#107 Sol Price (Costco)
What this covers
This episode follows Sol Price from his early ventures through FedMart and Price Club, the line that leads to Costco. A host narrates and quotes heavily, tracing how each business grew out of an earlier one. Fedco, a membership warehouse for federal employees in Los Angeles, inspired FedMart in San Diego, and FedMart's lessons shaped Price Club. The antecedents get attention too: Eugene Ferkauf's Korvette used membership to get around fair-trade laws, and a locker club for sailors showed that a focused niche could sustain a large store.
The middle of the episode covers operating mechanics. Price held that demand responds to price more than selection, so he stocked about 4,500 items instead of 50,000, cut labor hours (payroll being roughly 80 percent of operating cost), and accepted what he called an intelligent loss of sales. He paid FedMart workers $1 an hour when competitors paid $0.50. The host notes that Costco marks up around 14 percent and earns its profit from membership fees. Price Club opened below $30,000 in its first week against a $200,000 goal, and a credit union mailing rescued it. FedMart's pharmacy drew organized resistance from incumbents.
The contested material concerns people. Price distrusted training manuals ("you train an animal, you teach a person"), and the host pairs his inexperienced team with Henry Ford's suspicion of experts. The host also argues that Sam Walton copied freely from Price, and that Price steered Bernard Marcus toward Home Depot. Price's later drift into real estate is called a focus mistake. Robert Price closes on his father's legacy.
Sol Price's career shows that durable retail advantage comes from serving customers and employees rather than maximizing scale, from refining proven ideas instead of inventing from scratch, and from capping downside risk while teaching employees to think for themselves.
- Price borrowed and adapted existing models (Fedco, Korvette, locker clubs, Marco) and competitors such as Walmart and Home Depot then copied his concepts
- Paying employees above market rates and cutting selection to lower labor costs produced lower prices and better service
- Price repeatedly kept fallback options and fixed downside limits, such as keeping his law practice and negotiating a one-year lease exit
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Eugene Ferkauf's Korvette circumvented fair-trade price-floor laws by requiring shoppers to become members, a workaround that Price later borrowed, and the membership structure persisted in wholesale clubs long after the laws disappeared.
“He circumvented the fair-trade laws by requiring that shoppers became members in order to shop.”
Price argued that carrying fewer items increases sales because customer demand is more sensitive to price than selection, and since payroll is about 80 percent of retail operating costs, fewer items reduce labor hours and lower prices, so 4,500 items cost far less to handle than 50,000.
“Because payroll and benefits represent approximately 80% of retailer's cost of operations, pricing advantage follows labor productivity.”
Successful founders cap their downside through contract terms while leaving the upside open; Price negotiated a 10-year lease with a one-year cancellation right, limiting his exposure when the business was unproven.
“So you need to find ways to cap your downside in life, but always leave your upside unlimited.”
Sam Walton said he borrowed as many ideas from Sol Price as from anybody and liked the FedMart name so much that he adopted it for Walmart, and Walmart was founded in 1962, eight years after FedMart.
“I've stolen, I actually prefer the word, borrowed, as many ideas from Sol Price as from anybody else in the business.”
Price's intelligent loss of sales holds that customer demand is most sensitive to price rather than selection, so a store can stock fewer items, pioneer large package sizes, and accept losing the minority of customers who want a non-standard size.
“The intelligent loss of sales turns that theory on its head, postulating that customer demand is most sensitive to price, not selection.”
Price Club was conceived as a wholesale warehouse where small independent businesses would pool buying power, selling at low markups and charging a membership fee that provided most of the profit, a model the host says Costco later inherited.
“hundreds or even thousands of small businesses would pool their buying power by shopping at a wholesale warehouse.”
When Bernard Marcus, who had been fired from Handy Dan, visited Price Club in 1978, Price suggested he start a home improvement warehouse using his hardware experience, and Marcus opened the first Home Depot in Atlanta in 1979 with Arthur Blank.
“He suggested to Marcus that he open his own home improvement business using the knowledge and experience he had gained at Handy Dan.”
