What this covers
Patrick interviews Jon Stein, founder of Betterment, about how a robo-advisor actually works and where the category is going. Stein traces the company to his studies in economics and psychology and to a stint as a bank consultant, where products were built without talking to customers. He calls inertia his biggest competitor and says the company's edge is making sign-up and funding fast. Betterment's target customer is a mid-career professional around 45 with $250,000 to $2 million, though millennials use it heavily. He describes it as a tech company, with about half the team engineers or product managers.
The middle of the conversation is about portfolio mechanics. Betterment picks the best ETF in each asset class by expense ratio, liquidity cost, and tracking error, and will not issue its own because incumbents already reach about four basis points through scale. Stein admits there is no single right way to diversify, and defends a modest tilt toward value and small-cap factors. He cites the in-app tax impact preview, after which 75% of customers with a costly transaction cancelled the trade. Patrick presses on guardrails and limited choice.
The contested turns come on the future. Patrick expects the basics, including tax-loss harvesting, to become commodities. Stein disagrees, comparing added features at a fixed fee to Amazon Prime. He argues advisors undersell themselves as behavioral coaches, since clients call about inheritances, divorce, and marriage. He also sees the much-criticized 401(k)) market as an opening, and predicts universal automated advice within 10 to 20 years.
Stein argues that robo-advice wins by removing friction and automating portfolio management, tax work, and behavioral guardrails, so basic investment management will get cheaper and the durable value must come from the surrounding advice and services.
- Frictionless onboarding and inertia are the main barriers to getting people to invest, so ease of use drives acquisition.
- Basic portfolio construction and ETF access are already near-free, so fees must be justified by ongoing value like tax management and advice.
- Guardrails such as tax impact previews and limited choice protect investors from costly mistakes, and unlimited choice would mean little advice.
Automation makes investing effortless, overcoming customer inertia and complexity over time
- Betterment's main acquisition advantage is making sign-up, funding, goal setting, and coordination so easy and fast that people feel comfortable completing them in a short time.
“we had to make it really frictionless. From sign up to funding, to setting up your goals”
- Stein says his biggest competitor is inertia, because people are busy and avoid paying attention to their money, so getting them to act is the core problem.
“I sometimes say that our biggest competitor is inertia. It's so hard to get people to act”
- In 10 to 20 years, investment advice will be available to everyone and automated, so the questions about retirement contributions and Roth versus traditional IRAs will have accessible answers and people will not need to think about them.
“Just as easy, the future of investment advice is that it is available to everyone, and it's automated for us in a way that we don't have to think about it.”
- Stein compares automated investing to self-driving cars: the destination and the choice to drive remain with the investor, but the technology makes the mechanics effortless so people can focus on what they care about.
“You still have agency over where you're going, you'll still set the destination, and be able to drive if you want”
- When Stein explained basic investing to friends, such as buying mutual funds and rebalancing occasionally, people glazed over quickly, showing that investing seemed too complicated to most people.
“I'd say, well, I start here and I buy these mutual funds, and then you want to rebalance every once in a while, but people would glaze over pretty quickly.”
- People who think they know what a robo-advisor does but have never tried one should try it, because the breadth of services has expanded beyond what they likely assume.
“if you think you know what a Robo-advisor is, or does, but you haven't tried it out, check it out.”
- Jon claims it is easier to predict investment-advice conditions 10 to 20 years out than three to five years out, because the long-run answers to standard questions are knowable even though near-term market conditions are not.
“It's almost easier to look 10 or 20 years out, in a way, than it is to look three or five years out.”
Incumbents ignored customers, so building products around real customer needs wins
- Stein founded Betterment after opening seven brokerage accounts that were all hard to use and none did what he wanted, which was simply to manage his money for him, and after seeing banks build products without talking to customers.
“I'd open seven different brokerage accounts, and none of them was easy, none of them did exactly what I wanted, which was just manage my money for me.”
- Because nearly every 401(k) is criticized and there has been little innovation, Stein sees the low-innovation, high-complaint market as a sign of opportunity rather than a warning, the same way investment management looked risky before.
“There's just been so little innovation in there, and we see that... A lot of people say, when you see these spaces where there hasn't been a lot of innovation, watch out”
- Banks built products like six-month projects without ever talking to customers, iterating on existing mortgage and deposit products, which is why Stein believed incumbents would not solve the investing problem.
“they were building products without talking to their customers. It would be a six-month project, and we would never once talk to the customer”
- Jon Stein founded Betterment after studying economics and psychology, working as a bank consultant, and seeing that banks built financial products without talking to customers, and that investing complexity deterred people.
“I found through that experience of working with the banks, that I was learning a lot, and I loved it. But I find so often, they were building products without talking to their customers.”
Portfolios should be personalized and modestly diversified rather than bets on factors
- Betterment optimizes each customer's portfolio for their goals and situation, including state-specific municipal bonds for residents of different states, rather than offering one fixed portfolio.
