tan disputes the textbook assumption that every firm pursues the same outcome, usually shareholder profit, and argues that good companies choose different outcomes, an idea he calls Heterogeneous Outcome Pursuit. He pairs it with Equifinality, the point that many routes reach the same goal and each is optimal under a different definition of optimal. On that view, scripted procedures can backfire. He explains why Apple hardware feels like Apple and a Van Gogh feels like Van Gogh, and describes the Familiar-Yet-Novel Tension. Patrick connects this to the advertising principle MAYA, "most advanced yet acceptable."
The contested material is organizational. Tan says restaurant teams deliberately create uncertainty, and that Productive Discomfort makes them better at handling change. He describes hiring through a prolonged, undefined trial period, Negotiated Joining, which he restricts to uncertain roles, and he suggests reserving about 10 percent of an internship for undefined work. A long detour into food covers what labels omit, pesticide residues on strawberries, and why conventional wine would struggle if regulated like bottled water. Patrick also asks which parts of a firm's culture are hardest to copy.
Vaughn Tan argues that quality is an idiosyncratic, personally defined standard, and that innovators who keep building on their own past use deliberate productive discomfort and provisional, uncertainty-tolerant structures rather than de-risking.
- Makers and organizations pursue distinct, self-defined outcomes of quality, so strategy and innovation begin with heterogeneity of goals
- Productive discomfort, applied in calibrated cycles, builds organizational capacity to handle uncertainty, much like weight training
- Negotiated, provisional joining and trial periods reduce costly hiring false negatives and false positives in uncertain roles
Business success comes from defining quality and the right outcome, not from following the crowd.
- Superhuman charges around $30 a month for an email client on top of Gmail, which seems absurd given free email, but it succeeds by optimizing for a different outcome variable such as inbox zero for power users and a commitment to design.
“because they are optimizing, in my understanding, for things like inbox zero for power users of email”
- Success in business and investing requires being against the crowd and being right, and in Patrick's view the best way to be against the crowd is to focus obsessively on defining what quality means for the business.
“You need to be against the crowd and right to be successful in business and investing.”
- Most hard business problems trace back to getting the output right, which means asking the right question about what the business is trying to achieve, and this is very difficult to do.
“Every hard business problem I've ever seen relates to getting the output right. Asking the right question.”
Organizational culture and structure reveal more distinctive advantage than easily copied investment processes.
- Patrick's quantitative investment firm found that its research partners program produced the best results when open, unstructured exploration was combined with normal project-based work alongside the full-time team, a mix that emerged organically.
“the best results came when there was a very clean mix of completely open search time with very normal interactive, project-based time”
- Asking what about a firm's culture and organization is hardest to copy often reveals more than asking about its investment process, since process details are easily imitated while the organizational soil yields the most distinctive answers.
“What about the soil of the business would be hardest to copy? I find those to be the most interesting discussions”