McKinsey & Company: The First Management Consultants
What this covers
This Business Breakdowns episode has Romeen Sheth tracing McKinsey from its founding in the 1920s, when American companies were growing fast and there was almost no trained management class to hire from. He gives most of the credit for the firm's professional identity to Marvin Bower, who led it from 1950 to 1967, rather than to founder James McKinsey. The history includes the free McKinsey Quarterly, pitched as a practical Harvard Business Review and used for brand building and recruiting. It also covers the pressure from BCG and Bain in the 1970s and 80s, with their market-strategy focus and tools like the two-by-two matrix. A contested claim ties the Eisenhower White House reorganization to the origin of the chief of staff role.
The economics get unusually concrete. Sheth uses a public bid for a New Jersey COVID-response project, $180,000 a week for six consultants, to work out roughly $750 an hour, then compares per diem rates and the margin left after salaries. He describes the firm as an equal-weighted partnership of about 2,000 partners, with partners selling shares back at book value. Growth comes from expanding existing client relationships, and the 15,000-plus alumni network acts as passive marketing. Training puts juniors in front of senior executives early, backed by daily feedback and an obligation to dissent.
The last stretch turns to failure. Sheth links the Rajat Gupta era's push for revenue, including equity stakes in about 150 companies, to later ethics scandals, and he treats Enron as doubly damaging because Jeff Skilling was a former partner. He names four causes, one of them the pull between decentralization and central governance, and ends on whether a firm can keep its culture while changing its tactics.
McKinsey's durable advantage comes from a talent-development flywheel, a non-commercial professional ethos, and a shift toward software-embedded consulting, and its long-term health depends on keeping its founding culture while changing its tactics.
- Training, feedback, and alumni networks turn each consultant into a future client channel, so sales come mostly from existing relationships.
- Scandals under Rajat Gupta followed from chasing dollars and weakening accountability, not from the firm's core culture.
- Asset-based McKinsey Solutions software is a response to disruption and a way to earn recurring revenue beyond the traditional three-month strategy engagement.
Talent density and scale let McKinsey dominate and reach institutions across the economy.
- Because McKinsey sells advice and judgment, its addressable market is effectively GDP, since any institution that grows or changes may seek advice, which is why Sheth compares it to Amazon.
“GDP is kind of a proxy for market size for a company like McKinsey.”
- McKinsey has more than 15,000 alumni, and 200 to 300 of them run multi-billion-dollar organizations, including the CEOs of Google, Morgan Stanley, Alliance, and DoorDash.
“2 to 300 of them actually run multi-billion dollar organizations”
- McKinsey was founded in the 1920s during US hyper-growth, when companies needed growth strategy, infrastructure, and especially trained managers, and the country had almost no management class to hire from.
“There were no managers in American business at that point in time.”
- McKinsey generates about $10 billion in revenue with more than 30,000 employees across 130 cities and 50 to 60 countries, and it stays notably private about its client base and scale.
“It does 10 billion in revenue today. It's got 30,000 plus employees.”
- McKinsey's talent advantage comes partly from a self-reinforcing brand that attracts graduates of top schools, as the firm has built a honey pot of talent that peers like Goldman Sachs and Blackstone also draw from.
“they've built the honey pot and they've attracted the highest density of talent.”
- A concentration of very high talent density lets an organization move far and fast even at very large scale, and Sheth considers this the core of McKinsey's dominance and the key question for its future.
“when you have a concentration of just extremely, extremely high talent density, it makes for very interesting things.”
- Each team is run by an engagement manager who gives feedback daily, creating a high rate of repetition and learning from mistakes during a young consultant's first engagement.
“I was doing feedback every single day with the engagement manager.”
- McKinsey's obligation to dissent means even the most junior person must challenge the group to help the team find truth, and feedback runs both ways, including reviewing managers' performance.
“regardless of if you're the most junior person in the room... whatever it is your obligation is to dissent”
- McKinsey believes the fit between a player and the system matters as much as the player's raw quality, comparing the firm's staffing to building an NBA team with the right point guard, shooting guard, and center.
“it's as important of what kind of player you are, as what kind of system that you're in.”
- McKinsey deliberately hires a large number of people rather than a rejectionist, exclusive pool, keeping standards high while accepting that most hires will leave after an average tenure of two and a half to three years, after which they become alumni.
“We want to hire as many people as possible that can keep the bar because those many people, the business model is not going to change.”
- Each consultant has a professional development manager at the home office who acts as a free-agent coach, matching the person to projects that fit their skill development and personal preferences.
“their sole job is literally to serve as your agent.”