Price's involvement with Seven Seas, a locker club serving sailors, showed him that a large store selling many goods under one roof could succeed by catering to a focused niche segment of the market.
“They could be successful catering to a focused segment of the marketplace. In other words, a niche.”
Henry Ford argued that wise and practical people always know exactly why something cannot be done and that he therefore avoided hiring experts in full bloom, a view the host links to Price's inexperienced team.
“They always know the limitations. That is why I never employ an expert in full bloom.”
Price's team lacked retail backgrounds and so did not know what would not work, which let them experiment, test ideas and learn through trial and error, a process that cannot be replicated in school.
“most of us had backgrounds that were alien to retailing. We didn't know what wouldn't work”
Price believed that you train an animal but teach a person, and he distrusted procedures and training manuals because they substitute for thinking, so employees should understand why their jobs matter to the business.
“'You train an animal, you teach a person.' ... he believed that manuals were a substitute for thinking.”
Sam Walton admitted borrowing many ideas from Price's FedMart, and Charlie Munger argued that Walton invented nothing but copied everything smart and blew past competitors, so mastering the best existing ideas beats dreaming up everything oneself.
“Walton invented nothing, but he copied everything anybody else ever did that was smart. So he blew right by them all.”
After Mandell Weiss introduced Price to Fedco, a nonprofit membership warehouse serving federal employees in Los Angeles that drew San Diego shoppers driving 200 miles round trip, Price concluded that a similar membership retail model could succeed in San Diego.
“5,000 Fedco members lived in San Diego, and were driving 200 miles round-trip to take advantage of Fedco's bargain pricing”
When FedMart opened a discount pharmacy, local and state pharmacy groups pressured wholesalers not to supply it, obstructed its state permit, expelled Price, and made threats, showing how incumbents resist price competition in regulated markets.
“pressure placed on wholesale companies not to deliver or sell to FedMart, difficulty in obtaining a permit from the state Board of Pharmacy”
Eugene Ferkauf launched discount retailing with E.J. Korvette's first discount store in New York City in 1948, selling appliances and household goods at deep discounts from manufacturers' suggested fair-trade prices a decade before Price entered retail.
“Eugene Ferkauf, Founder of E. J. Korvette with his first discount store operating in New York City in 1948.”
The host argues that instead of spending heavily on advertising, a company can invest in making its product better, because humans are social creatures who tell friends about good products, so word-of-mouth is a stronger marketing engine.
“if you make your product better, humans are social creatures. And if they come across a good product or a good movie or good anything, what do we do? We tell our friends about it.”
The host says Costco marks up goods around 14 percent to cover operating costs and earns its profit mainly from membership fees charged for access to wholesale pricing.
“They mark everything up with a standard, I think it's like 14%. I could be wrong.”
Price's alter ego concept held that a store owner should train employees to do the work as well as he would himself, so the owner can focus on the highest-skill work and oversight.
“He must teach his employees to become his alter ego so that they understand the importance of their jobs”
Price Club's sales were below $30,000 in its first week against a $200,000 goal, and a partnership with the San Diego County Credit Union, which mailed a flyer to members offering free shopping access, turned the business around by bringing in group members who then became business members.
“We quickly contacted the San Diego County Credit Union to let them know that their members could shop at Price Club.”
Price held that a business exists to serve customers, and since employees serve customers, paying them well and providing benefits is essential; the host says Costco does the same.
“you need to make sure that you're paying them well and you're giving them benefits.”
Successive retail ideas were iterations: Fedco inspired FedMart, FedMart's experience led to Price Club, and Price Club became Costco, with Walton, Bezos and others applying the same ideas, so business innovation is largely cumulative.
“they're really iterations. All these ideas are iterations on -- like so you start with Fedco”
Price paid FedMart workers $1 per hour when competitors paid $0.50, reasoning that adequate wages reduce turnover, attract better candidates and make employees serve customers better, which in turn produces stronger profits.
“Employers were paying their employees $0.50 per hour. Sol knew that people could not live on $0.50 an hour. He decided that the wage rate at FedMart would be $1 per hour.”
Price redirected company resources into real estate development, which had lower immediate returns than Price Club's operating business and drew investor criticism, and he eventually became more focused on real estate than on the warehouse business, which the host calls a focus mistake.
