#195 Sid Meier (Computer game designer)
What this covers
This Founders episode has the host working through Sid Meier's memoir and drawing business lessons from the history of MicroProse and the Civilization series. Meier's story sits beside cases from other fields: Tom Clancy selling The Hunt for Red October for about $5,000, Akio Morita and Ralph Lauren refusing house brand offers, and the split between John Romero and John Carmack at id Software, which the host ties to mismatched ambitions.
The business material is concrete. In the 1980s, national chains leased shelf space to a distributor, so Sid Meier and Bill Stealey went to CES in 1984 to get noticed. MicroProse turned down a flat $250,000 buyout of Solo Flight. Sierra began by selling games in ziplock bags, and Doom's shareware release earned around $100,000 a day although only 1 to 2 percent of players paid. The host also looks at free-to-play economics, citing Nexon's 16 percent revenue gain and Candy Crush's 70 percent of non-paying users as evidence for Stated vs Revealed Preference.
On design, the episode covers Meier's rule that one good game beats two great ones, his decision to halve Civilization's map less than a month before release (Double It or Cut It in Half), and his reversal on modding, which he first opposed. The claim that good products need a single formidable leader rather than a committee is flagged as contested. It closes on Meier's view of a roughly 40-year career, judged by one's own scorecard, and on the point that big moments rarely feel big when they happen.
Using Sid Meier's memoir as a case study, the host argues that Meier's career shows how creative businesses succeed by keeping ownership, starting from the player's experience, and combining specialists' strengths rather than by chasing big breaks or deals.
- Meier turned down buyouts and house-brand deals to keep the upside of his work
- Meier designed from the player's perspective and cut features that did not serve the core experience
- Meier's successful projects relied on small early wins, iteration, and partners who covered his weaknesses
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Civilization succeeded despite conventional wisdom that strategy games cannot make big money and despite little initial marketing, spreading slowly through deep fan letters and word of mouth for years after release.
“The conventional wisdom said a strategy title would never make big money”
Gamers may say they hate microtransactions, but revenue shows they spend anyway: Nexon's free-to-play model raised corporate revenue 16 percent in a year, and about 70 percent of Candy Crush users never paid.
“A full 70% of Candy Crush users have never paid a dime for the game, yet it still brings in several million dollars a day”
Innovation is rarely a single big idea and is more often a series of small ideas brought together in new and better ways, as Meier's games demonstrated when dozens of incremental fixes, not one lightning bolt, rescued a game that went on to sell 250,000 copies.
“Innovation is rarely about a big idea. More usually, it's a series of small ideas brought together in new and better ways”
Tom Clancy sold The Hunt for Red October for about $5,000 and was still working as an insurance salesman after two successful books, and later lost control of his character rights due to contract problems.
“He sold it for $5,000”
Doom's shareware release gave away the first 15 levels for free, and only about 1 to 2 percent of players bought the rest, yet the game earned around $100,000 a day after release with a team of about six people.
“less than like, I want to say, 1%, 2%, something like that”
Stated opinions about game monetization differ from actual spending behavior, so product decisions should rely on revealed behavior.
“they state they don't like it, but they wind up spending a lot more money the other way”
National retail chains leased shelf space to professional distributors rather than choosing products themselves, so Meier and Bill went to CES in 1984 to get the attention of buyers and signed distribution deals.
“To get the attention we needed, Bill said we had to get ourselves to CES”
Creators do their best work with collaborators who give honest, critical feedback, and a bunch of yes-men fails to improve quality.
“It was hard to find people that gave me honest feedback. They're like, 'Hey, you are great.'”
Akio Morita of Sony and Ralph Lauren both refused early offers to produce goods under a retailer's house brand, because they were building a brand that mattered more than the immediate money.
“Yes, but I won't be forever. And one day, my company will be as well-known as your company”
In the 1980s retail game market, national chains leased their shelf space to professional distributors rather than choosing products themselves, so a game company had to get the attention of distributors, which meant upward mobility came all at once or not at all.
“The national chains didn't decide for themselves what products to carry. Instead, they leased out their shelf space to professional distributors”
Good games don't get made by committee and need a formidable individual leading them, a principle that Edwin Land, Steve Jobs, George Lucas, David Ogilvy, and Charles Kettering also hold, and Civilization's rotation of lead designers reflected the energy of the young team members.
“Good games don't get made by committee. You need that formidable individual that's leading it.”
Romero's desire for an empire versus Carmack's wish to just make good programs was a major cause of the breakup of id Software's partnership, so cofounders with mismatched goals tend to split.