Bower's training culture and elite reputation define McKinsey's enduring identity and expansion.
- James McKinsey was an accountant who believed businesses lacked rigor, and the firm's original name, McKinsey & Company Management Engineers and Accountants, reflected his view that consulting required the precision of engineers and accountants.
“The name spelled out what he thought a consultant's job was.”
- McKinsey operated an up-or-out system in which consultants moved to the next rank every couple of years or left, a discipline Bower enforced as part of performance management.
“There was an up or out philosophy at McKinsey. Every couple years, you're moving to the next rank, or kind of out.”
- Under Bower's one-firm philosophy, any consultant a client hires brings the entire backing of McKinsey, so the firm's knowledge and standing stand behind each individual.
“it's a one firm situation.”
- Bower's enduring legacy is a strong foundational culture combined with loose attachment to tactics, on the principle that the only way to stay at the top is constant reinvention.
“a strong foundational culture, but loose affiliation to tactics.”
- Marvin Bower contrarily hired young credentialed people with strong raw intellectual horsepower and trained them in-house, rather than hiring experienced experts, and used an up-or-out system to enforce performance.
“He was really bullish on hiring young credentialed talent versus experts.”
- Marvin Bower, not the founder, is the architect of McKinsey's culture: he wanted consulting to be a high-status profession like medicine and law, built around servant leadership and professionalism.
“Bauer is kind of heralded as the architect of the firm and really responsible for its expansion.”
- McKinsey's north star, its mission statement of advising clients at the highest level, has not changed in roughly 100 years, and enduring firms keep the core fixed while changing tactics.
“Their north star actually hasn't changed. That mission statement of what they do actually has not changed in 100 odd years.”
- The book The Firm, written about a decade earlier, captures McKinsey's history with more inside access than the firm had ever publicly allowed.
“it's called The Firm and it would was written I think maybe 10 years ago”
- McKinsey has played as integral a role in American capitalism as any organization, having operated for a century from a single starting location to global influence.
“playing, arguably, as integral role in capitalism as any organization can claim.”
- McKinsey is the world's preeminent management consulting firm. It is not the biggest consultancy, but it is the most well regarded and respected in the industry.
“McKinsey is the world's preeminent management consulting firm. It's not the biggest, but it's definitely the most well regarded and respected in the industry.”
- Bower held that how a consultant communicates matters as much as the content, and enforced strict professional norms such as short hair and no facial hair.
“Bower thought that the way you communicate something is as important as communicating it... folks had to have trimmed-cut hair. There was no facial hair.”
- Marvin Bower, not founder James McKinsey, is the figure credited with building McKinsey's professional identity and expansion, after he was hired by McKinsey and led the firm as managing director from 1950 to 1967.
“The guy that's talked about is a guy named Marvin Bauer. Bauer is kind of heralded as the architect of the firm and really responsible for its expansion.”
- Marvin Bower wanted consulting to be held to the same high status as medicine and law, so that a business problem would send executives to McKinsey the way a health problem sends patients to a doctor.
“Bauer is kind of heralded as the architect of the firm and really responsible for its expansion.”
- The talent flywheel began when McKinsey had only New York or Chicago offices and was concentrated inside financial institutions, and it grew more elaborate as the firm globalized and deepened its verticals and functions.
“When Bower and these guys ran the firm and it was only in New York or only in Chicago, that talent wheel was just inside specific financial institutions.”
- McKinsey, BCG, and Bain form the strategy 'Big Three' (NBB), with a separate tier of much larger operational firms tied to accounting, such as Deloitte, PwC, and KPMG, and IT and outsourcing firms such as Accenture, IBM Consulting, Capgemini, and Infosys.
“In the industry, they're known as NBB or the Big Three. There's another set of consulting firms that are significantly larger than those three”
McKinsey is shifting toward software and asset-based offerings that create recurring value.
- McKinsey often acquires software partners after working with them for a long period on client engagements, which de-risks deals because the firm has already seen the product in live use cases and can scale it quickly after acquisition.
“you're de-risking any deal that you're doing significantly from the outset, because you've already worked with that partner.”
- McKinsey faced an innovator's dilemma: it could keep moving up-market into more lucrative work or look downstream at cheaper providers disrupting it, and it chose the latter by building software-based solutions.
“McKinsey faced this innovators' dilemma moment of sorts.”
- McKinsey's Orpheus, a procurement and tail-spend management tool, embeds the firm's methodology in software that clients license over time, replacing a static one-time diagnostic with a self-serve recurring product.