“we optimize a portfolio for our customers, and for each individual customer's needs based on their goals, based on their situation.”
- There is no single right way to diversify a portfolio, because experts would each choose slightly different factors and tilts, all equally right and equally wrong, so a reasonable globally diversified portfolio is about the best one can do with available information.
“If you get 10 professors of finance or practitioners of finance in a room, each will have a slightly different view about factors you should use”
- Betterment recently added Vanguard and Goldman Sachs Asset Management portfolio options, where Vanguard is purely passive and GSAM uses smart-beta, letting advisors match clients to different investment philosophies.
“we announced partnerships with Vanguard, and with Goldman Sachs. We now have a Vanguard set of portfolios, and GSAM”
- Betterment tilts portfolios slightly toward value and small-cap factors because these factors have historically outperformed only very slightly over very long horizons, and the tilt is modest rather than a bet.
“values, and small-cap are some of those factors that tend to outperform just very slightly, over the very long term. We have a slight tilt towards those factors”
- Factor-based predictions are based on historical data, so a reasonable globally diversified portfolio is about the best one can do with available information, with further optimization being debatable.
“when we make these kinds of predictions, we're looking at historical data. And as long as you're being relatively reasonable”
Low-cost ETF selection and fee competition matter more than fee pressure on robo-advice
- Betterment will not manufacture its own ETFs because the big ETF providers already achieve costs of about four basis points through scale that no startup could match, and ETF price competition keeps fees low.
“it's four basis points in some of these ETFs. We could not match that cost if we tried to manufacture our own ETF, and in fact, no one could.”
- Betterment chooses the best ETF in each asset class from any provider by minimizing expense ratio, liquidity cost, and tracking error to maximize net returns for investors.
“Within any given asset class, we'll choose the best ETFs in that asset class, from any provider, be it Vanguard, or Schwab, or Goldman”
- Unlimited investor choice would provide little advice, so Betterment offers more flexibility through an advisor intermediating choices or guardrails within its advice framework rather than letting clients pick any exchange-listed fund.
“There is some limit to that, where if you just let people do anything, well, you're not providing much advice.”
- Robo-advice basics will not become free because providing services costs money, and as Betterment adds more features for the same fee, value rises like Amazon Prime, so fee pressure matters less than the value customers receive.
“No, it won't be free, just like ETFs aren't free, just like a Schwab brokerage account isn't free, or a bank account isn't free. Nothing is free”
- ETFs are better than mutual funds because they can be bought from any provider on the market, which creates price competition that mutual funds lack because switching providers requires separate pipes.
“you can buy any of them on the market, and so, there's competition in price in a way that there isn't in mutual funds.”
Retirement is the top savings goal and the core target market for Betterment
- Betterment's target customer is a mid-career professional around age 45 with a net worth of $250,000 to $2 million, facing retirement and college funding decisions, even though millennials use the service heavily.
“But our target customer is somebody who's maybe, age 45, or so. Somebody who's a mid-career professional with 250,000 to two million net worth.”
- Direct-to-consumer retail accounts remain Betterment's largest asset base, and Stein estimates about $5 trillion in retail investment accounts, $7 trillion in IRAs, and $5 trillion in 401(k)s serve customers like the target customer.
“There's something like five trillion in retail investment accounts, there's something like seven trillion in IRAs, and another five trillion in 401(k)s”
- Retirement is by far Betterment's most popular savings goal, followed by general wealth building and then a safety net fund.
“Retirement is by far, our most popular goal. It's the number one thing that people come to Betterment to save for.”
- Jon says retirement is the most important thing people have to save for, which is why they should save more for it than for anything else.
“It's the most important thing in life that people have to save for, is retirement.”
Automated back-office tools let advisors serve more clients and focus on life events
- Betterment's advisor platform automates back-office work such as tax-loss harvesting, tax coordination, rebalancing, and glide-path asset allocation changes, so smaller advisors can serve more clients and spend time on relationships.
“For financial advisors, we offer a way to automate many of the typical back-office processes that you might have to do”
- Advisors who describe their value mainly as behavioral management are selling themselves short, because clients rarely call about market moves and mostly call about life events like inheritances, divorce, or marriage that drive real financial questions.
“customers aren't calling in because of what the market's doing, they're calling in because of life events”
- Betterment sends clients with specialized needs to partner advisors, so advisors gain a referral channel in addition to back-office automation.
“not only does it help you with your existing clients, but we'll refer clients to you.”
Betterment's culture favors efficiency, long-term building, and empowered teams of builders
- Betterment's culture prioritizes efficiency and continuous iteration toward better rather than a fail-fast mindset, and it builds for the long term as an institution.
“It's not about failing fast, it's just trying things, and constantly improving. You're never looking for perfect”
- Betterment empowers its team by giving them great information and transparency and then letting them execute, which is one of the company's five core values.