“Romero wants an empire. I just want to make good programs”
Early indie developers sold games as physical copies in ziplock bags, a model Ken and Roberta Williams used to turn homemade graphical adventure games into a roughly $10 million a year company called Sierra On-Line.
“pioneered the ziplock distribution method turning their homemade graphical role-playing games into a $10-million-a-year company”
Opening Civilization to player modding seemed like tearing down the house but actually strengthened the franchise, because imagination heightens reality and fans who remodel the house do so because they want to stay in the neighborhood.
“imagination never diminishes reality, it only heightens it”
Nexon used small purchases within a free game as a last-ditch effort to save an online server that was losing subscribers, and the microtransactions raised total corporate revenue by 16 percent in one year, dwarfing previous subscription sales.
“increasing the total corporate revenue by 16% in 1 year”
Good products are not made by committee and need a formidable individual leader, a view Meier shared with figures like Edwin Land, Steve Jobs, George Lucas, David Ogilvy, and Charles Kettering.
“Good games don't get made by committee.”
MicroProse turned down a flat $250,000 buyout from HesWare for the full Solo Flight game because the game could sell far more than that, even though the company was cash-constrained, and Meier later described this as not selling the family jewels.
“I heard you shouldn't sell the family jewels”
Combining two great game ideas in one product left Meier with zero good games, so one good game is better than two great games, and deciding what to leave out is often more important than deciding what to include.
“The notion that one good game is better than two great games was such a revelation that it became known in my mind as the Covert Action rule”
When tuning a product, make large changes, doubling or halving, rather than many small 5 percent tweaks, because big moves reveal the real effect quickly; Meier halved Civilization's map less than a month before release and the game became more epic.
“Just double it and see if it even had the effect you thought it was going to have”
Big career moments rarely feel life-changing when they happen, and retroactive mythologizing makes people wait for something dramatic instead of throwing themselves into every opportunity.
“The big moments rarely feel like life-changing at the time, okay? And the danger of retroactive mythologizing is that it makes people want to hold out for something dramatic rather than throwing themselves into every opportunity”
Success should be measured by one's own scorecard of the exploits one values over a career of roughly 40 years, not by objective progress, and failures are reasons to continue rather than reload, as Pirates! design suggested.
“success could only be measured as a combination of your exploits and how much value you put on those particular exploits yourself in your scorecard”
Bill returned Meier's supposedly finished game the next day with a list of bugs and military inaccuracies, and that candid criticism convinced Meier the partnership could go somewhere, since honest critics are more valuable than admirers.
“a day later, he returned it to me with a list of bugs and military inaccuracies. That was when I knew that this partnership could really go somewhere”
A career lasts about 40 years between childhood and old age, so the goal is to pack as many adventures as possible into that window with no regrets, measuring success by one's own scorecard rather than objective metrics.
“As in real life, success could only be measured as a combination of your exploits and how much value you put on those particular exploits yourself in your scorecard”
Giving players the tools to modify Civilization, which Meier first opposed, became the main reason the series survived for decades because imagination heightens reality rather than diminishing it.
“What I didn't see at the time is that imagination never diminishes reality, it only heightens it”
When your work feels like play to you and like work to competitors, you are hard to compete with, and the goal is to make games for a living, not to build an empire.
“All that mattered to me was that I got to make games for a living”
Meier did not wait for a perfect plan or overriding artistic vision on day one; he put features into the game, tested them, and cut what was clunky, so the game grew through hard, consistent daily improvement.
“There is no map before you've explored the wilderness and no overriding artistic vision on day 1.”
A partnership that trades away ownership or caps upside in exchange for near-term cash can be far more costly than it looks, so founders should keep control of what they create.
“Partnership was not the same as ownership.”
A useful design filter is to ask whether you yourself would want to play the thing, keeping ideas only when the answer is yes, because the player's experience should drive decisions rather than what is easier for the designer.
“All I could do is keep asking myself, would I want to play this game? As long as the answer was yes, the idea stayed in”
The further apart two people's talents are, the more they can offer each other, so creators should stick to their own edge and bring in specialists who fill in their gaps rather than doing every task themselves.
“The dichotomy between someone else's talent and your own is a cause for celebration because the further apart you are the more you can offer each other”
The best way to prove an idea is good is to build it by sitting in each role in turn, programmer, artist, and tester, until it is playable, recognizable, and honestly judged, without needing to be perfect at any single role.
“Sit in the programmer chair until you have something playable, then sit in the artist chair”
The best work is work that feels like play to you while feeling like work to others, and quality of the product is what makes a creator's career sustainable.
