What this covers

The conversation is between Will and Rob Small of Stockbridge, and it uses TransDigm to compare private equity with owning the same kind of business in public markets. Small's most painful private equity loss was failing to win the 2003 take-private of TransDigm, yet investors earned more because the company later listed and could compound. He argues that fund lives and the pressure to return liquidity push managers to sell good assets early. Because managers are judged on IRR, they tend to sell winners to flatter the math. He calls this contested and not value maximizing.

The middle of the discussion covers how TransDigm runs. Small says the CEO, division presidents, and frontline managers all give the same answer about what drives value, and that the company's culture overwhelms the legacy cultures of the businesses it acquires. Execution is delegated by product line, while culture and practices are set centrally. He relays how Nick Howley concentrates on what he can control, and Small contrasts planning strategy ten steps ahead with running operations one step at a time. Pay gets its own stretch: say-on-pay votes and disclosure pushed executive grants toward annual awards, and Small says a board member would rather be accused of overpaying when shareholders have made a lot of money.

The last stretch is about risk and humility. Small covers TransDigm's staggered debt maturities, which left no near-term maturities when COVID hit, and admits his belief in 5 to 7 percent air travel growth was wrong. He also raises climate costs and a possible east-west decoupling. On portfolio construction, he explains why Stockbridge stops short of full concentration, why selling winners too early has cost more than diligence errors, and why he prefers buybacks to dividends.

Sharpest takeaway

Rob Small argues TransDigm compounds value because its disciplined, decentralized operating system and aligned owner-style pay reinforce each other, and that public-market permanent capital lets a holder compound longer than private equity's fixed-life, liquidity-driven structure allows.

  • A single operating focus (the 3Ps) is pushed through the whole organization, and culture, pay, and decentralized execution are designed to align with it
  • Public, permanent capital avoids the forced exit and liquidity pressure of PE funds, which can compound winners longer
  • Concentrating in the highest-conviction ideas, and selling winners only on price, has been more costly to get wrong than the mistakes from weak diligence

The argument · threads1 threads · 76 claims
0.57

Stockbridge's TransDigm additions at higher valuations tested buying above its original entry price.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • Stockbridge added to its TransDigm position in early 2013 and mid-2014 at roughly three and four times the original valuation, a test of buying at higher prices than the firm first paid.

    “the first of those occurred at about 3X Stockbridge's original valuation and the third at about 4X, roughly”