“Orpheus was a pretty cool solution, which was basically in the consulting workflow itself”
- Three-month strategy engagements once made up 80 to 90 percent of McKinsey's business but now account for 20 to 30 percent, with asset-based solutions taking up much of the rest.
“this idea of a three month strategy engagement, at one point in time that was 80 to 90% of the business. I think it's 20, 30% of the business today.”
- Around 2007 to 2008 McKinsey launched McKinsey Solutions, pairing advisory judgment with hard software assets, so clients receive a tool that continues delivering value after the engagement ends.
“what the idea behind McKinsey's Solutions was, was more asset based consulting.”
- McKinsey's software portfolio could plausibly match the scale of $100 million to $200 million ARR unicorns, meaning the firm may be sitting on a large software business that is rarely discussed.
“I can't imagine the McKinsey portfolio is any less than that from a revenue perspective.”
- Investors should back businesses with enduring competitive advantages and deep compounding moats, like Microsoft and Apple, which can spin off new products because their advantages persist.
“find companies that have an enduring advantage and really have a real moat.”
- McKinsey Solutions includes around 30 software products by vertical and function, and it leaves clients with self-serve software after the engagement so the methodology is licensed on a subscription basis rather than sold as one-time analysis.
“McKinsey Solutions has 30 different software solutions. It's by vertical. It's by function... we'll come in and we'll do the work, but then we'll actually leave a piece of software back that you can self-serve”
- Romeen believes the genie does not go back in the bottle: consulting will keep moving toward a hard, quantitative world. Partnering judgment and counsel should grow with complexity, while paying expensive consultants for manual Excel modeling will decline in a technology-driven world.
“I think the idea of paying for really, really expensive folks to do models and manual excel, et cetera, that type of work. I think the patients for that type of work definitely goes away in a more technology driven world.”
High margins are reinvested in talent, but sustaining them requires continually winning new engagements.
- A New Jersey COVID-response project with three work streams had a proposed fee of $180,000 per week for a six-consultant team, which works out to about $6,000 per consultant per day, roughly $750 per hour over an eight-hour day.
“for a team of six consultants, McKinsey proposed a fee of $180,000 per week.”
- Because clients pay for travel and other expenses, McKinsey's economics yield gross margins of roughly 60 to 70 percent, similar to technology businesses, without the reinvestment in capital that a tech firm of similar scale requires.
“you end up having a very, very high margin, almost like a technology-like gross margin business.”
- Sheth estimates McKinsey operates at roughly 25 to 30 percent EBITDA, and most of the remaining 30 to 40 percent of costs is reinvested in talent, through offices, training, and recruiting.
“I would spitball that these folks are probably operating probably around like a 25, 30% EBITDA”
- When Marvin Bower retired he sold his McKinsey shares back to the partnership at book value, and partners still sell back at book value, a practice Sheth considers rare among firms.
“when he retired, he sold his shares of McKinsey back to the partnership at book value”
- Consulting thrives in volatile environments because when companies have everything figured out, firms like McKinsey struggle, but rapid change and shrinking public-company half-lives increase demand for advice.
“I think if companies have everything figured out and there's no real macro shifts in the environment, businesses like McKinsey actually don't do well.”
- A services business like McKinsey must constantly win new engagements, so without ongoing sales it could decline sharply within months, and a shell of its former self would result from complacency and outdated methods.
“McKinsey's like six months away from going out of business at any given point in time.”
- Project margins are high because direct costs such as junior salaries are a fraction of the billed rate, and support teams such as offshore slide makers and analysts are often billed as separate resources rather than subsidized by the one-firm team.
“the secret about those projects is, oftentimes, those are billed at separate resources... it's a very, very high-margin business.”
Commercial drift under Gupta and weakened accountability caused McKinsey's scandals.
- McKinsey's scandals came from four forces: tension between decentralization and centralized governance, over-commerciality, limited accountability when clients were wrong, and the law of large numbers as the firm grew.
“I think it's three or four things. The first thing is I think it's a natural tension of decentralization and autonomy and centralization in governance.”
- Bower discouraged sales vocabulary, calling clients clients rather than customers and business units practices, and held that the firm should not be overtly commercial and should do what is in the client's interest.
“He didn't like sales. I mean, he didn't like calling clients customers, he wanted to call them clients.”
- Rajat Gupta was convicted of insider trading after his tenure, and several scandals occurred under his leadership.
“He was actually famously convicted of insider trading after his tenure as well.”
- Under Gupta, partner attrition, new partner admissions, and top partner earnings all reached record highs, and the resulting shift in incentives changed the firm's culture away from its non-commercial roots.
“in the Gupta era attrition amongst the partnership was at its highest.”