“Work that feels like play. No one can compete with you if you're -- what you're doing today feels like play to you, and it feels like work to them”
Meier was not a boisterous salesman or self-promoter and knew this was counterproductive, so he chose to rely on people who had the knowledge of the non-programming world, making his weakness someone else's strength.
“I was neither a boisterous salesman nor a self-promoter”
Clancy's regret over losing rights to his own character shows that keeping control of intellectual property avoids shady business arrangements, and Meier chose to keep his creations rather than sell them and watch the buyer profit.
“Tom was especially troubled by ongoing contractual issues with his first book and the fear that he might never again own the rights to his own character.”
A game designer should decide who the player is by asking who is having the most fun, which is the king in Civilization, the captain in Pirates!, the general in war games, and the tycoon in railroad games, and the same question can be applied to one's own life.
“Who is having the most fun? That's who you want your player to be”
A game is fundamentally a series of interesting decisions, and the gift of agency, the player's ability to exert free will over their surroundings rather than following a fixed narrative, is what sets games apart from other media.
“they are fundamentally comprised, as all games are, of a series of interesting decisions”
Meier's partnership with Bill worked because Meier was a craftsman who liked working alone and Bill was a master salesman, so each covered the other's weakness and the pair complemented each other like chocolate and peanut butter.
“they go together like chocolate and peanut butter”
Bill made repeated calls to hobby stores posing as various customers, and on the fourth call used a professional voice as a MicroProse representative, which prompted the stores to invite him in because of the imagined demand.
“Finally, on the fourth week, he'd use his professional voice”
A small initial success can light a fire and make people believe something might be possible, and believing it is possible is the first step to accomplishing it.
“You can't accomplish anything until you actually think it's possible. That's the first step.”
Young people's inexperience lets them take on enormous projects they would never attempt with full knowledge of the difficulty, but Civilization's scale burned Meier out for a long period afterward.
“sometimes it's useful to be a young person who hasn't learned how to doubt himself yet”
People play games to feel good about themselves, so designers should not make decisions that work against that reason players engage.
“People play games to feel good about themselves. So don't make decisions as a game designer that go against why they're playing”
Civilization fixes came from dozens of incremental changes and other people's better work, showing that gaming is collaborative and no one person can claim all the credit.
“Gaming is a collaborative effort, and it is silly to think that any one person can claim all the glory”
Games can make players feel strongly, as shown when Meier's mother became too emotionally invested to keep playing, and the same logic that led Louis B. Mayer to bet on sound films suggests products that evoke emotion win.
“Games were not just a diversion I realized. Games could make you feel”
The first step toward any creative project is almost always to sit down and start working, rather than waiting for clarity or permission.
“The first step is almost always to sit down and start working”
Meier kept his day job and worked half-time, rejecting full venture funding and loans, which gave him a safety net while building the company.
“I have a safety net, but I can also dedicate more hours of my week to making this company successful”
Robin Williams argued that other entertainment industries promote stars by name, so game designers should do the same, and Meier's games began carrying his name as a brand.
“Why should gaming be any different?”
Meier's optimism rooted in gratitude means that even an unglamorous first job, installing networked cash register systems, was treated as a good opportunity, and changing perspective changes how much enjoyment and misery one gets from life.
“I was glad to do anything”
Games cannot compete with the visual spectacle of movies, the length of novels, or the acoustics of albums, so prioritizing those features over gameplay leads to disappointment; games should instead lean into their own strength.
“The time has come for us to outgrow Hollywood envy”
Meier and Stealey launched with $1,500 in savings spent on floppy disks, label stickers, and plastic baggies, and they avoided loans and venture capital, which meant a few slow months of sales could have sunk the company.
“So with $1,500 in savings, we bought a stack of floppy disks, a package of label stickers, and a box of plastic baggies to put them in.”
SimCity was self-published by Will Wright after years of publisher rejection, and its focus on building rather than destroying inspired Meier's Railroad Tycoon and shaped his focus on perpetual progress.
“Will had spent years trying to convince publishers that his city building simulator was a game at all”
Jay-Z was refused by labels at 26 and created his own record label instead, an early example of an artist refusing a standard deal.
“no one would sign him when he was 26 years old back in the '90s. And so he just signed himself”
Creative ideas always build on earlier work, and Meier borrowed concepts from games like Seven Cities of Gold, so the ideas did not start with him and will not end with him.
