What this covers
This episode is a conversation with partners at Collaborative Fund, with Kanyi, Lauren, and Craig speaking for the firm and Patrick hosting. They describe how the firm works day to day: how it prices early deals, how it judges founders, and how it thinks about brand. Craig explains that the firm deploys capital steadily over about four years instead of timing the market, a form of Cost Averaging that keeps dry powder available when valuations contract. Lauren notes that a rigorous valuation is impossible at the seed stage. The firm asks instead whether the market could support a billion-dollar company and whether its check buys enough ownership. She also warns that an overpriced seed round makes the Series A harder to raise.
The founder discussion is the most developed thread. Kanyi ties a growth mindset to running experiments with fast feedback before product-market fit, and treats the pace of uncovering unknown unknowns as the measure of a founder's depth. Lauren counters that behind the tinkerer there must be an all-consuming drive. She also says founders have to choose between a winner-take-all race and a lifestyle business, since the middle position gets outrun. Brand gets a layered treatment: relationships, visual execution, and experience. Patrick argues for identity-based persuasion, which some of the claims contest.
The final stretch turns to exits. Patrick cites the shrinking count of public companies, and Craig describes a pendulum in public markets that now makes listing and staying listed harder. Quarterly pressure, Sarbanes-Oxley costs, and short CEO tenures are blamed for pushing founders to stay private, and the firm backs the Long-Term Stock Exchange as a response. Kanyi counters that being public gives companies liquid stock to hire with. Shorter forecasts cover urbanization and a new wave of founders building for their own children, and Lauren considers screen time and children's education.
Collaborative Fund's partners argue that early-stage venture success depends on fast experimental learning, founder motivation, disciplined pricing against the market, and brand built through experience and community, while the IPO and exit system is broken and needs institutional repair.
- Seed valuations are driven by competitive demand and must leave room for the Series A, so overpriced seeds damage future fundraising
- Pre-product-market-fit companies win by running experiments with closed feedback loops that build proprietary first-principles knowledge
- Liquidity has become scarce because public markets and regulation reward short-termism, so the firm backs new exit infrastructure such as the Long-Term Stock Exchange
Venture edge lies in spotting trends, brands and people before the market prices them
- Patrick applies Buffett's margin-of-safety idea, that if you have to model an investment it is not cheap enough, to venture investing, framing a firm's unfair advantage as a skill at spotting trends, brands, products and people before the market prices them.
“the idea that if you have to model it, it's not cheap enough. Like it has to be so obvious and that's kind of this idea of margin of safety.”
- Building something that scratches your own itch, rather than something a consulting study says is a growth area, is a litmus test for whether a business idea has real conviction and a route into brand.
“Do it because this scratches your own itch and maybe the itch now is your kid's itch not your own.”
Brand and low barriers, not capital intensity, make the moats worth investing in
- Appealing to a person's identity, by framing an action as consistent with who they are, is more powerful for changing behavior than rational argument, which is why brands that communicate through identity outperform those that try to persuade with reasons.
“there's no more powerful way of getting someone to do something than to say, to do this would align with what you identify yourself as.”
- Asset-light businesses can earn high returns with little capital, but because they are easy to build they can also lose much business very quickly, whereas capital-intensive businesses such as mining have a moat from high barriers to entry.
“if you can build a business on so little, you can also lose a lot of business very quickly.”
- Many of the most interesting businesses the firm invests in have very low barriers to entry, with brand being an almost ethereal moat that is important but very hard to quantify, define, or value.
“the barriers are incredibly low and almost ethereal like brand as an example is so important and powerful. But it's very hard to quantify, to pin down, to define, to value.”
Public markets are shrinking and distorted, so private status and listing are life-cycle choices
- The number of publicly traded companies today is only about half what it was several decades ago, which is a serious problem for venture funds that need exits and liquidity events to return capital.
“the decline in IPOs and the fact that there are only about half as many publicly traded companies today, as there were several decades ago.”
- Public companies are distorted by quarterly earnings pressure, with CEO tenure falling, companies spending less time in the S&P 500, and a rat race where everyone beats by a penny and no one loses by a penny, which is a massive distraction and a reason founders prefer to stay private.
“companies spend less and less time in the S&P 500, it's this quarterly kind of rat race to meet earnings. Everyone beats by a penny, no one loses by a penny.”
- Some of the most successful companies went public, then went private and advanced, with Dell as an example, which suggests public listing is a useful life-cycle step even if it is not permanent.
“companies that were public and then went private and advanced, that's like Dell”
Digital learning should replace parts of early curriculum to address children's screen-time problems
- Patrick believes programming should replace some core curriculum elements early in children's education, though it is hard to change core curriculum.
“I'm a big believer that programming should replace some core curriculum element early on in kids' lives”
- Patrick's own experience of screen-time addiction in his three-year-old son shows that the play-plus-digital-learning model addresses a real problem for parents.
“Even at three years old, he just, he wants the iPad, he wants the phone”
- A simple product test, such as giving a toy to a child and seeing whether they like it within minutes, provides fast feedback on whether a kids product works.
“So to use the villain test here, I have a three-year-old son”