The Voice of Pickleball
What this covers
This is a conversation between Thomas, founder of the pickleball media company The Dink, and hosts Matt and Dom. It works as a founder's retrospective on how a newsletter grew into a podcast, video, and sponsorship business. Thomas credits Sam Parr's My First Million podcast for the nerve to start. He describes a stretch when The Dink ran alongside Fromuth, his uncle's racket-sports wholesale business, and the split that pushed him into full-time media sooner than planned. He also recounts returning seed round money when a sale looked close, then seeing the stalled deal as a blessing in disguise.
The conversation then widens to the sport. Thomas says participation is growing fast, reportedly about double tennis, but turning players into weekend viewers is the central problem, the Participation-Spectatorship Gap. He doubts that celebrity team owners alone can build a viable pro league. He calls facilities the biggest opportunity and the toughest battle, likely to produce many losers. He cites Peloton as a warning about mistaking a surge for durable demand. Padel comes up as more exciting to watch but harder to build courts for.
The business discussion is where they disagree most. Matt defends curation as real value and in-person relationships as less transactional. They also cover newsletter saturation driving down CPC, why bundled ad packages sell to pickleball brands but rarely to outside ones, the difficulty of converting social followers into readers, and hiring experienced operators, who Matt says are roughly the top 5 percent.
Thomas Shields argues that The Dink succeeded by pairing a witty, irreverent voice with in-person relationship-building and content-to-commerce from day one, and that a niche focus on pickleball should be doubled down on before expanding to other sports.
- Early growth came from brand voice, physical presence (a branded van touring tournaments), and access to pros, not from original reporting
- Newsletter saturation creates a race to the bottom on CPCs, so niche focus and curated audiences are needed to command higher CPMs
- Diversifying across emerging sports was deferred after a sale fell through, in favor of concentrating on pickleball
In-person connection with listeners creates value before it generates revenue.
- The podcast creates a more personal relationship with listeners than the newsletter does, since fans approach hosts at tournaments and say they listen to the show.
“Our podcast, on the other hand, is really cool because my aunt here -- she's going to kill me.”
- Events are typically higher-margin for media businesses than other revenue, and in-person connection building can be a longer-term play that produces value before it generates money.
“whether it's through like events tend to be just higher margin.”
Cross-selling works counterintuitively because advertisers end up buying what they came for.
- Dom says the cross-selling answer shows that advertisers come asking for one thing, sellers try to sell something else, and the advertisers end up buying what they came for, which is counterintuitive.
“And I try and sell them something else, and it turns out they want the thing that they came for. How counterintuitive is that?”
Avoiding trending topics guards against mean reversion making the show look foolish.
- Dom avoids covering trending topics because he expects mean reversion, which could make the show look foolish, though Matt argues that the stakes of covering zeitgeist topics justify doing them well rather than avoiding them.
“I always shy away from things that are in the zeitgeist because I tend to think that mean reversion will happen at some point, and then we'll end up looking foolish.”
The Dink compressed about 25 years of business life cycles into two or three years.
- Dom observes that The Dink has packed roughly 25 years of business life cycles into two or three years, from side hustle to retail, media, and venture portfolio.
“You've crammed 25 years of business into two or three in terms of the life cycle of different things that have happened.”