What this covers
This is a Business Breakdowns conversation in which Matt questions Sean Stannard-Stockton of Ensemble Capital about Home Depot. It begins with the company's history against the housing cycle. Sean notes that sales began falling by the end of 2006, well before the more visible 2008 crash. He argues the 2008 crash was a mortgage-lending bubble and the worst housing environment in a century, so it should not be read as the typical downturn or as a template for today's rate-driven slowdown.
The middle of the discussion is a comparison with Lowe's. Home Depot splits revenue roughly evenly between pros and do-it-yourselfers, while Lowe's is about 25% pro, which Sean ties to a gap of several points in operating margin despite similar gross margins. He covers inventory turns near 8x, return on invested capital of 35% to 45%, and a gross margin that barely moves except through lumber, which swung about 400% in price. Capital spending on distribution centers is described as a cycle now ending, with capex guided to about 2% of revenue. The pandemic section covers roughly 30% revenue growth in a short span and the company's decision to charter its own ocean freight ships, which few peers could afford like Costco.
The more contested turns come near the end. Sean dismisses Amazon as a meaningful threat because heavy, bulky, urgent products are costly to ship. He forecasts that homeowners locked in at low mortgage rates will remodel rather than move, and he leaves open whether pro or DIY demand drives the next leg of growth. He closes with an investing lesson about stakeholders: value extracted from suppliers or employees becomes an unrecorded debt.
Home Depot's durable edge comes from serving professional contractors as a convenience-driven, mission-critical platform, backed by stakeholder-friendly supplier and labor practices. This lets it grow revenue and margins without adding stores, and makes its maintenance-driven demand less sensitive to housing and rate cycles than investors assume.
- Pro contractors provide about 50% of revenue from about 5% of customers, and both pros and DIY buyers pay for same-day access to parts.
- Revenue grew about 6% a year from 2012 to 2019 while store count stayed flat near 2,300, with operating margin rising from about 10% to 15% as SG&A leveraged against transactions.
- Maintenance spend is steady and locked-in homeowners keep reinvesting, so Home Depot's revenue has not tracked interest rates or housing transactions the way other housing-related companies do.
Home Depot's business showed no clear link to Fed rate increases, signaling little dependence on financing costs.
- Even though the Fed raised rates in 2018 and analysts worried about falling home sales, Home Depot's business did not show a clear rate link, which Sean treats as a sign of how little the business depends on financing costs.
“We've tried every which way to find a correlation between interest rates and our business, but we gave up because we just can't find one.”
Growth in baskets over $1,000 reflects pros buying whole lumber packages and flatbed deliveries to job sites.
- Baskets over $1,000 have been growing much faster than smaller baskets, reflecting pros ordering whole lumber packages and flatbed deliveries straight from distribution centers to job sites.
“So $1,000-plus baskets have been growing much faster than smaller basket sizes for Home Depot.”