- Enron was a double scandal for McKinsey because Enron's CEO Jeffrey Skilling was a former McKinsey partner, making the failure circular for the firm.
“the Enron CEO, Jeffrey Skilling, was a former McKinsey partner.”
- Under the Gupta-era growth push, revenue tripled to about $4 billion and looked healthy on the P&L, but the quality of the business and its cultural fabric was being torn down underneath.
“what wasn't as obvious was the fabric of that business was getting torn down.”
Consulting sells structured judgment on unfamiliar problems rather than verifiably right answers.
- Consulting is advising an organization on a challenge for a set period, and management consulting specifically advises management on the problems management faces, letting companies augment their teams with outside expertise.
“it's basically the idea of being an advisor to a person or an organization”
- McKinsey's marketing frames the firm as the place to call for any unfamiliar business problem, since a client's problem is usually unique internally but probably solved somewhere else, and the firm's name for its work is problem solving.
“whatever problem you're facing as a business, we can come in and solve it.”
- Clients are buying a specific insight from McKinsey, and that insight need not be right or wrong; the purchase is a structured judgment about a decision such as an acquisition.
“When you think about what somebody's actually buying, they're buying a specific insight, let's say.”
- McKinsey structures each engagement along three levers: how long the team works, how many people are on it, and how senior those people are, matched to the complexity and value of the client's problem.
“So one is, how long are they going to be helping you? The second is, how many folks are going to be helping you? And then the third is, what's the seniority of those folks”
- Most of McKinsey's commercial opportunities come from existing clients who expand engagements, so the firm's business development is a farming model rather than hunting for new logos.
“a lot of the vast majority of commercial opportunities actually just come from existing clients.”
Intensive training and early high-stakes exposure accelerate new hires faster than typical jobs.
- Every McKinsey employee, from junior to senior, goes through Embark, a structured program teaching the firm's vernacular, principles, and frameworks, which accelerates new hires once they are given autonomy.
“you go through something called Embark.”
- About one million people apply to McKinsey each year and fewer than 1 percent are hired, which Sheth cites as evidence of the raw intellectual horsepower of the firm's hires.
“a million people apply for a job to McKinsey every year and less than 1% get a job.”
- McKinsey's training model throws new hires into high-stakes situations early, such as presenting to a COO in the second week, while pairing them with a rigorous daily feedback culture so they learn quickly without being left to drown.
“throw them as much into the deep end as possible without a life jacket. Make them drown a little bit, but then have a culture, have a feedback culture that's so rigorous”
- A partner who is not the PDM runs performance reviews, collecting data from every team a consultant has worked on, so assessment is separated from the coach and the single project manager.
“your performance management leader that's not your PDM, your performance management leader is a partner at the firm”
- Each McKinsey team has an engagement manager who runs the team day to day, sits with the team full time, and gives daily feedback, while partners oversee several engagements at once.
“most teams have, what's called an engagement manager... the engagement manager is really the quarterback.”
- A typical McKinsey engagement lasts about 12 weeks, sometimes longer in recent years, and the intensity with one manager and one client makes the individual's experience narrow even though development is broad.
“The typical engagement is 12 weeks. Might have gotten a little bit longer in more recent years.”
- After a couple of years at McKinsey, consultants feel they have advanced substantially more than in a normal job, because intense training and rapid reps accelerate their growth.
“when you come out after a couple years, you certainly don't feel like you worked a job for a couple years. You feel like you've gotten significantly more advancement.”
McKinsey's strategy has shifted with leadership eras and competitive pressure over decades.
- Bower served as managing director for nearly 20 years, from 1950 to 1967, and stayed a partner until the early 1990s, and under his tenure McKinsey focused inward on capital allocation, organizational design, and resource allocation inside client companies.
“He served as managing director for almost 20 years from 1950 to 1967.”
- The rise of Boston Consulting Group and Bain & Company in the 1970s and 1980s pushed McKinsey to adjust, since those firms were externally focused on market strategy and introduced tools like the two-by-two matrix.
“Their claim to fame was they were externally focused. So they came up with two-by-two matrices”
- During the tenure of Rajat Gupta, McKinsey took equity stakes in around 150 companies near the dot-com era and did business with nearly anyone who could pay, which Sheth links to later ethics scandals.
“McKinsey took equity, I think, in 150 companies or so.”
- McKinsey's engagement with the Eisenhower White House on reorganizing the executive branch is when the chief of staff role came about.
“the chief of staff role was actually created by McKinsey”
- After the Gupta era, McKinsey experienced tepid growth, but Sheth argues that slower growth was matched by a return to its cultural roots and long-term thinking.