“The immediate financial returns on real estate were much lower than the returns on Price Club's operating business.”
Price placed great emphasis on teaching employees, and a quote attributed to Jim Sinegal says that if you are not spending 90% of your time teaching, you are not doing your job.
“If you're not spending 90% of your time teaching, you're not doing your job.”
Price viewed the retailer-member relationship as a professional fiduciary one, so FedMart avoided sales and advertising, relying on member word-of-mouth testimonials and investing savings into lower prices.
“We have in effect said that the best advertising is by our members, the unsolicited testimonial of the satisfied customer.”
Robert Price argues that his father's most enduring legacy is the lasting impact he had on the lives of people, including teaching them how to think, question assumptions, check facts, and care for others.
“his more enduring legacy may be the impact he had on the lives of the people who knew him”
Price Club stocked about 3,000 items versus roughly 50,000 at a typical grocery or discount store, used a warehouse format with rack storage and concrete floors, and shipped directly from suppliers, which let it sell for less.
“The typical grocery or discount store carried about 50,000 different items compared to Price Club's 3,000 items.”
Price noticed that San Diego downtown stores kept inconvenient hours, closed Sundays and evenings, and used decorative packaging and personal service, and he built the opposite model that served consumers better.
“Downtown store hours were 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Saturday, and they were closed Sunday and evenings.”
The host argues that Walton, Bezos and Sinegal never sold their businesses and became extremely successful, while Price's repeated sales of his companies cut his compounding short, so founders should let good businesses compound.
“Don't interrupt the compounding, right? Sam Walton never sold and became one of the richest people in history.”
Yvon Chouinard argued that to understand the entrepreneur you should study the juvenile delinquent, because both act on the sense that the existing situation can be improved and that they will do their own thing.
“if you want to understand the entrepreneur, study the juvenile delinquent.”
Price learned more about business from advising small business clients on bankruptcies, real estate, partnerships and estates than he ever did in law school, which led him to fall in love with business and leave law.
“Over a period of time, I really learned far more from my clients than I ever learned in law school.”
FedMart deliberately broke conventions of 1950s retail, including membership-only access, hours of 12:30 to 9 p.m., cash-and-check payment, and refusing fair-trade brands, which the host links to James Dyson's principle of pursuing difference because it must be better.
“FedMart broke about -- just about all the conventions in 1950s retailing.”
By the early 1970s, nearly twenty years after its founding, FedMart faced rising competition and imitators, and Price admitted the company was good at creating a business but less good at running one, which led to his decision to seek new models in Europe.
“we were good at creating the business, but we weren't as good at running the business.”
Price sold FedMart to the German retailer Hugo Mann, hoping to combine ideas with Mann's money, but Mann controlled the capital and decisions, and at a board meeting he spent 90 minutes criticizing Price's performance, a warning the host says was obvious only in hindsight.
“Rather than the friendly person we had seen, Mann launched into a 90-minute tirade criticizing Sol and FedMart's performance.”
Price kept his law practice while launching FedMart and gave it up only gradually, using it as a fallback to limit personal risk until the business was clearly successful, and he never regretted switching at age 41 in the late 1950s.
“Sol was still practicing law. He began spending more and more time at the main street location”
Price gave away legal services pro bono early in his career, which introduced him to community members, some of whom later became paying clients, so giving value first built his practice.
“his pro bono legal work introduced him to many people in the community, some of whom eventually became his clients”
Price's childhood eye deformity led to teasing and shyness, and he compensated by overachieving in school, reading early and skipping grades, which the host sees as an origin of his drive.
“The kids teased me a lot and consequently, I was shy, and I compensated this by being an overachiever in school.”
Price concluded that Price Club's only realistic buyers were Costco and Sam's, and in 1993 he merged Price Club with Costco, choosing his protégé Jim Sinegal over Walton's Sam's Club.
“There were only two realistic possibilities, Costco and Sam's.”
Price refused a mortgage with a major insurer unless a provision requiring separate bathrooms for white and colored people was removed, and the lender removed it.