“The ideas didn't start with us, and they can't end with us either”
Shareware started as business applications offered free to try with a request to send a check if you liked them, and game developers tried to adapt that model, but many downloaders simply did not pay.
“Shareware started out as like business applications for free, try it, download it. If you like it, send me a check.”
Claude Hopkins's principle that the more you tell, the more you sell applies to product documentation: MicroProse's manuals, like textbooks, created a deeper appreciation among the buyers who read them.
“the more you tell, the more you sell, right?”
Creators who sign deals without studying decades of music-industry exploitation repeat the same mistakes, and independent artists who keep ownership, use new technology, and make money show the better path.
“you're ignoring decades of history”
As Meier's company grew into a large, bureaucratic structure with licensing and corporate demands, he left to start a small studio, showing that scale can crowd out the work founders originally loved.
“I didn't like doing licenses, and I don't like the corporate structure that have been slowly but surely building up around me”
Meier saw no single turning point toward game design because play is a deeply embedded human instinct that everyone starts with, so the real question is why one stops playing, not when one started.
“The question, 'When did you start?' Would be better framed as 'Why didn't you stop?'”
Steam data shows Civilization V recorded about one billion player hours from its 2010 release through 2016, a six-year window into just one installment in a series spanning 29 years and 12 main titles.
“one billion is actually the number of hours played on Civilization V from its release in 2010 up through 2016”
Games were sometimes looked at sideways in confusion in the early days, and the cultural dominance gaming later achieved was not foreseeable to its pioneers.
“I don't think any of us could have imagined back then the kind of cultural domination that gaming would someday achieve”
Start with service to the customer: MicroProse's manuals and early helpfulness reflected a desire to serve players, which the host connects to Hopkins' advice.
“start with service”
Business is full of untrustworthy people, so one way to protect yourself is to maintain control over your work, as Meier learned from his conversation with Tom Clancy about how control of his character was lost.
“Wise people want to avoid other people who are just total rat poison, and there are a lot of them”
A slightly obsessive personality helps keep creative work focused on quality, but one must keep reading, learning, and seeking joy elsewhere because inspiration can come from unexpected sources.
“I think having a slightly obsessive personality is a useful thing”
Offering a free demo with an option to buy the full game is a fair pricing model, and it is not new since coin-operated arcades used a similar pay-per-play model long before.
“I do think the idea of a free demo with the option to purchase the entire game is a fair one”
Jay-Z's album framing argues that a $9.99 album can be worth over $1 million to a listener across a lifetime, and that rappers should talk about investing and building companies.
“I'm just trying to give you $1 million worth of game for $9.99”
Treating one's life as a video game, a framing Tim Urban used for Elon Musk as Grand Theft Life, is a rarely used way to approach life.
“the whole idea about treating your life as like you're playing a video game”
Shopify founder Tobi Lutke said he learned how to build companies by playing StarCraft, which he described as a game about resource allocation.
“he learned how to build companies by playing StarCraft”
Early software sales were constrained by hardware: each copy of Hellcat Ace had to be made one at a time on matched floppy drives, taking roughly 60 seconds per sale.
“Each individual sale back then translated to about 60 seconds of boredom in front of my matched pair of floppy drives”
Meier learned from Clancy's contract problems instead of paying his own tuition, which is a deliberate way to avoid expensive mistakes in business.
“I'm going to learn from other people's experiences.”
There is a large gulf between better and best, and a creator who wants lasting impact must aim to be on the far side of that gulf rather than merely producing something better than the competition.
“There's a pretty big gulf between better and best. And I always wanted to be on the far side of it”
Many wild dreams have turned out to be laughably conservative, so it is hard to write off anything as impossible, and people should avoid deciding in advance what a venture will become.
“So many of our wildest dreams have turned out to be laughably conservative that it's hard to write off anything as impossible”
Reading a founder's biography made the host more likely to spend money at that founder's company, as with Trader Joe's after reading a biography of its founder.
“I don't know if I've been to another grocery store since I've done that book”
Cofounder partnerships are like marriages, and most end in divorce, so founders should learn from cases like Romero and Carmack to avoid those pitfalls.
“Having a cofounder is like being married, and most marriages end in divorce. Same thing with cofounders.”
A founder who sets out in a small business, uses trade show exposure and distributor deals, and avoids giving up upside often succeeds, though this pattern is seldom seen in the entertainment industry.
“this should never be as surprising as it should be”
Quality was the driving force behind Meier's success, and the games' quality was what made the company succeed over time rather than marketing or deals alone.
“this is the most important part of this entire section, quality. Quality content, in this case, his games, quality was the driving force behind it all.”