“I would argue that tepid growth was also matched with the cultural affinity of getting back to the right place.”
Partnership governance and firm-wide pay encourage long-term, shared-gain thinking over individual origination.
- McKinsey partners receive a large performance-based component of pay tied to firm-wide results, not only the revenue they personally originate, which discourages a micro-business mentality and encourages long-term endurance and shared gains.
“McKinsey has kind of famously not had that eat what you kill type model.”
- McKinsey is run as an equal-weighted partnership with a managing partner rather than a CEO, about 2,000 partners globally, and managing partners serve rotating terms capped at three elections.
“McKinsey doesn't have a CEO. It has a managing partner, but the managing partner is not the CEO of the firm.”
- Part of partner compensation flows into MIO Partners, a vehicle that structures investments, sometimes after-tax products, that are more advantaged than what individual partners could do alone.
“It's called MIO Partners.”
- Given McKinsey's culture, Sheth would be surprised if the firm ever went public, though other consultancies like Accenture have done so.
“I'd be very hard pressed, or surprised if they ever went public.”
Public bid records reveal consulting economics, including high per-diem rates and large margins.
- Consultant per-diem rates range from about $3,000 a day for a junior consultant to $15,000 to $20,000 a day for a senior partner.
“It can be 3K for a junior consultant, and it can be 15 to 20K for a senior partner.”
- Although McKinsey is secretive about fees, public-sector bids are public records, so they provide real data for understanding consulting economics, using the New Jersey COVID-response project as an example.
“all do public set work. And when you do public sector work, the bids are public information.”
- A first-year consultant costs roughly $100,000 to $200,000 a year, so a six-person team costing about $120,000 in salaries against $750,000 a month in fees leaves a large margin for travel, support, and overhead.
“So you have 750,000. You're paying 6 times 20, 120,000”
Scale and the decentralization versus central control tension raise the risk of errors.
- Under Rajat Gupta, McKinsey chased revenue over the quality of revenue and adopted a stance of 'when we are right, we are right; when the client is right, we are right; when the client is wrong, they are wrong,' eroding accountability.
“McKinsey basically lost its way... it focused on chasing dollars as opposed to the quality of those dollars... In the Gupta era, McKinsey became the when they're right, we're right, when the client's right, we're right”
- McKinsey's scandals stem from a structural tension between decentralization that encourages entrepreneurial speed and centralized governance that controls risk, so every managing partner must re-balance this and the resulting outcomes swing between very high highs and very low lows.
“I think it's three or four things. The first thing is I think it's a natural tension of decentralization and autonomy and centralization in governance.”
- As the firm expands and employs many more people, the likelihood of messing up increases. Scale itself is a source of error risk.
“When you have expansion and you have that many people, there's more likelihood of messing up.”
Alumni and training, rather than advertising, drive McKinsey's client development.
- McKinsey's marketing is mostly passive: it trains consultants who become alumni, and those alumni in client leadership roles bring McKinsey back as their first call, so training doubles as client development.
“In a sense, it's they're training their next set of clients at the same time.”
- McKinsey Quarterly was created as a free, practical publication drawing sanitized client work, positioned as the practical Harvard Business Review, to build brand awareness and recruit students.
“the idea was to become the practical Harvard Business Review.”
The Big Three compete intensely with each other yet remain insulated from the wider consulting market.
- McKinsey, Bain, and BCG, known as the Big Three, compete intensely with each other but remain relatively insulated from the rest of the consulting industry, with McKinsey roughly $10 billion, BCG about $8 billion, and Bain about $4 billion in revenue.
“The competitive pressures between those three are very, very intense, but those businesses... have been growing at their fastest clips than ever before.”
- Fortune 500 executives choose among McKinsey, Bain, and BCG mainly by how specific their business problem is, because the three firms have similar talent, scale, and client networks.
“the way you're making that determination is really on the specificity of your business problem”
- McKinsey positions itself as the New York City of consulting: it covers every vertical and function, on the thesis that it is the best repository of business knowledge in the world.
“McKinsey likes to think of itself as the New York City of consulting. They do every vertical. They do every function.”
- Bain has chosen to go deep on functions and verticals, positioning itself as a regional, onshore player whose consultants travel less, and its private equity work led to the spin-out of Bain Capital.
“Bain has taken a approach of going very, very deep, from a functional and a vertical perspective.”
- Consulting is a roughly $150 to $200 billion market segmented into management, operational, and technology consulting, with McKinsey and its peers in strategy, Big Four accounting-linked firms in operations, and IT-focused shops in technology.
“consulting as a, call it, 150 billion to 200 billion dollar market.”