“he would not enter into the mortgage agreement unless the provision was removed.”
Entrepreneurial drive often comes from a youthful sense of not fitting in and a refusal to accept things as they are; Price was shy and teased as a child, compensated by overachieving, and was a mischievous student whose teacher warned he could become a gangster or do much good.
“he could go in one of two directions, a career as a gangster or someone who would do much good”
After suppliers cut off FedMart's gasoline, Price priced premium gasoline only a few cents above regular, since its cost was barely higher, and created a FedMart subsidiary acting as a wholesale supplier that shipped fuel through the Panama Canal to keep supply flowing.
“He created a FedMart subsidiary that functioned as a wholesale gasoline supplier.”
Price showed that stocking only the eight-ounce size of three-in-one oil, which was the best value per ounce, lost only the small share of customers who needed a smaller size, and the price advantage from scale outweighed that loss.
“Most people who need three in one oil will buy the eight-ounce size if that's all there is on the shelf. He said, 'Most, but not all.'”
Sol Price founded and took public three separate companies (FedMart, Price Club, and a real estate investment trust), a pattern of starting and then selling businesses that the host finds notable.
“he's probably one of the few people in the world that founded and took three separate companies public.”
In 1982 Sam Walton visited Price Club to learn about the warehouse club business, Price shared information generously, and Walton opened his first Sam's Club in Oklahoma City in 1983, after Walton had earlier modeled Walmart on FedMart.
“Once again, Sol was open and generous with information. The next year in 1983, Walton opened his first Sam's Club in Oklahoma City.”
Henry Ford's remark that true education comes through the discipline of life is echoed by the host, who argues that people learn far more from direct experience than from formal schooling.
“True education is gained through the discipline of life.”
Price advised that the way to succeed in retail is to put yourself in the place of a cranky, demanding customer and to view the business from the customer's perspective.
“if you want to be successful in retail, just put yourself in the place of a cranky demanding customer.”
Price believed his and his partner's strengths were in creative areas rather than in managing a large public company, and he felt tired of Wall Street pressure for growth, which is why he preferred a sale to a successor.
“He had always believed that his and my business strengths were in the creative area and not in the management side of operating a big business.”
Price set the same $1 wage in San Antonio as in San Diego and Phoenix, rejecting the practice of cutting pay in depressed markets, because workers there worked as hard and FedMart was already profitable.
“Employees in San Antonio worked just as hard and as well as other FedMart employees. Why not apply the same wage philosophy in San Antonio?”
Price Club offered partners a no-cost benefit that members valued, which the host says is a way to increase both partners' membership value and to gain distribution without paying for advertising.
“What if we add another value to your members? You don't have to pay us anything.”
FedMart broke with 1950s retailing by restricting shoppers to military or government employees who bought a $2 lifetime paper membership card, selling mostly for cash or check, and refusing to stock goods from manufacturers that enforced fair-trade pricing.
“Shoppers had to be military or government employees. They purchased a $2 lifetime paper membership card and needed to show their card in order to shop.”
Credit union members joining through a group membership card could qualify as business members for an extra 5 percent discount, which increased business memberships and sales because people who pay for memberships are more likely to use them.
“if they could qualify as business members, they would save an additional 5%”
Price Club was targeted at $200,000 per week but sales averaged below $30,000 in its first week, and employees parked in front-row member spaces to signal the store was open.
“Sol was hoping that Price Club would be on track within a month or two to do $200,000 per week. But by the end of the first week, sales were averaging below $30,000.”
Price told an overwhelmed employee that they were not running the store, the store was running them, and that managers must take charge and stay ahead of events rather than react to them.
“You're not running this place. It's running you.”
The host argues that the value of learning from past founders is reaffirmed by Costco, whose leader Jim Sinegal credits Price for nearly everything he knows, and Costco is among the most successful US retailers.
“Jim Sinegal recounted... my response was, 'No, that's inaccurate. I didn't learn a lot. I learned everything, everything I know.'”
Richard Branson negotiated with Boeing for a buy-back guarantee on airplanes so that if his first airline failed after a year, Boeing would repurchase the planes, capping his downside.