“I think, we empower our team to do great work, by giving them great information, transparency, and then letting them execute.”
- Betterment sees itself as a tech company that happens to solve customer problems in investing, with about half its team engineers or product managers and a small share of investment professionals.
“I definitely think of us as a tech company, that happens to be solving customer problems in investing.”
- Betterment has no chief investment officer; instead a managing director of investments leads investment decisions alongside an investment advisory committee.
“We have a managing director of investments who is that for us, and we have an investment advisory committee.”
- Jon describes Betterment's team as predominantly engineers who see themselves as builders, with PhDs and CFAs advising while engineers scale the advice.
“We are engineers in our mindset, we are engineers, predominately in the makeup of the team.”
Execution quality and tax-aware tools protect investors from costly trades
- Betterment paused trading at the open during Brexit, as major banks did, because it prioritized getting a fair price and good execution over the market's direction, and it executed customer orders faster than competitors once execution quality was assured.
“Not levels of the market, doesn't matter if it's up or down, but just... Can you get a fair price? Will you get good execution on your trades?”
- Betterment's in-app tax impact preview, which shows likely taxes before a transaction, led 75% of customers with a costly transaction to cancel the trade, avoiding taxes and market timing errors.
“when we show customers that information, 75% of those who have a costly transaction, decided not to go through with the trade.”
- ETF markets tend to be especially volatile at the open and close, so Betterment routinely pauses trading at those times to protect execution quality.
“we always pause trading at the open, because markets tend... And ETF markets especially, tend to be quite volatile at the open, and at the close”
- The tax cost information in the tax impact preview has always been available to investors, but no other firm had surfaced it to customers in an automated in-app way before Betterment.
“this is data that's always been there, no matter where you're investing, no one else has ever surfaced that information to customers in an automated in-app way.”
Expanding into the 401(k) market means competing business-to-business against incumbents
- Entering the 401(k) market means selling business-to-business to employers and competing head to head against incumbents like Fidelity to win the plan contract, rather than selling to individuals.
“It is going to the business, and competing head to head against Fidelity, or whoever the current 401(k) plan is, and winning that business.”
- Once a company signs up for Betterment's 401(k) offering, employees see an experience almost identical to the direct product, with contribution settings, account aggregation, and all IRA, taxable, and 401(k) accounts in one dashboard.
“once the company signs up, the process that the participants see, or the employees see is almost identical to the Betterment experience.”
- Betterment's 401(k) offering is its biggest product launch in a year, and the Uber driver partnership is an extension of that effort to make its service available to more people.
“it is our biggest product launch in a year, and the Uber thing is an extension of that.”
Behavioral economics and evolutionary books inform Stein's understanding of decision-making
- Books like Guns, Germs and Steel and a behavioral biology text on sex and evolution help explain how people evolved and behave, which Stein finds essential for understanding decision-making.
“I just learned a lot about people, and how we have evolved, and how we behave”
- Behavioral economics, the science of decision making, combines economics and psychology to understand how people make decisions and how to help them make better ones.
“what we call behavioral economics, or the science of decision making, and how we help people make better decisions.”
- Cornelius Vanderbilt is described as having created the corporation and the first stock, so his biography is a history of American business.
“he is the history of business. He created the corporation, he created the first stock.”
- Jon says Sapiens builds on Guns, Germs, and Steel and an evolutionary behavioral biology textbook, deepening understanding of how humans evolved and behave.
“To me, it builds on things that I've learned in other books like, Guns, Germs and Steel”
Personal habits and anecdotes shape Stein's priorities outside the business
- Stein's ongoing prioritization practice is a Google Doc of top priorities that he executes in priority order to resist inbox distraction.
“I keep a Google Doc of my top priorities, and I'm just executing through that.”
- Patrick and Stein both have two young daughters around the same ages, which they note as a coincidence.
“Yeah, I've got two daughters. Two years old, and five months.”
- Stein reads his daughter a bedtime story every day and tries to get home for it.
“it's important to read my daughter's bedtime story every day, I always try and get home for that.”
- Stein says many people were generous to Betterment and that he had many mentors as a consultant, but he would leave someone out by singling out one.
“I had so many great mentors. I feel like I'd be leaving someone out if I singled another one out.”
Word of mouth and a launch event supplied Betterment's early and ongoing customers
- Word of mouth and referrals have been Betterment's single largest source of new customers since its early days and have scaled with the business.
“our biggest source of new customers has been referrals. The single, most popular way that people find out about us is word of mouth.”
- Betterment launched in 2010 at a TechCrunch conference where about 20,000 people saw the presentation, and 500 of them signed up, which was the company's starting customer base.
“we launched at a tech conference, and something like 20,000 people saw that initial presentation at TechCrunch. And 500 of the braver ones decided to sign up.”