What this covers
This is a conversation in which Emily Sundberg, who writes a daily business-and-culture newsletter, is questioned by Matt and Dom about how she works and where the money comes from. It starts with her years on New York Magazine's social team and moves to what her writing is for. Her newsletter is first-person and voicy, closer to a podcast than to deep journalism, a contrast she noticed when a Times editor barred her from using "I". She doesn't answer founder PR pitches, and she is wary of consulting because it would eat the time the newsletter needs.
The range goes well beyond media careers. Her magazine story on Faire traced the sameness of Instagram-era CPG brands in gift shops nationwide to one wholesale marketplace. Coined terms like shoppy shops come up as sticking better when a respected magazine launches them. She argues that beauty and wellness are one pursuit, covering anti-aging, saunas, and GLP-1 drugs. Documentaries get a stretch of their own: her film on Gardiner's Island, why the real money goes to viral scam and true-crime stories around figures like Anna Delvey, and why controversial subjects yield weaker participants.
The contentious turns come from Matt, who says trends resist clean experiments and reaches for a Chaos Theory Analogy. He also treats early creator bets as Option Value, citing Condé Nast's Reddit stake. Sundberg forecasts that the newsletter boom is unsustainable: readers paying for many subscriptions will push Substack toward bundling. She says she is building direct reader relationships so she does not depend on it.
Sundberg argues her daily business newsletter works because her years of cross-industry relationships give her insider sourcing, and her personal point of view, which magazine reporting suppresses, generates the consulting, equity, and reader opportunities that a neutral reporter would not get.
- Relationships built across jobs at New York Magazine, Meta, and a D2C startup give her sources that outsider reporters lack
- Opinionated newsletter writing attracts founders, funds, and brands, while neutral magazine stories mostly bring readers who then go to the sources instead
- Platform-driven reach (Substack, press mentions, Matt Levine's link) amplifies a voice that is personal rather than institutional
Engaging directly with businesses and sharing real opinions unlocks deals, equity, and long-term creator options.
- Matt argues that building an audience and network that spans both 60-year-old finance people and college students is rare, and that Sundberg's ability to connect across those groups is a skill that is probably not deliberate but comes from working inside businesses and forming relationships across departments.
“when you're able to communicate with people that are 60 and then people in college, news flash. Like not many people are actually able to balance both of those things”
- Matt argues that early creator and media bets function as massive options whose payoffs are unpredictable, and the Reddit investment by Condé Nast, which he describes as turning a small stake into a large value over about twenty years, shows that you cannot reap the benefits without holding the options.
“they are massive options. You never know which one is going to work out. But if you don't have them, you'll never reap the benefits.”
- Matt argues that sharing well-formed opinions with real insight opens business doors such as consulting and equity opportunities in a way that merely sharing other people's stories does not, which makes opinion-driven writing a different kind of media asset.
“you can be part of content by just sharing someone else's story, which is great. And I think it's super helpful. It does not get you in the door with a lot of business opportunities the same way that sharing opinions.”
- Matt suggests that Sundberg's bundling problem could be solved by a group of writers teaming up to create an all-star newsletter collective similar to Puck, which he presents as an option for the newsletter economy.
“you could just team up and create an all-star team to found your own Puck, and that's an option as well.”
- Matt argues that a newsletter writer who engages directly with the businesses they cover can convert cultural insight into investment and business involvement more effectively than someone who only comments on trends from a distance.
“it makes way more sense to just do it in a very direct fashion where you're directly involved with the investments or the businesses that they're launching.”
- Matt argues the creator world still contains long-term options that could evolve significantly, even as short-term creator businesses become rocky.
“as the short-term stuff gets a little rocky, those long-term things are still there in a big way.”
Trends resist prediction, so trend-spotting, coined terms, and consumer opportunities are hard to anticipate.
- Matt argues that trends are nearly impossible to study with a clean experiment because too many variables are involved, so any quantitative study risks missing the point, which he links to chaos theory and the sensitivity of trend outcomes to small changes.
“you cannot control all the variables that are involved with making a trend work.”
- Matt argues that vanity is one of the deadly sins and that businesses built around it can be quite successful, so the boom in female-focused beauty brands suggests an opportunity for male brands that is probably already happening more than he realizes.
“vanity is one of the deadly sins. And usually, if you build businesses around those, you can be quite successful.”
- Sundberg and Matt agree that nicotine pouches such as ZYN are increasingly mainstream, and Sundberg notes that people have suggested branded ZYN cases for her readers.
“Yes. That's a big one and increasingly mainstream.”
- Matt observes that many people who begin as early trend-spotters lose touch with culture over time, and that Emily has kept a close grasp of trends across years, which he finds impressive.
“it's easy like kind of initially, but then you kind of graduate out of that and you can lose touch with things.”
- Matt argues many businesspeople believe they can spot trends early or sense culture, but their insight is often disconnected and six months late, which makes Sundberg's ability to stay ahead unusual.
“many of the businesspeople that Dom and I operate with like to think that they can spot trends early”
- Matt observes that many attempts to coin terms fail to stick, and that trend terminology is hard to predict, using the Mean Girls phrase fetch happen as a contrast.
“a lot of people try it and they just don't stick”
Cold plunges, fragrance, and gender-related media remarks form a peripheral side discussion.
- Matt says cold plunges seem to work, and even if the benefits are placebo, he respects the placebo effect as one of the best things available.
“they seem to work and even if it's placebo, I respect the placebo effect. It's one of the best things out there.”
- Dom suggests cultural differences in fragrance use, noting that he was surprised by Matt's strong aftershave, which Matt likened to a gas leak in its potency.
“It was potent is what I would say. ... I was not sure if there was a gas leak”
- Matt distinguishes cold showers, which he uses only after hard runs or long outdoor exposure, from cold plunges, which require equipment and take time to cool, and he argues they belong in different categories.
“One involves just turning the knob on a shower to a certain temperature. The other involves having a large piece of equipment”
- Matt Levine's decision to include Emily's dystopian girl-boss story in his newsletter probably reflected his playful side, and the hosts argue that female founders are often treated more poorly than male founders by the media.
“I generally believe that they get treated a bit more poorly than male founders from media.”