“Listen, I'm going to buy all these planes from you, but I need an out. So after one year, if I'm not succeeding, you have to agree to buy them back from me.”
The Inca empire built a great imperial state despite lacking wheeled vehicles, draft animals, iron and steel, and a writing system, so the host argues that there is not one right way to build something and that unconventional approaches can succeed.
“Despite these supposed handicaps, the Incas were still able to construct one of the greatest Imperial states in human history.”
The host argues that many entrepreneurs find their business later in life, noting Price was about 41 when he gave up law for FedMart and Sam Walton was 44 when he founded Walmart, so people who are confused early need not worry.
“He was like 44 when he founded Walmart.”
Price bought out independent operators who rented space inside FedMart so that every department followed one consistent merchandising philosophy, ensuring the entire store served customers the same way.
“They had a belief that there needed to be one merchandising strategy throughout the store.”
Price told his granddaughter that people always have more time than they think, that most people waste large amounts of their 168 weekly hours, and he kept a 'do it now' sign on his desk to fight impatience.
“We always have more time than we think. ... There are 24 hours in a day, 168 hours in a week. We just waste so much of it.”
During the war years, Price worked at his law office in the morning and at Consolidated, an aircraft plant, at night, and he thrived on being busy, which the host presents as a trait he developed in contrast to his father's avoidance of work.
“Unlike his father, who had managed to find ways not to work, Sol thrived when he was busy, working hard and feeling productive.”
Costco, Price Club, and FedMart succeeded by doing essentially the opposite of conventional retailers, which means success can come from pursuing an unconventional path rather than following the prevailing model.
“So when I read this section, you realize that like Costco, Price Club, FedMart, they do essentially the opposite of what everybody else was doing.”
Price's grandson died of a brain tumor in his teens, an event that the host says hit Robert Price deeply while he and his father were working together.
“his grandson dies of a brain tumor, really young. He was like 15.”
Price's father was lazy and likely faked an illness to receive disability benefits, and those benefits kept the family out of poverty during the Great Depression, which shaped Price's opposite drive to work.
“the fact that his father was on disability benefits actually saved the family from poverty.”
Price said FedMart cost $50,000 to start when the founders knew little, but five years later, with experience, opening a store cost $5 million, showing how learning changes the scale and scope of what founders attempt.
“it only took $50,000 to start a business ... And five years later ... it took $5 million to open one.”
When Costco needed to hire 200 people, about 22,000 applicants responded, which the host cites as evidence of the reputational payoff from paying above-market wages.
“They needed to hire 200 new people. 22,000 people applied for those 200 positions.”
Price found the cost of premium gasoline was only a few pennies above regular, so he sold only premium at a few cents above regular's price, using the lower-cost-per-unit structure to undercut the market.
“the cost to acquire premium gasoline was only a few pennies higher than the cost of regular.”
During World War II Price worked a schedule of law office hours followed by night shifts at Consolidated until 11:15 p.m., and he learned to love productivity, which later shaped his view that people always have more time than they think.
“He didn't complain. He said, 'I enjoyed the experience.' Unlike his father, who had managed to find ways not to work, Sol thrived when he was busy”
A Costco customer received quotes of about $700 for a prescription from several pharmacies but only $53 at Costco, and the host argues such experiences create lifelong customers.
“let's say he got three different quotes, and it was in the area of like $700. He calls Costco and it's like $53.”
The host notes that Price's efficiency logic resembles the cost-focused approach Herb Kelleher used at Southwest Airlines, which allowed Southwest to be one of the few profitable airlines.
“he uses a lot of ideas very similar to this one.”
Sol Price entered retailing almost by accident: while helping his mother-in-law Bertha defer taxes through a commercial property swap, he needed a tenant for a Main Street warehouse, and client Mandell Weiss suggested a Fedco-style store, which led to FedMart.
“Sol's client and good friend, Mandell Weiss, not only helped find a tenant, in so -- in doing so, he introduced Sol to his career in retailing.”
Reading biographies reveals that ideas credited to one founder were often learned from others, so books act as the original links in the chain of business knowledge.
“books are the original links.”